This study demonstrated that cognitive function was impaired in Mecp2 KO mice, and ghrelin improved the cognition of objects and investigatory behaviors. An investigation of the mechanism for cognitive deficits revealed that the dopamine responses to external stimuli were attenuated and the dopamine reuptake system was upregulated in the PFC of Mecp2 KO mice (Fig. 6A, 6B). Ghrelin restored the dopamine responses to external stimuli in the PFC of Mecp2 KO mice. As the ability of D1 receptor signaling to inhibit dopamine release would be upregulated and/or its ability to stimulate dopamine release would be downregulated in the PFC of Mecp2 KO mice, ghrelin likely adjusted the altered function of dopamine D1 receptor signaling (Fig. 6B, 6C). Thus, ghrelin has beneficial effects on cognitive deficits via dopaminergic mechanisms in Mecp2 KO mice. The findings of this study proposes that ghrelin and GHSR agonists that increase dopamine D1 receptor signaling are promising pharmacological approach to improve cognitive function in RTT.
Effect of ghrelin on cognitive deficits in Mecp2 KO mice
Cognitive impact of ghrelin and GHSR agonists has been reported in animal models with a diverse range of pathology of cognitive deficits [8, 39, 40]. Consistently, ghrelin increased cognition of objects and investigatory behavior in Mecp2 KO mice in the present study, although the impairment of recognition memory was not improved. It is possible that cognitive function in Mecp2 KO mice could be more severely impaired compared to Mecp2R168X mutant mice, another mouse model for RTT [41], and other animal models for various pathologies of diseases. In fact, more sufficient effects of ghrelin on recognition memory were observed in animal models for Alzheimer's disease [10], sepsis [42] and dwarf [43].
The ghrelin/GHSR signaling pathway could be downregulated in the animal models with cognitive deficits. Indeed, ghrelin KO mice exhibit impairment of recognition memory [10] and ghrelin-O-acyl transferase (GOAT) KO mice, lacking an enzyme that catalyzes acyl modification to generate active form of ghrelin (octanoyl-ghrelin), exhibit impaired memory function [44]. So far, there is little information available about plasma ghrelin levels in MecP2 KO mice [45]. In humans, plasma levels of ghrelin are high during infancy, decrease until puberty and then increase to adult levels [46, 47]. In RTT patients, plasma levels of ghrelin continue to decrease after 10 years and are kept low during adulthood [46, 48] and low levels of plasma ghrelin reflect clinical symptoms such as eating difficulties [49]. Low levels of plasma ghrelin has also been reported in patients with cognitive deterioration suffering from mild traumatic brain injury [50], Parkinson's disease [51] and type 2 diabetes mellitus [52]. These studies in humans suggest that low levels of plasma ghrelin may be causally related to cognitive deficits in RTT patients. Developmental changes in plasma ghrelin levels and correlation between plasma ghrelin levels and the severity of cognitive deficits in MecP2 KO mice should be determined in future studies.
Dopaminergic pathology in the PFC of Mecp2 KO mice
Dopamine in the PFC is known to respond to nociceptive stimuli such as saline injection [30]. The dopamine response to external stimuli such as saline injection and novel environment observed in the PFC of WT mice is attenuated in the PFC of Mecp2 KO mice, suggesting that cognition of nociceptive stimuli and novel environment is impaired in Mecp2 KO mice. In RTT patients, decreased pain sensitivity is reported by parents and carers in two-thirds of subjects [53], although distinct alterations of pain sensitivity between external pain as being reduced and internal (visceral) pain as being increased have been noticed [53, 54]. Studies in animal models demonstrated that MeCP2 plays important roles in the function of nociceptive pathways via peripheral (e.g., the expression of MeCP2 and its epigenetic roles in the dorsal root ganglion after spared nerve injury [55–57]) and central (e.g., the expression of MeCP2 leading to repression of histone dimethyltransferase G9a and expression of BDNF in central nucleus of the amygdala after persistent pain [58]) mechanisms, and that 50% reduction of MeCP2 levels in the brain of Mecp2flox/y mice induces the deficits in the pain recognition system [59]. It is likely that deficits in the central nervous system including decreased pain sensitivity and impaired cognition of external stimuli in Mecp2 KO mice cause the reduced dopamine responses in the PFC, and subsequently the reduced dopamine responses further impair cognitive function.
An optimum level of dopamine and activation of dopamine D1 receptor signaling in the PFC plays a key role in cognitive performance [4]. Cognitive deficits in Mecp2 KO mice can be in part attributable to the reduced dopamine responses to external stimuli in the PFC. The present study demonstrated that D1 receptors bidirectionally regulate dopamine release in the PFC of WT mice. In the PFC of Mecp2 KO mice, the ability of D1 receptor signaling to inhibit dopamine release would be upregulated and/or its ability to stimulate dopamine release would be downregulated, suggesting the alterations of D1 receptor signaling are mechanisms for the suppressed dopamine system.
The regulatory mechanism for dopamine release via D1 receptor signaling in the PFC has not been clarified. D1 receptors reside on different populations of pyramidal neurons in the PFC that project to striatal and other subcortical targets [60, 61]. Pyramidal neurons bidirectionally regulate the release of dopamine from mesocortical (VTA-PFC) dopamine neurons: activation of the PFC (Glutamate (Glu)) -basolateral amygdala (BLA) (Glu) -ventral pallidum (VP) (GABA) -VTA circuits [62] would result in inhibition of VTA dopamine neurons, whereas activation of the PFC (Glu) -ventral subiculum (vSub) (Glu) -NAc (GABA) -VP (GABA) -VTA circuits would result in activation (disinhibition) of VTA dopamine neurons [62]. If the function of D1 receptors in pyramidal neurons that activate the PFC-BLA-VP-VTA circuit or the PFC-vSub-NAc-VP-VTA circuit is upregulated or downregulated, respectively, the dopamine response to external stimuli in the PFC would be attenuated.
In addition, the PFC (Glu) -lateral habenula (Glu/trace amine) -rostromedial tegmental nucleus (RMTg) (GABA) -VTA circuit either inhibits or activates VTA dopamine neurons depending on whether stress conditions are chronic or acute, respectively [63]. D1 receptors are also present on GABAergic interneurons, most prevalently colocalizing with parvalbumin (PV)-positive interneurons in the PFC, which is involved in D1 receptor-mediated inhibition of the working memory circuit [64]. In Mecp2 KO mice, the inhibitory connections and functions of PV-positive interneurons on pyramidal neurons in visual cortex are upregulated, leading to the silencing of cortical circuits involved in vision [34, 65]. Alteration of D1 receptor function in PV-positive interneurons may potentially affect the inhibitory gating of various PFC-VTA circuits that regulate dopamine release in the PFC. Thus, functional alteration of D1 receptors expressed in subpopulation of pyramidal neurons or PV-positive interneurons and the biphasic neurotransmission of the PFC-VTA circuits that regulate dopamine release in the PFC would contribute to the attenuation of dopamine responses.
Experiments with cocaine infusions revealed that the function of dopamine reuptake sites, one of indicators for neuronal activity [66], is upregulated in the PFC of MecP2 KO mice (Fig. 6B (3)). The upregulation of the dopamine reuptake system would contribute, at least in part, to the low responses of dopamine to external stimuli in Mecp2 KO mice. Interestingly, in contrast to our findings, a marginal decrease in dopamine transporter density in the striatum of MecP2 KO mice was reported using positron emission tomography (PET) [67]. The modulatory role of dopamine D1 receptors in the dopamine reuptake system is not known, and their role in Mecp2 KO mice needs to be clarified in future studies.
Effect of ghrelin on dopaminergic pathology in the PFC of Mecp2 KO mice
Ghrelin is known to enhance dopamine D1 receptor signaling in neurons where GHSR and D1 receptors are coexpressed and form heterodimers [19]. Consistently, ghrelin restored the dopamine responses to external stimuli in Mecp2 KO mice via D1 receptor-dependent mechanisms. As cortical neurons coexpress GHSR and D1 receptors [19], it is possible that ghrelin treatment induces the formation of GHSR/D1 receptor heterodimers, leading the enhancement of D1 receptor signaling. In Mecp2 KO mice, the ability of D1 receptor signaling to inhibit dopamine release would be upregulated and/or its ability to stimulate dopamine release would be downregulated. The assumption of heterodimer formation supports the role of ghrelin in adjusting downregulated D1 receptor function (Fig. 6C (1)) more than upregulated D1 receptor function (Fig. 6C (2)).
Based on the assumption, ghrelin would preferentially restore the ability of D1 receptor signaling to stimulate dopamine release in response to external stimuli, leading to ameliorate cognitive deficits in Mecp2 KO mice. Behavioral evaluation of ghrelin effects with D1 receptor blockade will be necessary to confirm the importance of adjusting D1 receptor dysfunction for cognitive improvement. However, we could not perform the behavioral analyses with SCH23390 infusion, because the tubing connected to the infusion probe might interfere with the assessment of behaviors due to the muscle weakness and low body weight in Mecp2 KO mice. To overcome this limitation, Mecp2 KO mice at younger age prior to the onset of symptoms could be used for future studies.
The ability of ghrelin to downregulate the availability and function of dopamine transporters in Mecp2 KO mice (Fig. 6C (3)) cannot be ruled out, as they are critical to maintain extracellular dopamine levels [68]. However, the effects of ghrelin on dopamine transporters are not known at present.
In conclusion, ghrelin adjusts the altered D1 receptor function and subsequently restored the attenuated dopamine responses to external stimuli in the PFC of Mecp2 KO mice. The enhanced dopamine neurotransmission explains the action of ghrelin in ameliorating cognitive deficits in Mecp2 KO mice (Fig. 6). Ghrelin could be a potential therapeutic drug for cognitive deficits in patients with RTT and possibly other neurological disorders with cognitive deficits. Future preclinical studies are needed to explore whether the therapeutic benefits of ghrelin can allow for safe and sufficient clinical use in these conditions.