Urbanization and quick increase of population have negatively affected urban space. Each city has its own challenges and evaluation of existing conditions always take priority when implementing a program. Technology helps to constantly monitor cities and shortens the process of data extraction for critical conditions. Being cognizant of the conditions, examining the factors, and trying to plan and resolve them make it possible to offer better urban services, increase urban life quality, and make urban space livable. Recent advances in remote sensing and GIS have revolutionized the access to data, regional modelling, and spatial analysis. New satellites can take images of cities daily. Moreover, cloud systems that have been devised to process these data are able to analyze and examine data quickly and accurately.
Using remote sensing satellites is one the methods of data collection for urban studies. Optical and SAR satellites have been employed in different studies. Landsat, Sentinel-2, and PlanetScope satellites are optical and Sentinel-1 satellite is a SAR satellite. Landsat-series satellite has been monitoring the earth for 50 years (since 1972). Its images are the richest archive of the earth and one of its purposes is monitoring the regional changes over time. The information from this satellite are the basis of many studies regarding forest monitoring (Townshend et al., 2012; Banskota et al., 2014), change detection (Awty-Carroll et al., 2019; Hemati et al., 2021), water quality (Peterson, Sagan and Sloan, 2020; Al-Shaibah et al., 2021), land surface temperature (Balew and Korme, 2020; Ermida et al., 2020) and mapping vegetation (Schwieder et al., 2016; Peterson, Sagan and Sloan, 2020). The images from Landsat 8 satellite have also been used in urban studies such as urban heat island (Elmes et al., 2020), ecological evaluation of urban heat island (Dissanayake, Kurugama and Ruwanthi, 2020), quantification of carbon sequestration by urban forest (Uniyal et al., 2022), extracting urban impervious surfaces (Deliry, Avdan and Avdan, 2021),urban green infrastructure health assessment (Chang et al., 2021), and producing land use/land cover (LULC) maps (Nasiri et al., 2022; Theres and Selvakumar, 2022).
Satellites differ in terms of spatial, spectral, radiometric, and temporal resolution. Landsat 8 satellite has 16-day temporal resolution, 30-meter spatial resolution, and 15-meter panchromatic band. Compared with Landsat 8 satellite, the Sentinel-2 satellite has 10-day temporal resolution that becomes 5 days because of using two repeat cycle satellites. This satellite also has bands with 10, 20, and 60-meter resolutions. Data produced by this satellite are typically used in studies regarding climate change, land monitoring, emergency, management, and security (Sentinel-2 User Handbook, 2015; Gibson et al., 2020; Mngadi, Odindi and Mutanga, 2021). Some studies show that Sentinel-2 satellite performs better than Landsat 8 satellite (J. Wang et al., 2020; Q. Wang et al., 2020; Ghayour et al., 2021). Landsat 8 satellite and Sentinel-2 satellite images can be combined (Mandanici and Bitelli, 2016). Using the images of these two satellites can remarkably increase the phenological variation and, consequently, precision of maps (Nasiri et al., 2022; Pouya, Aghlmand and Karsli, 2022). PlanetScope satellite has better temporal resolution than Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 satellites. This satellite, which consists of 130 small satellites, takes images of the earth surface every day and may even take images of some regions more than once. What distinct this satellite from Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 satellites is the 3-meter resolution of its images (Planet Team, 2018). Its images can play a critical role in urban studies. However, few studies have been conducted in this regard. sentinel − 1 satellite offers ordinary and systematic data to monitor sea and land, emergency reaction, climate change, and security. Two underlying limitations of optical satellites are lack of imaging at night and bad weather conditions (existence of cloud) (Sherpa and Shirzaei, 2022). Sentinel-1 satellite does not have these restrictions. Combining its images with those of Sentinel-2 and Landsat 8 satellites has been utilized in different studies on mapping of crop types and crop sequences (Blickensdörfer et al., 2022), eliminating leaf area index and aboveground biomass of grazing pastures (Wang et al., 2019), surface moisture and vegetation cover analysis (Urban et al., 2018), urban change detection (Benedetti, Picchiani and Del Frate, 2018; Hafner, 2022), and river water mapping (Liu et al., 2022) that provided higher quality results. As yet Sentinel-1 satellite images alone have not been used in producing land use maps. However, many studies have combined them with optical satellites images such as Landsat 8 and Sentinel-2 that has led to increased accuracy of the maps (Brandmeier et al., 2022; De Luca et al., 2022).
Regarding monitoring urban growth, extensive studies have been carried out using remote sensing satellites images and GIS. Most of these studies have been based on Landsat series images with 30-meter resolution and deal with urban growth. In these studies, archived images are received to examine changes and growth `extent of urban space to propose strategies for planning to associative officials (Dhanaraj and Angadi, 2020; Roy and Kasemi, 2021; Wang, Murayama and Morimoto, 2021; Elhamdouni, Arioua and Karaoui, 2022). Most of the studies have generally dealt with urban growth issue because of restrictions such as lack of access to images with high spatial resolution and platforms with high processing power and have not examined the growth of roads, paths, and urban green space separately. The results obtained with these images are based on their spatial resolution. Thus, small streets and paths cannot be mapped. Additionally, green spaces that have a smaller area than spatial resolution do not appear in the results. For example, in Landsat 8 satellite, the area of each pixel is 900 square meters. Thus, the three main classes of green space, roads, and buildings are not clear well in these images. In Fig. 1, which shows one neighborhood of Eskişehir city in Türkiye, some parts of urban space that has low-area buildings, roads, and green space can be observed. In Fig. 1, three images of PlanetScope satellite with 3-meter resolution (a), Sentinel-2 satellite with 10-meter resolution (b), and Landsat 8 satellite with 30-meter resolution (c) can be seen. The main image position in this figure has been shown by red. This figure clearly indicates the spatial resolution of these three satellites. In the image with 3-meter resolution, different elements such as green space, roads, and buildings can be easily seen; but in image b, separation of classes is hard and in image c, is impossible.
Using new satellites with better spatial, spectral, radiometric, and temporal resolution has helped to gain more information on urban space to produce more detailed LULC maps. Although images with higher resolution produce more details of urban space, their spatial resolution is low, and it is necessary to combine the images of satellites to reach better results. Combining images can also increase the bulk of data and process of them. All the process needs to be done in cloud platforms. Google earth engine (GEE) cloud platform can be referred to as one of the most important progress in GIS and remote sensing area that not only offer GIS data but also makes it possible to do different analyses on them. GEE data do not require pre-processing. Moreover, not only data of its database can be used but also those of other sources can be uploaded. This, in turn, makes it possible to analyze a great deal of data in a short time simultaneously. Another advantage of GEE platform is the existence of strong libraries for processing of satellite images. These libraries offer important machine learning algorithms for classification and production of LULC maps.
In this research, we aimed to produce a 3-meter LULC map and then extract data from green space, roads, and buildings. The study was conducted by using optical images (PlanetScope and Sentinel-2 ), varying indexes estimated from the bands of these two satellites, and also images of SAR satellite in GEE cloud platform with machine learning algorithm. The study was done on two cities in Türkiye, that is, Ankara and Eskişehir to examine data and offer the best combination of data to achieve the study purposes.