Osteoarthritis is mainly characterized by damage to the joint cartilage, but it can also involve the subchondral bone, synovial membrane, and even the entire joint. Chondrocytes are the only cell type in normal cartilage. They secrete collagen and proteoglycan to form the cartilaginous matrix, which together with chondrocytes forms cartilage. Numerous internal and external factors, such as the peripheral biological clock, cell cycle regulation proteins, apoptosis, inflammatory factors, as well as nutrient metabolism inside and outside the cells, affect the division, proliferation, differentiation, and stability of chondrocytes, which can lead to local environmental imbalance and induce OA. Recent studies have increasingly recognized the importance of the peripheral biological clock in cartilage tissue and cells, whereby it has also been observed that the pain and stiffness of OA have a daily rhythm. Several studies have also found that the stability of the cartilage is regulated in the outer-circular biological clock mode [17–19]. As the core coordinator of the biological clock, Bmal1 is an important transcription factor that regulates the biorhythm and is essential for the development of hard tissue, including bone, cartilage, and teeth. It is expressed in intercellular stem cells, terminally differentiated bone cells, and cartilaginous cells [20]. Bmal1 has been widely confirmed to be associated with the occurrence and development of OA, exhibiting correlations with a lower rate of survival of cartilage cells in mouse growth plates, a decreased number of cartilaginous cells, increased apoptosis, and a significant loss of extracellular matrix [21, 22]. In addition, downregulation of Bmal1 not only impairs the survival and secretory function of cartilage cells, but also increases the expression of cartilage matrix degrading enzymes, including MMP13, which disrupts its balance, resulting in a gradual loss of cartilage [23, 24]. Among the well-known pathological changes of osteoarthritis, the progressive destruction of articular cartilage is the most significant. Matrix metalloproteinase 13 (MMP13) is the main catabolic factor involved in cartilage degradation. It has the special ability to irreversibly cleave Col2, the main component of the cartilaginous matrix, and plays a key role in the progression of OA. Bmal1 is a major contributor to OA among the biological clock genes, but the mechanism of its effects on Mmp13 in the joint cartilage is not fully understood and needs further study. In addition, a number of other biological clock genes, such as Per1 and Per2, are also associated with OA. It was found that the expression of PER1 protein showed an increasing trend in articular cartilage of OA rats and humans. Knockout of the Per2 gene in OA chondrocytes can alleviate the effects of IL-1β, hydrogen peroxide and alkaline calcium phosphate crystals on chondrocytes. It was also found that increased expression levels and ectopic expression of Per2 in chondrocytes could lead to changes in the expression of phenotypic markers, and regulate the activity of chondrocytes by affecting their phenotype [5, 25–27]. At the same time, it has also been observed that the increase of IL-1β after OA can cause the decrease of Bmal1 expression[28, 29]. Based on the finding that Bmal1 expression was decreased in OA cartilage cells, our results support the same conclusion and confirm that Per1 and Mmp13 expression also increased in OA. After expression of Bmal1 in normal cartilage cells, Per1 and Mmp13 expression decreased. The expression changes of Bmal1 influenced the expression of the cell cycle-related genes Wee1, Cdk1, and Ccnb1.
In the Cyclin-CDK-CKI cell cycle molecular network, cyclins form the regulatory core. At different times, CDKs combine with different cyclins that activate CDK functions and keep the cell cycles moving along the G1-S-G2-M phase transitions. At the same time, different CKIs can also bind corresponding CDKs or Cyclin/CDK complexes to stop CDK activity and phase transitions during the cell cycle. WEE1 is a G2 checkpoint enzyme-cell cycle regulator that protects the nucleus from the effects of the CDK1-CyclinB1 complex. It does this by mediating the phosphorylation of CDK1 on Thr14 and Tyr-15 as well as controlling the entry into mitosis (G2-M). CDK1 belongs to the family of CDKs, which can facilitate the transition of cell cycle phase G2 to phase M, as well as adjust the progression of phases G1 and S. CCNB1 is a cyclin that is mainly involved in the regulation of mitosis. Transcription begins in the S phase, peaks in the late G2 phase, and it is ubiquitinated and degraded in the late mitosis, thus exiting the M phase. CDK1 and CCNB1 are important regulators of cell proliferation, division, differentiation and apoptosis by regulating the transition from G2 to M phase of cell cycle and controlling cell cycle progression in the form of complexes.
Studies have shown that the biological clock proteins Bmal1 and circadian locomotor output cycles kaput (CLOCK) can form a complex and directly bind the Wee1 gene promoter in tumor cells to promote its transcription, while Bmal1 can induce mRNA synthesis in the liver, promoting the expression of Wee1. Conversely, when Bmal1 is knocked out, Wee1 expression is reduced[7, 30, 31]. When DNA is damaged, WEE1 blocks cells from entering into mitosis through CDK1 phosphorylation to regulate the G2/M checkpoint, giving the cell sufficient time to repair the damaged DNA and thus promoting survival [32–34]. When WEE1 is downregulated, the function of the G2/M checkpoint disappears or is defective, causing the cell to ignore the presence of DNA damage, prematurely pass the G2/M checkpoint, and enter abnormal mitosis, resulting in a mitotic catastrophe and apoptosis [35, 36]. In the course of development, the cartilage cells eventually differentiate into the phenotype of hypertrophic chondrocytes, which is controlled by CDK1 [15]. Studies have shown that increased CDK1 activity can disrupt the antiapoptotic function of Bcl-2 family proteins, accelerating karyokinesis and partially promoting proliferation [37], while in astrocytes and microglia, downregulation of CDK1 activity can inhibit neuronal autophagy and apoptosis [38]. In addition, high activity of CCNB1 can cause cell cycle disturbances, resulting in the activation of cell death mechanisms in the event of abnormal mitosis [39]. The results of this study showed that BMAL1 can indirectly lower the expression of CDK1 and CCNB1 while raising the activity of WEE1 in chondrocytes. When BMAL1 levels drop, WEE1 activity goes down, the G2 checkpoint stops working or malfunctions, but CDK1 and CCNB1 stay very active, increasing cell proliferation. At this point, cells cannot normally exit the S, G2, and M phases, DNA replication and mitosis times are shortened, which speeds up the cell cycle so that there isn't enough time to fix DNA damage cells, which leads to apoptosis. This offers a plausible mechanism through which the biological clock may affect the cell cycle, thus playing a role in the occurrence and development of OA.
The biological clock is a genetic oscillator that is closely linked to the cell cycle. This study confirmed that the expression of Bmal1 and Wee1 is positively correlated, while being negatively correlated with that of Per1, Cdk1, Ccnb1, and Mmp13. Bmal1 can positively control the expression of Wee1 as well as negatively control the expression of Per1, CDK1, CCnb1, and Mmp13. The amounts of BMAL1 and WEE1 proteins in OA chondrocytes decreased, while those of PER1, CDK1, CCNB1, and MMP13 increased. In addition, the cell viability increased, as well as the apoptosis rate. In the LV-Bmal1 group, the protein levels of BMAL1 and WEE1 were increased, while those of PER1, CDK1, CCNB1, and MMP13 decreased. At the same time, both the cell viability and apoptotic ratio went down. Based on this, it stands to reason that BMAL1 and WEE1 may be protective factors in OA, while PER1, CDK1, CCNB1 and MMP13 may be risk factors for OA. The clock gene Bmal1 causes chondrocyte apoptosis by regulating cell cycle and affects the initiation and progression of OA, providing a new perspective for the molecular mechanism of OA.