Pre-clinical trials tend to be executed in males only alleging that high variability due to the estrous cyclicity (which has been showed to be not relevant for most of the cases [46]) would mean to increase sample size and costs, leading to lack of female data. This study has stated the importance of sex segregation in order to get a closer look at the real drug metabolism panorama. Furthermore, we have identified a significant impact of sex in the expression of metabolism enzymes and efflux transporters implicated in the metabolization of IS and apixaban in the ileum, liver and kidneys of both treated and control mice, as basal expression levels already differ in a sex-dependent manner.
Our results in a pre-clinical model highlight the need to document the impact of sex in clinical trials with well-balanced sex ratios more precisely, particularly in the context of cardio-kidney metabolic syndrome and CKD where women are still underrepresented [47] [48]. For instance, in the DAPA-CKD trial, females comprised only 33% of the cohort [49]. A recent review study concerning sodium glucose cotransporter-2 inhibitors, a drug that reduces the risk of cardiovascular events and/or chronic kidney disease progression in CKD patients, [50] have showed a potential bias linked to sex in efficacy and adverse side effects. When more women were enrolled in the trials the reduction in cardiovascular mortality was smaller and drug-related complications were detected in a higher proportion in women. In the ARISTOTLE trial, females represented only 35% of the clinical trial population, limiting the power to observe specific outcomes related to the drug [51] and in another prospective study it was observed that during heart failure treatment, the optimal dose of RAS inhibitors to prevent the latter outcome is not the full dose but the half dose in women compared to men [52].
Uremic toxin buildup during CKD could exert an influence not only in the elimination of drugs excreted by the kidneys but also on the metabolism of drugs subjected to non-renal clearance, mainly the liver and the gut [53]. How modifications in these complex processes translate to patient pathology is poorly understood due to the large number of enzymes, transporters and metabolites implicated. Nonetheless, their understanding is essential as CKD patients are often prescribed several medications simultaneously. This poly-pharmacology results in frequently occurring drug-related adverse events, that could, in many cases be avoided if physicians were aware of the changes in drug disposition. [54]. Therefore, future clinical trials should also consider how pre-existent conditions, in this case CKD patients: uremic toxin accumulation, could alter the metabolism of a given drug and whether the dose should be sex-adjusted to minimize side effects and treatment rejection.
A correct management of haemostasis is essential to avoid bleeding and thrombosis in patients with CKD. Excess IS due to poor renal clearance can tip the scale towards a pro-coagulant state and over-activate AhR target genes which could interfere with xeno- and endobiotic metabolism. Understanding how IS interacts with commonly used anticoagulants, such as apixaban, and how it might affect its metabolization is required to better deal with haemostasis disbalance in patients with CKD.
To date, no human trials have revealed a link between IS accumulation and gender. Concerning apixaban, it is unclear whether its levels differ with gender in humans or not, and the implications it might have [16], [55]. According to the review work of Byon et al [16], despite apixaban accumulation in female subjects being up to 18% higher, no clinically relevant effects were observed. This could be due to the adherence not being closely monitored in some of the studies included and to a poorer collection of bleeding events. In our study, female mice showed a higher accumulation of IS (except from the AhR -/- mice treated with IS) and apixaban in plasma. Uneven efflux transporters expression, especially in the liver, could be behind this phenomenon. U.S Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recommends avoiding strong inhibitors and inducers of CYP3A and P-gp during treatment with apixaban (ELIQUIS (apixaban) tablets for oral use Initial U.S. Approval: 2012), nonetheless no dose adjustment is considered for patients at a higher apixaban accumulation/metabolization risks. Yet, several studies show that inhibition or genetic variation in the drug transporter gene ABCG2 affects the pharmacokinetics of apixaban[56] [57], which in some cases leads to increased bleeding risk [58].
The gut, a major drug absorption site, can be affected by sex-dependent differences in efflux transporter expression and metabolism disturbances caused by exogenous molecules like apixaban or IS, as seen in our study. When treating patients on multiple medications, addressing these factors is crucial to prevent treatment failure.
In the liver, females showed higher Abcb1a levels than males, however, this difference could not compensate for the fact that Abcg2 showed greater expression rates in all males, which is over 10 times greater than Abcb1a, and which would contribute to the excretion of apixaban and IS in the bile quicker. Furthermore, apixaban-treated males showed higher Cyp3a11 than females, which implies that apixaban metabolization rates could be enhanced. Moreover, apixaban induced Cyp3a11 expression in male liver, which would lead to even higher metabolization rates that could explain the lower accumulation, but could also lead to treatment ineffectiveness. Nonetheless, both of these effects disappear when apixaban is given in combination with IS, showing how these two compounds interact with each other metabolism.
In the liver of Ahr −/− mice, IS decreases Abcg2 expression (main efflux transporter) in both males and females. We hypothesize that when a drug inhibits AhR at the hepatic level, if IS concentration is high enough, a lower clearing rate could occur through the bile duct of such drug or others that are cleared through the affected transporters. Cyp1a2 is lowered under basal levels when AhR is knocked out, occasioning lower metabolization rates of other substances that are broken down by this cytochrome.
The whole liver proteomic analysis performed supported our previous findings at the mRNA level, and remarked the need to study both sexes in pre-clinical models.
On a different note, organic anion transporters OAT1 and OAT3, that import IS and apixaban from the bloodstream onto the kidney, show sex-dependent differences, a fact widely described in the literature both at the mRNA and the protein level, that seems to be due to testosterone production [59] [60]. If Scl22a6 (OAT1) and Scl22a8 (OAT3) were to have dissimilar transportation rates for apixaban and/or IS, they could play a very significant role in the plasma accumulation of the aforementioned substances in females. In humans, OAT1 and OAT3 are the second and first transporters of the Scl22a family with the highest mRNA expression, and this would be the equivalent to our female mice situation. hOAT1 mRNA was significantly lower in the kidney of patients with renal disease compared to normal controls [61], which could be one of the factors that could explain increasing IS accumulation as CKD progresses. Furthermore, several studies demonstrate that Oat1 knockout mice show an increase in IS plasma levels, that has not been observed in Oat3 knockout mice and that IS accumulation has been seen to inhibit OAT1 in vitro [62]. The kinetic parameters for rat OATs have been previously described: IS had a 10-fold greater Km value for rOat3 than rOat1 (Km = 174 µmol/L and Km = 18 µmol/L respectively). Moreover, kinetic analysis of the IS uptake by human kidney slices revealed two saturable components with Km1 =24 µmol/L and Km2 = 196 µmol/L similar to those of rOat1 and rOat3 [63]. Therefore, higher affinity of IS for OAT1 could be playing a major role in its excretion.
Bleeding time is higher in females treated with KCl + Apixaban than in males which could be due to the plasma accumulation of apixaban. Females treated with IS + Apixaban showed lower bleeding time than those only treated with IS or apixaban alone. An IS-rich milieu, could lead to endothelial damage and increased tissue factor and activation of coagulation [29], which could increase platelet activation [64] making them more reactive at the time of an injury, and therefore, lowering the bleeding time. These results suggest that during a procoagulant state, like CKD, the hemorrhagic effect of the accumulation of apixaban could be mitigated by the activation of coagulation. Therefore, since the monitoring of the thrombotic and bleeding risk during CKD is a real challenge, better identification of specific risk patients could reduce the chances of under- or over-treatment.
Further studies need to be carried out to assess the efficiency of the different efflux transporters and metabolization enzymes to better determine the cause of the apixaban and IS accumulation in female mice. Specifically, since our study is focused on short term effects, it would be interesting to see if this accumulation has any deleterious long-term effects. Moreover, recognizing the impact of sex differences in drug management is crucial for improving the care provided to women. It is essential to be correctly represented in clinical trials, so that possible underlying biological divergences related to sex can be regarded in order to better understand renal pathophysiology, disease progression and drug metabolization in both men and women.