This study evaluates the prognostic value of the BAPCOR scoring system on DSA for predicting clinical outcomes in patients treated with EVT for acute BAO. The results show that the BAPCOR score is a reliable predictor of clinical outcomes in acute BAO cases. Patients with higher BAPCOR scores are more likely to achieve favorable outcomes post-endovascular treatment at 3 months.
Numerous studies highlight the significance of collateral circulation in acute BAO cases [16], and assessing thrombus burden and collaterals in acute BAO plays an important role for determining prognosis and treatment efficacy. Collateral flow in BAO could originate from the anterior circulation through PCoAs, the posterior aspect of the C7 segment of the internal carotid artery (ICA), and anastomoses of cerebellar arteries. CTA and DSA are two commonly employed imaging modalities for identifying the culprit occlusive vessel and evaluating collateral flow in acute BAO patients. Favorable pretreatment collateral status has been associated to higher chances of positive outcomes following EVT for acute BAO. Ongoing efforts seek to standardize collateral assessment to facilitate more reliable and generalizable investigations into its clinical implications. Therefore, collaterals assessment represents a valuable aspect of acute BAO management, offering insights into predicting patient outcomes and informing treatment decisions.
CTA has become increasingly prevalent for collateral assessment in acute BAO due to its noninvasive nature, rapid imaging capabilities, and ability to visualize collateral flow from all vessels simultaneously. Several CTA-based grading systems have been used to assess thrombus burden and collateral flow, demonstrating predictive value for outcomes of acute BAO (Table 3). It is well documented that the presence of bilateral PcoA has been associated with a favorable prognosis following intravascular therapy [10]. van der Hoeven et al. [11] proposed the Posterior Circulation Collateration Score (PC-CS), mainly evaluating primary and secondary posterior circulation. Da Ros et al [12] assessed the extent of vertebrobasilar artery occlusion using the Vascular Computed Tomography Based Grading System in Posterior Circulation (PC-CTA). Additionally, Alemseged et al proposed the BATMAN score, which considers thrombus length and primary collateral circulation in acute BAO cases [13]. Their study showed that patients with a BATMAN score ≥ 7 are more likely to benefit from EVT and have favorable prognoses. However, the PC-CS, PC-CTA, and BATMAN scales predominantly rely on single-phase CTA images, which may be less sensitive to delayed collateral perfusion, thus inadequately reflecting collateral blood flow that fills slowly downstream of BAO.
Table 3
Comparison of prognostic score studies for acute basilar artery occlusion treated with endovascular thrombectomy.
| Year | Nomenclature | No. of cases | Total Scores | BAO length: P1/BA/V4 | Primary collateral: PcoA | Secondary collaterals: SCA/AICA/PICA | Favorable outcome score |
CTA | | | | | | | | |
Goyal | 2016 | CS | 21 | 2 | / | +/+ | - | 2 |
van der Hoeven | 2016 | PC-CS | 149 | 10 | / | ++/++ | ++/++/++ | ≥ 6 |
Da Ros | 2016 | PC-CTA | 15 | 6 | --/---/- | / | / | ≤ 2 |
Alemseged | 2017 | BATMAN-CTA | 73 | 10 | ++/+++/+ | ++/++ | / | ≥ 7 |
DSA | | | | | | | | |
Yang | 2018 | BATMAN-DSA | 63 | 10 | ++/+++/+ | ++/++ | / | ≥ 3 |
Shen | 2024 | BAPCOR | 47 | 15 | ++/+++/+ | ++/++ | ++/++/+ | ≥ 8.5 |
+: 1 point for presence of artery; -: 1 point for absence of artery. |
CTA still faces limitations in assessment of collateral circulation in posterior circulation stroke due to an incomplete understanding of its hemodynamics [17]. As the gold standard for diagnosing cerebrovascular disease, DSA offers superior spatial and temporal resolution, dynamically displaying blood flow direction and velocity, thus providing richer information. Although DSA-based ASITN/SIR scale [18] has been initially applied for posterior circulation strokes, it lacks specificity for acute BAO, and the PCoA scale overlooks the leptomeningeal anastomoses from the anterior circulation and cerebellar arteries.
Through investigation of the BATMAN score on different imaging modalities, Yang et al. [14] found that a BATMAN-DSA score ≥ 3 may be associated with good prognosis, which is much lower than the threshold of BATMAN-CTA ≥ 7. In our study, we further verified that a BATMAN-DSA score ≥ 4.5 is an independent predictor of a good prognosis. Moreover, the BAPCOR grading system for acute BAO offers a more comprehensive interpretation of the correlation between collateral circulation and good prognoses, encompassing thrombus burden, primary, and secondary collateral circulation. Similarly, the DSA-based angiographic collateral grading system for BAO (ACGS-BAO) emphasized the significance of the top of the BA in predicting EVT outcomes [15]. Both BAPCOR and ACG-BAO provide richer collateral circulation information, enhancing the comprehensiveness and reliability of assessing clinical outcomes in acute BAO treated with EVT.
Following the greenway mode of stroke in our stroke center, we adopted a comprehensive imaging approach combining “CT + DWI + MRA + DSA” to assess patients suspected of acute posterior circulation infarction due to large vessel occlusion. Specifically, DWI accurately detected the site of posterior circulation infarction, while MRA identified the presence of large vessel occlusion. Rapid pre-treatment DSA was utilized to pinpoint the culprit occlusive vessel and evaluate collateral circulation, providing valuable information for the surgical team. In addition, whenever feasible, local anesthesia was preferred to expedite DPT or DRT.
The BATMAN scoring system assesses the length of thrombus and primary collateral, whereas the BAPCOR scoring system offers better prediction for acute BAO by evaluating the length of thrombus, primary, and secondary collaterals. A higher BAPCOR score indicates a shorter thrombus or better collateral circulation, potentially correlating with a good clinical outcome in patients with acute BAO.
The main limitations of this study include its retrospective design at a single center, the relatively small sample size, and potential selection bias. In addition, the use of aspiration as the first-line EVT technique was relatively uncommon.