Study Design
The BrainHealth Project is a prospective, longitudinal, interventional, open-label, single-arm clinical trial. A pilot study was conducted from March to August 2020 to assess the feasibility of the online study platform and to develop a data-driven index of brain health [21]. Recruitment for the longitudinal study commenced in September 2020, following the conclusion of the pilot phase. The study aims to enroll 100,000 adults over a 10-year period, with ongoing recruitment and enrollment throughout the study duration. As the study progresses, data analysis and findings will inform the addition of more targeted data collection, and both interventional and observational sub-studies are planned.
All core procedures for the Project are conducted online via the BrainHealth Platform, accessible through a desktop computer or a full-function mobile app (launched in February 2024). Participants complete an initial online baseline assessment of their BrainHealth Index, followed by personalized online coaching every three months, with continuous access to online training, exercises, and educational resources aimed at optimizing brain health and overall well-being. Participants are encouraged to reassess their BrainHealth Index every six months for the duration of their involvement.
For a subset of participants who choose to link data from their personal fitness devices, metrics such as physiological markers related to sleep, physical fitness, and overall health will be collected. To assess the impact of cognitive interventions and the use of digital health and educational tools, we will also analyze participant engagement with the features and content available on the BrainHealth Platform. All activities involving the BrainHealth Project and BrainHealth Platform were approved by the University of Texas at Dallas’ Institutional Review Board prior to the initiation of research activities.
Participants
The study targets generally healthy adults aged 18 years and older. Inclusion criteria focus on participants' ability to access and engage with the online platform and content, as determined by self-report. These criteria include: fluency in English, access to an internet connection and device, and the ability to hear and read information on the computer or device. Exclusion criteria are based on specific health conditions. Individuals are excluded if they have a diagnosed neurodegenerative disease; a history of stroke, concussion, or brain injury that currently impairs their ability to function at their reported prior level (e.g., inability to carry out daily responsibilities); or a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder with non-independent functioning. Participants are not excluded for other diagnoses, such as learning disorders or psychiatric or medical conditions, in order to maintain the diversity of the generally brain-healthy population and to ensure the generalizability of the results. These characteristics will be captured through self-report, along with changes in demographic data collected at each assessment timepoint, to inform potential clinical subgroup analyses as appropriate.
Recruitment
Participants are recruited through word of mouth, online postings, social media and advertisements, such as through the Center for BrainHealth website and e-newsletter and registries such as the Alzheimer’s Prevention Registry as well as posts on social media platforms such as Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn. Study flyers or recruitment information are also shared through in-person and virtual events by the Center for BrainHealth. Two healthcare system partners of the Center for BrainHealth, one in the local Dallas area and one in the eastern United States, also share the study recruitment information through flyers and social media posts. Participants do not receive any payment or reimbursement for participation in this online study.
Data Collected and Instruments Used
BrainHealth Index (BHI) assessment (60–90 mins. total, avg. 70 mins.). The study’s primary outcome measure is the composite BrainHealth Index (BHI) score. The BHI is scored from a multidimensional assessment of brain health and performance, comprised of an online battery of cognitive performance measures and self-report questionnaires completed by participants through the BrainHealth Platform. The BHI is unique in that it is designed to measure change over time without the presumption of decline or a specified ceiling – i.e., characterizing the development and upward improvement of brain health rather than serving as a decline-oriented, adjusted normative, or diagnostic cognitive measure. Cognitive assessment includes tasks of complex thinking capacities such as reasoning, abstraction, mental flexibility, and strategy – each with alternate-stimuli versions randomized across timepoints. The self-report questionnaires measure other aspects of daily life that relate to brain health, such as emotional well-being, quality of life, purpose, happiness, resilience, social support systems, and sleep – utilizing tools that have been empirically validated in their respective literatures where possible. In these sections of the online assessment battery, participants self-report through rating aspects of their daily life within the prior 6 months. At each testing time point (baseline and every 6 months thereafter), participants have the opportunity to divide the assessments into shorter segments over time while saving their progress to date (up to two weeks duration) to complete the overall assessment. See Table 1 for a full list of measures.
Table 1
Measures included in the holistic BrainHealth Index assessment
Measure | Assessment Instrument |
Strategic Attention | Visual Selective Learning Task [22] |
Abstraction | Proverb Interpretation Task (developed at the Center for BrainHealth) |
Reasoning Synthesis Interpretation Memory | Test of Strategic Learning (TOSL) [23] Condensed synopsis of complex text (~ 550-word narrative) Fluency of take-home messages/interpretations from text Memory for text details (free and cued/elaborated recall) |
Innovation | Fluency of high-level Interpretations from Picture Interpretation Task (developed at the Center for BrainHealth, modeled after semantic verbal fluency task, adapted from Lezak et al. [24]) |
Processing Speed | Coding/Digit Symbol Task (developed at the Center for BrainHealth) |
Sleep | Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index (PSQI) [25] |
Compassion | Questionnaire adapted from the Light Triad Scale [26,27] |
Mood Depression Anxiety Stress | Depression Anxiety Stress Scale (DASS-21) [28] |
Meaningful Activities/Purpose | Engagement in Meaningful Activities Survey (EMAS) [29] |
Happiness | Oxford Happiness Questionnaire (OHQ) [30] |
Social Support | Social Support Survey Index [31] |
Resilience | Connor-Davidson Resilience Scale [32] |
Life Satisfaction | Quality of Life Scale [33] |
Social Engagement | Social BrainHealth Scale (developed at the Center for BrainHealth) |
Growth Mindset | BrainHealth Appraisal Questionnaire (developed at the Center for BrainHealth) |
Fitness | Metabolic Equivalents: Cardiorespiratory Fitness (CFEQ) [34] |
The BrainHealth Index yields four separate scores which are shared with participants through their BrainHealth Platform study dashboard, including a composite/global BHI score as well as scores for its three validated factors: (1) Clarity (readiness to reason through complex situations and create new opportunities or solutions, i.e., cognitive health), (2) Connectedness (to people and purpose, i.e., social health), and (3) Emotional Balance (steadiness in the face of difficult situations, ability to handle adversity while remaining productive and capable). These are based on a factor analysis of change scores from measures shown in Table 1 [21]. The University of Texas at Dallas’ Center for BrainHealth investigator team designed the BHI’s composite/holistic score to capture the multiple dimensions of brain health and the interdependency amongst these dimensions, based on machine learning analytics, rather than presupposed components. For each individual, the four scores are graphed to visually track progress over time. This data visualization allows participants to realize their brain health as a whole (composite BHI score) while also reflecting the multiple paths they have to support their brain health and performance over time (factor scores). The BHI uses the individual’s own performance against which to measure growth over time rather than being compared to a group norm, allowing for a more personalized approach that is independent of starting point. See Fig. 1, which displays the three validated factor areas and their contributing measures.
Demographic information. For each participant, at baseline we collect self-report data on age, gender identity, biological sex assigned at birth, race/ethnicity, country/U.S. zip code, household income, level of education, and occupation as well as any currently diagnosed medical or psychiatric conditions. At every subsequent online assessment timepoint (offered every 6 months), any changes in these data points are collected.
Training Materials
The online training materials included in this study protocol consist of the following:
BrainHealth Platform Training Modules, Habits, and Resources:
Training Modules. Participants access the training modules through the study’s online BrainHealth Platform which includes micro-learning videos, animations to motivate learning, activities, and learning/strategy application opportunities [21]. The training protocol is comprised primarily of evidence-based cognitive strategy learning, previously shown to improve aspects of neurocognitive and real-life function in clinical trials [6, 13]. The strategy-based cognitive training protocol, Strategic Memory Advanced Reasoning Tactics (SMART), was developed by Center for BrainHealth neuroscientists and clinicians to promote improvement in executive functioning and self-agency. The executive function/top-down SMART protocol trains three core strategies, specifically (1) strategic attention to reduce information intake, single-task to focus and make progress on daily goals, and brain down time, (2) integrated reasoning to quickly synthesize information/facts into succinct abstracted ideas and interpretations and apply to real life application, and (3) innovation to flexibly generate a multitude of ways to improve tasks, communications, meetings, relationships and missteps/mistakes. The strategies can be applied in the context of everyday-life activities and responsibilities. Based on more than 25 years of intensive research, SMART has been shown to positively impact areas of cognition (e.g., improved executive function, strategic attention, integrated reasoning, innovation, decision-making, and memory), well-being (e.g., reduced symptoms of stress, depression and anxiety), and real-life function (e.g., improved quality of life, initiation and prioritization of social engagement/relationships, and complexity of life work responsibilities). Gains in these areas were found to correspond with significant neural changes, including aspects of neural connectivity, cerebral blood flow, and neural efficiency [6–8, 18, 35–38].
All BrainHealth Platform SMART sessions are designed to be self-paced, consisting of 5–10-minute daily units. These sessions are reinforced with habit training and integration, encouraging participants to consistently apply tactical brain strategies to various everyday responsibilities and situations. Although training is available daily, participants can determine their own frequency of engagement. The training units combine education on brain strategies, explanations of the rationale to promote brain health literacy, and prompts for personal reflection and practical application. After completing the four SMART modules, training continues with online learning about solutions to minimize stress. These SMART strategies associated with stress management techniques are designed to build a more resilient mindset by integrating stress management techniques with healthy lifestyle choices such as physical exercise, diet, and mindful meditation—practices that have been empirically shown to reduce stress [39–43]. The sleep module provides information on not only the science of sleep and aspects such as sleep cycles, but also walks participants through sleep hygiene tips to help improve their quality and quantity of sleep. For detailed descriptions of these self-paced BrainHealth Platform training modules, see Table 2.
Table 2
Description of self-paced online training modules
Training module | Description | No. of units/ Total time |
1. SMART 01* | Provides strategies and interactive activities teaching how to block irrelevant information and focus on key priorities and critical information (strategic attention). Example: Organize your day to accomplish significant tasks – each day prioritize the top two tasks that require deeper-level thinking. | 6 units/ 55 min |
2. SMART 02* | Provides strategies and interactive activities on how to abstract big-picture concepts from information to better inform understanding and real-life decisions (integrated reasoning). Example: Extract key concepts from incoming information vs. trying to process and remember everything. | 4 units/ 35 min |
3. SMART 03* | Provides strategies and interactive activities on how to generate multiple and diverse solutions/perspectives/ questions to strengthen mental flexibility (innovation). Example: Identify multiple alternative perspectives/ideas on discordant issues. | 6 units/ 35 min |
4. SMART 04* | Provides real-life application scenarios where participants can practice dynamic implementation of the strategies from SMART 01–03 (strategic attention, integrated reasoning, innovation) in a synergistic manner. Example: Think about and prepare to ask your boss for a raise (considering your accomplishments, impact those accomplishments have had or could have on the organization, etc.). | 6 units/ 45 min |
5. Stress solutions 01 | Presents information about physiological and neurological response to stress, as well as cognitive strategies linked with SMART to manage and reframe stressors. Example: Reframe your perception of your response to a difficult situation from anxiety to excitement. | 5 units/ 40 min |
6. Stress solutions 02 | Provides accessible techniques to help “recharge your mental battery” in terms of stress or fatigue, as well as education on lifestyle factors that can positively impact overall health. Example: Take several short breaks throughout your day. | 4 units/ 30 min |
7. Stress solutions 03 | Provides research on the benefits of mindfulness, meditation, and healthy sleep habits, as well as practical tips on how to practice each one (linking with SMART strategies). Example: Participate in a mindfulness exercise. | 5 units/ 45 min |
8. Sleep | Presents research on the science behind sleep over the lifespan, the brain impacts of poor sleep, and practical tips for improving one’s sleep habits. | 16 units/ 75 min |
Total time | 350 min |
*Modules 1–4 provide the foundational cognitive strategies (SMART).
Habits. Each training module is paired with a set of brain-healthy "Habits" that participants can access once they complete the module. These habits allow participants to integrate specific training concepts or strategies into their daily routines. Participants can choose a habit, opt to receive daily reminders, and track their progress over time, earning levels and digital "badges" on the BrainHealth Platform. Examples of habits include minimizing distractions, taking regular breaks, completing two important big tasks each day, maintaining a consistent and healthy sleep routine, and exploring multiple possibilities to reapproach a challenge, perceived failure, dilemma or mistake. Additionally, habits can be focused on lifestyle improvements such as exercise, nutrition, and mindfulness.
Challenges. After completing the primary training modules, participants advance to a continuing series of "Challenge" units designed for reinforcement and extended application of the strategies and practices. These challenges are also delivered in 5-10-minute increments and feature diverse content, such as article readings and educational video clips. Each provides insights into the relevant brain science and includes reflection questions or practical application opportunities. Monthly challenge topics are organized into four weekly segments centered around a shared theme. Examples of these themes include memory habits, managing news consumption, navigating tough conversations, the science of confidence, breathing techniques, gratitude practices, etc.
Resources. Participants have access to a continually curated collection of educational resources on the broad topic of brain health, including media articles, published research studies, online lectures, etc. Additional training and resource content will be added throughout the study to offer ongoing learning opportunities and maintain participant engagement.
Online coaching:
Participants can engage in individual 20-minute videoconference coaching sessions every 3 months, conducted within the study platform. These sessions are led by a study brain health coach and can be self-scheduled by participants. Coaches are assigned based on availability and consist of study personnel with degrees spanning fields such as speech-language pathology, psychology, occupational therapy, education, or other areas of human performance. All coaches have experience administering and interpreting cognitive and human performance assessments, with a minimum of 2 years of post-graduate work experience in their respective field of practice.
During these sessions, brain health coaches offer individualized feedback on participants' BrainHealth Index results, guide them on engaging with the online training content, assist in setting personal brain health goals, and discuss how to apply the training strategies and practices to their specific goals or context. Following the session, coaches provide summary notes on the participant's BrainHealth Platform profile, articulating the key points discussed for easy access at any time. Participants can choose to utilize this quarterly personalized coaching as much or as little as they prefer.
BrainHQ training:
After completing their third BrainHealth Index assessment (typically one year post-baseline), participants have the opportunity to access BrainHQ [44] training for a limited time. Through the BrainHealth Platform, participants can engage in 14 BrainHQ training exercises over a period of up to 16 weeks. In contrast to SMART, which is strategy-based, BrainHQ is a computer exercise-based approach to cognitive training, with multiple studies supporting its effectiveness in enhancing cognitive performance [45]. Each exercise adapts in difficulty according to the participant's performance, using a specialized algorithm. The exercises made available to participants in the BrainHealth Project include those addressing attention, processing speed, memory, and decision-making. During the 16 weeks of BrainHQ access, participants are encouraged to engage with BrainHQ exercises four times a week for 30 minutes each session.
Retention of participants
Recognizing the importance of engagement and retention in a longitudinal study, we have developed and implemented solutions to address participant engagement and retention through three avenues: (1) technology platform enhancements, (2) improved communications, and (3) opportunities for community building among participants.
Initially, the BrainHealth Platform was accessible only via a web browser-based interface. However, to enhance accessibility and user experience, it has evolved to include a dedicated mobile application, launched in February 2024. This mobile app introduces advanced notification capabilities such as push notifications, sounds, and banners, which not only prompt participants to re-engage after periods of disengagement, but also remind them to complete essential study tasks, like the BrainHealth Index assessments. Furthermore, we have introduced gamification elements, such as earning “coins” for task completion and achieving higher ranks with each BrainHealth Index completed, to increase participant utilization and motivation.
We have continuously improved our study communications by making messaging clearer and more concise, ensuring participants are well-informed about their progress throughout the study procedures. The improved BrainHealth Platform now includes an onboarding navigation process that clearly outlines each study step, accompanied by visual tutorial elements. These tutorials help orient participants to their online study dashboard and explain or highlight key features to enhance ease of use. For a visual representation of the study participation elements, see Fig. 2. Additionally, we have expanded communication methods beyond email, incorporating the use of text messaging for participants who opt-in. This allows for more regular and continuing study engagement, such as facilitating daily habit completion and other study interactions.
The BrainHealth Project team also works to enhance participant engagement by offering monthly virtual group coaching sessions via Zoom. These 45-minute sessions are conducted live (not recorded) and are open to all study participants, providing social motivation and community-building opportunities. Additionally, in response to early participant requests for more information on the brain science behind the study, we host periodic virtual town hall webinars. These webinars, generally held annually or semi-annually, allow participants to deepen their understanding of the research they contribute to and foster a sense of involvement in a greater mission as citizen scientists. The town hall webinars are lecture-style, recorded, and subsequently made available in the BrainHealth Platform Resources section for all participants to access. In evaluating the impact of these offerings, we will assess whether these additional resources contribute to increased training utilization and improved study retention over time.
Data Management and Security within the BrainHealth Platform.
The online BrainHealth Platform, which hosts assessments and training tools, automatically uploads data to a secure cloud-based data management system. This system uses a relational database architecture, adheres to de-identification best practices, and implements stringent security protocols. Day-to-day study administration occurs via the platform’s secure administrative dashboard. For research analysis, additional data levels can be queried and integrated from various datasets stored in a cloud-based data lake. Access to data is strictly controlled, available only to authorized study personnel through secure access points, reinforced by strong password policies and multi-factor authentication.
Assessment Scoring and Quality Control.
The majority of the assessments included in the online BHI are automatically scored, except for three language-based cognitive performance measures (Abstraction, Reasoning, Innovation), which are manually scored by trained study personnel. To ensure data integrity and inter-rater reliability, quality control practices are in place. These include procedures for scoring review and consensus-building, as well as procedures for identifying and filtering invalid responses. This might involve noting any difficulties or interruptions that participants report encountering during the tasks or detecting the use of external aids.
Statistical Considerations
A key objective of the BrainHealth Project is to achieve precision brain health, recognizing that lifestyle interventions, cognitive training, exercise, and sleep impact individuals differently. The ultimate goal is to improve brain health for all participants, yet this improvement requires a tailored approach to meet each individual's specific needs. Consequently, the statistical approaches employed in this study prioritize individual prediction over population-wide inference. As such, formal power analyses are not relevant to sample size determination; however, see below for some population-based sub-studies that do require power justification.
In the machine learning literature, it is necessary to utilize tens of thousands of samples to train, validate and test complex, nonlinear prediction models such as neural networks (including deep learning networks), support vector machines and unsupervised tree or clustering methods. To determine the factors that influence and improve brain health in individual participants, we will utilize these nonlinear models and train them using large samples. Large samples will accommodate not only the training of the models, but also the validation and testing of them on independent samples such that estimates of generalization error can be obtained with low variance. For these purposes, we plan to recruit a baseline sample that will eventually yield an expected 15,000–20,000 individuals at the end of 10 years. These sample sizes are also comparable to those in the well-publicized Framingham Heart Study, which continues to determine factors related to heart health [11, 12].
Increased attrition and lack of adherence have been longstanding barriers to successful health-behavior interventions [46]. Given the online nature of the study and precedent from previous longitudinal, population-based studies involving internet-based/eHealth platforms [47], we similarly anticipate as much as 80%-85% attrition over the full 10-year study period. Therefore, to reach our goal we plan to recruit a baseline sample of 100,000 participants.
In addition to the sample requirements of neural network prediction models, a sample of 15,000–20,000 will allow population-based sub-studies as secondary aims in the BrainHealth Project. For example, within our workplace, mental illness, and caregiver sub-studies, we focus on analyzing the mean longitudinal changes in brain health. Additionally, we aim to document potential declines in brain health that may occur due to unexpected health events as reported by participants, such as undergoing chemotherapy, experiencing a concussion, contracting COVID-19, encountering significant grief, and other impactful life events. Importantly, we also examine participants' capacity to recover, facilitated by access to brain health training supports, as they continue their participation in the longitudinal study.
As the specificity of particular cohorts increases (e.g., males between 20–30 with less than a bachelor’s degree and a self-reported mental illness), the samples decrease markedly. However, having a total sample between 15,000 and 20,000 will allow rare cohorts to maintain at least samples of 100, which is required to detect effect sizes of at least 0.5 with 80% statistical power, adjusted for false positive control due to multiple testing.