The overall goal of this study was to contribute to health and wellness coaching literature by increasing our understanding of the relationship between HWC and body image. Our team examined 1) the relationship between participation in a 3-month HWC program and BA and (2) how the change in BA score was related to physical and mental health at baseline. There were two key findings. First, participation in the HWC program had a positive association with participants’ positive body image. Second, greater improvements in BA were linked to higher levels of baseline depression scores. Taken together, these findings are instrumental to supporting the potential benefits of health wellness coaching.
HWC has been shown to have positive effects on overall wellness in chronically ill populations such as those with heart disease, diabetes, and rheumatoid arthritis (23–25, 27, 47). These studies focused on measures of disease, medication compliance, and overall measures of health. Of note, none of these studies measured BA. If body image is part of wellness, as suggested in studies like those conducted by El Ansari et al (2014) and Becker et al (2019), the results of this study are in line with previous literature (10, 48). However, more concreate work surrounding body image and general wellness should be conducted.
To our knowledge there is no prior published study on the relationship between participation in a HWC program and BA or functional physical health measures such as muscular/cardiovascular endurance (i.e., sit-to-stand and 2-minute march test). Given the current evidence on the positive benefits of physical activity behaviors that result from HWC-focused programs, our findings highlight that adults also accrue benefits that promote healthy reflection in a manner that promotes more positive appreciation. This is important because evidence suggests that individuals who report high levels of body dissatisfaction and lower BA scores also report lower quality of life, higher rates of eating disorders, and higher rates of depression (13, 14).
Several implications can be drawn from the findings of this study. First, the experience of chronic illness may have a negative impact on people’s self-concept, as they experience such things as pain, discomfort, weight gain, changes in appearance, and a loss of control over their own bodies. The social stigma that comes along with illness may lead to other psychological destructive behaviors that impact self-esteem, loss of control over body and emotions, and/or feelings of personal failure (49–51). Nonetheless, as more findings become available on understanding how to promote positive health behaviors through health and wellness coaching, the importance of BA will remain an important area to explore and understand among middle-aged to older women at-risk for or with chronic health illness.
Ultimately, body image can be targeted in an effective way, especially among older populations who struggle to engage in physical activity. The investigation exploring the combined effects of a HWC program on BA and physical health measures in middle-aged to older adults with limited access to health and wellness services is worthy of highlighting. Our findings emphasize that both depression and physical fitness are important factors that contribute to mental health and body image (52, 53). Additionally, because the structure of the program was remote and an extension of an existing, sustained program, the findings of this study indicate that a program like Montana Journey to Wellness is one that can be easily applied in multiple areas such as gyms, schools, or medical facilities. Programs such as this can address the often-undiscussed body image issues of later adulthood, wherever they may be.
The Montana Journey to Wellness program, and the resulting study had multiple strengths starting with the implementation of an existing evidence-based (e.g., over 5 years) HWC program (i.e., Journey to Wellness), into two remote rural areas. To our knowledge, we have not identified other HWC programs that have conducted this collaborative approach to provide access and professional health services in adults at risk for chronic illness. The combined exploration of psychological and physical health measures, highlighting BA as an important factor, is also unique to this body of work within the HWC literature that may lead to other important research areas to explore.
In addition to the strengths of this study, the results must be interpreted within the study limitations. Limitations of this work include a lack of generalizability based on the convenience sampling. This intervention did not have a control group, so we are unable to ascertain how effective HWC is compared to traditional medical interventions or no medical interventions. Additionally, this study only included chronically ill women in a rural setting, and it is not possible to say how generalizable this HWC intervention would be on a different
population.