Callus induction and fresh weight
The effects of strigolactones on plants are not yet fully defined and it is unknown whether the observed effects are universal across plant species. 0.2 µM GR24 used alone in this study significantly reduced both callus formation and fresh weight (P < 0.05). While 0.2 µM GR24 used with NAA + BAP significantly reduced the incidence of callus formation, but had no significant effect on fresh weight. Fresh weight measurements showed similar trends in the control group and GR24 combined with NAA + BAP (Fig. 1). Mdodana (2012) found that strigolactone-deficient and insensitive mutants of wild-type A. thaliana Col-O were widely used in callus culture, also the media containing various amounts of 2,4-D and kinetin (2: 2 mg / L or 0.5: 0.05 mg / L) were successful and when these calluses were transferred onto media containing 0.1 µM GR24 and auxin or cytokinin, the amount of callus biomass increased in some of the mutants. Grobbelaar et al. (2014) demonstrated that strigolactones (GR24 and Nijmegen-1 (0.1 µM) generally had a minimal effect on the growth of Salvia frutescens nodal explants. However, when combined with 1 mg / L NAA, these hormones promoted biomass production. Similar results were also shown by Zulfiqar et al. (2020) in which 0.01 mg/L GR24 was the optimum amount for the callus growth of Helianthus annuus L. In this study, the frequency of in vitro callus formation and fresh weight were similar in amount to the control group but the highest was found in the 2NAA + 1BAP + 0.1 µM GR24 medium, indicating the synergistic relationship between auxins and strigolactones (Brewer et al. 2009; Hayward et al. 2009; Agusti et al. 2011).
Production of phenolic and aromatic compounds
As the main active compound, flavonoids play a notable role in a variety of pharmacological activities, including antiallergic, anti-inflammatory and antioxidant effects (Trombetta et al. 2005, Panico et al. 2005). Germano et al. (2002), Matthaus and Özcan (2005), Tlili et al. (2009) reported that the caper plant is a rich plant source of flavonoid compounds rutin (rutocide) and quercetin, also different parts of the plants contained phytosterols, tocopherols, carotenoids and glucosinolates. In literature reviews, no study has been found concerning the effect of GR24 on the amount of phenolic compounds in C. spinosa callus. In this study, the total flavonoid in the 2 mg L NAA + 1 mg/L BAP + 0.1 µM (P < 0.05) treatment increased by 19% when compared to the control. Goda et al. (2017) found that the total flavonoid content in C. spinosa callus from the 2,4-D medium was 0.85 mg/100 mg. It has also been stated in many studies that the rutin contained in the aerial parts were dominant flavonoid (Zhou et al. 2011; Argentieri et al. 2012). In our study except 0.2 µM GR24, rutin was the dominant flavonoid in leaf calluses obtained from all applications, and its content in 2 mg/L NAA + 1 mg/L BAP + 0.1 µM GR24 application increased approximately by 1.5 times when compared to the control group and the amount found was 16.9 µg/g DW (P < 0.05). While the GR24 applied alone significantly reduced the rutin content, the low concentration of GR24 used with NAA and BAP positively affected the amount of rutin (Fig. 2).. Tlili et al. (2010) found the rutin content of caper plant leaves collected from Tunisia flora as 13.52 mg/100 g, Behnaz et al. (2013) aslo examined the amount of rutin and quercetin in various parts of the capers and reported that the highest was found in the leaves at 25.2 and 10.4 mg/g respectively.
Palacio et al. (2012) found the amount of quercetin from the callus of Larrea divaricata leaves treated with 2 mg/L 2.4 D and 1 mg/L BAP to to be approximately 6 µg/g. In our study, quercetin was almost the same amount in all other applications (5.1–5.4 µg/g DW) except for the 0.2 µM GR24 application (quercetin was zero) (Fig. 2). This suggests that NAA and BAP are effective hormones in the accumulation of quercetin. According to many in vitro studies it is recommended to add BAP to the culture medium to increase the production of various secondary metabolites in plants. For example, Al-Ashoush (2017) and Udomsuk et al. (2009) reported that BAP had a positive effect on the amounts of some secondary metabolites in addition to the total isoflavonoids extracted. In addition, it has been documented that kinetin affects polyphenol groups such as quercetin and isomer by interfering with the synthesis of nucleic acids that can affect polyphenol production (Shah et al. 1976).
Kaempferol amount varied between 4.8 and 3.3 µg/g DW in applications (Fig. 2). Tlili et al. (2017) determined the amount of kaempferol in caper leaf extracts as 3.63%. Haifa et al. (2016) could not detect kaempferol in C.spinosa leaves in the Tunisian flora.
The total amount of phenolic substance increased by 48.8% compared to the control and the highest was found to be 72.79 µg/g DW in 2 mg/L NAA + 1 mg/L BAP + 0.1 µM GR24 application (P < 0.05). In other applications with GR24, this amount was found to be much lower, therefore the increase in the GR24 concentration decreased the amount of phenolic substance compared to the control, regardless of the presence or absence of NAA and BAP (Fig. 3).
Although this is not the case for the amount of chlorogenic acid, the highest amount of chlorogenic acid was found in this application as 46.4 µg/g DW, and also caught our attention as the highest among the analyzed phenolics. GR24 used alone also significantly increased the amount of chlorogenic acid compared to the control (Fig. 3). Rad et al. (2021) obtained 0.680 mg/g DW chlorogenic acid in caper leaves. There are studies analyzing the effects of auxin and cytokinins on the amount of chlorogenic acid in in vitro cultures of some plants. Erkoyuncu and Yorgancılar (2021) reported that 1 mg/L 2.4-D + 2 mg/L BAP treated leaf calluses of Echinacea purpurea L. contained 0.23 mg g chlorogenic acid; Szopo et .al. (2020) also determined the amount of chlorogenic acid as 20 mg/100 mg DW in Schisandra rubriflora microshoot extracts. Siahposuh et al. (2011) reported that kinetin stimulates chlorogenic acid production positively in Varthemia persica callus, and replacement of 2,4-D with NAA does not change chlorogenic acid production.
In our study, caffeic acid was not detected in calluses in any of the application, including the control group (data not shown). According to the findings of Oudah et al. (2019) the amount of caffeic acid in caper leaves was 73.542 µg/ml, Rezzan et al. (2013) reported no caffeic acid in the caper leaves collected from Gaziantep/Turkey flora.
Antognoni et al. (2008) reported that the production of α-tocopherol in Amaranthus caudatus and Chenopodium species calli were approximately 40 times lower than the tocopherol content in the plant leaves and other organs. In some cases, this is due to the lack of specialized cell structures (St. Pierre et al. 1999; Pasqua et al. 2003). In our study, the highest amount of α-tocopherol was found in the control group, and it decreased significantly in all applications with GR24. In callus cultures of C. spinosa, α-tocopherol accumulation was approximately 1000 to 5000 times lower than in leaves (20.19 ± 31.71 mg/100g),regardless of the culture medium (Tlili et al. 2009).
In our study, aromatic substance contents of calluses were generally examined under six groups as sulfur compounds, aldehydes, ketones, hydrocarbons and derivatives, alcohols and others (Table 1). In the GR24-only applied group, the total sulfur compound was found to be 87.53% and the dominant substance was methyl isothiocyanate (556-61-6). The pungent aroma of capers is usually caused by the very sharp methyl isothiocyanate released after an enzymatic reaction with a mustard oil glycoside known as glucocaparin (methyl glucosinolate) (Sozzi et al. 2012). El-Ghorab et al. (2007) and Bakr and El Bishbishy (2016) stated that the predominant essential oil in the caper plant collected from the flora was methyl isothiocyanate at 20.0% and 24.66%, respectively. In our study, this rate was found to be higher in all applications in caper calluses. Here, we can clearly state that callus culture is a good method for methyl isocyanate production. Zhang (2004) documented the cancer-preventive activity of a significant number of isothiocyanates, mostly of which occur in plants, especially in cruciferous vegetables. Moreover, glucosinolates via their hydrolysis products are among the most powerful antibiotic substances known from higher plants (Louda and Mole, 1991), with an established correlation between the content of glucosinolates (isothiocyanates) and disease resistance (Esteve 2020). Again, 0.2 µM GR24 application increased the total aldehyde content from 6.09–7.90%.
2NAA + 1BAP + 0.1 µM GR24 increased ketone and hydrocarbon compounds by 10 and 14 folds, respectively, compared to control group. It was realized that the combination of GR24 with the other two plant growth regulators had a positive effect and this effect was directly proportionional to the decrease in GR24 concentration. The dominant compound in ketones was acetoin (513-86-0), and n-hexan (110-54-3) in hydrocarbons and derivatives. The amount of alcohol and other aromatics was reduced in all applications with GR24 compared to the control. This article is the first to present the effect of GR24 on the amount of essential oil in C. spinosa callus. Romeo et al. (2007) recorded 8.42% sulfur compounds, 12.8 % hydrocarbons and derivatives and 7.48% alcohol in Eolian capers. Bidabadi and Sharifi (2021) stated that strigolacones (10 µM GR24) increased the essential oil content and yield in Dracocephalum kotschyi under drought stress. They also reported that increasing levels of SL application positively influenced essential oil content and yield in S. nemorosa where the lowest salt concentration (100mM NaCl) accompanied with 0.3 µM SL, resulted in the highest essential oil content and yield (Sharifi and Bidabadi 2020).
Table 1
Effect of various GR24 concentrations on the aromatic substance of caper calluses
Aromatic compounds
|
2NAA + 1BAP (Control) (%)
|
2NAA + 1BAP + 0,1 µM GR24 (%)
|
2NAA + 1BAP + 0,2 µM GR24 (%)
|
0,2 µM GR24 (%)
|
Sulphur compounds
|
83.58
|
66.97
|
83.27
|
87.53
|
Aldehydes
|
6.09
|
4.88
|
6.45
|
7.90
|
Ketones
|
1.32
|
19.3
|
6.55
|
0.34
|
Hydrocarbons and derivatives
|
0.56
|
5.8
|
0.83
|
0.62
|
Alcohols
|
6.08
|
1.62
|
1.86
|
3.00
|
Others
|
2.37
|
1.43
|
1.04
|
0.61
|
In conclusion, in this study, it was observed that GR24 may be effective in the production of phenolic compounds in caper callus cultures. It was realised that both the formation and wet weights of calluses cultured in the medium containing 2 mg / L NAA + 1 mg / L BAP + 0.1 µM GR24 were higher compared to other media, and this was the best application especially in the accumulation of chlorogenic acid, rutin and quercetin phenolics. It was also determined that GR24 used at lower concentrations was more effective, but much studies on this is required in the future. The lack of comprehensive genomic data for most plants with medicinal or nutraceutical properties has made it difficult to use common genomic (eg, microarray-based) approaches to study metabolic pathways. In vitro culture offers an attractive alternative to understanding the regulation of enzymes involved in plant secondary metabolism.