This cross-sectional observational study examined the relationship between dysphagia and social isolation in community-dwelling older people. The prevalence of sarcopenia in this study was 4%, which was slightly lower than that reported in previous studies [29], and the physical function of the population tended to be higher than the average for Japanese older people in the same region [30, 31]. Overall, 97% of the participants were independent in IADL. Therefore, it is likely that the participants in this study had better than average physical function and functional capacity.
Although there are various measures of social networks, such as social isolation, a systematic review and meta-analysis of social isolation in community-dwelling older people found that only 13 of 42 studies reported using the LSNS-6 to assess social isolation [32]. The LSNS-6 is an internationally used measure that has been validated for reliability and validity in Japan [17]. It has also been used in many studies of social isolation among Japanese community-dwelling older people [7, 14]. The EAT-10 is a questionnaire-based index of subjective deterioration in swallowing function. It is used internationally and has been validated for reliability and validity in a variety of subjects with dysphagia [18, 19], and been used in previous studies to assess swallowing function in community-dwelling older people [33]. The EAT-10 can be used to assess swallowing function in community-dwelling older people with good physical function. Thus, an association between dysphagia and social isolation was found using a validated assessment measure.
Dysphagia in community-dwelling older adults was independently associated with social isolation, IADL, physical function, and depressive symptoms. It has been reported that patients with dysphagia avoid eating with non-family members and stop eating out or with friends because of their isolation [34]. Increased dysphagia has been reported to affect social participation and quality of life adversely in patients with head and neck cancer with dysphagia [35]. We wonder whether this may lead to a narrowing of their social network as they worry about swallowing during meals because of their dysphagia.
Previous studies have reported that depressive symptoms in community-dwelling older people are associated with subjective assessments of oral function and social isolation [36, 37]. However, in the present study, using depressive symptoms as an adjustment variable in the multivariate analysis, we found that a subjective decline in swallowing function was independently associated with social isolation. It has also been reported that social isolation varies from country to country because of differences in cultures and values [38]. Therefore, it was suggested that the association between social isolation and dysphagia found in this study may also occur in the Asian older population.
By contrast, neither tongue pressure nor tongue and lip motor function was associated with social isolation. A previous study reported that oral function such as tongue pressure and tongue and lip motor function was not related to the social networks of community-dwelling older people [39]. Tongue pressure and ODK are mainly used to assess oral function such as tongue movement, which is one aspect of swallowing-related function, whereas the EAT-10 is mainly used to screen for dysphagia. Although these are assessments of feeding and swallowing, the subjective symptoms of dysphagia may be more strongly related to social isolation than assessments of a subset of swallowing function.
This study has some limitations. First, because this was a cross-sectional study, the causal relationship between social isolation and swallowing function could not be clarified. In the hypothetical model stage, we considered that social isolation may be caused by the deterioration of oral function, but the causal relationship needs to be verified in a future longitudinal study. Second, in this study, we focused on swallowing function, but we did not investigate the number of remaining teeth or occlusal force. It has been reported that tongue pressure is related to the number of remaining teeth, and that the effect of denture type on tongue pressure differs [40]. Oral status may have had an influence, but because the number of remaining teeth, denture type, and degree of fit were not examined in this study, this remains an issue for future research. Third, subgroup analyses could not be performed because of the sample size. The Strobe Statement also recommends subgroup analysis in observational studies. Subgroup analysis should include age, gender, and depressive symptoms, all of which may affect swallowing function and social isolation. However, subgroup analysis was not feasible with the sample size of the present study because of the high likelihood of a type II error. It may be necessary to collect more samples in the future.
In conclusion, the results of this study suggest that dysphagia is associated with social isolation independent of functional capacity, physical function, and depressive symptoms in community-dwelling older people.