3.1 Properties of p-conjugated ILs
Fig. 1 shows the DSC results of NMMI-TFSI measured in the initial state as a solid at 298 K. The DSC measurements showed an endothermic peak at 316 K during the first heating process (black), indicating the melting of NMMI-TFSI within the IL. However, freezing and melting transitions were not observed during the subsequent cooling and heating processes (red). Instead, changes in the baseline, indicating the glass transition of the liquid, were observed at 233 and 236 K during the cooling and heating processes, respectively. As reported by Tao et al. (Tao et al. 2014), the liquid state of NMMI-TFSI is stable at room temperature without crystallization for a long time (at least during the experimental time window). Even in this study, the synthesized NMMI-TFSI was observed to form a liquid at room temperature, and the supercooled liquid state was sufficiently stable to be used at room temperature without much concern for crystallization. The stability in the liquid state may be related to the bulky naphthylmethyl substrate of the NMMI cations. In this study, unless otherwise stated, we mainly focused on the liquid state of NMMI-TFSI at room temperature.
Fig. 1 DSC curve of NMMI-TFSI
For BzMI-TFSI, we only observed a baseline change in glass transition without freezing and melting transitions, suggesting that the liquid state was further stabilized by the change in functionality from naphthalene to benzene (Fig. S5).
NMMI-TFSI exhibits fluorescence emission derived from the naphthalene functional group. Fig. 2 shows the fluorescence spectra of NMMI-TFSI in the presence and absence of CH2Cl2. NMMI-TFSI diluted with 1 vol.% of CH2Cl2 solution showed sharp fluorescence spectra with a maximum at 338 nm, indicating monomer emission at the low concentration of NMMI-TFSI (Berlman 1971). In contrast, a broader peak with a maximum at a lower wavelength (407 nm) was observed for neat NMMI-TFSI. This indicates the dimerization of naphthyl groups within the excited state derived from the p-p interaction between the p-conjugated moieties, called “excimer emission” (Kołaski et al. 2012). Although Coulombic repulsive interactions can occur between NMMI cations, the formation of dimers between naphthyl groups is of considerable interest.
Fig. 2 Fluorescence spectra of NMMI-TFSI (red) and 1 vol.% NMMI-TFSI solution with CH2Cl2 (green)
The thermal stabilities of the p-conjugated ILs were determined via TG analysis under inert gas flow conditions (Fig. 3 (a)). NMMI-TFSI (red) did not show any weight change until approximately 570 K, indicating its high thermal stability as a general IL, similar to EMI-TFSI (black). Notably, 18 wt.% of residue remained at a higher temperature than the decomposition temperature of 640 K, whereas EMI-TFSI was thermally decomposed with a small amount of residue under the same heat-treatment conditions (i.e., 1.6 wt.%). Furthermore, the residual weight was comparable to the weight percentage of the naphthyl group in the formula mass of NMMI-TFSI (27%). In addition, we obtained 21 wt.% of residue for BzMI-TFSI (blue) via TG measurements under the same conditions, indicating the characteristics of the p-conjugated ILs upon heat treatment. The residues were black solids for both NMMI-TFSI and BzMI-TFSI, indicating the carbonization of the p-conjugated ILs by heating (Fig. 3 (b)). A similar tendency was reported by several researchers for ILs with p-conjugated functionalities (Zhou et al. 2019; Tao et al. 2014), indicating that p-conjugated moieties are effective carbonization sources.
Fig. 3 (a) TG profiles of NMMI-TFSI (red), BzMI-TFSI (blue), and EMI-TFSI (black) (b) Photograph of p-ILDC prepared from NMMI-TFSI as a precursor
3.2. Properties of p-ILDCs
To characterize the properties of the residual material obtained via the heat treatment of p-conjugated ILs, we mass-produced p-ILDCs from NMMI-TFSI and BzMI-TFSI in an electric furnace under N2 gas flow. A photograph of the product obtained using NMMI-TFSI is shown in Fig. 3 (b). The yield of the glossy black powders was similar to the residual amount obtained from the TG results (i.e., 112 mg of solid was obtained from 484 mg of NMMI-TFSI, and 293 mg of solid was obtained from 1.45 g of BzMI-TFSI).
The XRD profiles of the obtained p-ILDCs are shown in Fig. 4. The horizontal axis represents the scattering parameter q (= 4psin q /l). The XRD profiles of the p-ILDCs prepared from NMMI-TFSI (red) and BzMI-TFSI (blue) show three broad peaks located at q = 17.5, 30.5, and 53.3 nm-1. These correspond to the 002, 10, and 11 diffractions of graphitic materials, respectively. Table 1 lists the crystal structures of the p-ILDCs obtained using Scherrer’s equation. Here, dhkl and Dhkl denote the interplanar spacing and crystallite size of the hkl plane, respectively. Some nanometer-order structural developments in the stacking of graphene sheets and the graphene basal plane were observed, revealing the formation of a micrographite structure in the p-ILDCs. Furthermore, the intensive small-angle X-ray scattering of the p-ILDCs over 0.5 nm-1 < q < 5 nm-1 indicates the existence of a considerable volume of nanopores in the p-ILDCs (insets of Fig. 4).
The Raman spectra of both the p-ILDCs show broad G and D bands located at 1580 and 1350 cm-1, respectively, which are characteristic of amorphous carbon (Fig. S6). The D/G ratios of the p-ILDCs prepared from NMMI-TFSI and BzMI-TFSI are 0.91 and 0.92, respectively. The results from both the XRD and Raman scattering measurements suggest that the p-ILDCs are high-surface-area materials composed of aggregated micrographite.
Fig. 4 XRD profiles of the p-ILDCs
Table 1 Crystallinities of the p-ILDCs evaluated using XRD
Fig. 5 shows the N2 adsorption isotherms of the p-ILDCs at 77 K. The shapes of the isotherms for both p-ILDCs were hybrids of Type I and Type IV isotherms according to the IUPAC classification, suggesting the existence of micro- to meso-porosities. The type H4 adsorption–desorption hysteresis for these isotherms indicates that larger mesopores are connected to the bottleneck of micropores (Thommes et al. 2015). Table 2 lists the porosities of the p-ILDCs obtained from the N2 adsorption isotherms. The specific surface areas and microporosities (i.e., average micropore widths and micropore volumes) were determined via as analysis (Kaneko et al. 1992). The mesopore volumes were evaluated by subtracting the micropore volume from the total pore volume, which was obtained from the N2 adsorption amounts at P/P0 =0.95, following the Gurvich rule (Rouquerol et al. 2014). The specific surface areas of both the p-ILDCs were approximately 1000 m2 g-1, indicating that they are high-surface-area materials because of the nanoporosities. For both the p-ILDCs, the micropore volumes were larger than those of the mesopores, although the mesopore volumes were almost similar. These porosities are related to the characteristics of the precursor ILs. The higher surface area of the p-ILDCs prepared from NMMI-TFSI than those prepared from BzMI-TFSI can be attributed to the more developed aromatic structure of the naphthalene moiety, resulting in a lower D/G ratio and higher crystallite size of D11 for the p-ILDCs obtained from NMMI-TFSI, despite the small differences. Interestingly, the average micropore widths of both the p-ILDCs are c.a. 0.9 nm, and the pore sizes are comparable to the dimension of the TFSI anions (Futamura et al. 2017).
Fig. 5 N2 adsorption isotherms of the p-ILDCs obtained from NMMI-TFSI (red) and BzMI-TFSI (blue) at 77 K. The open and closed circles show adsorption and desorption, respectively.
Table 2 Porosities of the p-ILDCs evaluated from N2 adsorption isotherm measurements
The chemical composition of the p-ILDCs was determined using XPS measurements. The wide-scan spectra for both the p-ILDCs detected signals from carbon, oxygen, and nitrogen elements, but the signals of fluorine and sulfur elements, which originate from the TFSI anion of the precursor-conjugated ILs, were not detected (Fig. S7). Table 3 lists the compositions of C, O, and N in both the p-ILDCs from the XPS results. In both the p-ILDCs, 6-7% of N atoms were included in their structure. Fig. 6 shows the XPS narrow scans for N1s of the p-ILDCs. These profiles were deconvoluted into two components, C-N and C=N, which indicate imidazole-type nitrogen atoms originating from the cations of the p-conjugated ILs (Yan et al. 2005). These XPS results suggest that organic cation structures, including aromatic moieties, mainly form a carbon framework, despite the combustion of inorganic anions by heat treatment, resulting in the formation of nanopores.
Fig. 6 XPS narrow scans for N1s of the p-ILDCs obtained from (a) NMMI-TFSI, and (b) BzMI-TFSI. Deconvoluted C-N (pink) and C=N (yellow) peaks and the total (black) are also shown.
Table 3 Compositions of C, O, and N elements for both p-ILDCs from XPS results
3.3 Relationship between carbonization and the liquid structures of p-conjugated ILs
Here, we discuss the relationship between the micro- to mesoscopic structures of the p-ILDCs and the liquid structures of the precursor-conjugated ILs. Fig. 7 shows the X-ray scattering profiles of NMMI-TFSI (red) and BzMI-TFSI (blue) in the liquid state. The X-ray scattering profile of BzMI-TFSI shows three peaks located at 3.4, 8.7, and 13.4 nm-1 for q < 20 nm-1, which are attributed to the periodicity of the interionic structures in the liquid state. In NMMI-TFSI, the peak observed at 8.7 nm-1 in BzMI-TFSI became a shoulder, which indicates the loss of specific periodicity because of the bulky naphthylmethyl groups compared with the benzyl group, but the other two peaks at 3.6 and 12.7 nm-1 were similarly observed. In particular, the first peak shows that the mesoscopic structure exists in both ILs (i.e., c.a. 1.6 nm and 1.7 nm periodic structures for BzMI-TFSI and NMMI-TFSI in the d-spacing, respectively). The peak located at the small-angle scattering region (< 5 nm-1) is called a pre-peak, indicating the existence of the mesoscopic anisotropy of ILs called a domain structure (Triolo et al. 2007). Lopes et al. showed that the anisotropy of ILs can be attributed to a structure in which the nonpolar part, composed of organic groups, and the polar part, composed of inorganic groups, are separated (Lopes and Pádua 2006). The formation of the domain structure in both the p-conjugated ILs indicates the presence of neighboring aromatic functionalities. The proximity between the aromatic functionalities in the p-conjugated ILs is also supported by the excimer emission of NMMI-TFSI in the neat liquid state in the fluorescence spectrum, despite the monomer emission in the diluted solution (Fig. 2).
Fig. 7 X-ray scattering profiles of the p-conjugated ILs in the liquid state
To clarify the influence of neighboring aromatic functionalities in the p-conjugated ILs on the carbonization process, we investigated the effect of the dilution of NMMI-TFSI with EMI-TFSI as a solvent on the neighboring naphthyl groups and its relationship with the carbon yield by pyrolysis. Here, we assessed the neighboring naphthyl groups in the dilute NMMI-TFSI solutions by excimer emission from fluorescence measurements.
Fig. 8 (a) shows the fluorescence spectra of the binary IL mixtures of NMMI-TFSI and EMI-TFSI. Neat EMI-TFSI (black) did not show fluorescence over this wavelength region, despite the broad excimer emission of neat NMMI-TFSI (red), as shown in Fig. 2. The maximum intensity of the broad peak exhibited its highest value at an NMMI-EMI molar ratio of 3:1 (orange) and then continuously decreased with decreasing NMMI-TFSI content. Moreover, the wavelength at which the maximum intensity of the broad peak was observed exhibited a continuous blue shift as the proportion of NMMI-TFSI decreased. In contrast, the intensity of the monomer emission at l = 338 nm gradually increased with decreasing NMMI-TFSI content without any peak position shifts. These results indicate that the neighboring NMMI cations in the organic domain structures are maintained even at considerably low contents of the NMMI-TFSI solution (at least in NMMI:EMI = 1:9), despite the environment surrounding the adjacent states of the organic groups within the domain changing with the composition.
Fig. 8 (b) shows the NMMI-TFSI molar fraction (i.e., f NMMI) dependence of Iex/(Imono + Iex), where Iex and Imono are the intensities of the excimer and monomer emissions, respectively. As the fluorescence intensity depends on the amount of fluorescent species, this value indicates whether the excimer or monomer species is the predominant component in the solution. In Fig. 8 (b), this value becomes less than 0.5, at f NMMI = 0.1, indicating that the neighboring NMMI cations are minor in the solution, less than the molar fraction of NMMI-TFSI.
Fig. 8 (c) shows the TG curves for the binary IL mixtures of NMMI-TFSI and EMI-TFSI with different compositions. The residual weight after heating at 773 K decreased gradually with decreasing NMMI-TFSI content. However, this trend was not linear with respect to the NMMI-TFSI content. Fig. 8 (d) shows the f NMMI dependence of the residual carbon yields. A flexion point can be observed at f NMMI = 0.1, and the residual weight rapidly decreases at f NMMI < 0.1. The correspondence at the f NMMI of 0.1, where the monomer emission becomes dominant and the residual amount decreases rapidly, indicates that the neighboring aromatic rings are crucial in carbonization; this study is the first to elucidate this at a microscopic level.
Fig. 8 (a) Fluorescence spectra for the binary IL mixtures of NMMI-TFSI and EMI-TFSI with several compositions. The colors of the curves correspond to those of the molar ratios in the legend. (b) NMMI-TFSI molar fraction dependence of Iex/(Imono + Iex). Here, Iex and Imono are the intensities of the excimer and monomer emissions, respectively. (c) TG curves for the binary IL mixtures of NMMI-TFSI and EMI-TFSI with several compositions. The colors of the curves correspond to those of the molar ratios in the legend. (d) NMMI-TFSI molar fraction dependence of the residual weight from the TG results.
Finally, we propose a plausible synthesis mechanism for nanoporous carbon from p-conjugated ILs via heating (Fig. 9). In π-conjugated ILs, a domain structure, in which π-conjugated functional groups and inorganic components are mesoscopically separated and adjacent to each other, is formed. As ILs are thermally stable without evaporation, their domain structure is maintained up to the decomposition temperature. The carbonization reactions between π-conjugated functionalities can frequently occur in p-conjugated ILs at the decomposition temperature because of the highly condensed environments of aromatic moieties (i.e., cationic domain) while micropore formation occurs simultaneously, in which inorganic anions decompose via heat treatment. The average micropore size (0.9 nm) is comparable to that of the TFSI anion. The mesopores in the p-ILDCs could be derived from the mesoscopic aggregate structure of the anions (i.e., anionic domain).
Nanoporous carbons obtained from p-conjugated ILs can maintain the structural characteristics of the precursor ions (i.e., carbon framework structure and pore sizes), and we expect to investigate the synthesis of new porous carbons using characteristic ions with unique functional groups, such as the hooped macrocycle structure of benzene rings, in future studies (Bennett et al., 2021; Ogoshi et al. 2012; Takaba et al. 2019).