To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study in Japan to reveal a relationship between the changes in PA and physical and mental health in breast cancer survivors during the COVID-19 pandemic and risk factors based on a multifaceted assessment including psychosocial factors.
The proportion of breast cancer survivors whose PA decreased during the COVID-19 pandemic was 65.5%, whereas the proportion of those with increased PA was merely 3.5%. Almost half (45.6%) of the patients who had no exercise habits at the time of the survey had stopped exercising during the pandemic, and 60.3% of them did so for reasons related to COVID-19. In the EORTC function scales, participants with decreased PA had lower scores in all items. There was a significant difference in physical function between the two IPAQ groups. Consistent with previous reports [6–9, 28, 29], this study also showed that a decrease in PA may lead to a decrease in physical function.
Participants who were aware of their susceptibility to COVID-19 were more likely to have low PA regardless of the activity level, and the reason for this included cancer and cancer treatment. In a previous study [16], 119 patients (41.3%) reported their activities to have changed since their breast cancer diagnosis and “becoming less active.” In this study, the awareness of susceptibility to COVID-19 and the threat of infection along with cancer and cancer treatment likely contributed to the decline in PA observed in breast cancer survivors.
Furthermore, 68.4% of the patients were symptomatic, with fatigue the most common symptom (40.0%). In the EORTC symptom scales, those with decreased physical function showed a significantly higher level of fatigue symptomatology regardless of the activity level. Tabaczynski et al. [9] reported that PA decreased during the pandemic, which may have negative implications for cancer survivors in terms of QOL and fatigue. A relationship between PA and fatigue has previously been reported [30], but the results of this study showed that regardless of the activity level, decreased PA can lead more patients to become symptomatic, with a higher level of symptomatology including fatigue. To alleviate the symptoms, it is important to maintain the current activity level, whatever it may be.
Regardless of the activity level, participants with decreased PA also had higher scores for PHQ, a questionnaire module for depression, indicating a tendency towards moderate-to-severe depression. Seven et al. [31] showed that breast cancer survivors experienced different health challenges causing new physical and psychological symptoms, such as lymphedema, pain, burnout, and anxiety that may have long-term effects on their QOL. This study also showed that breast cancer survivors with decreased PA were aware of their susceptibility to COVID-19 and felt threatened due to their cancer and its treatment, resulting in reduced QOL. Furthermore, many of those with decreased PA, regardless of the activity level, reported that their life satisfaction had worsened, indicating that decreased PA is associated with an increased risk of depression and decreased QOL and life satisfaction.
Consequently, it was revealed that decreased PA in breast cancer survivors, regardless of the activity levels, has an impact on their physical and mental health. Tabaczynski et al. [9] concluded that behavioral strategies are needed to help cancer survivors to engage in and maintain PA.
In terms of support needs, 86.4% of participants requested “exercise that can be done at home,” followed by 70.7% of participants that desired “information provided through brochures.” In comparison with the period preceding the COVID-19 pandemic, more breast cancer survivors requested remote and home support rather than face-to-face support. In addition, those with decreased PA tended to request remote support by phone calls and emails, whereas those with maintained PA sought personalized support from healthcare professionals. Previously, Lucia et al. [32] reported an online home-based exercise intervention during COVID-19 lockdowns that could improve physical fitness and body composition in breast cancer survivors. Moreover, Blasio et al. [33] demonstrated that personalized feedback and supervised online physical exercise sessions conferred major physical activity benefits in breast cancer survivors during the COVID-19 pandemic. Therefore, remote support should be considered during pandemics. However, exercise intervention usually has a short-time effect and in the longer term, many survivors may become insufficiently active [34]. Breast cancer survivors may need continued motivation and practical support tailored to their individual characteristics and physical activity history to incorporate exercise into an everyday routine in the long term [35].
The main results of this study were the PA changes observed in breast cancer survivors during the COVID-19 pandemic and the most recent distributions of QOL and depression rates among this patient population. Interestingly, a decrease in PA, rather than the activity level per se, affected the mental and physical health of patients. Of particular importance, the risk of depression increased when patients who used to exercise stopped exercising.
Even though COVID-19 was downgraded to a “Class 5 disease” according to the Infectious Disease Control Law in Japan, the threat posed by the disease continues to exist. Currently, the Okinawa Prefecture, our survey area, is facing the 11th wave of COVID-19 in a context of medical shortages. As infection control measures will continue to be pursued, there is a need to develop personalized exercise support by healthcare professionals so that breast cancer survivors can continue exercising.
Study limitations
This survey was a cross-sectional study that was performed between February and July 2022, two years after the pandemic started. Therefore, the applicability of the results is limited. Nevertheless, this study offers some important insights that will be useful in considering future exercise support.