In order to understand the effect of extreme weather conditions and how wild, free-living animals respond to them, we generated a genome assembly and performed RNA-sequencing on key tissues in the Arctic specialist, the Lapland longspur, collected during two distinct types of extreme weather conditions (i.e., extreme spring and snowstorm). The high-quality genome assembly enabled an accurate annotation of genomic features and reliable quantification of gene expression changes.
We first investigated gene expression changes occurring between arrival and incubation under normal seasonal conditions, using this as a baseline to understand the transcriptomic dynamics in response to environmental adversity. The major transition between the two life history stages is the physiological adjustment to breeding status, which includes reproductive activity and cardiovascular function. Among other DEGs, ZP3 shows the most significant down-regulation pattern in testes. ZP3 encodes a protein essential for the sperm acrosome reaction, especially for binding of sperm to the zona pellucida. ZP3 knockout mice and human genetic mutation in this gene (OMIM:617712) have been shown to exhibit female infertility due to zona pellucida defect31–34. Recently, significant ZP3 expression was found in normal human and mouse testes (spermatogonia and spermatocytes) 17. A study in a non-mammalian vertebrate, the gilthead seabream (Sparus aurata) also demonstrated that the orthologous ZP3 gene is up-regulated in ejaculated sperm compared to haploid germ cells22. Evidence is accumulating for its important role in the male reproductive system, however, the molecular function of a down-regulated ZP3 in testis is unknown. Another interesting finding was in the cardiovascular system. DEGs in heart exhibit strong enrichment in cardiovascular development, circulatory system development, and positive regulation of vascular associated smooth muscle cell migration (e.g., IGFBP5). In addition, the glucocorticoid responsive gene FKBP5 also expresses at a lower level during incubation relative to arrival in hypothalamus and heart. This supports the hypothesis that during parental stages, the HPA axis activity is attenuated in wild breeding birds to prevent nest abandonment and favour parental care35. These DEGs and functional pathways identified under normal conditions provide a foundation to understand the interplay between life history stages and inclement weather events.
The two distinct inclement weather conditions triggered significant negative energy balance referred to as Type I allostatic overload 9, which makes an interesting proxy study for understanding the similarity and differences in their effects. The two extreme weather conditions act similarly as a source of allostatic load with limited food availability and higher thermoregulation demand, which limits the amount of external energy availability in the environment (EG) and increases the cost of maintaining minimum day-to-day homeostasis (EE) as well as energy required to make predictable changes under ideal conditions (EI). Yet, the influence of adversity and corresponding responses of animals largely depend on interplay of varied inclement weather types and the breeding cycle phenology.
The two extreme weather conditions in this study enabled us to compare transcriptomic changes between the two stress scenarios. In liver, genes with similar up- or down-regulated expression patterns reveal an energy expenditure that is consistent in the two scenarios. For instance, shared up-regulated genes (e.g., DLAT, PDHA2 and ELOVL5) are associated with terms such as ‘coenzyme biosynthetic process’ and ‘thioester biosynthetic process’. In liver, one of the most important thioesters is acetyl-CoA, which participates in the tricarboxylic acid cycle to produce energy in the form of ATP or GTP upon oxidization. Usually, acetyl-CoA is produced via glycolysis of glucose and degradation of fatty acid or amino acid. Genes that positively regulate cellular response to insulin such as SRC and NR1H4 were down-regulated in both inclement conditions, despite the fact that we did not identify statistically significant GO terms using shared down-regulated liver DEGs. Importantly, the large number of differentially expressed genes detected in liver, many of which are important and rate-limiting enzymes in processes of glycolysis and gluconeogenesis (e.g., PCK1), were found to associate with related GO terms, which indicates that the dynamic and metabolic activity in liver tissues is providing fuel to cope with the stress-imposed negative energy imbalance.
We have highlighted genes in hypothalamus whose expression is crucially regulated under the inclement conditions studied. FKBP5 was the most up-regulated gene in hypothalamus during the snowstorm incubation period. This gene is known to have significant relevance as a stress regulator 36,37. The acute snowstorm immediately affected the function of the HPA axis of Lapland longspur, with an increase in expression of FKBP5 in the brain. FKBP5 is a co-chaperone associated with Hsp90, negatively regulating glucocorticoid signalling, which is recognized as a mediator of stress-response. Both nucleotide and protein sequence of FKBP5 are also highly conserved across species, and a homozygous knockout of FKBP5 in mice was shown to cause abnormal depression or anxiety-related behaviours. Decreased circulating corticosterone levels are also seen in stressed mice 31. Normally, in response to stress, FKBP5 expression is increased by elevated glucocorticoids. This correlation is especially interesting in hypothalamus, as it subsequently modulates GR activity by reducing ligand-binding sensitivity and delays the translocation of GR. In turn, GR regulates the transcription of many nuclear expressed genes, including FKBP5 which is also shown to be determined by the epigenetic context and polymorphism of the locus 37. High FKBP5 expression additionally leads to GR resistance and subsequently influences many biological functions and gene transcription, for instance reduced expression of PCK1, as we observed 37. Induced GR resistance can result in an attenuated HPA negative feedback mechanism, whilst a failure to restore the baseline GC level has maladaptive and pathological consequences 38,39. Collectively, we demonstrate that during the snowstorm, the acute stress was extremely intense, reflected by the activity of HPA axis genes and the significantly induced FKBP5 expression level in the hypothalamus, eventually leading to a negative balance that had destructive and fatal outcomes.
Lapland longspurs had to fight against the chronic and prolonged inclemency of weather in the extreme spring scenario by triggering the emergency life history stage (ELHS), and actively trading off their breeding windows for the chance of survival. The reduced expression level of ZP3 and FMN2 in testes sheds light on the gene expression dynamics occurring during reproductive curtailment. In our analysis between benign life history stages, ZP3 was the most significantly down-regulated gene in testes of incubating birds. Recent evidence of up-regulated ZP3 expression was found in testes of some vertebrates 17,22. Similar high expression was found for FMN2 in early spermatids in a recent human single-cell study 32. FMN2 encodes a protein crucial for actin binding and cell polarity (mostly associated with female infertility) 33,34, as well as being an important component involved in stress-induced cell-cycle arrest in human cells 40. In addition, expression of TBC1D8 is increased in testis, with recent studies suggesting its function in cell death as a new cell apoptosis inducer 41, which may mark it as a potential key protein during curtailment of reproduction. Our discovery of low expression of ZP3 (and FMN2) in reproductively curtailed passerine birds further demonstrates that reduced gene expression can cause arrested spermatogenic maturation which underlies the impaired male reproduction in extreme spring. We therefore hypothesize that the testicular expression of ZP3 is crucial for the initiation of spermatogenesis, with function rapidly reducing upon entering the incubation period. To our knowledge, this study shows, for the first time in wild living aves, expression of ZP3 has fundamental function during spermatogenesis, and reduced expression may indicate reproductive inhibition. Compared to previous studies on the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal response to stress 42,43, novel genes identified in our study complement the few discovered genes in the male transcriptomic stress response and expand our understanding of the influence of a prolonged stressor on body systems.
We noted that the expression of FKBP5 was not significantly regulated in any tissue during the extreme spring, which may suggest that the HPA axis had likely acquired a temporal balance with improved plasticity and had adapted to perturbations at the sampling time point. These temporal dynamics could be achieved by many possible mechanisms (e.g., corticosterone binding globulin) 11,44. The fitness of the birds during the extreme spring may also be explained by the previously-studied association between HPA flexibility and FKBP5 expression 45. This pattern agrees with the “leave-it” strategy as previously proposed 5,8. Although FKBP5 levels can be a proxy for a chronic stressor 44, our study highlights the importance of considering the interplay of life history stage, extreme environmental conditions, coping strategy, and the temporal gene expression fluctuations.
When comparing the two scenarios from an allostatic load perspective, spring is thought to provide higher energy supplies in food compared to winter, however, the chronic effect of an extremely cold period imposes constant challenge on the energy balance, on top of the expenditure of life history stage transition (e.g., migration and pre-breeding). The ELHS was thus adopted by Lapland longspurs, which in turn suppressed the regular LHS (i.e., breeding). Through these series of physiological and behavioural stress challenges, the birds successfully managed to reduce their negative energy balance and reach a favourable outcome of survival. However, this was at the cost of a failed breeding attempt. In comparison, the extreme snowstorm is expected to have caused immediate overloads by dramatic energy expenditure via the environmental perturbation (EO) that is often expected during adversity along with glucocorticoid secretion. This negative energy balance resulted in an acute effect of EE + EI + EO > EG, with individuals failing to reduce the allostatic load eventually suffering pathological effects and, to a greater degree, death. This additionally supports the double-edged sword theory of glucocorticoid function and other allostasis mediators, which play protective and adaptive roles in the stress response, yet can also have damaging effects.
Beyond the above-mentioned genes, further genes are of interest, including those which contribute to the comprehensive stress response that induces physiological, behavioural and phenological changes. For instance, genes (e.g., FKBP5) that have been reported to be stress-related in human studies are associated with the adrenergic system, bipolar condition and the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system (RAAS). These genes were detected mostly in heart (COMT and LGALS2) and liver (AGT, ADRB2, and LGALS2) in our comparisons 25. In addition, we also found ZBTB16 to be upregulated in liver and heart in response to the snowstorm. Gene ZBTB16 encodes a zinc finger transcription factor that responds to corticosteroid regulation, and shows a robust induction by GR activation or stress exposure in human, mouse, and bird studies 43,46,47.
In summary, here we present a high-quality genome assembly of the Lapland longspur (Calcarius lapponicus), which has enabled a comprehensive transcriptomic study to investigate gene expression changes in key tissues, occurring in response to environment stress caused by extreme weather events at different stages of the Lapland longspur breeding cycle. Biological processes such as activation of HPA axis, reproductive function and energy regulation are shown to be central to the adaptive changes required in the host, with genes including FKBP5, ZP3 and ME1 being key players in these responses. This study provides data fundamental to our understanding of how species will have to be able to adapt to the rapidly changing climate we all now face.