A 31-year-old male had clinical features typical of pneumonia and subsequent arthritis, presented with a painful lump in his right knee. The patient, who had no previous medical history, went to his general practitioner (October 2018) due to a persistent cough and fever (40°C), lasting for one week. The patient had been touring California and Arizona, including camping in the wilderness, 20 days before his illness. The patient had no history of primary immunodeficiency or autoimmune diseases. He had neither chronic comorbidities nor conditions or diseases that could lead to an immunodeficiency disorder.He did not report the use of any drugs or harmful habits, such as excessive usage of alcohol or smoking. The patient was treated with broad-spectrum empirical antibiotic therapy (amoxicillin and clavulanic acid), leading to the clinical resolution of pneumonia after a few days. However, six weeks later (January 2019), he had a new fever, lasting three days (38°C). In August 2019, the patient returned to his general practitioner due to intense swelling and persistent pain in the right knee joint (new symptoms), limited mobility, and a local high skin temperature. The patient did not have any recurrent fever, chest tightness, chest pain, abdominal pain, diarrhea, or lack of appetite.
An anteroposterior radiograph of the knee did not show any appreciable findings in the bone, whereas CT and MRI visualized i) an ovular tumor-like lesion in the lateral condyle of the tibia with inflammatory involvement of the surrounding soft tissues (peripheral abscesses), ii) joint degeneration, and iii) the anterior tibial cavity, including cortical bone (Figure 1). Magnetic resonance imaging STIR-T2 sequence shows a focal subarticular lytic hyperintense pseudotumor mass through the proximal tibia with marked perilesional bone marrow and soft tissue oedema.
The diagnosis of solitary bone lesions includes clinical and radiological signs, and the combination of well analyzed signs leads to an efficient diagnostic probability. Osseous tumor-like lesions determining osteolysis and marrow and soft tissue oedema are uncommon conditions ascribable to different etiopathogenesis, ranging from neoplastic to non-neoplastic entities (Schmitt 2017; Norman et al. 1986; Stacy et al. 2011; Cottias et al. 1997; Sanghvi et al. 2009; Junaid, Bilal et al. 2021). The appearance of bone infection and bone tumors is often similar on imaging (Moser et al. 2012; Chung et al. 2012; Junaid S, Gnanananthan V et al. 2021).
By focusing our analysis on imaging, Hoffman's diagnostic approach to solitary bone lesions (Hoffman et al. 2022) is very instructive. Hoffman proposed a dual algorithm, first based upon CT imaging and then MRI, with the purpose of distinguishing between indolent and aggressive lesions.
Lesional density itself on CT scans does not discriminate with accuracy between benign and malignant, but other findings from our patient are worth considering (Table 2):
1. Margins. Ill-defined margins, without sclerotic borders (Vanel et al. 2009), as in this case, correspond most likely to aggressive lesions.
2. Matrix. Bone is a mineralized organic matrix containing osteocytes, osteoblasts, and osteoclasts. The local alterations in mineralization could be due to altered remodeling (tumors) or to the action of enzymes (osteomyelitis; Hofstee et al. 2020). In our case, a poorly organized matrix, intermixed with lytic areas, indicates aggressive behavior.
3. Size. Lesions shorter than 6 cm are statistically more likely to be non malignant.
4. Cortical involvement. The cortical integrity has been violated, suggesting the presence of an aggressive lesion and/or an infection.
5. Periosteal reaction. CT scans show some segments characterized by a thin, calcified periosteal reaction at the periphery. This is irregular and interrupted, which could indicate the aggressive nature of the lesion.
Lastly, the CT scan gives us an important detail. In the center of the lesion, it is possible to recognize an irregular region having a texture similar to the bone, suggesting the presence of a "sequestrum", which is an irregular bone fragment with a surrounding clear zone. If confirmed, the presence of a sequestrum would be very suggestive of infection (Moser et al. 2012).
MRI imaging, following Hoffman's diagnostic criteria, confirmed this first evaluation: generally, aggressive lesions have a T1 iso-hypointense and T2 hyperintense signal and extension to the soft tissue (Table 3). The perilesional oedema could be described in our case as large and irregularly outlined, with juxtaosseus oedema also evident, as typically in osteomyelitis (Vanel et al. 2009).
In conclusion, Hoffman's approach suggests the presence of highly aggressive osteomyelitis, and a recommendation for further evaluation (biopsy) would be reasonable.
An alternative diagnostic approach has been developed by the Society of Skeletal Radiology, a collaborative multi-institutional work to provide a bone reporting and data system (Bone-RADS) for solitary bone lesions identified on CT and MRI, integrated by clinical conditions (Chang et al. 2022; Connie et al. 2022). Following this algorithm, the knee solitary lesion above can be described as a Bone-RADS-4 (Table 4, fromChang et al. 2022, modified) and needs to undergo biopsy and/or oncologic evaluation. Adams' radiological approach for intra-articular mass, where the lesion can be classified as "Type 1" (Table 5, fromAdams et al. 2007), also leads to a biopsy requirement.
For diagnostic purposes, a CT guided biopsy (December 2019) demonstrated the presence of giant-cell granulomatous chronic osteitis with spores from Cryptococcus.
Five and a half years after the patient's California and Arizona tour (February 2024), his knee symptomatology was attenuated (after voriconazole for six months). However, the CT and MRI of the knee showed an enlargement of the osteolysis (Figure 2) featuring extensive synovial thickening, as well as an enhancement compatible with synovitis, in addition to an evolutive inflammatory involvement of the patella and femur (Figure 3).
In June 2023, the patient returned to his general practitioner, complaining about pain and swelling in his right foot big toe. Physical examination demonstrated joint effusion and palpable soft tissue mass in the interphalangeal joint. Laboratory studies were significant for erythrocyte sedimentation rate (37 mm/h), C-reactive protein (16.7 mg/dL), and IgG1 quantification (15.8 g/l). In particular, an increment in the ratio CD4/CD8 was found (2.3), due to the reduction of the CD8+ T-lymphocytes (20% T-lymphocytes CD3+CD8+, flow cytometry). Further investigation, including CT and MR imaging of the affected joint, showed erosive changes of the first phalanx of the right hallux, with radiological findings very similar to the previous knee-joint arthritis (Figure 4).
The patient underwent an excisional biopsy in August 2023, which showed necrotizing giant-cell granulomatosis and evidence for spherical PAS+/Grocott+ corpuscles, resembling Coccidioides Immitis. Filamentous fungi were isolated in fungal culture in September.