In the current study, we analysed behavioural and emotional problems, quality of life, anxiety, and depressive status of children with CPP (at diagnosis and at follow-up), and compared the results with age- and sex-matched healthy controls. In terms of behavioural and emotional problems, quality of life, anxiety and depressive status, the CPP groups did not differ from age-matched controls.
In contrast to previous reports on elevated behavioral and emotional problems in children with CPP[24], we found no significant differences in SDQ-A and SDQ-P scores between the three groups. In both groups with CPP, children and parents reported similar behavioural and emotional problems with CG. During puberty, it is known that psychological changes are known to follow physiological changes as a result of the activation of hypothalamic-pituitary axis[25]. As the children in the CPP group were younger and the possible effects of hormonal changes were treated in the early period, it is suggested that children diagnosed with CPP did not experience any emotional and behavioural differences. The fact that both parents and children consistently reported no emotional and behavioural changes, strengthens this conclusion.
In TURGAY scale which evaluates the symptoms of attention deficit hyperactivity, oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder, similar scores were found between the three groups. During adolescence, children experience some behavioural and emotional difficulties, increased risk-taking behaviour and impulsivity as well as difficulties in controlling anger[26]. In a cross-sectional study conducted in 2023, externalising behaviours were found to be more prevalent in female adolescents with CPP compared to the control group[27]. In another study, although the score assessing externalising behaviours was not considered to be clinically significant, it was found to be higher in adolescent girls compared to the control group. It was also suggested that the effect on behaviour emerged at a later age[28]. The findings of our study indicate that, although biological markers of adolescence have been observed in children, it is believed that their behavioural manifestations are more closely associated with their psychosocial developmental stage and chronological age than with this biological process. Furthermore, the data suggest that children do not exhibit behavioural patterns that are unique to the adolescent period.
The majority of studies conducted thus far on precocious puberty in children have focused on girls. In some of these studies, elevated rates of depression and anxiety have been observed in children experiencing precocious puberty[14], [29]. The onset of menarche has been shown as a reason for depressive symptoms[29]. Among anxiety disorders, social anxiety, which is associated with a lower self-image, has been reported to be more prevalent[15]. Conversely, similar to our study, some studies have reported that the groups diagnosed and treated with CPP did not exhibit any differences in terms of depressive and anxiety symptoms[30]. It is known that there should be a serious psychosocial stressor for the emergence of depression in childhood in association with the development of children's cognitive and emotional abilities[31]. Since the children in our study were relatively younger, it is thought that they did not differ from healthy children in terms of depressive and anxiety symptoms, even if they exhibited symptoms of adolescence.
It is established that children with a chronic disease experience a negative impact on their quality of life[32], [33]. There are limited studies that have analysed the quality of life of children with precocious puberty. In one of these studies, the CPP group included both treated and newly diagnosed children and no significant differences were identified in the quality of life of this group in comparison to healthy children[15]. In another study a total of 193 children were examined, including 59 children with CPP, 53 children with premature telarche, and 81 healthy children and their parents. No significant differences were found between the CPP, PT and control groups[1]. In our study, the quality of life of the group of children newly diagnosed with CPP and the group of children who had been receiving treatment for at least one year was found to be similar to that of healthy children according to both self-report and parental report. The favourable response to treatment and the absence of significant adverse effects during the treatment indicate that psychological well-being in children is associated with a high level of quality of life.
It should be noted that our study has some limitations. First of all, the limited sample size makes it difficult to generalise our results. Although children's psychiatric symptoms were assessed through scales, it is possible that structured psychiatric interviews for children might yield more accurate diagnoses of potential psychiatric disorders. A more detailed evaluation of children's physical characteristics such as height and weight, which change with the puberty process, could have provided a more accurate interpretation of the results. Furthermore, psychological problems that may arise in the longer term can be evaluated by longitudinal follow-up of the study groups.