Research Article
Onchocerca lupi in imported dogs in the UK: implications for animal and public health
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-493136/v1
This work is licensed under a CC BY 4.0 License
published 10 Feb, 2022
posted
You are reading this latest preprint version
The zoonotic nematode Onchocerca lupi is reported in two dogs in the UK, re-homed from Europe. One dog developed an ocular nodule seven years after arrival from Spain, whereas the other dog, originally from Romania, developed recurring nodular lesions in both eyes. In this dog, parasitism was particularly invasive and resulted in unilateral enucleation. Increasingly, former stray dogs of unknown infection status are entering the UK, raising veterinary and medical concerns.
Environmental changes, anthropic behaviour, and animal movements in Europe over the past 20 years have led to increased threats from a range of zoonotic viral, bacterial and protozoal vector-borne diseases [1]. During the same timeframe, there has been an emergence of conditions caused by various vector-transmitted nematodes, for which dogs and other carnivores act as reservoirs of zoonotic infection [2–3]. The movement of domestic dogs plays an important role in the epidemiology of these vector-borne diseases; the latter including, for example, mosquito-transmitted Dirofilaria spp. [3]. The UK Animal and Plant Health Agency recorded approximately 45,000 imported dogs in 2019, and this figure includes an unknown number of former stray animals from European countries, whose numbers have increased year-on-year for the past seven years. With a history of scavenging and exposure to biting disease vectors, these so-called ‘Trojan dogs’ can be harbingers of unfamiliar, pathogenic parasites including several types of vector-borne nematodes [3], for which treatment is not legally required before crossing borders.
An example of one such vector-borne nematode is the emerging canine eye worm Thelazia callipaeda, which is now endemic throughout much of Europe and associated with corresponding cases in humans [4]. The first reports of canine thelaziosis in the UK were recently diagnosed in dogs re-homed from Italy, France and Romania [5], and coincidentally, that same year a case of human disease in an international traveller was registered [6].
Another, more pathogenic canine eye worm has spread rapidly in several European countries - the filaria Onchocerca lupi [7]. This is also zoonotic, with the first human case described only 10 years ago [8]. Subsequently, up to 18 patients have now been diagnosed [7] in countries where canine onchocerciasis has become endemic, including the Southwest USA, where it is thought to have established following transportation of an infected dog from Europe [9]. Adult O. lupi usually localize in the episcleral tissues of infected dogs, and occasionally cats, whilst their microfilariae are located in the skin, particularly of the head. However, animals with patent infections do not always display overt clinical signs. Indeed, in endemic regions of Portugal, ocular nodules rarely form in dogs with mature, microfilariae-positive infections [10]. Here, we describe the first two cases of imported canine onchocerciasis in the UK, which presented with unusual pathogeneses. These raise concerns for animal and public health given the potential for this parasite to establish in the UK through the increasingly popular practice of re-homing dogs from other European countries.
An eight-year-old male crossbreed was investigated in January 2021 for a conjunctival perilimbal mass in the left eye, of two months’ duration (Fig. 1). The dog came from the Algarve region of Portugal aged one year and has remained in the UK ever since. Closely associated with the ventral oblique muscle, the mass was excised in its entirety and revealed multiple small white cysts containing parasite fragments (Fig. 2). Histopathology of the cysts demonstrated parasitic granulomas associated with degenerate and partially mineralised intralesional worms. Anthelmintic treatment was oral doxycycline for three months (targeting the Wolbachia symbionts in adult worms) and monthly topical imidacloprid and moxidectin (Advocate®) alongside monthly ivermectin. There were no further complications in this case.
The other dog was a seven-year-old female small crossbreed having entered in the UK as a former stray from Romania in January 2020. Seven months after arrival, and with no history of other travel, a raised tan, perilimbal mass (Fig. 1) was noted in the left eye. Due to progressive exophthalmos, the mass was surgically explored, revealing long, thin nematode fragments, and as in the case above, histology also revealed parasitic granulomas. This dog was already receiving monthly topical imadacloprid and moxidectin (Advocate®) since arriving in the UK, and oral doxycycline and prednisolone therapy was initiated. Three weeks following surgery, additional tan lesions appeared in the same eye and further exploration revealed that the parasites had reached as far as the optic nerve and were strongly associated with the extraocular muscles; given the extent of disease, the globe was enucleated. One month later, the right eye developed conjunctival hyperaemia. Two injections of melarsomine dihydrochloride were administered 24 hrs apart, alongside continued oral and topical prednisolone. Over the following three weeks, however, tan nodules appeared which on surgical removal revealed numerous live worms. As of April 2021, further lesions still remain.
Nematodes from both cases were morphologically identified as Onchocerca lupi based on the typical appearance of their cuticle (Fig. 2), which has an arrangement of prominent ridges and internal striae [11]. Identification was also confirmed by sequence analysis of cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 (coxI) and 12S rRNA gene fragments (10). BLAST analysis (http://blast.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ Blast.cgi) of sequences showed a high nucleotide identity with those of O. lupi available in GenBank (99.85–100%, coxI; 100%, 12S rRNA). Accession numbers deposited in GenBank are MW835250, MW835251, MW829782 and MW829783.
Onchocerca spp. have unusually long pre-patent periods of up to 18 months [12]. Although autochthonous transmission of canine onchocerciasis in the UK cannot be excluded, it is highly likely that the first dog was infected as a one-year-old in the Algarve region of Portugal, a known focus of transmission [10]. The pre-patent period noted here of seven years is extremely long but is comparable to a recent observation in Germany in a dog introduced from Greece, which developed eye problems six years following rescue [13]. Such cases of prolonged parasite and nodule development highlight challenges in case diagnosis and management of O. lupi, as well as in monitoring zoonotic disease incursion.
The second case presents an unusually severe pathogenicity, with exophthalmos in one eye and disease progression despite appropriate therapy. To the best of our knowledge, the appearance of new worms following surgical removal of an existing nodule is a novel finding, and the invasive nature of nodule growth necessitating globe removal is an exceptional outcome. However, subsequent nodule development in the previously healthy contralateral eye, a matter of weeks after enucleation of the infected eye, has been described previously [9] and suggests that nematodes may survive undetected until they form overt nodular lesions.
In both cases, lesions became prominent, with timely veterinary interventions. However, as already mentioned, not all dogs display overt clinical signs, especially when worms do not develop in the external parts of the ocular apparatus [7]. In undetected covert infections of mature worms, microfilariae will accumulate in the skin for a long time, allowing for potential parasite transmission.
The identity of vectors of this parasite remains unclear, but as for most Onchocerca spp., one or more species of Simulium (blackflies) may have a role. In the UK, there are least six species of blackflies recorded as biting both humans and dogs [14], of which S. reptans (west of England and Wales) and S. tuberosum/S. variegatum (north of England and Scotland) are abundant [15]. Considering that the black fly species composition is similar to that of countries in Europe where O. lupi is endemic and assuming they could act as vectors, we hypothesise that local transmission in the UK could occur. An assessment of the suitability of conditions in the UK for parasite circulation by modelling of climate, ecological and other factors is therefore required.
In conclusion, it is apparent that Onchocerca lupi infection may only become evident in dogs many years following importation. Nodules may be invasive and appear unpredictably with asynchronous development. The popular trend to re-home dogs from O. lupi-endemic regions of Europe will increase the risk of transmission of this parasite in the UK and presents a growing problem of One Health concern.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Owners of the dogs in this study have provided permissions for details of their pets to be published through their veterinarians who are co-authors of this article.
Consent for publication. N/A. No human subjects.
Availability of data and material
Sequence data: Accession numbers deposited in GenBank are MW835250, MW835251, MW829782 and MW829783.
Competing interests - None
Funding - None
Authors' contributions: John W. McGarry (identified the parasites, drafted and coordinated publication); Rossella Carrozza (veterinarian investigating Case 1, clinical work); Claire Bradley (veterinarian investigating case 2, clinical work); Maria Stefania, Latrofa (molecular identification of worms); Benjamin L. Makepeace (worm morphology, specialist advice); Domenico Otranto (molecular identification of worms, specialist advice). All authors contributed to the text and critical review of the MS.
Acknowledgements – None.
No competing interests reported.
published 10 Feb, 2022
posted
You are reading this latest preprint version