To investigate the capability of BECs to secrete recombinant proteins into the brain parenchyma, two plasmid constructs were designed to encode the fluorescent protein mCherry with and without the initial segment of the PDGF-β sequence potentially allowing for abluminal protein secretion under the control of the endothelial-specific C-Ocln promoter. In addition, a furin cleavage site was included to assess the efficiency of N-terminal sequence cleavage, also indicating sorting into a secretory pathway, as furin cleavage normally takes place in the Golgi apparatus. The 3XFLAG tag included upstream of the furin cleavage site and should only be present in uncleaved mCherry proteins (Fig. 1A). The combination of the PDGF-B sequence, 3XFLAG, and Furin cleavage is referred to as (PFF). To compare our results to previous studies, analog constructs were designed replacing the endothelial-specific C-Ocln promoter by the ubiquitous CAG promotor. The expected mechanisms and locations of signal sequence recognition, furin cleavage, and secretion with resulting protein sizes of 38 kDa for the non-cleaved mCherry and 30 kDa c for the cleaved mCherry are depicted in Fig. 1B.
HEK 293T and bEnd.3 cells were transiently transfected with the different constructs, to confirm their function and to evaluate the secretion pathway of mCherry, and its sensitivity to the furin cleavage mechanisms. Medium from the transfected cells was subsequently collected and analyzed by western blotting for detection of secreted mCherry. The resulting protein concentrations after transduction of HEK 293T and bEnd.3 cells were very different, making it difficult to simultaneously visualize the secreted proteins in the medium from both cell types (Fig. 2A). The inclusion of the PFF sequence results in a distinct cellular processing of mCherry. FLAG-staining of medium from HEK293T revealed a 38 kDa band corresponding to the complete protein product of PFFmCA, which has not been subjected to furin cleavage (data not shown). Avitag-staining revealed three bands, at approximately 38, 30, and below 25 kDa, in medium from both HEK293T and bEND.3 cells transfected with the CAG-PFFmCA or C-Ocln-PFFmCA constructs (Fig. 2A). These correspond to the complete non-cleaved mCherry produced (38kDa), and furin-cleaved mCherry, where the FLAG tag is removed (30kDa), suggesting that both cell types can recognize the furin cleave site. The band below 25 kDa is an unknown N-terminally truncated cleavage fragment of mCherry, as suggested by the retained C-terminal Avitag (Fig. 2A). When the cells were transfected with vectors not containing the PFF sequence, it was expected that mCherry would be contained intracellularly and therefore not be detected in the medium (Fig. 1B). However, a 30 kDa band was detected in medium from cells transfected with both non-secretory vectors (CAG-mCA or C-Ocln-mCA), suggesting that byproducts of intracellular proteins are released into the medium during cell lysis or the existence of a non-specific secretory mechanism, possibly due to high intracellular concentrations of mCherry especially in the HEK293T cells. Transfection with CAG-Luc (encoding Luciferase) was included as a negative control for mCherry-Avitag staining.
Furin cleavage efficiency is not affected by protein secretion quantity in bEnd.3 cells
HEK 293T cells seem more effective in producing furin-cleaved products than bEnd.3 cells, as indicated by the ratios between the full-length 38 kDa PFFmCA product and the furin-cleaved 30 kDa PFFmCA products (Fig. 2A). With furin cleavge being possibly limited in BECs, we wanted to investigate if the ratio of cleavage was affected by the quantity of secretion. Recognizing the high expression in vitro using the CAG promoter, we wanted to determine if the higher secretion would lead to lower cleavage ratio. bEnd.3 cells were transiently transfected with either CAG-PFFmCA or C-Ocln-PFFmCA. The medium was collected, and total mCherry protein concentration was measured using ELISA (Fig. 2B). The ratio of mCherry cleavage products was analyzed using western blot with Avitag-antibodies (Fig. 2C, D). Medium collected from bEnd.3 transfected with CAG-PFFmCA resulted in significantly higher mCherry concentrations compared to the medium collected from bEnd.3 transfected with C-Ocln-PFFmCA with concentrations of 10301 ± 397 and 531 ± 39 pg/ml, respectively (Fig. 2B). When analyzing the ratios of the full-length and the furin-cleaved mCherry-Avitag protein products there was no statistical difference identified between the two promotor types (Fig. 2C). This indicates that the likelihood of furin cleavage in BECs is not affected by the quantity of the protein of interest being secreted.
Transduction of mice with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-mCA and AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA leads to mCherry expression in both BECs and neurons.
To investigate mBEC protein secretion into the brain in vivo, the brain-specific AAV-BR1 viral vector was incorporated with the C-Ocln-mCA and C-Ocln-PFFmCA constructs. The C-Ocln promoter was used in vivo due to its higher mBEC specificity (12), which was expected to allow for differentiation between abluminal mCherry secretion originating from mBECs and mCherry expressed locally within the brain parenchyma. High concentrations of mCherry within the brain parenchyma would be expected if using the ubiquitous CAG promotor as this promotor allows for strong gene transcription in transduced neurons and astrocytes (12), potentially obscuring identification of mCherry derived from BEC by abluminal secretion. Mice were injected with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-mCA or AAV-BR1- C-Ocln-PFFmCA, or PBS (CTRL), and 28 days later the brain, plasma, and CSF were collected.
To investigate the presence and potential differences in the localization of mCherry within the brains of mice transduced with the AAV-BR1 vector encoding mCherry with and without the PFF sequence, we performed immunohistochemical staining of mCherry and the transferrin receptor (highly expressed in BECs) focusing on the cerebral cortex and hippocampal area (Fig. 3A). mBECs were seen to co-localize with mCherry, showing that these cells were successfully transduced by the AAV-BR1 vector. However, comparative to previous observations (12), the transduction efficiency in BECs was lower than anticipated. Furthermore, the stained brain slices presented unspecific scattered dots of mCherry staining, irrespective of whether mice vector or only PBS (Fig. 3A, indicated by grey arrows). The unspecific staining was often seen as small circular dots and interpreted as being lipofuscin granules with a diameter in the range of few microns and hence clear distinguishable from the solid cytosolic labeling of transduced cells. The low specificity of the staining therefore did not allow for assessment of protein secretion. In addition, in the cerebral cortex and especially in the CA3 region of the hippocampus several of the mCherry-positive cells had neuronal morphology, which was confirmed when staining for both mCherry and NeuN (neuronal marker), despite using the supposedly endothelial cell-specific C-Ocln promoter. mCherry-positive neurons could also be detected in the cortex, although less prominently. This indicates that the C-Ocln promoter is not as endothelial specific as first anticipated (Fig. 3B). The images did not reveal any additional signs of mCherry adjacent to cells transduced with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA compared to mice transduced with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-mCA (Fig. 3C), providing no clear evidence of secretion or unspecific uptake by surrounding cells. To further investigate luminal and abluminal secretion, mCherry protein concentration was measured by ELISA in plasma and CSF respectively. Despite the high sensitivity of the assay (data not shown), mCherry could neither be detected, in the low volume of CSF extractable from mice, nor in the plasma, mCherry is expected to locate differently when entering the secretion pathway, however, this could not be observed in mCherry-positive mBECs and neurons in the cerebral cortex at higher resolution (Fig. 3C). Again, no differences were observed in the cells transduced by either construct.
Inclusion of the PFF sequence does not influence mCherry mRNA levels in whole brain homogenates but leads to lower protein quantities in brain capillaries as well as brain parenchyma indicating secretion of mCherry.
It was initially expected that the PFF sequence would result in higher quantities of mCherry in the brain parenchyma, as a result of abluminal secretion, compared to mice transduced without the PFF constructs. We therefore compared mRNA in whole brain homogenates as well as protein concentrations in brain capillary-enriched tissue vs. brain capillary-depleted tissue (brain parenchyma homogenates) (Fig. 4A). As expected, the relative expression of mCherry in whole brain homogenate did not show notable variation, with mean ± SD expression in mice injected with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-mCA or AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA being 1.05 ± 0.34 and 1.28 ± 0.49 respectively (Fig. 4B), indicating equal transduction efficiency and gene expression between the two vectors.
Capillary tissue transduced with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-mCA and AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA had median and 95% CI of mCherry quantities of 77.1 [41.0, 113.3], and 37.5 [9.5, 65.6] pg/mg total protein respectively (Fig. 4C). The reduction of mCherry protein in capillaries by inclusion of the PFF is expected and indicates secretion of mCherry from capillaries transduced with the AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA. In the brain parenchyma, however, mCherry protein concentrations were likewise significantly higher when mice were transduced with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-mCA (32.6 ± 15.7 pg/mg total protein) compared to mice transduced with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA (6.8 ± 4.5 pg/mg total protein) (Fig. 4D). This is unexpected but in line with the observed transduction of neurons seen in stained brain tissue (Fig. 3). Importantly, the lower quantity of mCherry in the brain parenchyma of mice injected with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA strongly indicates degradation and/or clearance of secreted mCherry from the brain. This is highly important as it attests to the difficulty to prove mCherry secretion.
The PFF sequence does not promote differential microglia activation around mCherry-positive cells.
Although we did not succeed in measuring or visually observing abluminal secretion of mCherry, we wondered whether the extracellular presence of a nonendogenous recombinant protein, like mCherry might have triggered activation of microglia adjacent to transduced cells. Double staining for mCherry and CD11b (microglia marker) was therefore performed in both cortex cerebri and hippocampus (Fig. 5). No obvious differences were observed when comparing mice transduced with vectors with and without the PFF sequence. Microglia interacted with mCherry-positive cells in both conditions not suggesting increased activation by the presence of extracellular mCherry.
In vitro, the inclusion of the PFF sequence results in higher abluminal secretion of mCherry.
The transduction pattern upon using the endothelial-specific C-Ocln promotor deviated from previous studies showing overwhelming transduction of the vasculature (12). Instead, we observed transduction of neurons obscuring the detection of potential abluminal secretion of mCherry by mBECs. The vectors were therefore further investigated using an in vitro BBB model based on primary mBECs and mixed glial cells, where no neurons are present. Assuming some of the observed discrepancy in vivo between mRNA and protein quantity can be attributed to secretion, it remains unanswered whether transduction of mBECs with a vector encoding the PFF sequence contributes to increased abluminal secretion into the brain parenchyma, or if the secretion of mCherry by mBECs is mainly luminal, as previously reported using similar setups without the PFF sequence (5, 7). Since the C-Ocln was less endothelial specific than anticipated, and because comparable studies have been performed using strong ubiquitous promoters such as CMV and CAG (5, 7), we next also incorporated CAG promoter-driven mCherry constructs into the AAV-BR1 vector. Primary mBECs were transduced with the AAV-BR1 vector containing either the C-Ocln-mCA, C-Ocln-PFFmCA, CAG-mCA, or CAG-PFFmCA sequences and compared to non-transduced mBECs (CTRL). Four days post-transduction the polarized secretion of mCherry was investigated by analyzing medium collected from the upper and lower chambers in the in vitro BBB model, representing the luminal (blood) and abluminal (parenchyma) sides, respectively. mBECs were fixated to examine the intracellular sorting of mCherry, and during the experiment, the effect of transduction on the mBECs barrier integrity was examined (Fig. 6A). In general, the barrier integrity of the mBECs was not affected by the addition of AAV-BR1, however, mBECs transduced with vectors containing the CAG promoter had an initial decrease in barrier integrity on day 1, which persisted in cultures transduced with AAV-BR1-CAG-PFFmCA throughout the experiment but were normalized for cultures transduced with AAV-BR1-CAG-mCA (Fig. 4C). In control cultures, no mCherry was detected, but mCherry was observed evenly distributed through the cytosol of mBECs transduced with the vectors, not including the PFF sequence (AAV-BR1-CAG-mCA and AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-mCA), corresponding well with an intracellular distribution of mCherry. When the PFF sequence was included in the vector construct (AAV-BR1-CAG-PFFmCA and AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA) mCherry predominantly localized around the nucleus indicating entry into the secretory pathway and packaging in vesicles (Fig. 4B). More transduced cells were observed when the mBECs were transduced with vectors containing the CAG promotor.
No mCherry was detected in control cultures, while mBECs transduced with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-mCA, only had low, almost non-detectable luminal secretion in 50% of the culture wells (1.3 pg 95% CI [-1.6, 7.0]), while no abluminal secretion was observed (Fig. 4D). mBECs transduced with AAV-BR1-C-Ocln-PFFmCA revealed that the combination of the PFF sequence and C-Ocln promoter resulted in secretion of mCherry not statistically different between luminal secretion (15.7 pg 95% CI [9.6, 22.7]), and abluminal secretion (7.5 pg 95% CI [1.2, 29.6]) (Fig. 4E), although it provides a more favorable ratio of abluminal secretion than what has been reported before (5, 7). mBECs transduced with the AAV-BR1-CAG-mCA resulted in higher mCherry concentrations in both the luminal (181.0 pg 95% CI [88.7, 210.5]) and abluminal (27.2 pg 95% CI [9.1, 48.5]) chambers than observed with the C-Ocln promotor, with the concentration of mCherry in the luminal chamber being significantly higher (Fig. 4F). This was surprising as this vector do not contain the PFF sequence but could suggest that high concentrations of intracellular mCherry are unspecifically released primarily into the luminal chamber or a result of cell lysis. Transduction with the AAV-BR1-CAG-PFFmCA construct led to almost twice as high mCherry quantities in the abluminal chamber (1010 pg. 95% CI [586.7, 1191.0]) compared to the luminal chamber (593 pg. 95% CI [425.9, 709.3]), although not statistically significant (P = 0.0931) (Fig. 4G). Concluding on the in vitro data shown in Fig. 6, the combination of the CAG promoter and the PFF sequence therefore resulted in an abluminal quantity of mCherry being 100 times higher than abluminal secretion from mBECs transduced with vectors encoding the C-Ocln promotor. Together, these observations indicate that the inclusion of the PFF sequence in the vector construct promotes abluminal secretion, which is amplified when combined with the strong CAG promoter.