This study is the first to identify risk factors associated with suicidal behavior among Japanese forensic patients, utilizing nearly all available data from individuals under the MTSA in Japan. The rate of suicidal behavior among Japanese forensic outpatients was 6.9%, with completed suicides occurring in 1.5% of cases. Our findings revealed significant associations between suicidal behavior and direct outpatient treatment, a history of outpatient psychiatric care, a diagnosis of schizophrenia, and an arrest for arson.
4-1. Suicide among forensic outpatients
The suicide rate in the general population of Japan is estimated at approximately 0.02% [16]. In this study, the rate of completed suicides among forensic outpatients was 1.5%, indicating a significantly higher suicide risk in this group compared to the general population. As previously noted, forensic patients are at an elevated risk for suicide [5-7], a trend that is consistent among Japanese patients. Additionally, compared to the 0.1% rate of completed suicide among general psychiatric outpatients in Japan [17], forensic patients face a substantially higher risk. Furthermore, while the rate of suicidal behavior in the general population is estimated at 2.4% [18], this suggests an even greater risk of suicide attempts among forensic patients. These findings underscore the importance of intensive suicide prevention measures for Japanese forensic patients.
The heightened risk of suicide among forensic patients may arise from the inherently isolating conditions of their environments and the stigma associated with having committed a crime, which complicates their reintegration into society. Forensic patients often experience significant social isolation [19, 20], which is a known risk factor for suicide [21, 22]. Additionally, the stigma they face can adversely affect their mental health [23], potentially leading to suicidal behaviors. Therefore, future efforts in suicide prevention for forensic patients should focus on enhancing their social connections, including relationships with family and friends, and combating stigma against them.
4-2. Suicide and outpatient/inpatient history
This study found that the risk of suicide was higher among forensic patients who had received outpatient treatment in psychiatric clinics before committing criminal acts. However, this increased risk was not observed in patients with a history of inpatient treatment. Additionally, those treated directly as outpatients had a greater risk of suicide than those who were first treated as inpatients and then transitioned to outpatient treatment under the MTSA.
Psychiatric patients often have poor insight into their illness [24-26], which frequently results in medication non-adherence [27-29]. Inpatient treatment is believed to help maintain medication adherence, whereas direct outpatients may lack an understanding of the necessity of medication.
Moreover, patients need social support during psychological crises. Inpatients can build relationships with their medical staff, but social connections are often weak among forensic patients [19, 20]. Consequently, direct outpatients may be isolated, making it challenging to intervene when their conditions worsen. In general, poor adherence, including interruption of medication, increases the risk of suicide [30, 31]. Therefore, maintaining medication adherence and managing symptoms through enhanced support from their families and communities are crucial for forensic outpatients.
4-3. Suicide and schizophrenia
Previous studies have shown higher rates of suicide among patients with schizophrenia [32-34]. The risk of suicide has also been found to be higher among forensic patients with schizophrenia [35]. Therefore, the results of this study, which did not reveal a greater risk of suicide among forensic patients with schizophrenia, are inconsistent with previous findings.
One possible explanation for this inconsistency is the focused interventions implemented in Japan. Japan established a system for the treatment of forensic patients in 2005, more than 30 years later than in Western countries. When establishing the MTSA system, findings from foreign countries were utilized to design interventions specifically for patients with psychiatric disorders [36]. Given the known high rates of relapse [37-39] and suicide [32-34] among patients with schizophrenia, intensive care has been provided for forensic patients with psychosis under the MTSA. It is plausible that these intensive treatment efforts have been successful in preventing suicidal behavior among forensic patients with schizophrenia.
4-4. Suicide and arson
It is known that some arsonists have suicidal tendencies [40-42], and similar findings were observed in this study. Some arsonists are categorized as “suicidal” arsonists [43, 44]. It is estimated that approximately 18% of fire-related deaths in Japan are due to suicide [45], suggesting that some individuals may have committed arson with the intention of committing suicide. Therefore, the risk of suicide should always be considered when evaluating arsonists.
4-5. Limitations
This study identified risk factors for suicidal behavior, including suicide attempts, to facilitate early intervention for Japanese forensic patients. However, risk factors may differ between completed and attempted suicides, necessitating a comparison between them. Additionally, since attempted suicides in this study were based on self-reports, any suicidal behaviors not reported to medical staff were excluded.
Nonetheless, we have demonstrated that the risk of suicide is high among forensic outpatients and identified specific risk factors for suicide. Based on these findings, both a population-based approach for all forensic outpatients and a targeted high-risk approach for patients with identified risk factors for suicide should be implemented under the MTSA system.