Coverage
After a brief pilot, this intervention was released within WCM for all echocardiograms at the WCM main campus at the beginning of 2023. The coverage of the current intervention is local to WCM outpatient practice for patients who have MyChart. At the end of 2023, 91.7% of all outpatients at WCM were enrolled in MyChart, including 91.3% of all Cardiology patients and 94.2% of all Gastroenterology patients. For echocardiogram, this intervention included all rooms and transthoracic echocardiograms in the WCM outpatient clinic. After this release in 2023, EFP was released for screening colonoscopies at the beginning of 2024 for all patients referred for screening colonoscopies who were enrolled in MyChart. This quickly expanded to include esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD), sigmoidoscopy, and endoscopic ultrasound given the success in initial colonoscopy implementation.
Outcomes
For echocardiogram results were collected over the course of 14 months. Over this time period, 143 patients were included. Basic demographics of these patients can be seen in Table 1. 1786 appointment offers were made to patients using EFP. Of those offers, 59 were accepted, 214 offers were declined, 1452 expired, and 61 were no longer available when viewed due to the appointment slot being taken by someone else. Of the accepting patients, 52 showed up for their appointment, 5 cancelled, and 2 did not show up. 1106 offers were viewed by patients. Patients experienced an average of 12.8 days acceleration over their original appointment date. These results can be seen in Table 2.
Table 1 – demographic data for patients included in EFP for echocardiogram. Interactors were defined as those patients who either accepted or declined an offer, while non-interactors were those who did not respond or interact with any given offer.
Echocardiogram
|
Total (N=143), n(%)
|
Interactor (N=98), n(%)
|
Non-Interactor (N=45), n(%)
|
X2, P value
|
Gender
|
|
|
|
0.018, .11
|
Male
|
90 (62.94)
|
32 (32.65)
|
21 (46.67)
|
|
Female
|
53 (37.06)
|
66 (67.35)
|
24 (53.33)
|
|
Age
|
|
|
|
2.28, .68
|
<45
|
40 (27.97)
|
27 (27.55)
|
13 (28.89)
|
|
45-65
|
41 (28.67)
|
27 (27.55)
|
15 (33.33)
|
|
>65
|
61 (42.66)
|
44 (44.90)
|
17 (37.78)
|
|
Ethnicity
|
|
|
|
0.011, .006
|
Declined
|
25 (17.48)
|
13 (13.27)
|
12 (26.67)
|
|
Non Hispanic
|
113 (79.02)
|
84 (85.71)
|
29 (64.44)
|
|
Hispanic
|
5 (3.5)
|
1 (1.02)
|
4 (8.89)
|
|
Race
|
|
|
|
1.62, .20
|
Asian
|
12 (8.39)
|
9 (9.18)
|
3 (6.67)
|
|
Black
|
12 (8.39)
|
8 (8.16)
|
4 (8.89)
|
|
Declined
|
16 (11.19)
|
7 (7.14)
|
9 (20.00)
|
|
Other
|
10 (6.99)
|
6 (6.12)
|
4 (8.89)
|
|
White
|
93 (65.03)
|
68 (69.39)
|
25 (55.56)
|
|
Table 2 – breakdown of actions and behaviors of patient’s included in EFP for echocardiogram
Echocardiogram
|
|
Number of Patients included
|
143
|
Total Offers
|
1786
|
Accepted offers
|
59
|
Declined offers
|
214
|
Expired offers
|
1452
|
Appt no longer available
|
61
|
Average Days improvement for accepted appointments
|
12.8
|
Completed appointments
|
52 (88.14%)
|
No shows
|
2 (3.79%)
|
Cancellations
|
5 (8.20%)
|
Offers viewed
|
1106 (61.93%)
|
Offers viewed within 1 hour of release
|
240 (13.44%)
|
For endoscopy, results were collected over the course of 4 months. Over this time period, 666 patients were included. Basic demographics of these patients can be seen in Table 3. Over this time, 9338 appointment offers were made to patients using EFP. Of those offers, 322 were accepted, 821 offers were declined, 7640 expired, and 533 were no longer available when viewed due to the appointment slot being taken by someone else. Of the accepting patients, 168 showed up for their appointment, 105 were currently scheduled, 47 cancelled, and 2 did not show up. 6588 offers were viewed by patients. Patients experienced an average of 50.43 days improvement over their original appointment time. The no-show rate was less than 1%. In terms of type of endoscopy procedure, 95.7% of offers were for rescheduling a colonoscopy, with 3.8% EGD, and 0.5% for sigmoidoscopy or EGD with endoscopic ultrasound. These results can be seen in Table 4.
Table 3 – demographic data for patients included in EFP for endoscopy. Interactors were defined as those patients who either accepted or declined an offer, while non-interactors were those who did not respond or interact with any given offer.
Endoscopy
|
Total (N=666), n(%)
|
Interactor (N=443), n(%)
|
Non-Interactor (N=223), n(%)
|
X2, P value
|
Gender
|
|
|
|
0.0026, .04
|
Male
|
242 (36.34)
|
149 (33.63)
|
93 (41.7)
|
|
Female
|
424 (63.66)
|
294 (66.37)
|
130 (58.3)
|
|
Age
|
|
|
|
1.34, .49
|
<45
|
73 (10.96)
|
44 (9.93)
|
29 (13.00)
|
|
45-65
|
477 (71.62)
|
321 (72.46)
|
156 (69.96)
|
|
>65
|
116 (17.42)
|
78 (17.61)
|
38 (17.04)
|
|
Ethnicity
|
|
|
|
0.184, .09
|
Declined
|
155 (23.27)
|
98 (22.12)
|
57 (25.56)
|
|
Non-Hispanic
|
457 (68.62)
|
315 (71.11)
|
142 (63.68)
|
|
Hispanic
|
54 (8.11)
|
30 (6.77)
|
24 (10.76)
|
|
Race
|
|
|
|
0.986, 0.09
|
Asian
|
51 (7.66)
|
35 (7.9)
|
16 (7.17)
|
|
Black
|
62 (9.31)
|
38 (8.58)
|
24 (10.76)
|
|
Declined
|
125 (18.77)
|
77 (17.38)
|
48 (21.52)
|
|
Other
|
72 (10.81)
|
41 (9.26)
|
31 (13.9)
|
|
White
|
356 (53.45)
|
252 (56.88)
|
104 (46.64)
|
|
Table 4 – breakdown of actions and behaviors of patient’s including in EFP for endoscopy
Endoscopy
|
|
Number of Patients included
|
666
|
Total Offers
|
9338
|
Accepted offers
|
322
|
Declined offers
|
821
|
Expired offers
|
7640
|
Deleted Offers
|
2
|
Appt no longer available
|
533
|
Average Days improvement for accepted appointments
|
50.43
|
Completed appointments
|
168 (77.42%)
|
No shows
|
2 (0.92%)
|
Cancellations
|
47 (21.66%)
|
Scheduled
|
105
|
Percent offers viewed
|
6588 (70.55%)
|
Percent offers viewed within 1 hour of release
|
1311 (14.04%)
|
In echocardiogram, using chi-square to assess difference in demographics, patients who interacted with EFP (by either actively accepting or declining an offer at some point) differed significantly in ethnicity, tending to be more non-Hispanic than those who did not interact (P = .006). They also tended to be female (P = .11) and white (P = .20) although these did not achieve significance. Age did not seem to be a factor (P = .68).
In endoscopy, using chi-square to assess difference in demographics, patients interacting with EFP were significantly more likely to be female (P = .04) and were more likely to be non-Hispanic (P = .09) and white (P = .09) although these did not reach a significant threshold. Again, age did not seem to be a major factor (P = .49).
For complete chi-square tables please see supplemental tables.