The implementation of a probiotic protocol in our NICU was associated with a 90% reduction in rates of NEC > Stage 2 in babies born < 33 6/7 weeks. These results support the findings of many randomized control trials and metanalysis that have shown probiotics are associated with reduced NEC7,8,9,10. Although some studies suggest the superiority of multi-strain probiotics, others have suggested that Bifidobacterium alone offers a unique benefit to the premature gut11 and probiotic supplements containing B. infantis are more beneficial than supplements without B. infantis to premature babies12.
Our probiotic protocol was also associated with improved feeding tolerance, as a cohort and across all gestational ages, evidenced by decreased bloody stools, fewer mean TPN days and fewer mean days to full enteral feeds. Some studies have found that probiotics are associated with decreased time to reach full enteral feeds13, while others have found no effect on TPN days14.
Published data is limited regarding the association between probiotics and bloody stools in preterm babies. Although one study showed a decrease in isolated rectal bleeding in premature babies after initiating treatment with Lactobacillus rhamnosus, it was not of statistically significance15. To the best of our knowledge, this was the first study to evaluate bloody stools as a primary outcome after introduction of B. infantis. Prior to probiotic implementation, our NICU had a high baseline rate of bloody stools in babies < 34 weeks, which often prompted NEC evaluations, including bowel rest and broad-spectrum antibiotics. As dysbiosis is a likely risk factor for bloody stools16, we chose to broaden our protocol inclusion criteria to include babies born at 32 and 33 weeks completed gestation. The decrease we observed in bloody stools is consistent with research that has shown the B. infantis colonization decreases enteric inflammation17,18, reduces colonic mucin degradation19, and accelerates microbiome maturation leading to improved metabolic and immune function20. Overall, Bifidobacterium has been shown to assist in accelerating and maintaining the protective barrier function of the gastrointestinal tract.
Although metanalyses have shown that decrease late onset sepsis9,21, we did not find a decrease in late onset sepsis. We did have a reduction in both meningitis (from 3 cases to 0) and tracheitis (from 11 cases to 5), but neither were of statistical significance.
Metanalyses have also shown that probiotic use leads to a decreased duration of hospital stay for premature babies10. We did find a significant decrease in hospital stay for babies born at 31 weeks completed gestation but did find a significant decrease in duration of hospital stay for other gestational ages or in the probiotic cohort as a whole.
Important to the success of our study was support from attending neonatologists, nursing staff, dieticians, and pharmacists. Before implementation, we achieved consensus from all attending neonatologists, performed in-service training to nursing staff, and attained approval from our hospital’s antimicrobial stewardship.
As a single-center prospective cohort study, there are inherent limitations to this study. Rates of NEC vary year to year; our rate has been consistently 4-6% over the last decade. Another potential confounding variable is changes in clinical practice over time. Our feeding protocol and use of human milk remained consistent over both cohort periods. The decision to initiate enteral feeds is up to the discretion of the neonatologist on service, and we did see a reduction in the mean day of life that feedings were initiated from the control cohort to the probiotic cohort (from 1.3 to 0.9 days, p = 0.0009). Although delayed enteral feeds have been shown to be protective against NEC in formula-fed babies22, early human milk enteral feedings may be protective against NEC by stimulating hormone secretion, mucosal cell signaling, and peristalsis23, so this is potentially an important confounding variable in this study.
We were fortunate to have strong nursing support for probiotic use in our NICU, and many bedside nurses reported that babies were less fussy and had improved stooling patterns and consistency during the probiotic implementation period. This also represents a potential source of information bias, as bedside nurses may have been less likely to categorize stools as bloody.
Our probiotic protocol was initially planned and funded for 24 months, but we ceased probiotic use on September 29, 2023, when the FDA issued a warning regarding the risk of invasive, potentially fatal disease caused by use of probiotics in preterm infants. The majority of B. infantis sepsis or bacteremia case reports have occurred in babies with NEC or spontaneous intestinal perforation (SIP)24, and it is well known that when intestinal mucosal barrier is compromised, bacteria can translocate, leading to invasive infection. Bifidobacterium species are traditionally considered ubiquitous nonpathogenic commensal organisms and have low MICs (<0.5 mg/L) to beta-lactam antibiotics25, which makes them less pathogenic than the bloom of Proteobacteria that are known to proceed the development of NEC. Probiotic sepsis is a rare occurrence, and most cases result in recovery.26 On the other hand, NEC is a leading cause of death in premature babies and is a devastating disease with high mortality, morbidity, and neurodevelopmental disability27. Additionally, surgical NEC has been shown to have the highest total cost of all complications of prematurity28
Two proven and widely accepted interventions to decrease the risk of NEC are utilizing human milk22 and a standardized feeding protocol29. Data from meta-analyses support probiotic utilization as an intervention to decrease the risk of NEC. In 2023, just prior to the FDA warning, approximately 39% of NICUs in the U.S were using probiotics30. At that time, the percentage was steadily increasing; however, since the FDA warning, many NICUs have reported cessation of probiotic use.
This study demonstrates the benefits that probiotics can confer to premature babies. We saw a statistically significant decrease in NEC > stage 2, bloody stools, days to full enteral feeds, and TPN days. Our data supports continued research to determine optimal formulations and dosing of probiotics. Current evidence and our data support finding a path to gain FDA approval for probiotics to be used to prevent intestinal dysbiosis.