Higher taxonomic levels, such as phylum and class, do not always show differences when comparing two different conditions. Metagenomic studies comparing water from the Doce River, impacted after the collapse of the Fundão dam, with water from the Paraguaçu River (not impacted) showed similar bacterial community composition at the phylum level and different at other taxonomic levels (Cordeiro et al. 2019). In our study, a similarity in the density of Bacteroidetes was observed in the treatments without plants in the first sampling. In the Epsylon-proteobacteria class, this similarity occurred in the second sampling in the treatments with L. leucocephala. All the other phyla and classes evaluated had differences in at least one of the treatments with different proportions of tailings. A study carried out in the mining spill region of the Iron Quadrangle in the state of Minas Gerais, Brazil, verified the microbial and metabolic diversity in unimpacted and tailings-impacted soils after the revegetation process using sequencing of the V4-V5 region of 16S rRNA. The results revealed that Bacteroidetes were among the predominant microorganisms after revegetation. The predominant phyla they found were also Proteobacteria, followed by Acidobacteria, Verrucomicrobia, Planctomycetes and Bacteroidetes. Bacteria from vegetated soil showed high metabolic diversity and the presence of genes linked to resistance to iron-containing environments (Fernandes et al. 2018).
The presence of the legume influenced the density of Bacteroidetes and bacteria of the genus Pseudomonas. The lowest densities of these bacteria were found in the treatments without L. leucocephala, which differed from the treatments with the plant in both samplings. Bacteria of the genus Pseudomonas spp. were not found in the tailings without plants. In this same sampling and in the second one, the presence of these bacteria was observed, although in lower densities in this treatment with L. leucocephala. Species of Pseudomonas exhibit remarkable metabolic diversity, allowing them to thrive in various environments and serve as beneficial inoculants and plant growth promoters (Saati-Santamaría et al. 2022; Mehmood et al. 2023). These bacteria use root exudates, produce compounds that are toxic to pathogenic fungi and bacteria and chelate iron, contributing to plant health and growth (Guzmán-Guzmán and Santoyo 2022; Sanow et al. 2023). When introduced into metal-contaminated soils, Pseudomonas species have been shown to promote remediation by aiding in the detoxification and immobilization of heavy metals, thus contributing to the restoration of soil health and fertility (Shaheen et al. 2022). Their ability to improve plant growth, fight pathogens and aid in metal detoxification underlines the valuable contributions of Pseudomonas to sustainable agriculture and environmental remediation efforts. In addition to Protobacteria and other bacteria, Pseudomonas are ACC deaminase-producing, an enzyme can help alleviate the heavy metals toxicity. This enzyme promotes root growth by hydrolyzing ACC, the immediate precursor of ethylene, a plant hormone related to senescence and oxidative stress (Etesami 2018). In addition, mechanisms of Pseudomonas sp. action include nitrogen fixation, nutrient availability (i.e., K and P solubilization with the production of organic acids, siderophores and phosphatases), resistance to pathogens and alterations in soil microbiome (Bressanin et al. 2022). Their study with tailings from the Fundão dam found greater growth and survival of Hymenaea courbaril seedlings when the substrate was inoculated with Pseudomonas. Their resistance to metals further underlines their suitability for phytostabilization processes, emphasizing the importance of microbial community dynamics in the successful efforts of these processes.
Regardless of the presence or absence of L. leucocephala in the substrates, the density of Acidobacteria, Actinobacteria and bacteria from the Firmicutes phylum differed between the time intervals between samples. Acidobacteria plays significant ecological roles, as evidenced through their active participation in key carbon, nitrogen, and sulfur biogeochemical circuits (Kalam et al. 2020). Studies suggest that the abundance of the Actinobacteria and Firmicutes phyla is significantly correlated with metal-contaminated environments (Fernandes et al. 2018). Over time, the densities of these bacteria in the rhizosphere increased, especially in the treatments with little or no tailings. Soils with deposits of zinc waste were re-vegetated with eight plant species, and after 5 years sequencing was carried out to verify the structure and diversity of the bacterial community (Luo et al. 2018). The authors observed that revegetation promoted an increase in the microbial community in the rhizosphere of the plants, among the phyla that increased were Proteobacteria, Acidobacteria, and Bacteroidetes, and there was also an increase in the abundance of plant growth-promoting bacteria. In an ecosystem belonging to a historical area of the Iron Quadrangle, Minas Gerais, Brazil, which suffered mining activities until its total depletion, observed that Proteobacteria was the most predominant phylum, followed by others with emphasis on Acidobacteria and Bacteroidetes, as also observed in our study (Fernandes et al. 2018). According to the authors, this is an important component of natural bioremediation in iron mining areas undergoing a regeneration process. Emenike et al. (2023) also observed that bioremediation was enhanced in metal-contaminated soil by consortia of proteobacteria. According to the authors, ureolytic (urease-producing) microorganisms such as proteobacteria possess the potential to ameliorate soils contaminated with a vast spectrum of heavy metal(loid)s. Proteobacteria considerably increased the bioreduction rate of As, Cu, Zn, Mn and Cr, making them potential remediation agents for the bioreduction of heavy metal(loid)s in contaminated environments.
Acidic environments such as mining tailings can harbor Acidobacteria and Actinobacteria (Johnson and Aguilera 2016). These bacteria can live in these acidic, metal-rich environments because they have heavy metal resistance mechanisms. These bacteria can be used as biomarkers after contamination by mining tailings containing iron, as they may possess genes related to the iron cycle (Haferburg and Kothe 2007; El Baz et al. 2015; Kelly et al. 2023). In the iron ore waste used in the present study, the iron concentrations were five times higher in the pure tailings treatments when compared to the treatments without tailings (Freitas et al. 2023). The impact of the deposition of tailings from the Fundão dam caused an increase in soil density and silt content, reducing macroporosity, microbial biomass carbon, basal respiration, enzymatic activity and the density of some microbial groups (Silva et al. 2021). However, they observed that some microbial functional groups had a higher density in these areas, which shows the potential of revegetation to increase the quality of this environment. The presence of vegetation favors the development of resistant microorganisms by supplying nutrients and energy through the deposition of organic matter, as well as by the release of exudates by the roots (Valentim dos Santos et al. 2016). In addition, the authors state that when stressful conditions occur in the soil, such as contamination by heavy metals, contaminant-resistant groups tend to increase their population competitively in relation to less resistant ones. Thus, the population can even reach higher values than those observed in uncontaminated sites. Our results corroborate these findings.
In a research into the ecological restoration of mine tailings, significant differences were also observed in the relative abundance of the Alpha- and Delta-proteobacteria classes, and bacteria from the Acidobacteria, Firmicutes and Nitrospira (Li et al. 2016). In our work, the number of bacteria from the Firmicutes phylum, and the Delta, Gamma and Beta-proteobacteria classes were lower where there were only mining tailings without the presence of the plant. In the presence of L. leucocephala and over time, the number of bacteria increased in the treatments with the lowest proportions of tailings. In the treatments with 100% tailings, the number of these bacteria remained lower than in the other treatments, possibly due to the influence of the compounds present in the tailings over time. Considering the two factors together, the presence of plants and the time interval, the difference among the treatments was found among the proteobacteria of the epsylon, gamma and beta classes, including the Gallionella ferruginea species. The average density of Epsylon-proteobacteria found was lower in the treatments with only tailings, with and without L. leucocephala in both samplings, indicating that the more tailings the lower the number of these bacteria. However, in the presence of plants, the densities of this class were higher in all treatments at 8 months after planting and lower at 14 months. The presence of the plant seems to have influenced the growth of these bacteria only initially. All the classes of proteobacteria evaluated were the predominant group in all the treatments and over time. This was the case even though the densities of bacteria belonging to the Alpha-proteobacteria class were not evaluated and even though there was no difference in the densities of bacteria belonging to the Delta-proteobacteria class between treatments with or without the presence of L. leucocephala, nor between sampling times. The most abundant class of proteobacteria was the Gamma-proteobacteria class. The presence of Gamma-proteobacteria can improve the environmental stability of tailings. In environments with mining tailings containing iron, copper and gold, when subjected to acidification, they were able to promote the adsorption of metals such as arsenic, cobalt, lead, zinc, nickel and chromium, inhibiting the leaching of these metals(Henne et al. 2019).
A study that compared the microbial community in a river impacted (Doce River) and another not impacted (Paraguaçu River) by the Fundão dam tailings spill also found a predominance of proteobacteria in both rivers (Cordeiro et al. 2019). However, when other taxonomic levels were evaluated, it was observed that in the impacted river there was a predominance of Bacteroidetes, Gamma-proteobacteria and Actinobacteria, and in the non-impacted river there was a predominance of Beta-proteobacteria. The authors concluded that the tailings altered the microbial community of the Doce River. Their genomic analysis of the bacteria found in the impacted samples also showed that there was an increase in genes linked to microbial virulence, respiration, membrane transport (efflux pump for metals), iron and nitrogen metabolism (denitrification and nitrogen fixation), and microbial motility. However, amino acid, fatty acid, carbohydrate and pigment metabolism genes decreased in the bacteria found in the impacted water samples.
The density of Gallionella ferruginea bacteria in the treatments without plants showed no statistical difference. After eight months of plant cultivation, the number of bacteria increased in the treatments that did not contain 100% tailings, and after 14 months of cultivation, the T75% and T100% treatments had a decrease in the number of these microorganisms. According to Reis et al. (2014), absence or reduction in Gallionella density in remediated environments after mining activities can be used as an indicator of reaching the end point of remediation processes. G. ferruginea is an acidophilic bacterium and can grow microaerophilically in an environment with the presence of metals, promoting the oxidation of ferrous iron (Ayangbenro et al. 2018). G. ferruginea obtains all of its cellular carbon from CO2 fixation when grown under aerobic gradient conditions in a mineral salt solution with iron sulfide. Adding a new carbon source, such as glucose, increases carbon uptake and leads to a decrease in CO2 fixation (Hallbeck and Pedersen 1991; Eggerichs et al. 2020). Legumes can release exudates through their roots, the exudates contain glucose and fructose, and can promote the acidification of the medium, and the development of microorganisms that adapt to these conditions (Chaer et al. 2011). Consequently, this leads to a high average density of microorganisms and a low respiration rate, as observed in the treatments with the presence of leucaena and throughout the study period. Experiments carried out to investigate the effect of temperature (20 and 35°C) and bacterial diversity by sequencing the 16S rRNA gene, in samples of acid drainage from the Carnoulès mine (France), observed that the temperature of 20°C, provides the dominance of iron-oxidizing bacteria, such as Gallionella spp. was associated with almost complete oxidation of iron (98%) (Tardy et al. 2018). In experiments using water samples without the influence of human activity from the Sucio River (Costa Rica), which originates from volcanic rocks, 89.39% of the sequences were identified as proteobacteria by sequencing, in particular the Betaproteobacteria class (80.16%). Of these, the largest proportion (43.89%) were bacteria from the genus Gallionella. Bacteria of this species have been considered key in the Sucio river ecosystem, as they participate in iron and sulphur metabolism (Arce-Rodríguez et al. 2017). On the other hand, in samples of neutral drainage water from the Elizabeth well mine, Slovinky (Slovakia), the composition of the bacterial population was characterized and the presence of iron-oxidizing Proteobacteria of the Gallionella and Leptothrix genera was observed, the occurrence of which did not change during the years 2008 to 2014 (Kisková et al. 2018). Therefore, Gallionella spp. is present in natural environments without anthropogenic action and in mineral extraction environments.
The increase in the number of prokaryotes in the treatment with tailings after 1 year and 2 months of planting L. leucocephala does not correspond to the bacteria identified with the probes used. None of the bacteria evaluated showed a higher density in this treatment at that time (T100% with L. leucocephala planted 14 months ago). In this way, not even 10% of the prokaryotes accounted for by DAPI staining were identified. These prokaryotes may be Archaea and/or the probes used do not have the specificity to reach all the bacteria in their taxonomic group. Among the 12% of Archaea found, there was a predominance of the Euryarcheota phylum in the water samples from the areas impacted by the Fundão dam collapse (Cordeiro et al. 2019).
The potential use of microorganisms in bioremediation depends on their identification and also on their ability to be cultivated and kept alive. Many of the microorganisms found in mine drainage do not grow in known culture media to date. In order to identify them, it is necessary to sequence them, assemble their genomes and compare them with a database, which is constantly being updated (Bressanin et al. 2022; Santos et al. 2023). Many microorganisms present in extreme environments have yet to be identified and/or classified. The omics era (metagenomics, proteomics, metabolomics, transcriptomics, etc.) has opened up new ways of understanding the nature and functionality of extremophilic microorganisms. They still face limitations related to sampling practices, handling, storage, processing and interpretation of the range of data generated (Gupta et al. 2019).
Interactions among members of microbial communities are often fundamental to their roles as bioremediators and biostimulators. One microorganism can produce metabolites and be used by another microorganism, and the interaction between them promotes growth. Often, these interactions enable behavior (gene expression) that neither party could perform in isolation (Marx 2009; Hillesland 2018). Evidence of co-occurrence and metabolic dependence with other bacteria has been found in two bacteria belonging to the Saccharimonadia class from copper mines (Lemos et al. 2019). These bacteria found by them have small genomes and do not contain genes associated with the biosynthesis of essential amino acids, nucleotides, fatty acids and cofactors, requiring them to live in symbiosis with other bacteria, such as those of the Hydrotalea genus. Understanding the interactions between microorganisms tends to bring the concept of a microbial community into practice. That is, using a group of bacteria from different species, or even a group of Bacteria, Archaea and Fungi.