3.1 Grain yield and yield components
The individual factors of year、locations and N fertilizer application method had a significant influence on kernel number per cob, 1000-grain weights and grain yield (Fig. 1). Compared with P2, averaged across 1000-grain weights and grain yield of P3、P4、P5 and P6 was a significant increase. Also, the average grain yield of P4、P5 and P6 was 4.7%、15.2%、3.4%, 6.4%、12.6%、2.1% and 3.5%、15.4%、8.1% higher than that with P3 in Zhenjiang, Xuzhou and Suqian in three years, respectively (Fig. 2). Moreover, grain yield of P5 was higher under combined application conditions (for Zhenjiang, Xuzhou and Suqian was 11523.7kg ha− 1, 9983.2kg ha− 1, 16730.1kg ha− 1 in 2019, 7581.3kg ha− 1, 8697.7kg ha− 1, 9795.9kg ha− 1 in 2021 and 12460.6kg ha− 1, 14095.5kg ha− 1, 10731.2kg ha− 1 in 2022). Variance analysis showed that there was also a significant two-way interaction between year and N fertilizer application、year and locations method on kernel number per cob, thousand kernel weights and grain yield (Table S1)。
3.2 Dry Matter Accumulation
Different fertilization methods significantly affected dry matter accumulation (DMA) of summer maize, with significant differences among different locations, years and treatments (Fig. 3). Fertilization significantly increased the total DMA of maize. Compared with P2, the average DMA of P3、P4、P5 and P6 were significantly increased by 2.7%、5.6%、12.1% and 5.3% in different years and locations. Moreover, the DMA of P5 was higher under combined application conditions (for Zhenjiang, Xuzhou and Suqian was 19484.9kg ha− 1, 21333.7kg ha− 1, 20932.6kg ha− 1 in 2019, 17860.7kg ha− 1, 16386.6kg ha− 1, 17561.1kg ha− 1 in 2021 and 18488.2kg ha− 1, 24863.0kg ha− 1, 19980.8kg ha− 1 in 2022). As a whole, the DMA of slow-release nitrogen fertilizer was higher than that of ordinary nitrogen fertilizer, and the ratio of post-silking accumulation to total growth period of P5 treatments was higher than that of other treatments.
3.3 Dry matter translocation
Fertilization significantly increased dry matter transport of maize, and there were significant differences among different fertilization methods (Table 2). Compared with P2, averaged across total translocation of P3、P4、P5 and P6 was significantly increased by 8.9%、19.9%、48.4% and 19.0% in different years and locations. The effect of combined application was better than that of a single application of slow-release fertilizer. Moreover, the translocation of P5 was higher under combined application conditions. The trend of transfer rate and contribution rate was consistent with that of translocation. For yield formation, it was mainly attributed to dry matter accumulation after flowering and dry matter transportation before flowering, and the appropriate increase of dry matter transportation could promote yield formation. Also, as shown in Table 3, there were significant differences in leaf translocation, total translocation and Transfer rate among years, while stems, heaths and contribution had no significant effect. Only leaf translocation and transfer rate had a significant effect between locations, while total translocation and contribution for stems and sheaths had no significant impact. There was also no significant three-way interaction between years、locations and treatments on translocation.
Table 2
Effects of different fertilizer combinations on maize dry matter translocation.
|
Location
|
Treatment
|
Stems and sheaths
(kg ha− 1)
|
Leaves
(kg ha− 1)
|
Total translocation
(kg ha− 1)
|
Transfer rate
(%)
|
Contribution
(%)
|
2019
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
745.5c
|
236.9c
|
982.5de
|
12.8bc
|
11.1b
|
P2
|
751.9c
|
274.7abc
|
1026.6cde
|
12.9bc
|
11.2b
|
P3
|
752.7c
|
295.3abc
|
1048.1cde
|
13.0bc
|
11.1b
|
P4
|
860.5bc
|
283.4abc
|
1143.9cde
|
14.1bc
|
11.5b
|
P5
|
871.0bc
|
459.4a
|
1330.5bcd
|
14.3bc
|
11.5b
|
P6
|
844.9bc
|
296.1abc
|
1141.1cde
|
13.5bc
|
11.1b
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
732.4c
|
313.5abc
|
1046.0cde
|
14.6abc
|
10.1b
|
P2
|
920.8bc
|
309.4abc
|
1230.3bcd
|
15.7abc
|
11.8b
|
P3
|
922.0bc
|
327.5abc
|
1249.6bcd
|
15.5abc
|
11.9b
|
P4
|
939.7bc
|
405.7abc
|
1345.5bcd
|
16.8ab
|
13.2ab
|
P5
|
1167.7ab
|
432.9ab
|
1600.7ab
|
18.7a
|
13.5ab
|
P6
|
1013.0ab
|
345.8abc
|
1358.9abc
|
16.7ab
|
12.6ab
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
735.8c
|
233.0c
|
968.8e
|
12.0c
|
11.8b
|
P2
|
714.4c
|
272.3abc
|
986.7cde
|
12.1c
|
11.1b
|
P3
|
794.1bc
|
307.0abc
|
1101.2cde
|
12.6bc
|
12.8ab
|
P4
|
815.0bc
|
336.5abc
|
1151.6cde
|
13.0bc
|
12.9ab
|
P5
|
1361.1a
|
366.4abc
|
1727.6a
|
18.7a
|
16.6a
|
P6
|
896.4bc
|
264.9bc
|
1161.4cde
|
13.6bc
|
14.1ab
|
2021
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
664.7cd
|
256.7cd
|
921.5de
|
14.8bc
|
12.8bc
|
P2
|
744.0bc
|
420.5ab
|
1164.5bc
|
14.6bc
|
13.3bc
|
P3
|
896.7bc
|
304.7bc
|
1201.5bc
|
14.9bc
|
14.0bc
|
P4
|
905.2bc
|
364.0bc
|
1269.2bc
|
15.4bc
|
14.7bc
|
P5
|
961.2bc
|
496.7a
|
1458.0ab
|
17.4ab
|
15.6bc
|
P6
|
948.2bc
|
312.0bc
|
1260.2bc
|
15.0bc
|
14.6bc
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
421.8e
|
202.0e
|
623.8g
|
11.8c
|
12.3bc
|
P2
|
696.6cd
|
191.6e
|
888.2ef
|
12.3c
|
12.2cd
|
P3
|
706.5cd
|
270.3cd
|
976.9cd
|
13.1bc
|
13.7bc
|
P4
|
791.5bc
|
274.5cd
|
1066.0cd
|
13.5bc
|
14.7bc
|
P5
|
1359.2a
|
326.6bc
|
1685.9a
|
20.3a
|
20.7a
|
P6
|
832.7bc
|
208.4de
|
1041.2cd
|
14.1bc
|
14.0bc
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
486.4de
|
190.9e
|
677.4fg
|
11.4c
|
10.1d
|
P2
|
742.8bc
|
213.5de
|
956.3de
|
12.5c
|
13.5bc
|
P3
|
817.4bc
|
214.9de
|
1032.4cd
|
12.6c
|
14.8bc
|
P4
|
938.7bc
|
235.3de
|
1174.1bc
|
13.9bc
|
15.3bc
|
P5
|
1067.ab
|
253.4cd
|
1321.3bc
|
14.4bc
|
17.1ab
|
P6
|
917.3bc
|
197.3e
|
1114.6bc
|
13.4bc
|
14.7bc
|
2022
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
550.6i
|
551.6ab
|
1102.2ij
|
15.7de
|
13.9de
|
P2
|
689.9gh
|
592.5ab
|
1282.4fg
|
16.8cd
|
15.3cd
|
P3
|
846.6ef
|
524.9ab
|
1371.6ef
|
17.6ab
|
15.5cd
|
P4
|
1012.4bc
|
582.3ab
|
1594.7bc
|
19.6ab
|
16.7bc
|
P5
|
1285.8b
|
686.2ab
|
1972.1ab
|
21.7a
|
21.4a
|
P6
|
969.7bc
|
668.8ab
|
1638.5bc
|
19.7ab
|
18.5ab
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
807.9ef
|
430.4bc
|
1238.3gh
|
14.5ef
|
12.3gh
|
P2
|
929.4cd
|
623.5ab
|
1552.9cd
|
16.6cd
|
13.6ef
|
P3
|
1170.7bc
|
629.4ab
|
1800.2bc
|
17.4bc
|
13.7ef
|
P4
|
1218.4bc
|
719.7ab
|
1938.1ab
|
18.4ab
|
14.8cd
|
P5
|
1614.3a
|
685.1ab
|
2299.4a
|
20.3ab
|
16.7bc
|
P6
|
1121.9bc
|
730.4ab
|
1852.3bc
|
19.2ab
|
13.7ef
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
595.0hi
|
359.8c
|
954.8j
|
14.1f
|
10.9h
|
P2
|
726.7fg
|
474.5bc
|
1201.3hi
|
16.5cd
|
13.3fg
|
P3
|
910.1cd
|
521.4ab
|
1431.6de
|
18.6ab
|
15.4cd
|
P4
|
944.2cd
|
716.4ab
|
1660.6bc
|
20.1ab
|
17.6ab
|
P5
|
1191.0bc
|
688.7ab
|
1879.7bc
|
21.4ab
|
19.9ab
|
P6
|
885.4de
|
793.4a
|
1678.9bc
|
20.1ab
|
17.9ab
|
Note: Different letters represent the significance of differences between different treatments in the same place at P < 0.05. P1 as no fertilizer, P2 common nitrogen fertilizer application, P3 slow-release nitrogen fertilizer application, P4 common nitrogen fertilizer and slow-release nitrogen fertilizer 1:1 application, P5 1:2 application, P6 2:1 application. |
Table 3
Analysis of variance for stems and sheaths, leaves, total translocation, transfer rate and contribution
Sources
|
Stems and sheaths
(kg ha− 1)
|
Leaves
(kg ha− 1)
|
Total translocation
(kg ha− 1)
|
Transfer rate
(%)
|
Contribution
(%)
|
Y
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
L
|
ns
|
ns
|
**
|
ns
|
ns
|
M
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
Y×L
|
ns
|
ns
|
**
|
ns
|
ns
|
Y×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
L×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
Y×L×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
Using year (Y), locations (L) and nitrogen fertilizer application method (M) as three fixed factors ns not significant (p > 0.05). ns: indicates p > 0.05 (non-significance), while * and ** respectively indicate p < 0.05 and p < 0.01 (significance).
3.4 Nitrogen uptake at pre-silking and post-silking
Different fertilization methods significantly affected nitrogen uptake at pre-silking and post-silking of summer maize, with significant differences among different locations, years and treatments (Fig. 4). Fertilization significantly increased the total nitrogen uptake of maize. Compared with P2, averaged across total nitrogen uptake of P3、P4、P5 and P6 were significantly increased by 4.8%、10.2%、21.3% and 11.6% in different years and locations. The effect of combined application was better than that of a single application of slow-release fertilizer. Moreover, P5 treatment has the best impact (for Zhenjiang, Xuzhou and Suqian was 204.1kg ha-1, 227.2kg ha-1, 222.7kg ha-1 in 2019, 198.6kg ha-1, 191.8kg ha-1, 190.2kg ha-1 in 2021 and 229.4kg ha-1, 235.4kg ha-1, 221.9kg ha-1 in 2022).
3.5 Nitrogen translocation
Different fertilization methods had significant effects on nitrogen translocation of summer maize, and significant differences between treatments (Table 4). Compared with P2, averaged across total translocation of P3、P4、P5 and P6 was significantly increased by 12.7%、28.0%、49.7% and 25.9% in different years and locations. Moreover, the translocation of P5 was higher under combined application conditions. Also, as shown in Table 5, There were significant differences in stems and sheaths translocation, total translocation and contribution among years, while leaves、transfer rate had no significant effect. There was also no significant three-way interaction between years、locations and treatments on translocation. The trend of transfer rate and contribution rate was consistent with that of translocation.
Table 4
Effects of different fertilizer combinations on maize nitrogen translocation.
Year
|
Locations
|
Treatment
|
Stems and sheaths
(kg ha-1)
|
Leaves
(kg ha-1)
|
Total translocation
(kg ha-1)
|
Transfer rate
(%)
|
Contribution
(%)
|
2019
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
31.0gh
|
10.3e
|
41.4h
|
50.9de
|
43.7ef
|
P2
|
36.9de
|
17.9de
|
54.9fgh
|
52.8cd
|
54.5de
|
P3
|
38.8cd
|
20.5de
|
59.3de
|
55.3ab
|
59.0ab
|
P4
|
44.2bc
|
22.0de
|
66.2de
|
57.3ab
|
63.9ab
|
P5
|
57.3ab
|
26.2cd
|
83.5bc
|
59.6a
|
64.0ab
|
P6
|
44.7d
|
22.5de
|
67.3de
|
57.1ab
|
63.0ab
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
26.6h
|
22.2de
|
48.8h
|
48.9de
|
41.9g
|
P2
|
33.6ef
|
23.9cd
|
57.5ef
|
48.2f
|
45.3fg
|
P3
|
43.5bc
|
25.0cd
|
68.6cd
|
51.0cd
|
50.9de
|
P4
|
48.9ab
|
26.1bcd
|
75.1bc
|
53.0bc
|
54.3bc
|
P5
|
54.1ab
|
30.4abc
|
84.5ab
|
55.3ab
|
58.1ab
|
P6
|
47.7ab
|
26.1bcd
|
73.9bc
|
53.6bc
|
52.4cd
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
31.1fg
|
20.2de
|
51.3gh
|
48.8ef
|
52.0cd
|
P2
|
43.7bc
|
24.3cd
|
68.1cd
|
52.7bc
|
57.0ab
|
P3
|
45.4bc
|
29.7abc
|
75.1bc
|
55.0ab
|
58.7ab
|
P4
|
52.2ab
|
33.0ab
|
85.3ab
|
57.0ab
|
64.2ab
|
P5
|
57.8a
|
34.3a
|
92.1a
|
59.5a
|
66.9a
|
P6
|
50.1ab
|
29.8abc
|
80.0ab
|
54.1bc
|
63.0ab
|
2021
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
23.6i
|
15.2j
|
38.9g
|
50.0c
|
41.0h
|
P2
|
30.7ef
|
26.3ef
|
57.0de
|
52.3bc
|
49.7efg
|
P3
|
30.2ef
|
29.8bc
|
60.0cde
|
52.7bc
|
50.0efg
|
P4
|
32.5def
|
33.4ab
|
65.9bc
|
53.5bc
|
51.1def
|
P5
|
35.6cd
|
36.0a
|
71.7ab
|
55.8ab
|
52.9de
|
P6
|
35.6cd
|
30.5bc
|
66.2bc
|
54.0bc
|
50.6efg
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
17.4j
|
18.0ij
|
35.5g
|
49.5c
|
49.4efg
|
P2
|
28.2gh
|
20.7hi
|
49.0f
|
51.9bc
|
45.4fgh
|
P3
|
27.2hi
|
22.1gh
|
49.4f
|
51.1bc
|
46.2fgh
|
P4
|
32.9de
|
27.4cd
|
60.4cde
|
52.9bc
|
52.6de
|
P5
|
44.9ab
|
31.5bc
|
76.4a
|
59.5a
|
57.1bcd
|
P6
|
32.6de
|
27.2de
|
59.8cde
|
55.6ab
|
49.1efg
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
13.3j
|
21.9hi
|
35.3g
|
49.2c
|
44.3gh
|
P2
|
29.4fg
|
20.0hi
|
49.4f
|
49.5c
|
53.8cde
|
P3
|
33.9de
|
20.1hi
|
54.0ef
|
51.8bc
|
59.3abc
|
P4
|
40.3bc
|
21.2hi
|
61.5cd
|
52.0bc
|
61.5ab
|
P5
|
48.0a
|
26.9de
|
75.0a
|
53.3bc
|
64.8a
|
P6
|
37.6cd
|
23.3fg
|
60.9cde
|
52.1bc
|
60.2ab
|
2022
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
19.8i
|
17.1jk
|
37.0i
|
48.0fg
|
39.4e
|
P2
|
35.6fg
|
22.4gh
|
58.0gh
|
50.3ef
|
53.5ab
|
P3
|
40.7de
|
26.7ef
|
67.5fg
|
52.5bc
|
56.0ab
|
P4
|
45.8cd
|
34.9cd
|
80.8cde
|
60.0ab
|
58.5ab
|
P5
|
66.3a
|
33.5cd
|
99.8ab
|
61.4ab
|
63.1a
|
P6
|
47.7cd
|
27.6ef
|
75.4def
|
55.6ab
|
59.8ab
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
18.3i
|
17.8ij
|
36.2i
|
39.6h
|
40.5de
|
P2
|
26.5hi
|
33.6cd
|
60.2gh
|
51.9cd
|
47.0bc
|
P3
|
31.1gh
|
41.5bc
|
72.7ef
|
54.2ab
|
52.1ab
|
P4
|
42.6cd
|
39.7bc
|
82.4cde
|
57.9ab
|
56.6ab
|
P5
|
50.3bc
|
534.0a
|
103.0a
|
62.8a
|
62.1a
|
P6
|
41.0de
|
47.1ab
|
88.1bc
|
60.4ab
|
57.3ab
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
20.9i
|
15.3k
|
36.3i
|
43.4gh
|
44.9cd
|
P2
|
34.6fg
|
20.6hi
|
55.3h
|
47.2fg
|
50.1ab
|
P3
|
38.8ef
|
25.4fg
|
64.3fgh
|
50.6de
|
56.2ab
|
P4
|
41.8cd
|
32.3cd
|
74.2def
|
52.4bc
|
57.9ab
|
P5
|
56.7b
|
28.5ef
|
85.3cd
|
54.3ab
|
63.3a
|
P6
|
43.0cd
|
30.7de
|
73.7def
|
51.2cd
|
60.1ab
|
Note: Different letters represent the significance of differences between different treatments in the same place at P < 0.05. P1 as no fertilizer, P2 common nitrogen fertilizer application, P3 slow-release nitrogen fertilizer application, P4 common nitrogen fertilizer and slow-release nitrogen fertilizer 1:1 application, P5 1:2 application, P6 2:1 application. |
Table 5
Analysis of variance for stems and sheaths, leaves, total translocation, transfer rate and contribution.
Sources
|
Stems and sheaths
(kg ha− 1)
|
Leaves
(kg ha− 1)
|
Total translocation
(kg ha− 1)
|
Transfer rate
(%)
|
Contribution
(%)
|
Y
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
ns
|
**
|
L
|
**
|
**
|
ns
|
ns
|
**
|
M
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
Y×L
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
ns
|
ns
|
Y×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
**
|
ns
|
ns
|
L×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
Y×L×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
Using year (Y), locations (L) and nitrogen fertilizer application method (M) as three fixed factors ns not significant (p > 0.05). ns: indicates p > 0.05 (non-significance), while * and ** respectively indicate p < 0.05 and p < 0.01 (significance) |
3.6 Nitrogen utilization
Different fertilization methods had significant effects on partial factor productivity of the nitrogen utilization of summer maize, and significant differences between locations and treatments (Table 6). Compared with P2, averaged across PFP, NAE and NRE of P3、P4、P5 and P6 was significantly increased. Moreover, in the experiment of three years and places, the P5 treatment had the best effect among all the treatments. Also, as shown in Table 7, there were significant differences in PFP and NAE over the years, while NRE had no significant effect. There was also significant two-way interaction between years and locations while no significant three-way interaction between years、 locations and treatments.
Table 6
Effects of different fertilizer combinations on maize nitrogen use efficiency.
Year
|
Location
|
Treatment
|
NPFP (kg/kg)
|
NAE (kg/kg)
|
NRE (%)
|
2019
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
45.6ab
|
10.4cd
|
18.4bc
|
P3
|
48.0ab
|
12.8bcd
|
26.2ab
|
P4
|
47.9ab
|
12.7bcd
|
28.6ab
|
P5
|
51.2a
|
15.9bcd
|
36.3a
|
P6
|
44.9b
|
9.75d
|
34.9a
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
36.3g
|
8.73d
|
18.7bc
|
P3
|
42.8efg
|
15.1bcd
|
18.0bc
|
P4
|
42.0fg
|
14.3bcd
|
19.0bc
|
P5
|
44.3efg
|
16.6bcd
|
24.2bc
|
P6
|
40.9fg
|
13.2bcd
|
19.5bc
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
62.4bc
|
16.7bcd
|
9.45d
|
P3
|
64.4abc
|
18.7abc
|
17.1cd
|
P4
|
66.1ab
|
20.5ab
|
19.5bc
|
P5
|
71.3a
|
25.6a
|
27.3ab
|
P6
|
57.2cd
|
11.5cd
|
25.8ab
|
2021
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
28.0i
|
6.2bc
|
15.9fg
|
P3
|
28.8hi
|
6.9bc
|
18.0ef
|
P4
|
30.2gh
|
8.4ab
|
24.0cd
|
P5
|
33.6ef
|
11.8a
|
26.1bc
|
P6
|
31.0fg
|
9.1ab
|
23.9cd
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
31.9fg
|
2.3f
|
20.2def
|
P3
|
33.2ef
|
3.6de
|
20.9de
|
P4
|
34.8de
|
5.2cd
|
26.9bc
|
P5
|
38.6bc
|
9.0ab
|
34.7a
|
P6
|
34.9de
|
5.3cd
|
27.9bc
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
35.8cd
|
3.0ef
|
10.2h
|
P3
|
38.0bc
|
5.2cd
|
11.9gh
|
P4
|
40.1ab
|
7.3ab
|
18.2ef
|
P5
|
43.5a
|
10.0ab
|
29.6b
|
P6
|
42.4ab
|
9.6ab
|
17.6ef
|
2022
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
47.7bc
|
13.4cd
|
14.3f
|
P3
|
44.9cd
|
10.6de
|
22.6cd
|
P4
|
49.3bc
|
15.0bc
|
26.1cd
|
P5
|
55.3ab
|
21.0ab
|
39.1a
|
P6
|
49.1bc
|
14.8bc
|
23.8cd
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
45.7cd
|
8.3ef
|
17.3ef
|
P3
|
54.0ab
|
16.6ab
|
24.7cd
|
P4
|
60.3a
|
22.8ab
|
28.0bc
|
P5
|
62.6a
|
25.2a
|
39.2a
|
P6
|
55.4ab
|
18.0ab
|
33.4ab
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
P2
|
37.1e
|
7.0f
|
20.4de
|
P3
|
40.3de
|
10.2de
|
23.5cd
|
P4
|
40.9de
|
10.8de
|
31.5ab
|
P5
|
47.6bc
|
17.6ab
|
37.2ab
|
P6
|
43.8de
|
13.7bc
|
29.8ab
|
Note: Different letters represent the significance of differences between different treatments in the same place at P < 0.05. P1 as no fertilizer, P2 common nitrogen fertilizer application, P3 slow-release nitrogen fertilizer application, P4 common nitrogen fertilizer and slow-release nitrogen fertilizer 1:1 application, P5 1:2 application, P6 2:1 application. NRE stands for efficiency of N recovery, NPFP refers to partial factor productivity of N and NAE stands for agronomic efficiency of N. ns: indicates p > 0.05 (non-significance), while * and ** respectively indicate p < 0.05 and p < 0.01 (significance). |
Table 7
Analysis of variance for nitrogen use efficiency.
Sources
|
NPFP (kg/kg)
|
NAE (kg/kg)
|
NRE (%)
|
Y
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
L
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
M
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
Y×L
|
**
|
**
|
**
|
Y×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
L×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
Y×L×M
|
ns
|
ns
|
ns
|
Using year (Y), locations (L) and nitrogen fertilizer application method (M) as three fixed factors ns not significant (p > 0.05). ns: indicates p > 0.05 (non-significance), while * and ** respectively indicate p < 0.05 and p < 0.01 (significance)
3.7 Economic benefits
The main cost of maize planting in Jiangsu province is the whole land, seeds, fertilizers, pesticides, harvesting and other field labor, and the total cost is approximately 11043 yuan ha-1 ~ 13578 yuan ha-1 (Table 8). Compared with P3, P5 reduced costs by 2.6%、2.8%、2.8% and increased income by 6.6%、16.9% and 38.6% in 2019、2021 and 2022. This showed that a single application of slow-release nitrogen fertilizer increased the income with higher cost. In contrast, the combined application of slow-release nitrogen fertilizer could further reduce the cost based on increasing income. Compared with other treatments, P5 increased yield to achieve the maximum net returns.
Table 8
Effects of different fertilizer combinations on maize economic benefits (yuan ha-1).
Year
|
Location
|
Treatment
|
Input costs
|
Total cost
|
Income
|
Net returns
|
Seed
|
Fertilizer
|
Other agricultural inputs
|
2019
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
15847.7hi
|
4804.7gh
|
P2
|
993
|
1319.0
|
10050
|
12362
|
20537.4ef
|
8175.4de
|
P3
|
993
|
2349.0
|
10050
|
13392
|
21612.1ef
|
8220.1de
|
P4
|
993
|
1834.0
|
10050
|
12877
|
21586.1ef
|
8709.1de
|
P5
|
993
|
2007.5
|
10050
|
13050.5
|
23047.5de
|
9997.0cd
|
P6
|
993
|
1662.2
|
10050
|
12705.2
|
20236.3ef
|
7531.0de
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
12438.8i
|
1395.8i
|
P2
|
993
|
1319.0
|
10050
|
12362
|
16371.4gh
|
4009.4hi
|
P3
|
993
|
2349.0
|
10050
|
13392
|
19277.6fg
|
5885.6ef
|
P4
|
993
|
1834.0
|
10050
|
12877
|
18906.3fg
|
6029.3ef
|
P5
|
993
|
2007.5
|
10050
|
13050.5
|
19946.0ef
|
6895.5de
|
P6
|
993
|
1662.2
|
10050
|
12705.2
|
18405.4fgh
|
5700.2fg
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
20555.2ef
|
9512.2cd
|
P2
|
993
|
1319.0
|
10050
|
12362
|
28109.7bc
|
15747.7ab
|
P3
|
993
|
2349.0
|
10050
|
13392
|
28989.1ab
|
15597.2ab
|
P4
|
993
|
1834.0
|
10050
|
12877
|
29783.7ab
|
16906.7a
|
P5
|
993
|
2007.5
|
10050
|
13050.5
|
32093.6a
|
19043.1a
|
P6
|
993
|
1662.2
|
10050
|
12705.2
|
25740.4cd
|
13035.1bc
|
2021
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
14759.7k
|
3716.7j
|
P2
|
993
|
1470.0
|
10050
|
12513
|
17025.3j
|
4512.3hi
|
P3
|
993
|
2535.0
|
10050
|
13578
|
17496.6ij
|
3918.6ij
|
P4
|
993
|
2002.5
|
10050
|
13045.5
|
18362.4gh
|
5316.9gh
|
P5
|
993
|
2160.0
|
10050
|
13203
|
20469.5ef
|
7266.5ef
|
P6
|
993
|
1845.0
|
10050
|
12888
|
19331.1fg
|
6443.1fg
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
18001.7hi
|
6958.7ef
|
P2
|
993
|
1470
|
10050
|
12513
|
20211.0fg
|
7698.0de
|
P3
|
993
|
2535
|
10050
|
13578
|
20890.9de
|
7312.9ef
|
P4
|
993
|
2002.5
|
10050
|
13045.5
|
21190.9de
|
8145.4de
|
P5
|
993
|
2160.0
|
10050
|
13203
|
23483.8bc
|
10280.8bc
|
P6
|
993
|
1845.0
|
10050
|
12888
|
21255.8de
|
8367.8de
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
19913.9fg
|
8870.9cd
|
P2
|
993
|
1470.0.
|
10050
|
12513
|
21767.2cd
|
9254.2cd
|
P3
|
993
|
2535.0
|
10050
|
13578
|
23088.6bc
|
9510.6cd
|
P4
|
993
|
2002.5
|
10050
|
13045.5
|
24363.3ab
|
11317.8ab
|
P5
|
993
|
2160.0
|
10050
|
13203
|
26448.8a
|
13245.8a
|
P6
|
993
|
1845.0
|
10050
|
12888
|
25777.9ab
|
12889.9ab
|
2022
|
Zhenjiang
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
15438.5gh
|
4395.5fg
|
P2
|
993
|
1470.0
|
10050
|
12362
|
21494.4bc
|
8981.4cd
|
P3
|
993
|
2535.0
|
10050
|
13392
|
20214.9de
|
6636.9ef
|
P4
|
993
|
2002.5
|
10050
|
12877
|
22198.8bc
|
9153.3cd
|
P5
|
993
|
2160.0
|
10050
|
13050.5
|
24921.2ab
|
11718.ab
|
P6
|
993
|
1845.0
|
10050
|
12705.2
|
22136.2bc
|
9248.2cd
|
Xuzhou
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
16845.4fg
|
5802.4ef
|
P2
|
993
|
1470.0
|
10050
|
12513
|
20588.8cd
|
8075.8cd
|
P3
|
993
|
2535.0
|
10050
|
13578
|
24340.6ab
|
10762.2bc
|
P4
|
993
|
2002.5
|
10050
|
13045.5
|
27145.5a
|
14100.1ab
|
P5
|
993
|
2160.0
|
10050
|
13203
|
28191.1a
|
14988.1a
|
P6
|
993
|
1845.0
|
10050
|
12888
|
24948.8ab
|
12060.ab
|
Suqian
|
P1
|
993
|
/
|
10050
|
11043
|
13529.7h
|
2486.7h
|
P2
|
993
|
1470.0.
|
10050
|
12513
|
16712.4fg
|
4199.4gh
|
P3
|
993
|
2535.0
|
10050
|
13578
|
18156.7ef
|
4578.7fg
|
P4
|
993
|
2002.5
|
10050
|
13045.5
|
18419.4de
|
5373.9ef
|
P5
|
993
|
2160.0
|
10050
|
13203
|
21462.5bc
|
8259.5cd
|
P6
|
993
|
1845.0
|
10050
|
12888
|
19713.1de
|
6825.1de
|
Significant level (F value)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Y
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
**
|
**
|
P
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
**
|
*
|
T
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
**
|
**
|
V×P
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
**
|
**
|
V ×T
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
*
|
*
|
P×T
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
ns
|
ns
|
V×P×T
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
ns
|
ns
|
Note: Different letters denote significant treatment differences (Tukey's HSD post hoc tests, P < 0.05). P1 as no fertilizer, P2 common nitrogen fertilizer application, P3 slow-release nitrogen fertilizer application, P4 common nitrogen fertilizer and slow-release nitrogen fertilizer 1:1 application, P5 1:2 application, P6 2:1 application. Y denotes the year, P is the location and T refers to the treatment. ns: indicates p > 0.05 (non-significance), while * and ** respectively indicate p < 0.05 and p < 0.01 (significance) |
3.8 Correlation analysis
Correlation analysis between yield and each index under different fertilizer combinations(Fig. 5). The yield was positively correlated with kernel number per cob, thousand kernel weights, dry matter accumulation, nitrogen uptake and nitrogen translocation. Moreover, nitrogen uptake and translocation positively correlated with PFP, NAE and NRE. This showed that fertilization combinations could improve nitrogen uptake and translocation to meet the demand of yield increase and increase NAE, and grain yield could also be increased by cultivation measures to increase kernel number per cob and thousand kernel weights.