This study explored the feasibility of using a lower tube voltage of 60 kVp for patients with BMI ≤ 26 kg/m2 in CCTA. Some previous study have validated that the low tube voltage of 70 kVp could help to reduce the radiation dose for these subjects with BMI ≤ 26 kg/m2[7, 14]. However, there is still no a study discussing whether using the CCTA protocol with a lower tube voltage of 60 kVp can effectively reduce the radiation dose for these subjects with BMI ≤ 26 kg/m2. Furthermore, we found that the CCTA protocol with the low tube voltage of 60 kVp can also contribute to the reduction of contrast agent dose.
Due to the characteristics of X-rays, the literature on CCTA examination at a tube voltage of 70 kVp [7] indicates the feasibility of a contrast injection flow rate of 3 ml/s and a dose of 33 ml, with the contrast injection rate and dose positively correlated with the tube voltage. Therefore, a lower tube voltage of 60 kVp could consider a lower contrast dose (28 ml) and an injection flow rate (2.5 ml/s), reducing the likelihood of adverse reactions and radiological adverse events caused by iodinated contrast agents[15, 16] compared to the conventional CCTA examination. The one-beat (free heart imaging) protocol, also known as cardiac freezing technology, uses motion correction technology (CardioCapture) to reduce respiratory motion artifacts and improve the low tube voltage CCTA examination success rate [17]. The iterative Karl-3D reconstruction algorithm reduces image noise and improves image quality to meet clinical diagnostic requirements at a lower radiation dose [18–21]. The peak energy of X-ray photons under the tube voltage of 60 kVp is close to the K-edge of contrast agent materials (33 keV for iodine) [22], enabling higher image contrast under the premise of reducing the total amount of iodine. However, the reduction of X-photons passing through the examined body usually results in a relatively poor SNR ratio. Therefore, the Karl-3D iteration algorithm is needed to improve the CCTA image quality, and the one-beat heart freezing technology is also used to reduce the interference of subject respiratory motion artifacts and further improve the CCTA image quality.
This study analyzed CCTA images of 107 subjects with BMI ≤ 26 kg/m2. Results were: CT values, SNR and CNR results of AO, RCA, LAD and LCX in the low-dose group are higher than that in the conventional group. However, except for the AO, CT values, SNR and CNR results of RCA, LAD and LCX are not statistically significant between the two groups (P values > 0.05). Besides, there is no significant difference for the objective evaluation of coronary arteries (RCA, LAD, LCX) between the low-dose group and the conventional group, while objective image evaluation of AO in the low-dose group was slightly better than that in the conventional group, showing improved image quality compared to the conventional group. The Cohen's kappa coefficient of both groups are over 0.81, indicating there is an almost perfect agreement between two raters in both groups and there is no significant difference between these two groups in this study. Radiation dose of the conventional group is higher than that of the low-dose group. All dose indicators of the conventional group are significantly higher than that of the low-dose group, which is about 7.5 times that of the low-dose group (P values < 0.001). This fact indicates that the low-dose group could effectively reduce radiation dose compared to the conventional group.
The tube voltage is usually set to 120 kVp for the conventional CCTA examination based on common CT scanners, and it is reduced to 100 kVp in the high-end uCT960 + scanner. However, the correspondinhg ED value at 100 kVp tube voltage still remains around 4.073 mSv. In this study, the ED value can be controled to 0.541 mSv for the uCT960 + to combined with 60 kVp tube voltage, One-beat (free-heart imaging) protocol and iterative Karl-3D reconstruction algorithm for CCTA examination, indicating a significantly effective radiation dose reduction for subjects.
It should be noted that this work has several limitations. For example, the number of selected subjects is small and the gold standard (DSA) is lacked. More experimental validations and analyses are required in future researches.
In conclusion, One-beat protocol incorporating ultra-low tube voltage of 60 kVp scanning technology based on uCT960 + scanner can obtain a satisfactory CCTA image quality meeting clinical requirements. Given the reduction of radiation dose and contrast dose, this scheme may have a good clinical application prospect.