We have developed a user friendly, adaptable virtual biobank platform for infectious disease specimen collections in Australia. We provide detailed descriptions of the technical design and process for the development of the Australian Partnership for Preparedness Research on InfectiouS disease Emergencies (APPRISE) Virtual Biobank. The APPRISE Virtual Biobank provides a tangible example of a value-adding, collaborative approach to improve biospecimen access for existing, distributed biospecimen collections.
With the launch of the Virtual Biobank, we demonstrate the potential for drawing together existing infectious disease biospecimen collections in a central platform without requiring changes to ethical and governance arrangements. The Virtual Biobank provides near real-time details of specimens that may be available for further research, which has been promoted to the infectious disease research and response community (Smith et al., 2023). The Virtual Biobank is also a platform which can be further developed and expanded in response to future needs.
A key consideration for the development of the Virtual Biobank was the need to engage with collections within scope of their existing ethics and governance arrangements. This ‘light touch’ ethics approach meant that no changes were required to the ethics approvals for participating collections, which was a motivating factor for some Data Custodians. Despite this, site specific governance approvals were still rigorously applied, with some sites requiring additional approvals. Now that the Virtual Biobank has been established, it is easily expandable to additional collections using the current engagement model. We also have commenced discussion with both existing and potential Data Custodians about an expansion of the data available through the portal which may require future ethics and governance changes. The ‘light touch’ approach also very clearly leaves the existing governance processes in place for specimen access, addressing one of the key concerns of Data Custodians (i.e. ensuring that they retain control over who can access their specimens).
The virtual biobank concept is not new. Virtual biobanks have been implemented to draw together multiple collections within a single institution (Zhang et al., 2015), and to connect resources across multiple organisations, either nationally (Saginur et al., 2023) or internationally (Ongarello, Fernandez Suarez, & Betsou, 2022). These have typically been large collaborations focussed on samples for commercial applications (Ongarello et al., 2022; Watson, Clark, & Williams, 2021) or to support large co-ordinated sample collection efforts (Saginur et al., 2023), (Asperger et al., 2021). Virtual biobanks have been noted for their benefits to transparency and sample metadata curation, particularly in the context of specimens for use in diagnostic test development where sample provenance and quality assurance is critical (Ongarello et al., 2022; Watson et al., 2021). The APPRISE Virtual Biobank is novel in three key aspects: 1) it enables the integration of specimen collections within the context of (and in parallel with) their existing governance arrangements, 2) it provides a (near) real-time snapshot of available specimens and not just a catalogue of specimens available at the time of integration and 3) it includes specimen collections across a diversity of institutions and database setups.
The current iteration of the APPRISE Virtual Biobank is a proof-of-concept that disparate studies can be drawn together in a harmonised way. The technical architecture is adaptable for easy integration of additional collections, as well as for expanding the data available on specimens within the portal. Through the development of the Virtual Biobank, we have fostered understanding of the infrastructure and data-related elements associated with infectious disease specimen collection in Australia. An expansion of the Virtual Biobank is already underway, and in future we can see potential to harmonise protocols for consent and specimen access and to provide quality assurance metrics, for example by noting collections that meet recognised quality standards e.g. ISO standards (National Association of Testing Authorities, 2024), or PBMC processing standards (Dyer et al., 2007). In the first instance, a pre-established Material Transfer Agreement could be considered for participating collections, as already exists for some distributed infectious disease collections (Saginur et al., 2023).
The Virtual Biobank project will enable further discussions around the purpose and process of specimen collection and use for infectious disease research. By improving the visibility and accessibility of existing collections, discussion of ongoing storage and access sustainability can be facilitated. This could include furthering the idea to link some collections together through a centralised governance mechanism, particularly when the study is no longer active. We can also focus collective attention on the desired outputs of biobanking efforts, including the distribution of samples for additional research and supporting new collaborations (Rush et al., 2020). The Virtual Biobank also addresses an almost universal concern among specimen donors and collection holders that valuable biospecimens are collected and stored, but not used (Cadigan et al., 2013). By making existing collections visible, they become more accessible, and we hope to enable a more streamlined access process in the next iteration where a harmonised application form could be considered by the separate governance bodies.
The process of establishing the APPRISE Virtual Biobank has not been without challenges. There was an initial cautiousness from some Data Custodians to engage in the project. In some cases, the Data Custodians and study leads were very keen to participate, but further discussion was required to ensure they received the institutional support to do so. The different institutional contexts for each participating collection presented a complex range of requirements, both formal and informal. This included the need to identify the relevant contact points for IT, security and database issues (often changing, or unknown to study investigators), navigating institutional governance approval processes and obtaining the necessary internal IT and security permissions. This all took time, and often required technical discussion. A further challenge was the need for flexibility to access or allocate IT resources – some institutions were able to do this without hesitation, whereas others required the project to purchase independent IT infrastructure.
The APPRISE Virtual Biobank brings together distributed infectious disease biospecimen collections. We have started with collections focussed on SARS-CoV-2, since these were active and recruiting during the development process. The platform, however, is easily extendable to collections in other disease areas, including pathogen collections. Now that we have established the process for integration of collections into the Virtual Biobank, it will be quicker and easier to bring new collections onboard. This is an important contribution to pandemic preparedness, with rapid access to high-quality specimens needed to progress infectious disease research including the development of diagnostics and treatments as well as investigation of disease pathogenesis and host impacts (Peeling, Boeras, Wilder-Smith, Sall, & Nkengasong, 2020).