CALHM2 is localized to the inner mitochondrial membrane
To ascertain the function of CALHM2, we first sought to determine its localization in the cell. We assessed the endogenous subcellular localization of human CALHM2 in human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) immortalized human retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cells by structured-illumination microscopy. We found that CALHM2 co-localized with the mitochondrial-specific dye MitoTracker and TOM20 (Fig 1a). CALHM2 does not appear to co-localize with the ER marker anti-Sarcoendoplasmic Reticulum Calcium ATPase (SERCA) (Fig 1a).
Further analysis of the structured-illumination imaging revealed that CALHM2 is enveloped by the TOM20 staining and overlaps with superoxide dismutase 2 (SOD2), a component of the mitochondrial matrix (Fig 1b). Quantitative co-localization analysis using Pearson’s Correlation showed a higher correlation between SOD2 and CALHM2 than CALHM2 and TOM20 (Fig 1b), supporting the view that CALHM2 is at the inner membrane. To confirm that our anti-CALHM2 antibody signal is specific, we generated three independent RPE cell lines for CALHM2 knock-down (KD), targeting two distinct sites of the CALHM2 gene (Lines 1.1 and 1.2 target the same site, while Line 2 targets a second site, Ext Data Fig 1). In these cell lines, the CALHM2 signal is reduced confirming the specificity of our antibody (Fig 1a, Ext Data Fig 1).
Next, we studied the submitochondrial localization of CALHM2. We purified mitochondria from RPE cells and treated them with different concentrations of digitonin to remove the outer mitochondrial membranes. In this assay, proteins from the outer mitochondrial membrane are lost differentially compared to proteins in the inner membrane or matrix. We used the following proteins as markers of different mitochondrial compartments: TOM20 and mitochondrial calcium uniporter (MCU) for the outer and inner mitochondrial membranes, respectively, and PDH for the matrix. Treatment with digitonin reduced TOM20 levels substantially, indicating removal of the outer membrane, while reduction in MCU levels was less, and PDH was relatively preserved (Fig 1c, d). CALHM2 was well preserved compared to TOM20, suggesting that it is not localized in the outer membrane. CALHM2 levels were more comparable to MCU and PDH. Next, we assessed subcellular localization to mitochondrial-associated membranes (MAMs) via biochemical fractionation (Fig 1e,f). CALHM2 and the mitochondrial matrix protein PDH are enriched in the mitochondrial fraction, while Long-chain-fatty-acid-CoA ligase 4 (FACL4) is enriched in the MAM fraction (Fig 1e,f). Together, these data allow us to conclude that CALHM2 is localized to the inner mitochondrial membrane.
For greater structural resolution, we performed electron and expansion microscopy to reveal if CALHM2 is localized to the inner boundary membrane, the cristae membranes, or the cristae junctions. Immunogold labeling revealed that CALHM2 is most frequently distributed in cristae membranes (Fig 1g). Using expansion microscopy, we confirmed that CALHM2 is not localized to the plasma membrane and is exclusively in the mitochondria at low magnification (Fig 1h). At high magnification, CALHM2 is found most frequently at cristae and cristae junctions (Fig 1i).
CALHM2 binds to the mTFP and regulates mTFP levels
To begin elucidating a role for CALHM2 in mitochondria, we expressed a CALHM2-Myc construct in RPE cells, immunoprecipitated the myc epitope, then performed liquid chromatography mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) to identify associated proteins. Surprisingly, amongst the top binding partners of CALHM2 were ECHA and ECHB, subunits of the mTFP (Fig. 2a, Ext Data Table 1). The mTFP is a hetero-octamer, with two genes, HADHA and HADHB, that encode the a (ECHA) and β (ECHB) subunits of the mTFP, respectively. Together these two subunits of the mTFP perform three consecutive steps in β-oxidation: 2-enoyl-CoA hydratase activity, an NAD+-dependent 3-hydroxyacyl-CoA dehydrogenase activity, and a CoA-dependent 3-ketothiolase activity. These steps culminate in the production of acetyl-CoA that is fed into the TCA cycle to produce NADH and FADH2 for oxidation in the electron transport chain.
To verify that CALHM2 binds to the mTFP, we performed reciprocal immunoprecipitation and western blotting (Fig 2b). With IP of either CALHM2, ECHA, or ECHB, we could detect each of the other proteins that are not present in an IgG control. Interestingly, while both subunits of the mTFP and two chaperone proteins (HSP90 and HSP70) were detected in this LC-MS/MS analysis, other proteins of the inner mitochondrial and cristae membranes such as components of the electron transport chain were not detected (Extended data Table 1). Struck by the mitochondrial localization of CALHM2, the association of CALHM2 with both subunits of the mTFP (ECHA, ECHB), and the importance of the mTFP in fatty acid metabolism, we focused our analysis on the relationship between ECHA, ECHB, and CALHM2.
Next, we wondered if CALHM2 regulates mTFP protein levels or function. We isolated mitochondria and examined protein levels in two different CALHM2 KD lines (Fig 2c). Testing the mitochondrial extracts, we noted reduced levels of ECHA and ECHB in both KD cell lines (Fig 2c). To evaluate whether ECHA was mislocalized as opposed to simply reduced in level, we compared the cytosolic fraction to our mitochondrial fraction. Interestingly, ECHA appeared relatively elevated in the cytosolic fraction compared to the mitochondrial fraction in CALHM2 KD cells vs. WT (Figure 2d). This result suggests that CALHM2 may be required for the proper localization of the mTFP to the mitochondria.
To better address the localization of ECHA in response to CALHM2 KD, we returned to our structured illumination immunofluorescence studies. We compared the localization of ECHA to TOM20, present in the mitochondrial outer membrane. In WT cells, ECHA appears to be surrounded by the TOM20 mitochondrial signal (Figure 2e – see merged channel). However, in the CALHM2 KD cell line, ECHA appears to be mislocalized and the geometry relative to TOM20 is not preserved. In this case, quantitative co-localization analysis using Pearson’s Correlation showed a higher correlation between TOM20 and ECHA in CALHM2 KD cells compared to WT indicating that ECHA was mislocalized (Fig 2e).
CALHM2 affects mitochondrial cristae and fatty acid levels
If CALHM2 is necessary for mTFP mitochondrial localization and function, we expected CALHM2 KD cells to exhibit abnormal fatty acid metabolism as previously described in mTFP disease and HADHA mutant and KD cells21. BODIPY is a commonly used indicator of intracellular neutral lipid levels. We found that CALHM2 depleted cells have an increase in the BODIPY signal (Fig 3a,b), suggesting an accumulation of these lipids in the cytosol.
In addition to its role in the mTFP, the α subunit of the mTFP (ECHA) acts as an acyltransferase in cardiolipin remodeling21. Cardiolipin is an essential diphosphatidylglycerol lipid in the inner mitochondrial membrane that plays a critical role in creating normal cristae structures and positioning of inner membrane transport complexes22,23. Cardiolipin was reduced in CALHM2-depleted mitochondria compared to WT (WT) (Fig. 3c), further evidence that mTFP function was impaired.
Cardiolipin is specific to the inner membrane making up 20% of the lipid content. Therefore, reduction of cardiolipin is likely to affect mitochondrial inner membrane structure. We examined mitochondrial ultrastructure by transmission electron microscopy of CALHM2 KD cells and identified abnormalities in cristae morphology (Fig 3d). In WT cells, the mitochondria are oblong with characteristic cristae formed by the inner membrane. In the majority of CALHM2 KD cells, the number and size of the mitochondria are normal (Fig. 3d and Ext Data Fig 2); however, the mitochondria have a reduced number of cristae as predicted by the decrease in cardiolipin levels (Fig 3d). Altogether, we conclude that CALHM2 is essential for inner mitochondrial membrane structure and cardiolipin levels in addition to normal lipid metabolism.
Due to the disruption of mitochondrial cristae and a presumed failure to metabolize fatty acids, we predicted that cellular ATP content should be low in CALHM2 depleted cells. We found that ATP levels of CALHM2 KD cells are approximately 50% of the WT levels (Fig 3e). In the context of abnormal lipid metabolism and a drop in ATP levels, we wanted to assess the overall health of these cells via cell division rate. We counted the number of cells in mitosis per hour. Over a 36 hr window, the number of cell divisions in CALHM2 KD cells was roughly a third of the number in WT cells (Fig 3f), suggesting a global growth defect.
CALHM2 affects cellular respiration
The TCA cycle generates energy via the oxidation of acetyl-CoA that can be derived from carbohydrates during glycolysis, fatty acids during β-oxidation, or proteins during amino acid catabolism. We predicted that a loss of CALHM2 would lead to a reduction in fatty acid metabolism as mTFP no longer localizes to the mitochondrial matrix. When β-oxidation is inhibited, glycolysis may compensate by producing acetyl-CoA from pyruvate (Fig 4, illustration). This process results in the acidification of the extracellular medium due to the production of lactate, which can be measured as the Extracellular Acidification Rate (ECAR).
To determine how CALHM2 KD cells use glycolysis compared to WT cells, we measured ECAR in the presence and absence of glucose. In the absence of glucose, we observed no difference in the ECAR of WT and CALHM2 KD cells, indicating similar overall rates of glycolysis under these conditions (Fig 4a). Upon the addition of glucose (5 mM, Fig 4b), we observe an equivalent increase in ECAR between the two groups, suggesting glycolysis is not increased in response to the reduction of β-oxidation in CALHM2 KD cells (overlapping red lines in Fig 4b after glucose addition compared to gray lines which are reproduced from Fig 4a). Strikingly, the addition of the ATP synthase inhibitor oligomycin to WT cells approximately doubles their ECAR response to glucose, revealing a higher glycolytic capacity. However, in CALHM2 KD cells, exposure to oligomycin does not elevate the acidification rate any further (Fig 4b, split in red lines after oligomycin), showing a diminished response of glycolytic acidification to ATP synthase inhibition. These data suggest that CALHM2 KD cells are either at their maximal glycolytic capacity and cannot respond to the oligomycin-induced loss of ATP production or that CALHM2 KD cells have a reduced demand for ATP synthesis under these conditions.
To understand the mitochondrial respiratory rate and capacity of CALHM2 KD cells, we next assessed oxygen consumption rate (OCR) in response to various metabolic substrates. In the absence of glucose (2 mM glutamine), baseline and protonophore (FCCP)-stimulated respiratory capacity are decreased by nearly half in CALHM2-depleted cells compared to WT (Fig 4c, e), consistent with a reduction in oxidative capacity. In 5mM glucose-containing media, both cell lines strongly suppress their respiration. Respiration is almost completely inhibited by glucose in CALHM2 KD cells compared to a less severe reduction in WT cells (Fig 4d, e, compare red lines to gray). This reduction in OCR shows that both WT and CALHM2 KD shift toward glycolytic ATP production in the presence of glucose; however, the relative difference between them indicates that respiratory capacity is markedly lower in CALHM2 KD cells.
Since CALHM2 KD cells seem to be at their maximal glycolytic capacity in 5mM glucose, we sought to bypass glycolysis by providing either pyruvate or lactate (in No glucose) to determine if respiration could be rescued (Fig 4 illustration). The acute response and maximal capacity of WT cells to lactate are enhanced over CALHM2 KD (Ext Data Fig 3a-c). This suggests that either LDH or redox shuttling is limiting the use of lactate for acetyl-CoA production in CALHM2 KD cells. Interestingly, upon the addition of pyruvate, CALHM2 KD cells increase respiration comparably to WT cells but do not reach WT levels (Fig 4 e,f, comparing dotted red to solid red lines after pyruvate). Additionally, the maximal respiratory rate (FCCP response) is still lower in CALHM2 KD cells, consistent with a diminished respiratory capacity (Fig 4e). In summary, while CALHM2 cells can respond to pyruvate, they still have a diminished respiratory capacity suggesting that downstream metabolism may be affected such as the TCA cycle or electron transport.
PDH is localized to the mitochondrial matrix and links glycolysis to the TCA cycle by converting pyruvate into acetyl-CoA (Fig 4, illustration). As our data indicate that CALHM2 KD cells have a disrupted oxidative response to endogenous glycolytic products, we sought to characterize the levels and activity of PDH and essential TCA enzymes. To address step-by-step defects in glycolytic and mitochondrial metabolism, including PDH activity, we performed Mass Isotopomer MultiOrdinate Spectral Analysis (MIMOSA) on WT and CALHM2 KD cells. This technique uses the incorporation of mass [U-13C6]-D-glucose in place of the unlabeled forms for analysis of labeled products by LC-MS/MS24. The relative rates of production of matrix acetyl-CoA from pyruvate versus other sources such as β-oxidation are determined from the fractional contribution of pyruvate oxidation by the mitochondria (VPDH/Vcs). PDH activity is significantly reduced in CALHM2 KD cells (Fig 4g) compared to WT. Indeed, PDH protein levels are significantly reduced in CALHM2 KD cells (Fig 4h).
We next measured TCA cycle intermediates by LC-MS/MS and found that CALHM2 KD cells have a dramatic decrease in concentration of all the measured metabolites (citrate, succinate, malate) (Fig 4i-k). These data suggest that there may be insufficient anaplerosis to maintain the TCA cycle metabolite pool. The related enzymes of the TCA cycle, citrate synthase, succinate dehydrogenase A (SDHA), and malate dehydrogenase (MDH2) are also reduced (Fig 4I-n).
Finally, we examined components of the electron transport chain to address the last steps of oxidative metabolism in the mitochondria. Complexes I, II, III, and V levels are decreased in CALHM2 depleted cells, although more markedly for CI and CII (Ext Data Fig 3d,e), supporting the conclusion that TCA cycle and ETC enzymes are downregulated.
In summary, CALHM2 KD cells are unable to efficiently utilize endogenous lactate and pyruvate to drive the TCA cycle and the ETC. Interestingly, we expected to see a defect primarily in β-oxidation of fatty acids but not glycolysis/TCA/ETC; however, our data highlight that CALHM2 is essential for these other metabolic processes.
CALHM2 is a protein import channel for ECHA
Our results thus far suggest that CALHM2 is localized to the mitochondria, regulates mTFP localization, and is essential for normal cristae structure, cardiolipin and fatty acid levels, and normal cellular respiration. Based on cryo-EM, CALHM2 is a connexin-like transmembrane channel19,20, and given the mislocalization of ECHA in our IF studies, we speculated that CALHM2 imports the mTFP to the matrix side of the inner membrane (Fig 5a).
To investigate the ion channel’s biophysical properties, we carried out proteoliposome and planar lipid bilayer recordings of purified reconstituted CALHM2. Previous whole-cell electrophysiology of overexpressed human CALHM2 showed that CALHM2 produces a robust voltage-dependent current in the absence of Ca2+ and is Ca2+ inhibited19. In keeping with this previous report, our single channel recordings demonstrate that CALHM2 forms a large conductance voltage-gated channel with multiple sub-conductance states and a peak conductance value of ~1 nanoSiemens (nS) (Fig. 5b, far left CTL before ECHA and Ext Data Fig. 4). Similarly to the whole cell currents reported19, CALHM2 forms a negatively rectifying channel which is inhibited by the addition of calcium to the bath during the recordings (Fig 5b, Ext Data Fig 4c).
Next, to test whether CALHM2 might be an import channel, we designed ECHA and ECHB N-terminal peptides and added them to the recording chamber during electrophysiological measurements. When the N-terminal ends of transiting mitochondrial proteins pass through import channels, they inhibit channel activity in a concentration dependent manner13,25,26 (Fig. 5a). Consistent with this notion, in patch-clamp recordings of proteoliposomes, we observed an inhibition of CALHM2 channel activity upon the addition of both the ECHA and ECHB peptides whereas a control peptide (N terminus of COXIV) had no effect (Fig. 5b and Ext Data Fig. 4a-d).
We examined the concentration dependence of the peptides on CALHM2 conductance in planar lipid bilayers. In a representative trace (Fig 5c), the first addition of the ECHA peptide significantly reduces the peak conductance of the channel and the number of subconductance states (Fig 5c - C is closed, O1-O3 are smaller, less open, subconductance states) and see amplitude histogram 5d (green to blue peaks). The second addition of the peptide completely inhibits channel conductance (Fig 5c,d, right end of trace, loss of O1-O6, amplitude histogram - blue to red peaks). The group data confirm that ECHA reduces CALHM2 conductance in a concentration dependent manner (Ext Data Fig 4e,f). In bilayer recordings, we failed to observe CALHM2 channel activity at positive voltages, consistent with the published report on whole cell currents (Ext Data Fig 4f,h)19.
In contrast to ECHA, in a representative recording with ECHB, the first addition of peptide fails to inhibit conductance, but instead increases the frequencies of transitions between subconductance states suggesting an interaction of ECHB with the channel but a failure to completely inhibit conductance (Fig 5e top panel and f green to purple). Further addition of ECHB reduces the probability of channel opening and peak conductance (Fig 5e top panel and f, Ext Data Fig 4g,h). To study if the interaction between CALHM2 and ECHA and ECHB peptides is voltage-dependent, we changed the voltage from -20 mV to -50 mV (compare top and bottom in Fig 5e and amplitude histograms f, g). The voltage change reopens the channel, although at a subconductance state. Subsequent additions of ECHA peptide completely inhibit channel conductance in a dose-dependent manner (Fig 5e bottom panel and g). These results indicate that ECHA is more efficient than ECHB at inhibiting CALHM2 conductance at the concentrations tested in our assay.
While electrophysiological recordings show an inhibition of CALHM2 channel activity with either peptide in a concentration-dependent manner, we could not distinguish between channel transit or inhibition (Fig 5j). Therefore, we used a low concentration (2.5 µg) of ECHA, where there was no discernible block of CALHM2. At higher concentrations (5 µg), the channel was partially inhibited (Ext Data Fig 4i). To test for transit of the peptide through the channel, we added the low concentration (2.5 µg) of ECHA to only the cis side of the lipid bilayer chamber, recorded channel activity, and then removed the solution from the trans side for MALDI TOF analysis (Fig 5h). The MALDI TOF trace confirmed the transit of the ECHA peptide from the cis to the trans side (Fig 5h,j). We did not detect the ECHB peptide on the trans side when we repeated this experiment with ECHB on the cis side (Fig 5i, Ext Data Fig 4j). This result was surprising, as we have shown ECHB directly interacts with CALHM2 in the IP assay and can inhibit channel activity (albeit less efficiently) in a concentration dependent manner.
Because of the differential transit of ECHA and B through the channel, we studied the charge distribution of the ECHA and ECHB presequence peptides. The alignment of amino acid sequences of ECHA and ECHB revealed that the former has more negatively charged amino acid residues and is more linear in structure, which could explain the differences in the interaction of these peptides with CALHM2 (Ext Data Fig. 4k).