In this study, radiation-treated UCMSC lenses were prepared by combining highly oxygen-permeable hydrogel lenses with irradiated UCMSCs, forming a novel therapeutic modality that could utilize immune modulation by UCMSCs to reduce corneal inflammation and neovascularization.
MSCs are adult mesenchymal stem cells with immunoregulatory functions that have been used to treat corneal alkali burns in some studies and have achieved good curative effects [37–39]. However, intravenous use of UCMSCs has the potential risk of stimulating tumor growth through intercellular interactions to stimulate the development of ovarian tumors [40] and can also enhance the proliferation and migration of cancer cells [41, 42]. In addition, human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-mismatched MSCs are eliminated by the host immune system [43]. Moreover, it has been reported that less than 1% of systemic infusions of MSCs reach the target tissue [44, 45]. Most systemically used MSCs are trapped in the lungs, thus affecting their immune activity [46, 47]; therefore, many cells are usually required to achieve the desired therapeutic effect, which limits the feasibility of applying mesenchymal stem cell-based therapies in the clinic [44].
Therefore, the benefit of using MSCs locally to treat corneal alkali burns is that the drug acts directly on the target organ, theoretically preventing MSCs from entering the systemic circulation and bypassing the lung first-pass effect to target delivery cells [48] to improve drug utilization efficiency.
However, keeping UCMSCs on the surface of the eye without the help of other drugs is difficult. Currently, the principal preservation method for UCMSCs is to use Matrigel to support the growth of UCMSCs [49, 50], but Matrigel is not a scientifically approved product, so it is impossible to use clinically. In previous studies, several researchers have identified MSCs. They were attached to fibrin gel and then transplanted into the cornea [51], while other researchers used MSCs implanted into amniotic membranes [14, 52]. However, fibrin has previously been reported to alter the phenotypic and functional characteristics of stem cells [53]. In addition, the amniotic membrane has inherent immunosuppressive potential [27, 54], which affects its therapeutic efficacy.
To safely and efficiently apply UCMSCs to the ocular surface, we developed a radiation-treated UCMSC lens (China invention patent: ZL202011504302.4) composed of irradiated UCMSCs and specific silicone hydrogel lenses to provide both a sustainable immunomodulatory effect and high oxygen permeability. In our previous study, the authors retained most of the irradiated UCMSCs (15 Gy) on silicone hydrogel lenses for at least 5 days and maintained their immunomodulatory effects, which helped these lenses treat corneal alkali burns. The results also indicated that a high dose of UCMSCs (2.0 × 105 cells) on lenses had the greatest effect on both anti-inflammatory and antineovascularization effects in the treatment of corneal alkali burns [21].
After establishing the rabbit alkali burn model, the groups were established as follows. First, the radiation-treated UCMSC lenses were composed mainly of blank hydrogel lenses and irradiated UCMSCs. Interference of lenses on therapeutic effect should be excluded. Therefore, the efficacy of UCMSCs on radiation-treated UCMSC lenses should be compared between the blank lens group and the radiation-treated UCMSC lens group. As our previous study revealed that UCMSCs on lenses maintained high viability and cell numbers within 5 days [21], the lenses were replaced every 3–4 days to maintain the therapeutic effect of UCMSCs on the ocular surface. Additionally, the lenses may be removed during treatment due to factors such as animal scratching, so all rabbits in both groups underwent eyelid suturing. Second, the use of radiation-treated UCMSC lenses is characterized by the local use of UCMSCs, and the UCMSC I.V. group was established to explore whether local application can obtain better results than systematic use of UCMSCs. Third, comparisons were made between the untreated group and the UCMSC I.V. group to observe the therapeutic effect of UCMSCs. To ensure that all the experimental animals in the experimental group had the same influencing factors except for the experimental comparison factors, all the animals in the untreated group and the intravenous injection group were given eyelid sutures. Fourth, a blank normal group was used to determine the indicators of a normal cornea to assess abnormalities after corneal alkali burn and recovery in the treatment group. Overall, we established four experimental groups and one normal control group.
Compared with those in the blank lens group and the radiation-treated UCMSC lens group, the IF value, degree of corneal edema, neovascular area and degree of corneal epithelial repair in the latter group were significantly greater, which indicates that the local use of UCMSCs is effective for anti-inflammatory and corneal repair. In addition, the PCR results demonstrated that the local use of UCMSCs can reduce neovascularization by downregulating vascular growth-related factors.
Compared with the untreated group and the UCMSC I.V. group, the systemic use of UCMSCs had a certain therapeutic effect on the treatment of corneal alkali burns by reducing neovascularization and inflammation and promoting corneal repair.
The results from the two groups above showed that both systemic and local use of UCMSCs inhibited inflammation and neovascularization after alkali burn injury and promoted corneal repair.
Finally, the therapeutic effects of intravenous injection of UCMSCs and radiation-treated UCMSC lenses after corneal alkali burn injury were compared, and the results showed that there was less inflammation and corneal neovascularization in the radiation-treated UCMSC lens group than in the UCMSC I.V. group. The above results suggested that the local use of UCMSCs in radiation-treated UCMSC lenses was more effective than the systemic use of UCMSCs in the treatment of inflammation and neovascularization (P < 0.05). However, there was no significant difference in the extent of corneal epithelial injury repair (P > 0.05). In conclusion, the efficacy of radiation-treated UCMSCs is significantly better than that of systemic UCMSCs, especially in terms of their anti-inflammatory and antivascular effects.
To determine how radiation-treated UCMSC lenses function when they cover the surface of injured eyes, we performed GSEA and KEGG analyses between the blank lens group and radiation-treated UCMSC lens group, considering that the effects of the treatment were influenced by many factors, including UCMSCs, blank lenses, alkali burn, and intravenous injection, which rigorously excluded these influencing factors.
Our results showed that radiation-treated UCMSC lenses play a role in treating alkali corneal burns via Th17 cell differentiation and the successful regulation of relevant cytokines.
First, in the GSEA and KEGG analyses, Th17 cell differentiation was the second most enriched pathway. The top-ranked enriched pathway, the pathway of type I diabetes mellitus, is closely related to endocrine disease, a disorder of carbohydrate metabolism [55], which we excluded because it was a separate disease and did not seem to be relevant to the current study.
Second, Th17 cells are a subset of CD4 + T cells that specifically secrete IL-17, and most Th17-mediated effects involve IL-17A, which is a key factor in the recruitment, activation and migration of central granulocytes. Moreover, it has been suggested that the activation of Th17 cells is the main cause of long-term inflammation in the anterior segment after alkali burns and may be a therapeutic target for inhibiting inflammation in alkali burns [56]. This finding was consistent with the results of immunohistochemistry on the 18th day after modeling in this study, which showed that there were many IL-17-positive cells in the corneas from both the radiation-treated UCMSC lens group and the blank lens group, while there were no IL-17-positive cells in the normal corneal tissue. Studies have shown that UCMSCs can inhibit the function of Th17 cells [57], which is consistent with our cell experiments, which showed that coculture of UCMSCs and PBMCs can reduce the proportion of Th17 cells. Therefore, it is feasible to use UCMSCs to inhibit Th17 activation as a therapeutic target. In this study, there were significantly fewer IL-17-positive cells in the radiation-treated UCMSC lens group than in the blank lens group, and ELISA and PCR results also proved that the IL-17 expression in the radiation-treated UCMSC lens group was lower than that in the blank lens group. These results indicate that UCMSCs, which play a major role in radiation-treated UCMSC lenses, can inhibit the production and infiltration of Th17 cells.
Third, Th17 cell differentiation mainly includes three stages: induction, expansion and stabilization. At each stage, Th17 cell differentiation is finely and intricately regulated by various cytokines and signaling molecules, and to further examine which stage of the Th17 cell differentiation pathway is the main pathway involved, we tested 10 cytokines from this pathway, not only IL-17, in irradiated UCMSCs on lenses. Among them, radiation-treated UCMSC lenses downregulated the expression of IL-6, which is one of the main factors that promotes Th17 cell differentiation in the induction phase. Moreover, the lenses also downregulated IL-23, which is normally expressed in the stabilization phase, while they upregulated the expression of STAT1, which is involved in inhibiting the induction of Th17 cells induced by IL-6. In addition, radiation-treated UCMSC lenses also reduced the levels of IL-17A and CCR6, which are products and markers of Th17 cells [58], respectively. In addition, the level of IL-4, which is a negative regulating factor of the differentiation pathway, was significantly increased in the radiation-treated UCMSC lens group, and CD3G, IL-1B, and LAT, which are upregulated in this pathway, were downregulated in the radiation-treated UCMSC lens group compared to the blank lens group. Overall, radiation-treated UCMSCs suppressed the Th17 cell differentiation pathway, especially in the induction phase and the stabilization phase. The evidence above showed that radiation-treated UCMSC lenses successfully inhibited inflammation via inhibition of the Th17 cell differentiation pathway.
The shortcomings of these studies are as follows. First, since the corneal curvature of rabbits is obviously smaller than that of humans and there is a nondegenerate third eyelid, the lenses placed in the rabbit conjunctiva sac may change position due to the movement of the rabbit's eye, which limits the therapeutic effect on the injured site. Second, to avoid lenses detaching from the cornea during treatment, the eyelid should be sutured every time, which can affect the experimental results. Third, severe swelling and ulceration of the eyelids on the 18th day led to the relatively short observation time of the rabbit alkali burn model, corneal inflammation in each group of rabbits did not completely subside, and no obvious scar formed, which led to the finding that the effect of UCMSCs on corneal scar formation and inhibition was not recorded in this study. Fourth, there is a lack of therapeutic studies on Th17 cell targets. In further studies, we will complete a Th17 cell differentiation-related gene knockout experiment and observe the therapeutic effect. If the therapeutic effect is significantly decreased, Th17 cell differentiation could be a therapeutic target of UCMSCs for treating corneal alkali burns after radiation.