Our study demonstrated that artificial ascites significantly reduced pain and vagal reflex incidence during ultrasound-guided percutaneous sclerotherapy for ovarian cysts. This finding aligns with previous studies highlighting the benefits of creating a physical separation between the target area and surrounding tissues to minimize complications[15]. The high success rate of sclerotherapy in both groups confirms the efficacy of this minimally invasive technique. However, the observation group, which utilized artificial ascites, showed a higher cure rate and effective rate, suggesting that artificial ascites may enhance the effectiveness of sclerotherapy. The reduced pain incidence and severity, along with the lower rate of vagal reflexes in the observation group, likely contributed to more complete and successful treatments. Pain and vagal reflexes can lead to incomplete or failed procedures; by minimizing these complications, artificial ascites ensures smoother and more effective sclerotherapy.
Effectiveness in Pain Reduction
The significant reduction in VAS scores in the observation group compared to the control group (2.3 vs. 5.2, P < 0.01) supports the notion that artificial ascites can mitigate pain during and after sclerotherapy. The most probable mechanism is that the physiological saline solution rapidly dilutes the sclerosing agent that leaks from the puncture site, thereby reducing its irritative symptoms and minimizing direct tissue irritation and mechanical stimulation. This aligns with previous findings by Meng et al. who observed similar reductions in pain incidence using this technique[15, 19, 20]. A similar reduction in procedural pain has been observed in artificial ascites-assisted radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for hepatic tumors[18]. The use of artificial ascites provided a safer distance between the liver and adjacent organs, thereby minimizing collateral damage during RFA and reducing postoperative pain[21–23, 20].
Nausea and Infection Rates
The incidence of nausea was recorded as a symptom often accompanying vagal reflex. In our study, patients who experienced vagal reflex also reported nausea. The observation group had a significantly lower incidence of nausea compared to the control group, consistent with the reduced vagal reflex incidence. Additionally, our study found that the post-operative infection rate was 0% in both groups, indicating that the use of artificial ascites does not increase the risk of infection.
Effectiveness in Sclerotherapy Efficacy
The efficacy comparison between the observation and control groups at 3, 6, and 12 months post-treatment showed that both groups had high cure rates (93.18% in the observation group vs. 82.14% in the control group, P < 0.05). The effective rate was also higher in the observation group (100%) compared to the control group (91.07%, P < 0.05). The significant difference in effective rates indicates that the artificial ascites technique likely improves sclerotherapy efficacy by providing a safer puncture path and reducing sclerosing agent leakage into surrounding tissues. Meng et al. reported that the use of artificial ascites led to better visualization during puncture and fewer complications [15].
Reduction of Vagal Reflex Incidence
The significant reduction in the incidence of vagal reflex in the observation group suggests that artificial ascites helps to minimize the direct stimulation of the vagus nerve during the procedure. One key mechanism is that the physiological saline solution rapidly dilutes the sclerosing agent that may leak from the puncture site, thereby reducing its irritative symptoms and minimizing direct tissue irritation. This rapid dilution of the sclerosing agent not only mitigates its immediate irritant effects but also prevents the diffusion of the agent to nearby sensitive structures, such as nerves, which could otherwise trigger a vagal reflex. The physical separation created by the artificial ascites also contributes to this protective effect by providing a buffer zone that further minimizes the risk of inadvertent nerve stimulation.
Sclerosing Agent Mechanism
Both 95% medical ethanol and polidocanol work as sclerosing agents by denaturing the cellular proteins of the cyst wall, impairing its fluid secretion function. This results in sterile inflammation within the cyst cavity, leading to subsequent collapse, atrophy, adhesion, and closure of the cyst wall, which is then absorbed by the body. The chemical action causes the cyst wall cells' proteins to coagulate and degenerate, impairing their ability to secrete fluids. Consequently, sterile inflammation occurs within the cyst cavity, leading to subsequent collapse, atrophy, adhesion, and closure of the cyst wall, which is then absorbed by the body[24–28]. T Thus, this mechanism provides a clear pathophysiological basis for the reduction of ovarian cysts through sclerotherapy.
Clinical Implications
Given the findings of this study, artificial ascites offers a practical and safe method to improve procedural comfort and efficacy during ultrasound-guided sclerotherapy. This is particularly useful in cases where cysts are located deep within the pelvis or near vital organs, as these situations increase the risk of accidental damage and complications. Moreover, its application can be extended to other minimally invasive abdominal procedures to further enhance patient safety and procedural success.
Artificial ascites has potential applications beyond ovarian cyst sclerotherapy. It has been increasingly used in ultrasound-guided ablation treatments for uterine fibroids and adenomyosis. In these procedures, artificial ascites helps to create a clear separation between the target tissue and surrounding organs, such as the bowel and bladder, thereby minimizing the risk of thermal injury to these structures. This technique not only improves the safety of the procedure but also enhances the precision of the ablation.
Limitations and Future Directions
While encouraging, the retrospective design and the moderate sample size of this study may limit the generalizability of the findings. Future research should include prospective randomized controlled trials to validate the effectiveness of artificial ascites across a broader demographic and explore its potential applications in other minimally invasive abdominal surgeries, such as liver or pancreatic interventions. Additionally, studies should aim to standardize the optimal volume of artificial ascites to maximize safety and efficacy.
Furthermore, the physical isolation mechanism of artificial ascites has proven applications in thermal ablation treatments for thyroid nodules and breast nodules, where it is commonly used to protect surrounding tissues by creating a buffer zone with injected fluids. This technique's efficacy in reducing thermal damage to non-target tissues during ablation has been well-documented and is widely accepted in clinical practice[29–33]. However, the application of fluid injection to alleviate conditions caused by constrictive adhesions remains underexplored. Such techniques could potentially be used to relieve compression in conditions like stenosing tenosynovitis, adhesive fasciitis, and peripheral nerve compression caused by surrounding adhesions. These areas represent promising avenues for future research, focusing on developing methods to inject therapeutic fluids that can effectively reduce adhesion and improve mobility without surgery. Initial studies could explore the feasibility, safety, and efficacy of this approach, potentially leading to novel treatments for a range of compressive syndromes.
Future Directions
Future investigations should aim to expand on these findings by exploring the impact of artificial ascites on different types and sizes of ovarian cysts and potentially extending its use to other surgical contexts to further enhance patient safety and procedural success[34].