Twenty patients were interviewed, with a mean age of 37.2 years (range: 27–58 years). The majority of the patients were married (14/20) and unemployed (14/ 20). The average duration of disease was 33 months (range: 8–108 months). Detailed demographic and disease characteristics of the participants are presented in Table 2. In this study, the experience of unmet needs was comprehensively analyzed by categorizing them into microsystem, mesosystem, and macrosystem levels. Three themes and nine sub-themes emerged, reflecting BCS' unmet needs across these categories: microsystem (normalization and self-growth), mesosystem (acceptance and respect in the family and workplace), and macrosystem (expansion of the support system). Figure 1 illustrates these themes and sub-themes.
Theme 1: Microsystem —Normalization and self-growth
Management of somatic symptoms and function
This category encompasses three thematic clusters: ‘management of therapeutic adverse effects’, ‘functional rehabilitation’, and ‘control of metastatic recurrence’. Somatic symptoms and dysfunction impact participants' work, life, socialization, and basic physiological needs, creating significant unmet needs during the survivorship period. Participants undergoing complex integrated antitumor treatments report persistent somatic complaints, including nausea, pain, skin changes, and menopausal symptoms, which severely affect their quality of life.
“All the symptoms followed. After surgery, my chest felt like it was wrapped tightly in bandages. After chemo, I was nauseous, lost weight, and had significantly less energy than before. After radiation, the skin on my chest started peeling, then broke down and pushed out. Now I'm menopausal and have hot flashes and night sweats, but those don't seem to matter as much to the doctors because I survived. How I wish all of this could be effectively controlled so that I could return to my pre-illness state.” (Participant 2)
Additionally, participants described damage to lymphatic circulation and impairments in limb, sensory, and cognitive functioning due to treatment, which hindered their recovery. They expressed a desperate need for effective management to return to a "normal" state, which would facilitate the resumption of family roles and work.
“After being discharged from the hospital, my arms and shoulders moved awkwardly. My hands and feet would occasionally feel numb, like ant bites. My memory was not as sharp as it used to be, and my thinking had become sluggish. As an accountant, I cannot afford to make a single mistake, so it's quite challenging for me at the moment. I am unsure if I will be able to fully recover from all of this.” (Participant 3)
Despite completing successful surgery or chemotherapy, participants continued to harbor concerns about cancer recurrence and potential metastasis to other parts of their body. The fear of cancer recurrence was identified as the main source of their psychological anguish.
“Even though I had completed surgery and chemo for several years, when alone, I often had a thought all at once that I was afraid of the cancer coming back or metastasizing, which was a big part of my mind.” (Participant 6)
Seven participants experienced systemic symptoms such as pain, weight loss, anemia, and edema, as well as site-specific metastatic symptoms (involving the lung, liver, bone, and brain) during their survival period. They were highly motivated to find effective ways to manage recurrent metastatic symptoms to prolong their survival.
“This past year has been a struggle with repeated hydrothorax and unbearable pain, and I'm desperately hoping to manage it. I'm praying that the cancer won't spread and that I can extend my life (tears in my eyes).” (Participant 4)
Maintenance of body image, femininity, and sexuality
This category encompassed four theme clusters: ‘compensation for physical deficiencies’, ‘breast reconstruction’, ‘hair loss care,’ and ‘sexual and reproductive support’. Participants reported changes in body image following comprehensive treatment, such as missing breasts, hair loss, and altered appearance, which led to feelings of frustration, sadness, and diminished self-esteem. However, they also expressed hope that through image management, they could restore their feminine image and reintegrate into their families and society more positively.
Most participants in this study had undergone modified radical mastectomy, impacting their feminine characteristics. They expressed a desire to maintain their ideal female silhouette and compensate for postoperative physical changes using bras and prostheses. Each individual had specific preferences regarding the material, shape, availability, comfort, and fit of prosthetic breasts.
“I feel inferior due to my lack of breasts, so I have tried various methods to compensate for it. I have bought silicone and cotton breast prostheses, but neither of them is comfortable to wear. The silicone one is not breathable and causes me to get rashes when I wear it for extended periods in the summer, and it is too cold in the winter. The cotton one has uneven weights on both sides, making it difficult to maintain balance. At present, there are not many types of prosthetic breasts. We hope that in the future, we will have more choices in terms of fabric, style, material, and function.” (Participant 6)
Some participants began focusing on breast shape and aesthetics during their recovery to preserve their unique female characteristics, highlighting the importance of breast repair and reconstruction.
“As a young, unmarried woman, I am particularly conscious of the aesthetics of my form. Breast reconstruction is definitely something I plan to do when I am feeling better.” (Participant 15)
Participants described the loss of hair, eyebrows, and eyelashes as traumatic changes that diminished their feminine personality, attractiveness, and temperament, causing distress in daily life and interpersonal interactions. However, they noted that healthcare professionals often underestimated the psychological impact of hair loss.
“Healthcare professionals are used to hair loss in oncology patients, but as a female, it was extremely upsetting to observe my hair coming out in large amounts. My self-esteem was crushed, and I've been reluctant to go out ever since for fear of people seeing my ugly appearance. I think it's also necessary for healthcare professionals to provide hair care, such as regrowing hair.” (Participant 5)
Participants also expressed the need for skincare and cosmetic guidance to address surgical scarring, post-treatment skin pigmentation, broken fingernails, facial swelling, and other visible changes. They emphasized the importance of maintaining self-image, harmony in intimate relationships, returning to work, and social acceptance.
“The treatment altered my l appearance and I was aghast at what I saw. My skin was lackluster, my face was swollen, and since my job called for me to appear neat and attractive, I was hesitant to use any beauty products since I was apprehensive about their potential consequences. I can't even look at my scars, let alone my husband's. Can you get rid of them?” (Participant 10)
Due to medication and surgeries, young patients often experience symptoms such as decreased libido, vaginal dryness, and painful intercourse. These changes, coupled with fears of losing fertility, instill a deep sense of inferiority in patients. Influenced by traditional Chinese culture, many are reserved and discreet when discussing fertility and sexual experiences. Despite difficulties related to their sex lives or sexual dysfunction from treatment, many patients hesitate to discuss these issues with medical professionals due to fear of judgment or discrimination. Respondents appreciated the professional and authoritative information support provided by hospitals and expressed a desire for safe, professional information sources. Most participants expected professional information support and guidance to assist in making informed fertility decisions, wishing for medical staff to offer diverse information channels to satisfy their needs.
“Knowledge about this (sexuality and fertility) is necessary for me at such a young age, but it feels too embarrassing to ask in public. It’s hard to tell what's true on the internet, but we still trust our doctors the most. Hopefully the hospital will push out little articles and videos in the form of official accounts.” (Participant 13)
“When it is mentioned about sex and fertility, we would like to have more privacy, and it would be more convenient if hospitals could set up a small program for the whole management platform, so that we can communicate with our doctors online.” (Participant 10)
Adoption of healthy behaviors
This category encompassed three thematic clusters: ‘cultivation of a healthy lifestyle’ and ‘self-regulation of negative emotions. Experiencing the pain of illness, most participants began to reconsider their previous lifestyles and became more health-conscious. They sought to acquire accurate and comprehensive knowledge about diet, physical activity, Chinese medicine, and health maintenance to manage their treatment effectively and minimize the risk of illness recurrence and metastasis.
“Breast cancer is a chronic disease, and the main thing is to be persistent and maintain good habits so that you can live, so I change my old bad habits, such as staying up late, stop smoking and drinking, and I pay more attention to my health than before.” (Participant 11)
“After I was discharged from the hospital, I began to realize the importance of exercise, and in order to avoid relapses and complications, I tried to maintain a regular exercise routine, and I was also applying Chinese medicine to regulate my body, so as to ‘support the positive and dispel the evil’.” (Participant 18)
Despite professional treatment, participants experienced various negative emotions, including depression, anxiety, sadness, fear of relapse, and psychosomatic issues such as suicidal thoughts. They felt powerless and uncertain about how to seek help, expressing a need for professional psychosocial support.
“After treatment, I was in a terrible emotional state. Nothing interested me. Subsequently, due to the inadequate review results, I was unable to sleep the whole night. I was filled with negative thoughts and even contemplated suicide. Thankfully, my husband was aware and took me to psychotherapy. In reality, many patients surrounding me have psychological issues that need assistance to reduce their negative emotions and mental stress.” (Participant 12)
Theme 2:Mesosystem—Acceptance and respect in the family and workplace
Internal to the mesosystem—Strengthening family resilience
Breast cancer places significant stress on the entire family system, leading to the redistribution of family responsibilities, diminished intimacy, substantial financial burdens, and restricted family communication. Participants expressed a desire for their family systems to demonstrate resilience and support in appropriate ways to maintain healthy family functioning.
In China, where women often shoulder a larger share of caregiving tasks and contribute to the family's financial responsibilities, married participants noted the importance of receiving greater understanding and support from their family members, especially their husbands. This support includes managing household chores, caring for family members, and assisting with children’s education. Family members' mutual care, respect, effective communication, and shared understanding of each other's feelings are crucial in jointly facing the challenges posed by the disease, thereby enhancing family resilience.
“This is the 9th year of my illness, and everyone thinks it's a miracle of life, but in fact, my family, especially my husband's companionship, who never left me during my illness, took care of the household chores, took care of my young daughter, and we communicated with each other and never hid our bad feelings.” (Participant 1)
Unmarried participants expressed a need for robust support from their families, particularly from their parents. They hoped their parents would accompany them to medical appointments and assist in decision-making. In appreciation of their parents' commitment, they also desired time to recover and heal.
“I had just graduated from grad school and breast cancer had almost crushed me. I had cried late at night in the hospital, feeling so lonely. For me, there were only my parents, but they were out of town and had jobs. How I wished I could have been with my parents when they visited me and helped me make decisions.” (sobbing) (Participant 6)
External to the mesosystem—Provision of return-to-work assistance
Participants noted that returning to work represents a crucial step toward recovery from their illness due to its increased opportunities for socialization, financial resources, and the realization of self-worth. However, they faced numerous obstacles in the process, including limited re-entry options into the workforce post-recovery, fatigue, diminished energy, reduced work capacity that precludes performing previous roles, and fears that hastening their return might trigger a recurrence of cancer. Participants expressed that the current vocational rehabilitation guidance provided by medical staff, based on individual assessments, is inadequate. They also desire acceptance and respect from colleagues and supervisors, adjustments to their job duties to align with their current capabilities, and opportunities to assume more suitable roles.
“Employers may be hesitant to hire me due to my history of cancer, as I could request leave or resign unexpectedly and my work efficiency is not at its peak, thus I cannot be a regular employee of the company, only a temporary worker at best.” (Participant 7)
“After being back at work for six months, I'm still feeling embarrassed due to the rejection, taunts, or excessive concern from some of my colleagues. I'm willing to put in the effort to adjust to my work status and not hinder the progress of everyone else, if my leaders and colleagues give me the time to do so.” (Participant 17)
Theme 3: Macrosystem—Expansion of the support system
Diverse treatment facility support
This category comprised two thematic clusters: ‘authoritative and diverse medical information support’ and ‘optimization of medical resources.’ Disease-related information forms the foundation of treatment decisions for breast cancer patients and the scientific basis for their self-management. Most participants advocated that hospitals and national health organizations should provide patients with more knowledge and information support through multiple channels.
“Knowing little about the disease, it is clear that healthcare workers are too occupied to provide us with extensive knowledge. Unfortunately, the information available on the internet is not trustworthy. It would be beneficial if you could talk more about it, or if public hospitals created an official website or platform with cancer information.” (Participant 8)
“With cancer impacting so many people, the nation should take steps to educate the public on how to prevent and control it.” (Participant 9)
Considering the differences in age, cancer stage, treatment modalities, and adverse effects, participants expressed a diversity of needs for medical information during the survivorship period. Some participants would prefer to receive tailored instruction on topics such as cancer recurrence and metastasis, management of menopausal symptoms, contraception, improvement of sexuality and intimacy, and genetic counseling for tumors.
“I had a relapse and my emotional state was worse than when I was first diagnosed two years ago. Fortunately, I had the support of my doctor who told me that there was a cure. I will always remember the doctor's kindness as he examined my condition and discussed the treatment plan.” (Participant 19)
“The couple's life is not what it used to be…I often use the internet to look for information, but I'm unsure of its accuracy. Doctor doesn't talk about private issues such as sex and fertility either. It would be great if you could suggest a sexual health and fertility clinic or online counseling.” (Participant 13)
“I am a doctor, so I know that professional genetic testing is very necessary, if it is positive, the chances of recurrence and metastasis are very high, but at present, the testing in this regard is not common enough.” (Participant 15)
Participants expressed concern about the inconsistency of healthcare services received during the transition from active treatment to survivorship. Common needs identified for medical institutions included issuing longer-term prescriptions, optimizing follow-up appointment services, proactively providing reimbursement receipts, and enhancing the capabilities of internet hospitals. These changes would help reduce the costs associated with repeated treatments and cross-regional medical care.
“The hospital should improve the process of access, giving more thought to our requirements. For instance, when I have a review, I have to book two appointments to come to the hospital, which is a waste of time and money.” (Participant 13)
“It would be a great convenience to us if the hospital could offer the service of ordering medication online and having it delivered to our doorstep via express delivery.” (Participant 10)
Accessible integration of communities
This category included two thematic clusters: ‘accessibility of cancer survivor care in community continuity’ and ‘actively organizing activities for cancer patient group.’ Participants have high expectations for the continuation of cancer care within the community. They hope their local primary hospitals will provide effective symptom management, ongoing treatment, maintenance of vascular access, and physical rehabilitation for cancer care in the future. This would not only provide easier access to healthcare but also reduce unnecessary non-medical expenditures.
“It's so hard to get to the hospital every time! Besides having to book a bus ticket in advance, it takes over 5 hours on the road. It would be a lot easier and less expensive if our local hospitals were able to provide chemotherapy and radiation treatments and maintain retained venous catheters.” (Participant 8)
The community can actively coordinate and encourage social groups to organize various activities for cancer patients, thereby fostering peer support and facilitating the exchange of information among them.
“During my home rehabilitation time, I was quite lonely and had no social life. But with social workers introducing me, I found a group of breast cancer patients where I acquired understanding of how to recover and cope with my emotions. It was no longer necessary to pretend to be fine, as the group shared the same experience and could relate to each other.” (Participant 9)
Health and payment policy favoritism
This category included two thematic clusters: ‘optimization of health insurance structure’ and ‘convergence of healthcare organizations.’ Most participants noted that cancer treatment is costly and, coupled with decreased work capacity leading to reduced income, results in significant financial strain on patients and their families. Improvements in the country’s health and payment policies could alleviate this burden significantly. Participants specifically called for the extension of major illness medical insurance coverage, reduction in the cost of cancer drugs, and expansion of insurance reimbursement for these medications.
“I sometimes even want to give up treatment, considering the financial pressure. The most direct way to alleviate our burden now is to reduce the price of anti-cancer drugs, increase the reimbursement rate, and allow more drugs to be added to health insurance coverage.” (Participant 10)
Additionally, some participants expressed a desire for increased commercial insurance investment in medical care for breast cancer patients to lessen the financial burden of the disease.
“Before I got sick, I had taken out an insurance policy for major illnesses. The insurance firm gave me recompense, which helped to lighten my financial load and spared my family from taking on any of it. Nonetheless, there are still too few commercial insurance policies for cancer, and there are also many limits with regards to buying them.” (Participant 11)
Furthermore, interviewees expressed a need for high-quality, standardized, and equitable healthcare resources. This requires better integration between healthcare institutions and the development of healthcare consortia, which would help reduce redundant consultations across regions, improve patient experiences, and enhance survival outcomes.
“At present, there is a marked difference between regions in terms of the quality of medical resources, with most of the best care being located in "big hospitals" (tertiary hospitals). To ensure I receive the best care possible during my recovery, I would be greatly reassured if I had access to online consultations, remote consultations, and the sharing of health records.” (Participant 20)
Destigmatization of cancer
The public often stigmatizes cancer, associating it with “bad luck,” “death,” and “contagiousness.” This widespread cognitive bias against cancer patients is a significant factor in the macro-environment that hinders their recovery, survival, and ability to thrive and realize their value.
“My family and friends avoided me, believing that cancer would bring them misfortune. When I went back to work, my colleagues also questioned if I was still capable of doing my job due to my cancer-stricken status. All I wanted was to be treated like ‘normal people’.” (Participant 12)