The highlight of the study was the analysis of mutations of the Beta thalassemia gene in a large number of antenatal women from a North Indian population. One in every twenty antenatal women was found to be HA carrier. The relationship of hematological parameters with different mutations of HA, and NDA was delved upon. Among beta thalassemia mutations, IVS1-5 was the most common. There was real-world implementation of a simple algorithm to provide prenatal diagnosis to the couples, which can be useful in low and middle-income countries (LMIC). For every 253 women tested, one with HA trait couple was identified. One thalassemia major case was prevented per 1000 women screened. The challenges faced in the LMIC and the tropical country set up ranged from high incidence of HA carriers in this part of the world to the presence of concomitant NDA cases making the diagnosis difficult. Delay in the antenatal booking was also a hurdle in the management.
High incidence of HA carriers in the population
The National Capital Territory (NCT) of Delhi is a largest metropolitan city in India and is densely populated with an estimated population of 18.6 million in 2016 6. It has a heterogenous demographic profile significant representation from numerous ethnic groups and religious communities, such as Sindhis, Punjabis, Bengalis, Mahars, Kolis, Saraswats, Lohanas and Gaurs 6. In the present study the incidence of carrier status of hemolytic anemia in antenatal women coming to the tertiary hospital of Delhi was 4.55%, which was higher than the pooled prevalence of beta-thalassemia carriers for Indian population (3.74%, 95% CI 2.52–4.97) and nearly same as its estimation among tribal groups (4.6%, 95% CI 3.2–6.2) 7. The higher number of HA in the study may be accounted for by our hospital being a tertiary care center, and receiving many high-risk cases. The prevalence of β-thal trait in central India is estimated to range between 1.4 and 3.4% 8, in South India, it is between 8.5% and 37.9% 9. The Northern and Western Indian states have a higher thalassemic burden as it is more prevalent in ethnic communities 10.
Diagnosis of carrier state late in pregnancy
Screening for HA should be done during adolescence or premaritally. However, due to lack of awareness and government commitment apart from many other sociodemographic reasons, premarital screening is still in its infancy in India. The antenatal period is considered to be the best practical time to screen as the population comes in contact with the hospital services during this time. It is also the final opportunity to provide a prenatal diagnosis if both partners are traits. In the present study, only one-quarter of women came for antenatal check-up during the first trimester, leading to late diagnosis. Screening for HA should be done early in pregnancy as it requires an algorithm. A concentrated effort towards education and awareness of the coming generations is constantly needed in the complex and heterogeneous Indian population.
Confrontation in diagnosis due to concurrent NDA
The HbA2 cut-off of 3.5% for HA carriers along with reduced MCV (< 80fl) and MCH (< 27pg) along with a relatively high RBC count and normal RDW is taken as HA. Due to high Iron deficiency anemia (IDA), the microcytosis and hypochromia due to IDA may blur the HA picture making the diagnosis based on the CBC report alone, a difficult task. In the present study, the majority of HA and NDA had moderate anemia, the MCV levels were significantly low in HA and was a better parameter compared to MCH, similar findings have been observed in other studies also 11. HPLC testing is a useful adjunct as a screening modality of thalassemia, but CBC is needed additionally in cases with HPLC between 3.2–4.0% 11, 12. The RBC count and RDW provides vital information, hence, should be analyzed when HBA2 is in the borderline range.
Limitations of RBC indices in HBD and HBE
In HBD carriers, although the mean hemoglobin was found to be low, however, the MCV, MCH, and Mentzer index was in the normal range, hence could be diagnosed with certainty by HPLC only. Similarly, in HBE traits, the indices were lowered only marginally and could not be identified by the Mentzer index but could be diagnosed on HPLC due to the high HbA2 levels. For Beta thalassemia mutations, the Mentzer index was a good parameter to suspect the thalassemia trait. However, borderline/normal HbA2 levels (3.0–3.9%) may often lead to a diagnostic dilemma. Previous studies have shown that borderline HbA2 with near normal or reduced red cell indices is most often due to the cap site + 1 (A > C) mutation and the poly-A (T > C) mutation, several other β thalassemia carriers show borderline or normal HbA2 levels common among them is the presence of δ gene mutations which could reduce HbA2 levels significantly 13. β genotyping should be done in a couple when one of the partners is a classical carrier of β thalassemia 13.
Logistics of screening and molecular test in LMIC
The husband was called for HPLC and CBC only when the HPLC report of the wife was abnormal so the burden of doing the husband’s HPLC in all 7077 cases could be avoided and was instead performed in 392 cases only. Also, the mutations were required in the 38/7077(0.5%) couples when both partners had abnormal HPLC reports. The Sanger sequencing of beta-globin gene was needed only in 14/7077 (0.2%) couples, and in the rest 24 cases, the mutations could be ascertained on ARMS PCR which is cheaper alternative in terms of consumables and equipment.
Relative distribution of HA mutation in the study population
More than 350 different mutations of beta-globin gene have been reported so far 14. However, Many studies have suggested that, the four most common mutations IVS I-5 (G→C), Codon 41/42 (- TCTT), 619-bp deletion and FS 8/9 (+ G) account for nearly 90% of the thalassemia mutations 2, 12, 15. HbS is more frequently observed in the tribal populations, HbE in the eastern region, and HbD in Punjab 12. It is also important to remember that couples at risk of having a baby with certain conditions like HbD-hereditary persistence of fetal hemoglobin (HPFH), HbD-β-thalassemia, and homozygous HbD or HbE disease do not require prenatal diagnosis as they would usually have a very mild clinical presentation and they can lead a normal life 16. In our study also, the prenatal diagnosis was not done as both partners had HBE carrier status 10.
Strengths and weakness of the study
The strength of the study was the, prospective inclusion of a large cohort of antenatal women. The detection of the genotype status of the carriers provided the data of the relative distribution of the HA mutations in the population. The weakness could be that the data was hospital based hence selective and thus not easily exploitable to estimate the true burden of the disease.