These four cases describe patients harboring two different gene variants in NR32C as cause for renal PHA1, one variant being novel. Two of them had symptoms in childhood but could abstain from medication later. Case 4 would most likely been able to cease medication much earlier.
Case 1
3 with a previously not described genetic variant in the NR32C gene had still elevated aldosterone and normal renin concentration and normal blood pressure in adulthood while Case 4 had elevated both aldosterone and renin concentrations and normal blood pressure. This is in line with the different clinical pictures in renal PHA1, which is also seen within kindreds with the identical genetic variants. Thus, of the two dizygotic patients and their mother only one had salt-wasting manifestations during infancy.
In neonatal kidneys glomerular filtration is reduced and the distal nephron is immature, leading to impaired ability of sodium and water reabsorption. In an investigation of 48 healthy neonates these had increased plasma potassium and aldosterone concentrations, but equivalent sodium levels compared to their mothers [14]. This suggests a partial mineralocorticoid resistance in newborns. This may be caused by a low expression of mineralocorticoid receptor in infants [15]. With age renal maturity may overcome this resistance possibly by an increased expression of mineralocorticoid receptors [14]. Another explanation could be a potential reduction of the hyperactivity in the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system in childhood [16], reducing the mineralocorticoid resistance with age.
When symptomatic renal PHA1 is present, substitution with mineralocorticoid treatment with fludrocortisone 0.05-2 mg/d divided in 1–2 doses is recommended similar to salt-wasting CAH [6, 17]. Doses are adjusted considering clinic, potassium, sodium and renin concentrations. During infancy sodium is also supplemented with 1–2 g/d (17–34 mEq/d)[17]. With improvement in aldosterone sensitivity supplementation can gradually decrease and is rarely necessary after 3 years of age [1, 7]. This in contrast to our Case 4 who was treated with sodium chloride 9 g/d for a prolonged period. Without medication some patients may still as adolescents and adults experience symptoms co-occurring with infections or dehydration.
Both sisters had significant breast asymmetry. We have not found any association with this and PHA1. Case 4 had several co-occurring conditions. CMT1 is driven by genetic variants in PMP22 in chromosome 17 degrading myelin but is to the best of our knowledge not linked to PHA1, nor is ADHD or dyslexia. Interestingly Case 4 had also a 1-year younger sister with both PHA1 and CMT1.
Very high concentrations of the mineralocorticoid receptor have been found in the rat brain and the hippocampus [18], but there has not been evidence for neurological impairment in renal PHA1. If this could be associated with Case 4 CMT1 or ADHD is not likely, since NR32C is located on chromosome 4q3 and PMP22 on chromosome 17. Possibly a partial mineralocorticoid resistance protects the brain from a negative effect or humans, in contrast to rats do not have an abundance of mineralocorticoid receptors in the brain.
In diagnosing hyponatremia and renal PHA1 several differential diseases are considered. The heredity, clinical picture with or without virilization and pigmentation could point to CAH or another PAI disorder. Blood pressure and aldosterone are generally low in PAI but aldosterone should be elevated and blood pressure low-normal in PHA1. In the salt-wasting series presented by Wijaya et al. 169/187 had CAH, 1 had SF-1 gene variant, 9 had X-linked adrenal hypoplasia congenita, 4 had
aldosterone synthase deficiency (primary hypoaldosteronism) with a genetic variant in
CYP11B2 [11]. The one child with renal PHA1 had a verified heterozygous variant in the
NR3C2 gene. Most salt-wasting conditions are hereditary, unless there are urinary tract
obstruction or infections, if so symptoms vanish when treated [11, 5, 19]. Hospital acquired
hyponatremia was found in 86 of 2012 neonates up to 100 days old and of these 30% were
iatrogenic [20].
Few studies have evaluated the consequences of renal PHA1 in adults. Patients with renal PHA1 have life-long elevation of plasma aldosterone, renin and angiotensin II concentrations [21]. There were no differences between 6 patients with renal PHA1 and 20 controls on blood pressure, congestive heart disease or potassium or sodium concentrations, despite that those adults with renal PHA1 had a 14-fold increase in aldosterone concentrations. Thus, affected patients with renal PHA1 could not be distinguished from other individuals, suggesting that they regulate sodium at the expense of chronically elevated aldosterone [21]. Aldosterone in renal PAH1 did not lead to volume expansion, hypertension, or heart failure in this study.
Elevated plasma aldosterone concentrations are linked to cardiac remodeling and fibrosis also ahead of increased blood pressure in familial hyperaldosteronism [22, 23]. In primary aldosteronism (PA) increased aldosterone is also linked to cardiac impairment and chronic kidney disease [24, 25]. Mortality is also increased, especially if PA is diagnosed in patients > 56 years old [26].
If elevated aldosterone also increases the risk of cardiovascular disease in renal PHA1 has been investigated by Escoubet et al. [27]. In a case-control investigation 39 patients with renal PHA1 and 39 controls were studied with cardiac and vascular ultrasound, cardiac MRI, pulse wave velocity and 24-hour ambulatory blood pressure. No cardiac dysfunction was found, surprisingly the left ventricular function was better in the patients with renal PHA1 than in controls. Further there was no thickening of the vascular wall, stiffness or remodeling, although the plasma aldosterone concentrations were in the same range as in patients with PA.
The deleterious effects of aldosterone thus require full activity of the mineralocorticoid receptor. Patients with renal PHA1 also had increased salt intake and hypotension more often and had increased miscarriages compared to controls [27].
In an investigation by Walker et al. 12 adult patients with renal PHA1 were compared with 10 controls [28]. Patients with renal PHA1 had increased plasma cortisol, which was associated with higher plasma renin, lower high-density lipoprotein and cholesterol. Waist
circumference was also larger but there was no difference in blood pressure, carotid intima thickness or when investigated with cardiac ultrasound. This gives support that PHA1 in adults have no or low impact on life.
Of note, all our patients were short. If this was a result from failure to thrive in infancy cannot be proven, as two of the cases did not have clinical symptoms during childhood. To investigate this series with a larger population is needed.
In conclusion, we present four adult cases with renal PHA1 with different phenotype and one novel variant in the NR3C2 gene. All seemed to be unaffected by their renal PHA1 in adulthood, two were affected in the childhood-adolescence while the other two were found in adulthood during family screening. Renal PHA1 seems to have good longtime prognosis.