3.1 XRD patterns of different samples
X-ray diffraction (XRD) was used to analyze the crystalline characteristics and the phase structure of g-C3N5, ZnO, Ce-CN, ZN/CN, and ZN/Ce-CN (Fig. 1(a,b)). The diffraction peak of CN at 2θ = 27.4° was generated by the stacking of conjugated aromatic systems, corresponding to the (002) plane. No peak corresponding to Ce species was observed in Ce-CN due to the trace quantity and homogeneous dispersion of Ce single atoms [26]. However, for Ce-CN catalyst, obvious shifts toward a higher 2θ value (about 0.2) were observed. This could be due to Ce doping, which induces distortion in the g-C3N5 lattice, similar to Ce-C3N4 [27]. All peaks in the range of 2θ = 30 ~ 80° were indexed according to the hexagonal wurtzite ZnO structure (JCPDS No. 99-0111) [28]. ZnO remains in its crystalline phase even after g-C3N5 hybridization. As a result, the diffraction peaks of ZN/Ce-CN contain each separate peak for Ce-CN and ZnO with different intensities. Furthermore, the absence of any other new peaks shows that the effective synthesis of ZN/Ce-CN was accomplished.
3.2 IR
FTIR spectra were also utilized to explore the characteristics of the as-prepared ZN/Ce-CN at each step (Fig. 2). Similar characteristic peaks are detected for typical CN networks in graphitic of virgin g-C3N5 and Ce-CN materials. The IR bands at 1240 cm-1, 1318 cm-1, 1411 cm-1, 1560 cm-1, and 1640 cm-1 are ascribed to the C-N stretch (νC-N) of heptazine (C6N7) aromatic nucleus in g-C3N5 as similar to g-C3N4 material. Whilst the characteristic broad peaks at 3154 cm-1 is attributed to symmetric and asymmetric stretching vibrations of the -NH2 (νN-H) and -OH (νO-H) groups [29]. The sharp peak observed at 812 cm-1 was related to the breathing mode of triazine units in g-C3N5 [30], and it was obviously found in the ZN/Ce-CN composite. There are no further vibration modes found for Ce-CN, indicating that the structure of g-C3N5 is unaffected by cerium doping. The entire graphite-like structure of cerium-doped is essential for the π-delocalized electron system, which aids in the generation and transportation of photogenerated carriers [31]. O-H stretching vibration accounts for the intense broadband at about 3450 cm-1 in the FTIR spectra of undoped ZnO [32]. The loading of ZnO broadens the peak bands of the O-H stretching vibration in ZN/CN and ZN/Ce-CN significantly. A well-defined band appears at 599-400 cm-1, which could be due to the stretching vibration of the Zn-O bond [10], and it was clearly identified with a little shift in the ZN/CN and ZN/Ce-CN composite. Notably, the successful synthesis of heterojunctions in ZN/Ce-CN can be confirmed by the characteristic peaks of ZN/Ce-CN containing both Ce-CN and ZnO.
3.3 Morphological properties
TEM and HRTEM measurements were done to better understand the structure and content of the produced samples. It is evident from the ZN/Ce-CN TEM images (Fig. 3a) that ZnO nanoparticles were successfully deposited on Ce-CN nanosheets, demonstrating the composite of ZnO and Ce-CN, which is a fundamental requirement for heterojunctions production. Additionally, using HRTEM analysis, the interaction between the nanocomposites was investigated; the outcomes are displayed in Fig. 3b. HRTEM images further confirmed the presence of heterojunctions, with inter-planar distances of 0.281 and 0.247 nm corresponding to the (100) plane and (101) plane of ZnO, respectively [33]. Because of the low crystallinity, the lattice streaks of Ce-CN were not detectable. In addition, the utilization of energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) verified the existence of Zn, Ce, C, N, and O (Fig. 3(d-i)). The homogeneous distribution of all the elements suggests that the ZN/Ce-CN structure was successfully constructed.
3.4 XPS analysis
The ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite's surface chemical composition and valence states were ascertained by XPS analysis; the outcomes are shown in Fig. 4. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) survey spectrum was utilized to confirm the presence of elements in ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite which include C, O, N, Ce, and Zn, as shown in Fig. 4(a), which coincides with the EDX analysis (Fig.4i). In the HR-XPS spectrum of C 1s (Fig. 4(b)), the peaks at 284.9 eV and 287.9 eV which represent the C-C (sp3) and N-C=N (sp2) bonding respectively [34]. The sp3 carbon peak was caused by the presence of residual unreacted precursor, turbostratic carbon, and adventitious carbon, whereas the sp2 carbon peak was caused by aromatic carbons building heptazine units (C6N7) of g-C3N5 matrix. The peak positioned at 398.5 eV in the HR-XPS spectra of N 1s (Fig. 4(c)) was assigned to the additive contribution of the secondary C=N-C/anionic nitrogen in the O-Zn-N linkage [19]. The typical peak at the binding energies of 399.4 eV corresponds to the tertiary (N-(C)3) nitrogen of the heptazine (C3N4) moiety. As a result of the cumulative contribution of bridging azo (C-N=N-C) nitrogen and residual -NH2 on the edge, a peak with a band energy value of 400.4 eV was detected. HR-XPS spectra of ZN/Ce-CN in the O 1s region (Fig. 4(d)) revealed two unique deconvoluted peaks at BE ≈ 530.6 and 531.7 eV. The former corresponds to the lattice oxygen of ZnO, whereas the latter corresponds to surface-adsorbed OH species. The position of the Zn 2p3/2 and Zn 2p1/2 peaks for the ZN/Ce-CN (Fig. 4(e)) are around 1022.2 eV and 1045.3 eV, respectively, demonstrating that the Zn element resides largely in the form of Zn2+ [8, 35]. The Ce 3d spectrum is seen in Fig. 4(f), which is associated with the Ce4+ 3d3/2 cerium state and has peaks with binding energies of 898.4 and 882.02 eV. The thick layer of g-C3N5 covering the ZN/Ce-CN surface is the reason for the faint Ce signal [36]. Hence, the ZnO/Ce-CN nanocomposite's XPS spectrum revealed a robust chemical connection between ZnO and Ce-CN, which leads to the heterojunctions formation.
3.5 UV-Vis
Using UV–vis DRS (Fig. 5(a)), the optical characteristics of the as-obtained pure g-C3N5, ZnO, Ce-CN, ZN/CN, and ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite were determined. ZnO's absorption edge is approximately 397 nm, while g-C3N5's is approximately 725 nm. g-C3N5 has a higher visible-light absorption capacity than pure ZnO, indicating that it can be activated by visible light and that it is a photo-responsive material capable of improving ZnO's light absorption capability. Because of an extended π conjugated network resulting from the overlap between N 2p in a heptazine π conjugated system and N 2p orbitals of bridging azo moieties, g-C3N5 absorbs substantially in the visible region, with band tails reaching 660 nm [29]. While the absorption edge of Ce-CN is roughly 713 nm, compared to pure g-C3N5, the Ce-CN absorption band has a blue shift, which could be caused by the quantum confinement effect and Ce-CN's defect state following cerium doping [37]. However, when compared to pure ZnO, the visible light absorption of ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite increased considerably, and a large redshift was observed. It suggests that the nanocomposite are good photocatalytic materials. The Tauc model was utilized to further estimate the band gap values of the photocatalysts [38], as demonstrated by the Tauc plot presented in Fig. 5(b). For g-C3N5, ZnO, Ce-CN, ZN/CN, and ZN/Ce-CN, the observed band gaps (Eg) were 1.96, 2.71, 1.77, 2.66, and 2.31 eV, in that order. Ce-CN doping results in a significant improvement in the light absorption intensity (band gap decreased to 2.31 eV) of ZN/Ce-CN, which supports higher photocatalytic activity.
3.6 PL
Fig. 6 depicts the optical photoluminescence (PL) emission spectra stimulated at 389 nm, which were utilized to determine the carrier transfer efficiency in the photocatalytic process. The noticeable fluorescence emission peaks of g-C3N5 indicate significant photogenerated electrons and holes recombination rates. Ce is added to g-C3N5 to lessen the intensity of its PL emission. The PL emission peak of ZN/Ce-CN was further reduced after composite with ZnO, indicating that the recombination of carriers in the heterogeneity of the composite photocatalyst was significantly suppressed, effectively promoting carrier migration and separation [39].
3.7 Photo-electrochemical properties
In general, the greater the intensity of the photocurrent, the greater the electron-hole separation and migration efficiency. The effectiveness of charge separation was further investigated using transient photocurrent response and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The photocurrent transient response curve (I-t) (Fig. 7(a)) shows that when exposed to radiation, the photocurrents generated by ZN/Ce-CN are substantially stronger than those generated by pure g-C3N5 and ZnO. The photocurrent responses of pure g-C3N5, ZnO, and ZN/Ce-CN reverted to their initial values once the irradiation was discontinued. This reveals that the productivity of an electrons and holes dissociation has enhanced after combining g-C3N5 and ZnO due to higher photo-excited electrons production and transmission capacities [40, 41].
Furthermore, as shown in Fig. 7(b), the photo-generated carriers' transfer efficiency was thoroughly investigated using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). The radius of the arc is closely related to the transport efficiency of the photogenerated carriers, the smaller the radius, the higher the transport efficiency due to less charge transfer resistance [42]. In the EIS Nyquist plots, the arc radius of the ZN/Ce-CN composite was smaller than that of Ce-CN and ZnO, implying an increase in electronic conductivity. Furthermore, ZN/Ce-CN possessed the highest electronic conductivity, which might be attributable to the formation of sufficiently tight interfacial connection between ZnO and CN. Photoelectrochemical study clearly showed that combining ZnO and Ce-CN can effectively improve interfacial electron transport, resulting in the generation of sizable free electrons that can further activate the MB efficiently, thus greatly enhancing the catalytic efficacy of the system [42].
3.8 Photocatalytic degradation activity of MB
As shown in Fig. 8(a), the produced nanoparticles' photocatalytic activity was assessed using methylene blue dye as a model pollutant. Initially, the dye solution was agitated with the photocatalyst in the dark for 30 minutes to achieve adsorption-desorption equilibrium. The pristine ZnO NPs and pure g-C3N5 nanosheets exhibited a poor photodegradation efficiencies percentage under 90 minutes irradiation at 69% and 55% respectively. It indicates that the recombination rate of photo-induced electron-hole pairs is faster in the one-component system of ZnO and g-C3N5. In comparison to single-component materials, all doped and composite photocatalysts demonstrated noticeably improved photocatalytic performance. ZN/(1%)Ce-CN nanocomposite shown the highest MB degradation efficiency of 97%, which was relatively higher than that of Ce-CN(76%), ZN/CN(77%), ZN/(0.25%)Ce-CN(92%), and ZN/(0.2%)Ce-CN(86%), under 90 minutes of UV-visible light irradiation. As a result, the effective production of heterojunctions under the synergistic effect of ZnO and Ce-CN plays a critical role in methylene blue degradation.
Next, Fig. 8b shows that the catalyst's degradation time of MB and -ln(C/C0) is proportionate, in line with the first-order kinetic equation [43, 44]. The rate constant of (1%)ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite was 0.312 min-1, which is 5 times higher than that of g-C3N5, 2.9 times higher than that of ZnO, 3 times higher than that of Ce-CN, and 2.5 times higher than that of ZN/CN. The results revealed that (1%)ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite had a high photocatalytic degradation efficiency for removing MB.
The role of pH on UV-Vis assisted degradation of MB in the presence of ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite is shown in Fig. 8c. At pH 13, ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite exhibited the most photocatalytic activity, reducing MB to around 99%. The ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite degraded from 99% to 42% when the pH was lowered from 13 to 2, suggesting that the alkaline environment aids in the adsorption and photodegradation of MB. This is because the active sites of ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite amass a significant amount of H+ ions in the pH range of 2-4.8, rendering them positively charged and repelling MB (a cationic organic molecule). With a pH of 10-13, there will be a lot of negative charge on the surface of the photocatalyst, which increases the strong electrostatic attraction between the electrocatalyst and the positively charged MB and promotes photocatalytic efficiency. However, with a pH of 10-13, there will be a lot of negative charge on the surface of the photocatalyst, which increases the strong electrostatic attraction between the ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite and the positively charged MB and promotes photocatalytic efficiency [45].
3.9 Determination of reusability of composite ZN/Ce-CN
One of the most important features for degrading organic dyes is the material's stability [46]. To evaluate the stability of ZN/Ce-CN, the recycled photodegradation removal experiment of MB was studied. The photocatalytic degradation efficiency of ZN/Ce-CN composite stayed constant at 87.67% after five cycles (as seen in Fig. 9(a)), varying by about 2% to 4% per cycle, suggesting that it still possesses high photocatalytic activity. In addition, The XRD measurement results (Fig. 9(b)) demonstrated that the fresh ZN/Ce-CN and the utilized ZN/Ce-CN have similar XRD signals, indicating that ZN/Ce-CN had good structural stability. The results of this experiment revealed that the photodegradation efficiency of the ZN/CN nanocomposite slightly decreased after cycling experiments, which could be due to the fact that the photocatalyst was washed with distilled water several times and used for a long time, reducing their surface area and thus limiting the arrival of methylene blue to the active site. However, it does not affect the good stability and reusability of ZN/CN in the photocatalytic degradation process.
3.10 Trapping of reactive species
In order to identify the primary active species, free radical scavenger experiments were also used. Potassium iodide (KI), isopropanol (IPA), and p-benzoquinone (p-BQ) were respectively added to capture h+ (holes) [47], •OH (hydroxyl radical) [48] and •O2- (superoxide radical) [49].
According to Fig. 10(a), without the use of a trapping agent, the degradation rate of MB was 97%, but it reduced dramatically with the addition of potassium iodide (KI), from 97% to 52%, showing that the h+ play a prominent role in the photocatalytic degradation process. The degradation rate of MB reduced from 97% to 67% when isopropanol (IPA) was introduced, demonstrating that •OH constitute a major component impacting degradation. Additionally, the degradation rate of MB dropped marginally from 97% to 81% with the addition of p-benzoquinone (p-BQ) solution to the reaction solution, indicating that only a small portion of the degradation reaction is caused by •O2-. According to the findings, the principal active ingredient is h+ in the photocatalytic degradation reaction, while •OH also play a significant role, with some contribution from •O2-.
To confirm that the degradation process generates the aforementioned reactive oxidants, a possible free radical detection was performed utilizing an ESR test using DMPO as a probe (Fig. 10(b-d)). Under dark conditions, h+ showed a strong activity signal, which gradually decreased with increasing light time, due to the oxidation of TEMPO to TEMPO+ by h+, which has a strong oxidizing ability [50]. It can be seen that there are h+ in the degradation reaction, and the ZN/Ce-CN nanocomposite can maintain a significant quantity of h+ in the light. It implies that the h+ species plays the most important function in the photocatalytic process.
Fig. 10(c,d) show that under dark conditions, ZN/Ce-CN had almost no active species characteristic signals, but after 10 minutes of light irradiation, DMPO-•O2- and DMPO-•OH appeared as significant characteristic peaks, producing more photogenerated carriers, which provides significance for the photocatalytic reaction [51].
3.11 Band structure of ZN/Ce-CN composite and charge transfer mechanism
The Mott-Schottky technique was used to determine the type of semiconductor and the flat band potential (Ef). The Mott-Schottky curves (Fig. 11(a,b)) for ZnO and Ce-CN have positive slopes, suggesting that they are both n-type semiconductors [52]. In the meantime, ZnO and Ce-CN had Ef values of -0.49 eV and -0.59 eV, respectively, concerning the Ag/AgCl electrode and pH of 7. That is, ZnO and Ce-CN had conduction band potentials of -0.29 eV and -0.39 eV, respectively, concerning NHE, pH = 7. Additionally, ZnO and Ce-CN had band gaps (Eg) of 2.71 and 1.77 eV, respectively, according to Fig. 5(b). As a result, their corresponding valence band potentials were 2.42 and 1.38 eV, respectively.
Together with the Eg values of Ce-CN and ZnO in the DRS diagram and the band potentials form Mott-Schottky test (Fig. 11), a potential mechanism is conjectured (Fig. 12). For Ce-CN and ZnO, the CB potentials are -0.39 and -0.29 eV, respectively, and the VB potentials are 1.38 and 2.42 eV, respectively, for pH = 7 relative to NHE. Ce-CN could form S-scheme or a type II heterojunctions with ZnO because its CB and the VB potentials were more negative than ZnO's. Which was it, out of the two? A lot relied on the specific electron transfer mechanism in this case. The electrons generated on the CB of Ce-CN would flow to the CB of ZnO when exposed to light if a typical type II heterojunctions formed (Fig. 12, left). However, as the CB potential of ZnO (-0.29 eV) is more positive than the redox potential of O2/•O2- (-0.39 V versus NHE, pH = 7) [53], •O2- cannot be generated. In a similar manner, the h+ produced on ZnO's VB would flow to Ce-CN's VB. However, it is evident that •OH cannot be formed as the VB potential of Ce-CN (1.38 eV) is more negative than the redox potential of •OH/OH- (2.42 V vs NHE, pH = 7) [54], which is inconsistent with the experimental data. Consequently, it is possible to rule out the creation of type II heterojunctions in ZN/Ce-CN composites (Fig. 12, left).
On the contrary, in the S-scheme heterojunctions (Fig. 12, right), the photogenerated electrons are transported from ZnO to Ce-CN. The e- produced on ZnO’s CB would flow to Ce-CN’s VB and combine with the h+ on it. The e- on the CB of Ce-CN would convert O2 to •O2-, while the h+ on the VB of Ce-CN would react with OH- to form •OH. Ultimately, the MB and its degradation intermediates were oxidized by the generated reactive species h+, •OH, and •O2-. The results of reactant scavenging tests and ESR spin trapping confirm the aforesaid observations. The above analyses all point to the creation of S-scheme heterojunctions in the ZN/Ce-CN composite.