4.1 Adjustment of the Pandemic Policy and Parents’ Mental Health
Before the pandemic policy was adjusted, the outbreak of COVID-19 in China prompted the implementation of comprehensive and strict measures to limit the spread of the virus (Li et al., 2020). However, these measures had unintended consequences, with many parents experiencing heightened levels of parenting stress, anxiety, and uncertainty. Furthermore, the lack of social interaction and outdoor activities exacerbates parents' mental health issues (Liu et al., 2022). In December 2022, China adjusted its pandemic policies, canceling several control measures related to COVID-19 (Wilson & Flahault, 2023). This brought about a sense of relief and hope for many parents, as they were able to resume in-person schooling and social activities. These changes provided much-needed respite, allowing parents to feel more relaxed and less overwhelmed. Nevertheless, ongoing uncertainty surrounding the pandemic and the emergence of new variants have also contributed to lingering feelings of anxiety and stress(Canady, 2020). Importantly the potential mental health consequences of major societal changes resulting from changing COVID-19 restrictions in China cannot be directly compared with those in other countries. Our findings highlight a significant impact on parents' mental health during this unprecedented period, with varying levels of depression, anxiety, and parenting stress experienced depending on demographic factors, preexisting COVID-19 experiences, and lifestyles.
4.2 Socioeconomic Disadvantages and Increased Mental Health Risks during COVID-19
The present study examined the impact of socioeconomic disadvantages on Chinese parents during the first wave of nationwide infection, which occurred in the first three weeks after the adjustment of the pandemic policy. Our findings indicate that lower parent age, lower social status scores, lower household income, more children, and mothers were associated with worse mental health conditions among parents. These results are consistent with findings related to general adult samples in other countries (Moreland-Russell et al., 2022), but our study extends the literature by focusing specifically on parents and highlighting important associations with socioeconomic factors. Notably, 92.8% of the parents in our sample reported that they were infected or under infection during the first three weeks after the policy adjustment. Vulnerable families with socioeconomic disadvantages, such as those with lower social status scores and household income, were particularly affected during the pandemic and were at the highest risk of facing ongoing uncertainty surrounding the pandemic and the emergence of new variants. Douglas et al. (2020) reported that these effects are even more daunting for families with low incomes or limited employment options, families who face greater health risks, and families who face inequities in access to educational and health resources, deepening the racial and ethnic divide in educational attainment and overall health and well-being. Moreland-Russell et al. (2022) reported that being female or experiencing job or income loss were associated with worse mental health and working from home or part-time and job or income loss due to COVID-19 were associated with poor parental mental health. Our findings underscore the need for targeted interventions and support services to help vulnerable families cope with the negative impacts of the pandemic on their mental health.
Similarly, we found that the number of children in a household was associated with a higher level of parenting stress and the perceived impact of policy adjustment. It is possible that a larger household size was associated with fewer resources allocated to each family member. Kang and colleagues (2023) reported that family size was positively related to the use of violent discipline, because they faced job loss or reduced income due to COVID-19, which contributed to the worsening mental health status. Johnson and colleagues (2021) reported that parents who lived with more than one child in the household reported more parental stress. Disposable income decreases as family size increases. Therefore, families may be under more financial strain when the household size is larger.
Moreover, we found that parent age significantly predicted parenting stress. Specifically, we observed that young parents experienced greater parenting stress when facing large-scale public infections, possibly due to their lack of childcare experience and limited social and health resources, which are particularly relevant in the context of policy adjustments. Johnson and colleagues (2021) found that younger parents (ages 21–44) reported significantly higher levels of parental stress than older parents did. These findings may reflect a general vulnerability among younger parents, who have less experience with parenting combined with the increased burden of having younger children to take care of. These findings highlight the importance of considering parental age and related factors in understanding parenting stress in challenging circumstances.
Our study examined the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on mothers and fathers, who are the primary caregivers of families. We found that mothers experienced greater negative impacts of policy adjustment and parenting stress than fathers did, likely due to the increased amount of time spent at home by both parents and children during the pandemic. This dynamic led to greater interaction between mothers and children, which in turn contributed to higher levels of parenting stress among mothers. Our findings are in line with those of a previous study in which female sex was associated with poor mental health (Moreland-Russell et al., 2022). This may be derived from the disproportionate care thken by women and the associated greater burden in overcoming challenges related to the pandemic. These findings highlight the unique challenges faced by mothers during the pandemic and the importance of considering gender in research on the effects of public health crises on families.
4.3 Preexisting COVID-19 experience and Mental Health Risks
Since the outbreak of COVID-19 in 2020, China has implemented a markedly different approach to address the pandemic than other countries around the world have. One key difference is the level of government control and enforcement of public health measures. China has implemented strict measures, including lockdowns, travel restrictions, and mandatory quarantine, with severe penalties for noncompliance. In addition, China implemented widespread testing and contact tracing early in the pandemic, which helped contain the spread of the virus. While these measures were effective in controlling the outbreak, they also had a significant impact on individuals, as many people experienced lockdowns, travel restrictions, and quarantine(Wu et al., 2021) .
In the present study, preexisting COVID-19 experience was differently associated with Chinese parents’ mental health conditions during the first wave of nationwide infection following the policy adjustment. In line with previous studies, the COVID-19 pandemic has had a profound impact on individuals through the impacts of environmental stressors (Westrupp et al., 2021). In our study, parents who lived in areas previously designated as medium to high risk for COVID-19 reported higher levels of depression and perceived more negative impacts of the policy adjustment. The experience of living in high or medium risk areas may contribute to depression, anxiety, and increased stress related to parenting in the context of a pandemic (Chi et al., 2020). The negative experience from the environmental stressors caused by the pandemic may also contribute to increased tension within families (Ben Brik et al., 2022). Additionally, the negative experience of living in an area of heightened risk can cause parents to become overly cautious or fearful when facing new challenges and uncertainty after policy adjustment, leading to social isolation and a reduced sense of community, which could be a possible cause of depression (Johnson et al., 2022; Yue et al., 2022). The uncertainty and fear associated with the virus, combined with the added responsibility of managing home-based learning for children, can exacerbate these negative feelings and expectations during the early stages of policy adjustment (Morgan et al., 2022).
During the COVID-19 pandemic, many parents and children in China experienced remote learning due to quarantine measures (Deng et al., 2021). However, our study found that this experience had negative impacts on parents' mental health after policy adjustment, which is in line with prior research (Adams et al., 2021). Specifically, parents reported increased levels of depression, anxiety, and parenting stress (Moreland-Russell et al., 2022). It is possible that the added responsibility of managing their children's education at home, combined with potential disruptions to work schedules and increased financial stress, contributed to these negative feelings (Douglas et al., 2020; Killgore et al., 2021). Furthermore, parents from socioeconomically disadvantaged backgrounds, may feel pressure to ensure that their children receive adequate education, and may experience guilt or frustration if they perceive their own limitations in supporting their child's learning. In addition, the lack of social interaction and increased isolation associated with remote learning may exacerbate feelings of loneliness and depression for both parents and children in the face of ongoing uncertainty and the threat of infection.
The COVID-19 pandemic has led to unprecedented disruptions in daily life and increased isolation, including periods of quarantine (Demaria & Vicari, 2021; Johnson et al., 2022). While being quarantined or isolated can be challenging for many parents, it also presents opportunities to build resilience and coping skills within family lives (Pugliese et al., 2022). Research has shown that parents spend significantly more time at home during quarantine, which may increase opportunities for parent-child interaction and strengthen their relationships (Khoory et al., 2022). Furthermore, parents reported a greater sense of connection to their children during quarantine (Wozniak-Prus et al., 2023).
In this context, the experience of quarantine may help parents explore creative approaches to home-based education and parenting. It can provide an opportunity for reflection on parents’ own parenting styles and perspective-taking, which may lead to improved mental health and a more positive outlook on the future, even in the face of uncertainty (Wozniak-Prus et al., 2023). Additionally, quarantine can foster adaptability and resilience, which are valuable skills for navigating future challenges (Pugliese et al., 2022). Therefore, our findings suggest that the experience of quarantine was associated with alleviating the depression, anxiety and pressure associated with home-based education and parenting during the policy adjustment.
4.4 Protective Factor of Parents’ Mental Health: Sleep
The present study revealed that sleep duration is a comprehensive protective factor against the mental health challenges faced by Chinese parents during the COVID-19 policy adjustment. Higher sleep duration was associated with lower levels of depression, anxiety, and parenting stress, as well as more positive perceived impacts of policy adjustment among Chinese parents. Research has consistently demonstrated that adequate sleep and good sleep habits are associated with overall health and well-being, including improved mood, cognitive function, and physical vitality (AlDabal & BaHammam, 2011). Notably, 92.8% of the Chinese parents in our study reported being infected or having family members infected within the first three weeks after the policy adjustment. Adequate sleep has been shown to have a positive effect on immune function, which is especially important when facing ongoing uncertainty surrounding the pandemic and nationwide infection (Wearick-Silva et al., 2022). Therefore, prioritizing sleep is an important protective factor for maintaining healthy mental and physical conditions after pandemic policy adjustment.
4.5 Implications
Overall, this study highlights the importance of considering the mental health of parents in the context of pandemics. We identified several factors connected with poorer mental health outcomes when facing infection threat and the uncertainty of future pandemic conditions during policy adjustment, most notably socioeconomic disadvantages, preexisting COVID-19 experiences and inadequate sleep. Our findings provide empirical evidence for policy actions to support and protect families from the likely adverse impacts of the pandemic. For example, additional support should be provided for older parents, mothers, and families with many children. Parents with socioeconomic disadvantages may experience more pressure to ensure that their children receive adequate education and health support during the pandemic, leading to guilt or frustration if they perceive their own limitations in supporting their children during public health emergencies. Mothers and parents of older age and large family sizes should prioritize their own self-care and seek support from others, as they appear to be susceptible to the negative psychological impact of policy adjustment. Special attention should be given to socioeconomically disadvantaged parents, as they are at high risk for mental health problems.
Our results suggest that parenting stress and mental health concerns (e.g., depression and anxiety) are associated with greater perceived impacts among children in online classes, schools, and educational institutions. Therefore, schools should play a role in supporting parents by providing resources and guidance to support remote learning. Programs that focus on home-based learning and finding new ways to support children's education should also be developed for vulnerable parents. Furthermore, our findings support increased investment in evidence-based mental health interventions for parents, children, and families who have negative preexisting COVID-19 experiences. Governments and healthcare institutions should provide support and resources to help families cope with the ongoing effects of the pandemic.
While a large majority of participants reported their infection during the study, as a protective factor, our results highlight the importance of adequate sleep for parents in a policy adjustment context. Parents should be aware of the potential positive effects of sleep, particularly when they and their children are at risk for mental health problems during pandemic. Maintaining adequate sleep can be an effective strategy for parents to promote both mental and physical health at a minimal cost.
4.6 Limitations and Future Directions
Several limitations of the present study should be noted. First, prepandemic mental health data were not collected, which may have influenced our results as preexisting mental health conditions and other factors related to the impact of COVID-19 were not taken into account. Second, our sample consisted of Chinese parents from urban areas, limiting the generalization of our findings to more diverse socioeconomic backgrounds. Future research should aim to recruit a more diverse sample of parents to better understand the mental health challenges faced by parents from different backgrounds. Finally, our study examined only the mental health of Chinese parents within the first three weeks following the policy adjustment. As pandemic policies continue to change and evolve, future research should consider using longitudinal designs to examine how the predictive factors identified in our study relate to changes in parents' mental health outcomes over a longer period of time. It is important for researchers to identify both risk and protective factors that impact parents' mental health during highly stressful public health crises on a longer time scale.