In the general context where we evaluated abundance patterns between zones, we showed that the infrastructure zone (IZ) and moderate use zone (MZ) concentrate the highest abundances of endemic birds. In addition, we noted that endemic species are distributed particularly in the IZ and MZ and that, from another perspective, these species occur widely in the conservation zone (CZ), IZ and MZ. Under a general approach to the use of phytophysiognomies along the transects, we analyzed the abundance patterns of vulnerable birds along the Cerrado stricto sensu and Riparian Forests in the NP. We also assessed how the species are distributed across these phytophysiognomies and presented a scenario of historical and future vulnerability of the NP based on annual fires and deforestation in and around the area.
Patterns and key species for conservation in the NP
The prevalence of endemic birds in the NP may be due to the wide coverage of native vegetation and, therefore, the low impact of anthropogenic activities on Cerrado stricto sensu formations and Riparian Forests in the three zones, especially IZ and MZ (Aguiar et al. 2015; Schwaida et al. 2023). These zones were originally intended for visitation in the NP, covering 83% of its extension (ICMBio 2019),, and have proved crucial for the conservation of the vulnerable birds assessed here. In more detail, the Cerrado stricto sensu and Riparian Forests, in turn, occupy the majority of the NP (92%), (ICMBio 2019). However, we reiterate the need for future studies on the composition, richness and diversity of birds in phytophysiognomies not assessed here. In this sense, the Campo Limpido Humidum/Vereda (2.9% of the PA), Campo Limpido/Sujo (2.1%) and Cerradão (0.5%) are formations that potentially harbor critical habitats, including potential Cerrado endemics in the NP.
In this way, we emphasize that this scenario is extremely positive, since the persistence of endemic birds in these territories may be a reflection of the proper design of management actions and use of the territories. Therefore, we stress that maintaining minimum viable populations of vulnerable birds by conserving the heterogeneity and coverage of native vegetation in these locations may be perfectly feasible. For this reason, our study reinforces the need to reconcile sustainable management practices and ecotourism in the search for greater conservation effectiveness in the NP and in reserves with similar zoning contexts (Stronza et al. 2019; Develey 2021; Lees et al. 2022). This perspective is corroborated especially because the transect evaluated in IZ is part of one of the access routes to the second main tourist attraction in the NP. It is estimated that the Cachoeira da Prata (-6.99S and -47.165W) receives around 10,000 to 12,000 tourists a year (REGO, 2023 - head of the NP; Personal communication), a visitation dynamic that apparently has had no impact on the persistence of vulnerable birds in IZ (ICMBio 2019).
From a broader point of view, we stress that the planning of actions for the conservation and management of the NP, and particularly of its avifauna, should consider two fronts (Margules and Pressey 2000). Therefore, long-term systematic monitoring of bird communities (1), (De Lima et al. 2022; Pollock et al. 2022) and the inclusion of local residents in actions to combat natural and anthropogenic impacts (2) are key actions (Dawson et al. 2021). This is especially relevant given the essential role of large PAs in the conservation of the Brazilian Cerrado and the crucial need for continued action in this direction (Dawson et al. 2021; Pollock et al. 2022).
Of the seven endemic birds evaluated here, six have been recorded in an IBA in the state of Maranhão: Neothraupis fasciata (Chapada dos Veadeiros National Park), Melanopareia torquata, Cypsinagra hirundinacea, Cyanocorax cristatellus, Charitospiza eucosma and Saltatricula atricollis (Boa Esperança Dam), (De Luca et al. 2009). In specific terms, we would point out that the wide distribution of M. torquata, C. cristatellus, and C. eucosma, Procnias averano, Campylorhamphus trochilirostris, and Ara chloropterus throughout the three zones and phytophysiognomies may be a reflection of the dynamic connectivity between the savannah and forest formations in the NP. For example, M. torquata is a bird typical of grassland regions predominantly made up of sparse Cerrado, especially landscapes rich in termite mounds and insects (Sick 1997; Sigrist 2010). On the other hand, C. cristatellus is a typically arboreal species that occupies transition zones encompassing grassland and densely wooded areas, and is not restricted to a single habitat (Sick 1997; Sigrist 2010). With a similarly dynamic ecological preference, Charitospiza eucosma usually uses both spaced shrubs and Cerrado fields (Sick 1997; Sigrist 2010).
More specifically, P. averano is among the most important dispersers of plants through the consumption of fruits that make up its typically frugivorous diet (Sick 1997). The species has been included among the endemic and threatened birds of crucial importance in the conservation of the Atlantic Forest in northeastern Brazil, especially due to its presence in ecotonal regions (Pereira et al. 2016). This reiterates the potential role of Procnias averano as a target species for the conservation of vulnerable birds in the NP, especially since this PA is made up of multiple phytophysiognomies and ecotonal interfaces. Similarly, the wide occurrence of C. trochilirostris throughout the three zones may be a direct reflection of the connectivity between these territories. This hypothesis is reinforced since the species is typically associated with flooded riparian forests, potentially transiting along these formations that connect a range of phytophysiognomic formations in the NP (Sick 1997; Bennett 2003a, b; Sigrist 2010; ICMBio 2019). Furthermore, C. trochilirostris is perhaps the species that clearly represents the dynamics and distribution of the more than 400 springs of the Tocantins River present in the NP (ICMBio 2019). This is why we emphasize that the numerous riparian corridors and, consequently, the diversity of habitats present in the different zones are critical aspects in terms of the connectivity and conservation of the NP (Sick 1997; Beier and Noss 1998; Bennett 2003a; Wiegand et al. 2005; Sigrist 2010; ICMBio 2019; Fischer et al. 2021; Pörtner et al. 2021). Although assessed as a species not at risk (LC), Ara chloropterus is a bird that, similar to the others mentioned above, moves between savannah and forest formations (Sick 1997; Sigrist 2010). This reinforces the patterns shown here in which the vulnerable birds of the NP are widely distributed throughout the zones and particularly concentrated in the Cerrado Stricto Sensu and Riparian Forest formations.
In terms of vulnerability, A. chloropterus is one of the main targets of wildlife trafficking in Brazil (Halle 2018). For example, almost 30,000 specimens were exported to more than 55 different countries/territories between 2000 and 2013 (Halle 2018). The impact of population decline resulting from habitat loss and trafficking are such imminent risks to the species that it has been considered virtually extinct in Rio de Janeiro, vulnerable in Paraná, and critically endangered in São Paulo (Halle 2018; WWF 2021).
In a similar context, the true parrot (Amazona aestiva) is one of the psittaciformes most threatened by wildlife trafficking in Brazil and South America (Costa et al. 2018; Halle 2018). The search for specimens of A. aestiva is fueled especially by its extraordinary ability to imitate, which is why it is considered the most "talkative" species and one of the rarest parrots, from this illegal perspective (Sick 1997; Sigrist 2010; Halle 2018). In just 13 years, A. aestiva has had 60,780 individuals exported outside South America. In particular, South Africa and Argentina accounted for almost 80% of this illegal export (Halle 2018). In addition, we would highlight the fact that the species is among the main taxa received at Wild Animal Rehabilitation Centers (CETAS). This has occurred mainly because A. aestiva is the target of clandestine capture after the reproductive period, when the chicks are under parental care (Costa et al. 2018; Halle 2018). Particularly in Brazil, between 2005 and 2009, CETAS received 250,206 birds which, in turn, corresponded to the biological group with the highest number of individuals killed due to mistreatment in captivity (86%), (Destro et al. 2012). In the same period, A. estiva was the 15th most seized bird in enforcement and anti-trafficking operations (Destro et al. 2012). In this sense, given the intense flow of tourists that predominates in the NP, we cannot rule out the hypothesis that A. aestiva may attract criminal actions aimed at capturing it and other birds of economic interest. This scenario reinforces the importance of periodic inspections in large PAs which, similar to the NP, are home to psittaciformes as vulnerable and targeted by trafficking as A. chloropterus and A. aestiva.
From a final perspective of analysis in terms of ecology and vulnerability, C. ferdinandi is a species whose way of life (OLMOS; SILVA; PACHECO, 2006) clearly reflects the dynamics of connectivity and transition between the Cerrado Stricto Sensu and forest landscapes (Ribeiro and Walter 2008). The species tends to forage near bodies of water and occurs along riparian or gallery forests, preferably in dense lianas and shrubs (Sick 1997; Sigrist 2010, 2013). In addition to this availability of habitat, the choice of climatic biodiversity refuges with a focus on species as vulnerable as C. ferdinandi is a fundamental strategy in Cerrado conservation planning (Borges et al. 2019; Borges and Loyola 2020). This is because the species is among the four birds that will potentially be most vulnerable in the Cerrado in 27 years (Borges and Loyola 2020). The reason is that its occurrence could be restricted to areas completely outside those indicated as refuges in the face of the synergistic impact of deforestation and climate change (Borges et al. 2019; Borges and Loyola 2020). In detail, Cercomacra ferdinandi, along with Pyrrhura pfrimeri, Synallaxis simoni, and Paroaria baeri, has conservation priority, essentially with a focus on monitoring their populations (Borges and Loyola 2020). Fortunately, in the interior of the NP, the forecasts are positive in terms of deforestation (Fig. 7, 1), however, we warn of the long-term destructive effect that fires can have on the habitats critical to the population maintenance of C. ferdinandi. Until recently, the species was recorded predominantly in PAs located in the state of Tocantins (Cantão State Park, Araguaia National Park, Bananal Island Environmental Protection Area), (Dornas and Pinheiro 2018). Therefore, recording the species in the NP broadens the prospects in terms of conservation, especially with a view to mapping key areas for establishing ecological corridors that include the species' distribution and living areas (Olmos et al. 2006; Sigrist 2010; Dornas and Pinheiro 2018; Ferreira 2021).
Taken together, projections indicate that the occurrence of these species will be limited to regions with a greater extent of native vegetation, however, under high climatic abnormalities (Borges and Loyola 2020). In this sense, we are alerted to the fact that the NP is located in one of the regions where there will potentially be less native Cerrado vegetation cover and climate instability by 2050 (Borges and Loyola 2020). This reinforces the primary role of the NP in the conservation of C. ferdinandi, since this PA is still home to an area mostly made up of primary Cerrado formations and their ecotonal transitions (97.7% coverage), (ICMBio 2019). In addition, the NP is at the limit of C. ferdinandi 's distribution, which potentially includes key microhabitats for the conservation of the species both within the PA and along adjacent ecosystems. Since C. ferdinandi was only recorded once in this study, we would like to point out that there are still numerous gaps, notably knowledge regarding reproductive sites, density patterns and the species' home range in the NP. Among the priority actions for the conservation of C. ferdinandi is the mapping of relevant areas for the implementation of ecological corridors throughout its area of occurrence (Olmos et al. 2004; Pinheiro and Dornas 2009; Dornas and Pinheiro 2018). This makes the NP and its multiple networks of riparian corridors and springs a potential scenario for the conservation of the species. Especially, the expansion of dams and hydroelectric plants on the Tocantins River, particularly the Estreito Hydroelectric Plant (Maranhão), represent the main threats to populations of C. ferdinandi (Olmos et al. 2004; Pinheiro and Dornas 2009; Dornas et al. 2012).
This reinforces the need to expand our knowledge of the species' biology and distribution in the NP, where its populations are theoretically protected from these threats. More broadly, this myriad of available habitats are potential targets for practices such as multi-species monitoring via radiotelemetry, the release of post-rehabilitation individuals in CETAS or the strengthening of endangered species via reintroduction or translocation. Therefore, systematic long-term planning becomes critical in the NP, especially considering the current and future picture of destruction in the Cerrado and increased susceptibility to fires in response to climate change. The potential effect of stressors on the NP's avifauna due to the influx of tourists and the vulnerability of species to wildlife trafficking also reinforce this picture of threats. We therefore highlight the unique importance that the NP represents for the conservation of the Cerrado, its vulnerable species and biodiversity expressed through provisioning services, regulation, cultural values and well-being.
The potential future vulnerability of the NP as a Single Large reserve
The NP is at an average distance of 180 km from other PAs which, in detail, are the Mata Grande Extractive Reserve and the Parnaíba River Springs National Park (Maranhão) and the Tocantins Fossilized Trees Natural Monument. This makes the NP a Single Large reserve immersed in an unprotected matrix and under historic anthropogenic impacts.
Large PAs such as the NP constitute effective barriers against deforestation in the Cerrado (Nelson and Chomitz 2009). As we have shown here, deforestation has shown a historical reduction under a future perspective of annual rates that could reach zero from 2025 onwards (Fig. 7, 1). However, we also note that the ecosystems adjacent to the NP could be completely impacted by deforestation (Fig. 7, 1). This is critical given that the reduction in effective size as well as the loss of crucial habitats in response to anthropogenic impacts results in the destruction of external sources of colonizers (Lahti and Ranta 1985; DeFries et al. 2007; Belote and Wilson 2020; Fahrig et al. 2022; Riva and Fahrig 2022; Szangolies et al. 2022). In terms of bird conservation, adjacent ecosystems play an essential role. This is because populations can concentrate in small hotspots outside PAs, potentially harboring individuals of critical importance in species turnover (Brown 1984; Brown and Kodric-Brown 1997; Hanski 1998; Hanski and Ovaskainen 2000). From this perspective of prevalent fires in and around the interior and the extensive suppression of ecosystems adjacent to the NP, we warn that this PA could represent a major site of extinctions in the future (Simberloff and Abele 1976; Pickett and Thompson 1978; Fahrig 2020). More specifically, with low or zero colonization rates, extinction becomes the dominant process in populations, impacting the dynamic balance of the PA and culminating in the long-term decline of species (Pickett and Thompson 1978; Hansen and DeFries 2007).
This context reinforces the urgency of making political decisions that substantially reduce deforestation in the area surrounding the NP. As it is a Single Large reserve, ecological restoration programs and the establishment of corridors that include adjacent ecosystems are key strategies for mitigating these potential impacts. Particularly in the Cerrado, the remnants of native vegetation adjacent to PAs have been mostly converted into monocultures and pastures (Carvalho et al. 2009; Aguiar et al. 2015; Françoso et al. 2015; Schwaida et al. 2023). This brings us to a challenging global scenario involving destructive land use and occupation models, the urgent need to restore ecosystems and establish dynamic areas (Several Small), (MMA 2010; Françoso et al. 2015; Edwards et al. 2019; Belote and Wilson 2020; Fahrig 2020; Riva and Fahrig 2022).
Theories such as metapopulation dynamics (Hanski 1998), island biogeography (Simberloff and Abele 1976; Wilson 2009) as well as disturbance ecology (Rykiel 1985; Burton et al. 2020) and landscape ecology (Hobbs 1993; Wiens 2009) have sought to understand the processes that determine spatial patterns in dynamic ecosystems such as those present in the NP (DeFries et al. 2007; Belote and Wilson 2020; Fahrig et al. 2022; Riva and Fahrig 2022; Szangolies et al. 2022). Overcoming this challenge requires understanding not only the patterns of internal dynamics between the mosaics of habitats and phytophysiognomies, but above all the role of adjacent ecosystems in maintaining biodiversity within PAs (Brown 1984; Hanski 1998; Belote and Wilson 2020). The imminent biotic homogenization in response to the extensive global destruction of natural remnants has resulted in a scenario of functional destabilization in ecosystems (Jongman 2002; Wang et al. 2021). Additionally, on a landscape scale, disturbance regimes determine the successional stages of communities along habitat patches, as well as their size and density (Pickett and Thompson 1978). Even knowing the adaptive potential of Cerrado species to fires (Simon and Pennington 2012), an imminent scenario of vulnerability may be unfolding. If we consider the current situation of deforestation around the NP, high temperatures, prolonged droughts and, therefore, greater susceptibility to fires, this PA could lose its resilience in the long term. (Carvalho et al. 2009; Françoso et al. 2015; Zalles et al. 2019; Borges and Loyola 2020; MapBiomas 2023). Therefore, this threat potentially represents one of the clear reflections of environmental stochastic dynamics and its long-term negative effects on PAs (Takashina 2021).
Current and future prospects for the conservation of the NP
The patterns of abundance and use of the zoning interfaces and phytophysiognomies from the birds assessed here constitute a key initial step for continued monitoring and conservation actions in the NP. In this sense, the NP and PAs, which similarly have extensive native vegetation cover, can be effective in conserving vulnerable Cerrado birds, even though they are mostly used for visitation and ecotourism. The myriad of habitats still conserved are key targets in terms of connectivity and conservation in the NP, and are potential targets for practices such as multi-species monitoring via radiotelemetry, release of individuals after rehabilitation in CETAS or population strengthening of threatened species via reintroduction or translocation. Therefore, systematic long-term planning becomes critical in the NP, especially considering the current and future picture of destruction in the Cerrado and increased susceptibility to fires in response to climate change. The potential effect of stressors on the PN's avifauna due to the influx of tourists and the vulnerability of species to wildlife trafficking also reinforce this picture of threats. In this sense, we emphasize the crucial role of the NP for the conservation of the Cerrado, its vulnerable species and biodiversity expressed through provisioning services, regulation, cultural values and well-being.
From a warning perspective that includes the internal dynamics of connectivity, susceptibility to fires and the potential future impact that the destruction of adjacent ecosystems could have on the NP, we highlight some alternatives. Actions to combat deforestation and fires of anthropogenic origin in and around the NP should be a priority. In addition, we suggest establishing restoration programs around the NP, taking into account unprotected natural areas, as well as expanding knowledge about the home range, distribution and reproductive sites of the species targeted in this study. In addition, we emphasize that the NP is a key territory for the conservation of vulnerable Cerrado birds, given the current scenario of species extinction, increased catastrophes in response to climate change and global efforts to restore terrestrial ecosystems. However, we warn of the NP's vulnerability to the imminent destruction of adjacent ecosystems. Substantially reducing deforestation and restoring these territories may be the only way to prevent this Single Large reserve from becoming a site of long-term extinctions.