Clinical features
Patient 1, a male child, was born with a birth weight of 4100g and is the first child (G1P1) of healthy parents. The mother was 28 years old and the father was 29 years old at the time of his birth. No abnormalities were observed during the neonatal period. However, at the age of 1 year, the patient was diagnosed with a right-sided testicular hydrocele. At 2 years and 1 month, he experienced febrile convulsions, which recurred six times over the next two years. At the age of four, the patient experienced an unprovoked fall accompanied by minimal clonus in both upper limbs, which resolved within a few seconds without any noticeable impairment of consciousness. Subsequently, ten months later, the patient experienced another fall while walking. Brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and ambulatory electroencephalography (AEEG) conducted during interictal periods yielded normal results.().
Patient 2, a 10-year-old female, was delivered via cesarean section and had a birth weight of 3850g. Her mother was 20 years old and her father was 19 years old at the time of delivery. She is the first child (G1P1) of her parents. During a subsequent follow-up, she demonstrated deficiencies in object tracking and sound tracking abilities. Additionally, she had not yet achieved any developmental milestones and experienced her initial visible generalized tonic-clonic seizure at the age of 4 months. An electroencephalogram revealed the presence of spinous slow waves in the right anterior and middle temporal regions (Fig.1).Subsequently, she was prescribed oral solutions of sodium valproate and levetiracetam, as well as topiramate capsule, 4 months later, the seizure was achieved. At the age of 2 years, she showed obvious lack of language, rigid behavior, lack of interest and reaction to human voices, she also began to walk unsteadily and independently. After the age of 3 years, her parents described that she can speak only several single words, noticeable attention deficit, and an increase in activity and impulsivity. Brain MRI showed normal findings at the age of 4 months,19 months, and 3 years.
Patient 3, a 10-year-old male, was born to a mother with a history of two instances of embryonic development cessation. Despite being born in good health, he exhibited delayed developmental milestones, such as walking at the age of 2, and experienced his first febrile convulsion at the age of 5. Subsequently, he suffered from falls and generalized tonic-clonic seizures, which were successfully managed with the administration of Valproate.
Patient 4, a 6-year and 10-month-old female, had an unremarkable birth and developmental history. However, starting at 14 months of age, she experienced five episodes of febrile seizures.
Patient 5 was a 1-year,10-month-old boy. He has a severe global developmental delay, characterized by a lack of eye contact even with close individuals and unable to walk or speak. He started experiencing partial seizures at the age of 3 months and they remain very frequent despite taking VPA,TPM,VPA orally.
Figure 1 shows the electroencephalogram of patient2 and patient3;
Table 1 shows the clinical features and variants of all our patients and Literature patients reported before.
Table1:The clinical features and variants of all patients
f
|
Patient1
This study
|
Patient2
This study
|
Patient3
This study
|
Patient4
This study
|
Patient5
This study
|
Patient6[3]
|
Patient7[3]
|
Patient8[3]
|
Patient9[3]
|
Patient10[3]
9’s sister
|
Patient11[4]
|
Patient12[1]
|
Patient13[5]
|
Age/sex
|
7y5m/M
|
10y/F
|
10y/M
|
6y10m/F
|
1y10m/M
|
5.5m/F
|
32m/F
|
5 y/F
|
17y/M
|
13y/F
|
10m/M
|
11y/F
|
10y/F
|
variant
|
c.166C>T
p.Arg56Trp
|
c.862A>G
p.Thr288Ala
|
c.644T>C
p.Leu215Ser
|
c.988_989insTTATG
p.Glu330Valfs*22)
|
c.460C>G
p.Leu154Val
|
c.851T>C p.Val284Ala
|
c.871C>G p.Leu291Val
|
c.788T>C p.Met263Thr
|
c.975C>A p.Phe325Leu
|
c.975C>A p.Phe325Leu
|
c.1003A>C p.Asn335His
|
c.875C>A p.Thr292Lys
|
c.839C>T
p.Pro280Leu
|
Inheritance
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
Father (mosaic)
|
Father (mosaic)
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
De novo
|
Pregnancy/ neonatal mensurations
|
N / N
|
N / N
|
Two embryos stop developing with unknown causes before the patient were borned(G1,G2)/ N
|
N / N
|
N / N
|
N / N
|
Excess fetal hiccuping / N
|
N / N
|
N / N
|
N / N
|
N / N
|
NA
|
N / N
|
Neonatal findings
|
N
|
N
|
N
|
N
|
N
|
Hypotonia, failure to thrive, respiratory distress
|
Severe hypotonia
|
Hypotonia, respiratory distress
|
Jaundice
|
NA
|
Severe hypotonia, neonatal hypothermia
|
NA
|
N
|
Age of walking
|
N
|
Around 36m
|
24m
|
N
|
Can't walk independently
|
Too young
|
Not able
|
Not able
|
14m
|
Around 12 m
|
Too young
|
Not able
|
NA
|
Current language ability
|
N
|
Very poor,several single words
|
N
|
N
|
Severe
|
Too young
|
Not able
|
Very low
|
Decreased ability
|
Slightly decreased
|
Too young
|
Not able
|
Decreased Comprehension,expression
|
Cognitive development
|
N
|
Severe
|
N
|
N
|
Severe
|
Severe
|
Profound
|
Severe
|
Moderate
|
Mild/moderate
|
Severe
|
Profound
|
Sever
|
ASD
|
No
|
Yes
|
NO
|
No
|
Yes
|
Too young
|
NA
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
Too young
|
NA
|
Yes
|
Age at seizure onset
|
2y1m
|
4m
|
5y
|
1y2m
|
3m
|
1m
|
1d
|
2d
|
17y
|
2y
|
10w
|
6w
|
15m
|
Seizure type at onset
|
Fever seizure,Generalized tonic-clonic
|
Generalized tonic-clonic
|
Fever seizure,drop seizure, and generalized tonic-clonic
|
Fever seizure
|
Focal seizure
|
Ocular revulsion
|
Ocular version,Focal clonic
|
Generalized tonic-clonic
|
Complex partial
|
Complex partial
|
Mastication and blinking
|
Clustered focal seizures, spasms
|
EIEE
|
Seizure types during disease course
|
Fever seizure,and drop seizure
|
Generalized tonic-clonic
|
Fever seizure,drop seizure, and generalized seizure
|
Fever seizure
|
Focal seizure
|
Absences, clonic
|
Behavioral arrests, clonic, tonic
|
Spasm, clonic
|
Generalized tonic-clonic
|
Complex partial
|
Hypertonus, grimacing and facial flushing, partial tonic with clonic eyelid movements
|
Tonic, tonic-clonic and myoclonic
|
Tonic with upward eye deviation, or eye and head deviation to either side
|
Status epilepticus
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No
|
Yes
|
NA
|
N
|
No
|
Frequency of seizures,max
|
2/w
|
10/d
|
4/w
|
Only had 5
|
6/d
|
20/d
|
15/d
|
10/d
|
Only had 3
|
NA
|
At least once daily
|
N
|
N
|
Current AETs
|
No
|
LEV
|
VPA
|
No
|
OXC,TPM,VPA
|
VPA, PHT
|
PB, CLB, CLN, VPA, TPM
|
Sabril, hydrocortisone
|
LTG
|
OXC
|
TPM, GVG
|
VPA, PB, CLB
|
VPA, CLB
|
Pharmacoresistance
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
No with treatment
|
No with treatment
|
Partial response
|
Yes
|
N
|
Head circumference, SD
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
-1
|
-2
|
-3.75
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
0
|
Neurological examination
|
N
|
Hypotonia, ADHD
|
N
|
N
|
Global developmental delay
|
Hypotonia, pyramidal syndrome
|
Severe hypotonia, reduced reflexes, cortical visual impairment
|
Hypotonia
|
Features of autism
|
N
|
Severe hypotonia, choreiform movements
|
Severe hypotonia, spasticity, cortical visual impairment
|
Hypotonia, ADHD, developmental delay
|
MRI: age / main abnormalities
|
2y1m/N
|
4m, 19m, 3y/N
|
5y/N
|
1y/N
|
3m/N
|
3m/N
|
23m/generalized brain atrophy, abnormal myelination; CC thin and short
|
2y/N
|
17y/N
|
13y/N
|
10w/N
|
9y/
hypomyelination
|
Normal,19 m
|
EEG: age / main abnormalities
|
2y1m, 2y10m, 4y1m, 4y11m/N
|
4m/spinous slow waves in the anterior and middle temporal regions
|
5y, widespread spinous slow waves discharging during sleep
|
1y/N
|
3m/A large number of multifocal spikes, sharp waves, sharp slow waves, and fast waves rhythms were observed during sleep
|
2m/isolated spike,rapid rythm
|
28 m / multifocal spikes right and left hemisphere; generalized spikes and polyspikes
|
8d/discontinous, diffuse spike
|
17y/normal, bilateral frontal/ fronto-central sharp activity, but not truly epileptiform
|
NA
|
Fast background activity and left centro-parietal spikes
|
2y/slow and disorganized back ground with multifocal epileptic form discharges
|
Onset of epilepsy was normal,but later investigations showed slow and irregular background activity, without paroxysmal activity
|
N: normal
NA:can’t obtain the information because of Lost access or other reasons
Molecular Findings
In the study, we identified five variants in GABRA2 among the five unrelated families. These variants included four missense variants (c.166C>T, p.Arg56Trp; c.862A>G, p.Thr288Ala; c.644T>C, p.Leu215Ser; c.460C>G, p.Leu154Val) and one frameshift variant (c.988_c.989insTTATG, p.Glu330Valfs*22). None of these variants were previously reported and they were not found in various databases such as dbSNP, 1000 Genome Project, ExAC, ESP, gnomAD, and our inhouse database. To validate their authenticity, Sanger sequencing was performed (Figure 2). According to ACMG standards and guidelines, these variants were rated as Uncertain significance,Pathogenic or likely Pathogenic(PS2_Moderate+PM2_Supporting+PP2+PP3=VUS; PS2_Moderate +PM1+PM2_Supporting+PP2 +PP3=LP; PS2_Moderate +PM1+PM2_Supporting +PP2+PP3=LP; PVS1+ PS2_Moderate +PM2_Supporting=P; PS2_Moderate+PM1+PM2_Supporting+PP2+PP3=LP; respectively).
In silico Analysis result
GABRA2 is a transmembrane protein with three main domains: Signal peptide (pink), Neu_chan_lig-bd(green), and Neu_chan_memb(purple); M1,M2,M3,M4 are the four transmembrane areas. (Figure 3A,3B). So far, all 7 reported variants are located in the Neu_chan_memb domain, two of the five variants identified in this study are also located in this domain, the second/third transmembrane areas(M2/M3) to be more exactly, the other three located in Neu_chan_lig-bd domain(Figure 3B). Protein conservation analysis in 15 species revealed all of these five variants were located in highly conserved regions.(Figure 3C).
The 3D structure of wild type and mut. type GABRA2: Arg56(wild) vs Trp56(mut.), Thr288(wild) vs Ala288(mut.), Leu215(wild) vs Ser215(mut.), Leu154(wild) vs Val154(mut.) see Figures 4A-4F, show hydrogen bond and protein sequence changes.