3.1. Physicomechanical properties of comminuted biomass
After the fungal pretreatment, particle size was slightly reduced, particularly in the case of comminuted shavings. Differences between wood species were marginal, at the edge of statistical error. The particles of comminuted shavings and particleboards had an average size of 0.44 mm ± 0.06 mm, with a median of 0.43 mm. The size xg was notably higher for raw pine comminuted shavings at 0.61 mm (Table 2).
The impact of fungal pretreatment on the material's mechanical properties from comminuted particleboards was statistically significant in most instances. These changes were more pronounced for pine than for poplar. Notably, the results concerning the strength σc were particularly striking, where for raw pine and poplar particleboard materials, they were 33.7 kPa and 42.1 kPa, respectively. After pretreatment, they increased to 48.7 kPa and 64.4 kPa, respectively.
Table 2
Parameters (mean values and ± standard deviations, SD) of physicomechanical properties of pine and poplar comminuted shavings and particleboards in the raw state and after 17 weeks of pretreatment with Pleurotus ostreatus; MC, moisture content; xg, the geometric mean of particle size; δ, angle of external friction for wood comminuted material-chrome steel; σ1, major consolidating stress; σc, unconfined yield strength; ffc, flow index; τ, shear stress; c, cohesion; φe, the effective angle of internal friction; φc, angle of internal friction for determined flowability; φlin, linearised angle of internal friction; HHV, higher heating value; CF, crude fibre; NDF, neutral detergent fibre; ADF, acid detergent fibre; ADL, acid detergent lignin
Parameter
|
Pine
|
Poplar
|
shavings
|
particleboard
|
shavings
|
particleboard
|
raw
|
treated
|
raw
|
treated
|
raw
|
treated
|
raw
|
treated
|
xg, mm
|
0.61b* ± 0.01
|
0.42a ± 0.02
|
0.42a ± 0.02
|
0.42a ± 0.01
|
0.51b ± 0.03
|
0.44a ± 0.01
|
0.43b ± 0.01
|
0.40a ± 0.03
|
MC, %
|
5.80a ± 0.06
|
6.60b ± 0.05
|
5.11a ± 0.04
|
6.73b ± 0.01
|
5.57a ± 0.07
|
5.65b ± 0.03
|
5.31a ± 0.08
|
6.60b ± 0.03
|
δ, °
|
|
|
30.5a ± 2.5
|
34.6b ± 0.9
|
|
|
30.5a ± 2.5
|
32.4b ± 2.0
|
σ1, kPa
|
|
|
123.2a ± 2.5
|
161.6b ± 12.2
|
|
|
117.5a ± 20.7
|
141.7b ± 11.3
|
σc, kPa
|
|
|
33.7a ± 3.9
|
48.7 b± 7.3
|
|
|
42.1a ± 9.5
|
64.4b ± 13.8
|
ffc, –
|
|
|
3.70a ± 0.46
|
3.39a ± 0.62
|
|
|
2.99a ± 1.1
|
2.31a ± 0.68
|
τ, kPa
|
|
|
34.8a ± 0.4
|
46.1b ± 1.6
|
|
|
34.9a ± 0.7
|
44.4 b± 1.2
|
c, kPa
|
|
|
9.25a ± 1.25
|
11.19a ± 2.39
|
|
|
12.74a ± 4.38
|
17.57a ± 5.44
|
φe, °
|
|
|
37.3a ± 0.1
|
45.4b ± 1.2
|
|
|
35.9a ± 3.2
|
42.9b ± 1.2
|
φc, °
|
|
|
23.1a ± 1.5
|
29.9 b± 3.0
|
|
|
20.0a ± 5.4
|
23.9a ± 3.5
|
φlin, °
|
|
|
32.5a ± 1.0
|
41.0b ± 3.1
|
|
|
28.7a ± 5.6
|
33.7a ± 5.0
|
HHV, MJ·kg–1
|
18.37b ± 0.18
|
17.50a ± 0.50
|
18.72b ± 0.07
|
17.23a ± 0.27
|
17.74a ± 0.29
|
16.89a ± 1.05
|
17.61b ± 0.39
|
16.65a ± 0.41
|
CF, %
|
75.8b ± 0.4
|
65.9a ± 0.6
|
68.2b ± 0.7
|
52.3a ± 0.5
|
67.7b ± 0.4
|
64.2a ± 0.7
|
63.5b ± 0.7
|
48.0a ± 1.7
|
NDF, %
|
93.6b ± 0.9
|
85.0a ± 0.7
|
88.4b ± 0.4
|
75.1a ± 0.6
|
93.9b ± 1.0
|
91.1a ± 1.5
|
91.5b ± 0.9
|
81.9a ± 1.0
|
ADF, %
|
81.5b ± 0.3
|
78.5a ± 0.2
|
71.7b ± 0.7
|
66.4a ± 0.7
|
78.7b ± 0.7
|
77.0a ± 0.5
|
72.5b ± 0.7
|
64.3a ± 0.2
|
ADL, %
|
37.8b ± 1.8
|
30.6a ± 1.7
|
38.4b ± 2.1
|
31.6a ± 2.2
|
26.7b ± 1.8
|
21.3a ± 2.1
|
24.9b ± 1.2
|
16.6a ± 1.3
|
Cellulose, %
|
43.7a ± 1.8
|
47.9 b± 1.7
|
33.3a ± 2.6
|
34.8a ± 2.5
|
52.0a ± 1.9
|
55.7b ± 2.5
|
47.6a ± 1.9
|
47.7a ± 1.3
|
Hemicellulose, %
|
12.1b ± 0.7
|
6.5a ± 0.6
|
16.7b ± 1.0
|
8.7a ± 1.3
|
15.2a ± 1.6
|
14.2a ± 1.9
|
18.9a ± 1.6
|
17.6a ± 0.9
|
Lignin, %
|
37.8b ± 1.8
|
30.6a ± 1.7
|
38.4b ± 2.1
|
31.6a ± 2.2
|
26.7b ± 1.8
|
21.3a ± 2.1
|
24.9b ± 1.2
|
16.6a ± 1.3
|
* Values in each row between raw and treated material with the different letters are statistically significant at p < 0.05.
The angle δ for both pine and poplar raw particleboards was consistently 30.5°, but after fungal pretreatment, it increased by almost 4° and by 2°, respectively. All three types of internal friction angles (φe, φc, and φlin) were higher for the comminuted pine particleboard compared to the poplar one, and their increase post-treatment was statistically significant (for poplar: φc and φlin close to significant). Following fungal pretreatment, a more substantial increase in stresses σ1 was observed in pine particleboard, by 31%, than in poplar one, by 21%. Similarly, stresses τ increased by 32% and 27%, respectively, which was also statistically significant. The impact of pretreatment on the cohesion of the materials was less pronounced, with increases of 21% and 38% for the respective species, with a broad scatter of values rendering these differences not statistically significant. The flow coefficient decreased post-treatment by 8.4% for pine particleboard and 22.7% for poplar particleboard, indicating that the poplar particleboard experienced a more significant reduction of this coefficient than pine. The enhancement in mechanical parameters, particularly friction angles (δ, and φ), c, and τ and σ1 stresses following fungal pretreatment, suggests a potential influence on pressure agglomeration processes, potentially facilitating the production of more strength pastilles. Fungal pretreatment enhances the cohesion between material particles, as corroborated by the literature (Ballen Sierra et al. 2023).
The HHV for pine and poplar wood decreased after fungal pretreatment by almost 1 MJ·kg–1, with the reduction being more pronounced for pine. Notably, the HHV of raw pine particleboards containing UF was initially the highest at 18.72 MJ·kg–1, but after pretreatment, it dropped to 17.23 MJ·kg–1, representing an 8% decrease. These reductions are primarily attributed to lignin degradation and other fibrous compounds. Evidence of the interdependencies among the analysed parameters was provided by partial correlations between HHV and CF, NDF, ADF, and ADL, which were 0.876, 0.579, 0.709, and 0.818, respectively, indicating a strong correlation of HHVs with the structural components of the biomass. What is more, supported by the statement that lignin's lower heating value (related to HHV) was 23–27 MJ·kg–1, compared to 19 MJ·kg–1 of cellulose and hemicellulose, as detailed in the form of a regression equation (Demirbas 2004). Interestingly, a more significant decrease in HHV was observed for particleboards than for shavings alone, suggesting that the fungus could degrade the UF present in the boards.
Fungal pretreatment caused a statistically significant increase in the material MC, notably in particleboards, where the MC rose from 5.2–6.6% on average. Comparable changes were observed across both wood species. Pine shavings exhibited an increased MC from an initial 5.8–6.6%, while poplar shavings maintained a similar level at 5.6%. This noticeable rise in MC for pine and poplar post-treatment demonstrates that fungal pretreatment can effectively enhance the material's water absorption capacity. This aligns with findings from research (Wenny Surya Murtius et al. 2024). The oyster mushroom, recognised for its ability to degrade lignin and partially hemicellulose, along with other wood components, alters the cellular structure of the material (Badu et al. 2011), thereby increasing its porosity (Kumar et al. 2021), which in turn facilitates moisture absorption (Banik et al. 2017).
The differences observed in MC between pine and poplar and between wood and particleboard materials may stem from the distinct properties of these materials. Pine and particleboard materials seem more susceptible to fungal pretreatment, particularly in lignin degradation, which can lead to notable changes in water absorption. The dynamics of moisture absorption may also relate to the wood's inherent structure and chemical composition, and fungal decay may have a relatively more substantial influence on pine. Assuming that UF acts as a hydrophobic agent, it restricts moisture absorption from the air, explaining the lower MC in comminuted raw particleboards with UF (5.2%) compared to wood shavings (5.6%). The impact of fungal pretreatment on MC was more pronounced in UF-bonded particleboards than in shavings alone, suggesting that the Pleurotus ostreatus had to overcome the UF barrier, likely resulting in resin degradation. Changes in MC aligned with alterations in CF, NDF, ADF, and ADL content, as evidenced by Pearson correlation coefficients of − 0.971, − 0.927, − 0.903, and − 0.510, respectively. Since lignocellulosic compounds are connected with fibre content, some correlations were observed. Interestingly, a strong correlation existed between NDF and hemicelluloses (r = 0.857). It is worth mentioning that NDF is equivalent to the content of all wood structural components together, not sole hemicelluloses. Lignin content was directly linked to ADL but positively correlated with CF (r = 0.679). Following Pleurotus ostreatus pretreatment, ADL content decreased significantly, beneficially increasing cellulose content, indicated by a negative correlation coefficient between these variables (r = − 0.906). Statistically significant correlations were observed in most pairs of parameters, except between NDF and ADF associated with ADL. The more porous structures, capable of absorbing increased moisture, concurrently reduced the concentration of TS, leading to lower CF, NDF, ADF, and ADL values. The ADL content in pine materials was consistent between raw shavings and particleboards at 37.8% and 38.4%, respectively, and for treated materials at 30.6% and 31.6%. For poplar materials, ADL content was notably lower than in pine ones, with absolute differences of 11.1% for raw shavings, 9.3% for treated shavings, 13.5% for raw particleboards, and 15.0% for treated particleboards. The reduction in ADL content after fungal pretreatment confirmed its effectiveness in degrading lignin and was consistent across raw-treated material pairs, showing a more beneficial effect on particleboards of both wood species. The decreases in NDF and ADF content suggest partial degradation of holocellulose polymers, potentially advantageous for fermentation processes, as highlighted in the literature (Wan and Li 2012). The influence of fungal pretreatment was more substantial on changes in NDF (hemicellulose, cellulose, lignin) content than ADF (cellulose, lignin). It was more significant for particleboards than shavings and pine than poplar.
3.2. Pressure agglomeration of biomass and pastille strength
Fungal pretreatment and the choice of wood species significantly influenced many parameters describing the pressure agglomeration of particleboard materials in pastille formation. Variables such as pastille density (ρa), pastille ejection pressure (pu), specific work of ejection (Lv), and the diameter (dm) significantly shaped the physical properties of the agglomerates (Table 3). However, the effects of wood species on compaction work (Ls) and the impacts of fungal pretreatment on linear agglomerate expansion (Rl) and piston displacement during pastille ejection (su) were not statistically significant.
Table 3
Results of the analysis of variance and mean values with SD for specific compaction work (Ls), degree of compaction (Is), compaction susceptibility coefficient (ks), agglomerate (pastille) expansion index concerning its length (Rl) and diameter (Rd), maximum pressure to push the agglomerate out of the die opening (pu), specific work to push the agglomerate out of the die opening (Lv), piston displacement to push the agglomerate out of the die opening (su), single agglomerate density (ρa), concerning wood species (TW), material pretreatment (MT), and die opening diameter (dm)
Factor
|
Ls,
kJ·kg–1
|
Is,
–
|
ks,
J·m3·kg–2
|
Rl,
%
|
Rd,
%
|
pu,
MPa
|
Lv,
kJ·kg–1
|
su,
mm
|
ρa,
kg·m–3
|
TW
|
0.6175
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
0.0499
|
< 0.0001
|
dm
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
MT
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
0.3743
|
0.0450
|
0.0011
|
0.0048
|
0.1327
|
< 0.0001
|
Mean and ± SD for wood species (TW)
|
Pine
|
22.89a* ± 2.61
|
3.28a ± 0.46
|
363.3b ± 84.7
|
14.35b ± 7.01
|
3.94b ± 2.01
|
0.65b ± 0.31
|
0.038b ± 0.026
|
2.43b ± 1.05
|
1002.3b ± 40.8
|
Poplar
|
22.84a ± 3.16
|
3.96b ± 1.15
|
288.5a ± 96.0
|
11.80a ± 6.46
|
3.81a ± 1.98
|
0.29a ± 0.25
|
0.019a ± 0.021
|
2.23a ± 2.21
|
970.0a ± 52.1
|
Mean and ± SD for die opening diameter (dm, mm)
|
6
|
19.96a ± 1.55
|
3.64b ± 1.04
|
248.5a ± 68.7
|
16.57b ± 4.11
|
6.65c ± 0.33
|
0.59b ± 0.46
|
0.020a ± 0.018
|
1.43a ± 0.83
|
956.0a ± 64.3
|
8
|
22.89b ± 1.73
|
3.73c ± 0.90
|
368.2b ± 86.1
|
17.54b ± 4.65
|
2.65b ± 0.21
|
0.44a ± 0.22
|
0.049b ± 0.030
|
3.82c ± 1.87
|
1000.2b ± 31.3
|
10
|
25.75c ± 1.69
|
3.49a ± 0.87
|
361.1b ± 87.6
|
5.11a ± 2.54
|
2.33a ± 0.33
|
0.38a ± 0.25
|
0.016a ± 0.010
|
1.74b ± 1.22
|
1002.3b ± 29.7
|
Mean and ± SD for material pretreatment (MT)
|
Raw
|
21.70a ± 2.46
|
2.85a ± 0.22
|
389.8b ± 71.5
|
12.88a ± 7.40
|
3.84a ± 2.01
|
0.43a ± 0.36
|
0.026a ± 0.022
|
2.41a ± 1.24
|
958.5a ± 49.1
|
Treated
|
24.03b ± 2.83
|
4.39b ± 0.73
|
262.1a ± 76.7
|
13.27a ± 6.27
|
3.91b ± 1.98
|
0.52b ± 0.30
|
0.031b ± 0.028
|
2.26a ± 2.11
|
1013.8b ± 30.8
|
* Values between factor levels with different letters are statistically significant at p < 0.05.
Work (Ls), compaction susceptibility coefficient (ks), linear (Rl) and diametric expansion (Rd), pressure (pu), work (Lv), displacement (su), and density (ρa) were statistically higher for pine than poplar. It was observed that the harder pine shavings were more challenging to densify compared to the more plastic poplar shavings, underscoring the importance of the raw material’s physical properties on the agglomeration process. Efficient densification of the more robust pine wood required higher die heights than those for poplar wood (Monedero et al. 2015), indicating the significant role of wood mechanical properties in the pressure agglomeration process, potentially affecting the efficiency and costs of pastilles production.
In producing pastilles from the particleboard materials, the diameter dm played a crucial role in determining the work Lv and the physical characteristics of the resulting agglomerate. It was observed that increasing the dm from 6 mm to 8 mm significantly affected the required compaction work while producing higher-density pastilles. This increase in density was advantageous, as denser agglomerates from the same type of biomass typically exhibit better structural stability and are less prone to disintegration during transport and use. The comparison material doses were 0.2, 0.3, and 0.5 g for dm of 6, 8, and 10 mm. Under such conditions, the height of the compacted material sample was inversely proportional to the dm. Consequently, reducing the compaction height led to producing pastilles with a higher density, as layers with a reduced height (thickness) are more readily compacted. The mechanism of better compaction of a thinner material layer stems from the reduced effect of the material's elasticity compared to a thicker layer. The comminuted shavings and particleboards were more easily rearranged, filling voids and displacing air between particles, and then overcoming elasticity, they underwent plastic deformation under the sudden increase in the compaction pressure gradient, resulting in the need for more significant work Ls. During compaction, feedback from the bottom of the die increased the transverse pressure from the deformation, which was proportional to the axial pressure (Miao et al. 2015).
Pastilles expansion, or the ability to return to their original shape after the load has been removed, tended to be inversely proportional to the dm. This implies that more minor dm led to more significant expansion, which may be undesirable for maintaining the cohesion of the agglomerates. Conversely, susceptibility ks, or the ease with which the material compresses, was proportional to the die orifice diameter, suggesting that larger holes facilitate compaction while reducing the required pressures. Pastille expansion was linked to the compaction mechanism and the plastic deformation of particles, which is more favourable for those compacted in thinner layers. Thus, particles plastically bound by mechanical bridges in larger-diameter pastilles underwent less expansion.
Fungal pretreatment increased the work Ls required to produce pastilles from 21.70 kJ·kg–1 to 24.03 kJ·kg–1, and the results show that this additional energy contributed to the production of pastilles with a significantly higher density ρa, 1014 kg·m–3 instead of 959 kg·m–3 (by 5.8%). The pretreated material was more susceptible to compaction than the raw material, as it required less work to achieve a change in density ρa, with susceptibility ks values of 262 J·m3·kg–2 and 390 J·m·kg–2, respectively. Pastilles' Rd and Rl expansion were slightly more significant for pretreated materials, indicating subtle differences in their physical properties resulting from the fungal pretreatment process. However, the Rl change was not statistically significant.
For comparison, the work Ls for noncomminuted pine shavings was higher at 42.7 kJ·kg–1, and the density ρa was lower at 994 kg·m–3, while for poplar shavings, these values were 32.7 kJ·kg–1 and 978 kg·m–3, respectively (unpublished authors' data). This is because, at the exact dosage, larger shavings were characterised by higher material elasticity and more significant shape deformations. Shape deformations cause proportional lateral pressures, increasing friction on the agglomerate's lateral surface and the die opening. Since the comminuted biomass after biological pretreatment exhibited higher angles δ and φ and more extensive c, along with a lower flow index than the raw material (Table 2), overcoming these higher resistances and performing more work Ls was necessary. These phenomena were also observed during the production of feed pellets (Hejft 2002).
Differences in pressure agglomeration parameters can be attributed to changes in the fibre content of the biomass. The degradation of fibres by the fungus affected the structure of lignocellulosic compounds, facilitating the formation of pastilles with greater efficiency and density. Correlations between the work Ls and fibre content, such as CF and ADF, alongside density ρa and NDF and ADF, suggest a relationship between the physicochemical properties of the materials during the agglomeration process.
Pastilles made of raw and fungal pretreated materials and subjected to radial and axial compressive loading exhibited varying values of modulus of elasticity (E), specific energy of compression until the agglomerate cracks (Ej) and maximum tensile strength during pastille cracking (σp). The modulus E was not statistically significantly affected by the diameter dm (p = 0.8057, Table 4). Generally, pastilles with higher strength σp exhibited a lower modulus E. Axially loaded pastilles displayed strengths σp an order of magnitude greater than those loaded radially, with noticeable differences in the impact of various factors on strength parameter values. Given that pastilles show lower resistance to radial than axial loads, radial pressures are more significant when handling these products; thus, the interpretation of results will focus on this aspect. Pastilles made from pine particleboard demonstrated more resistance to radial compressive deformation compared to those made from poplar particleboards, with strengths σp of 2.14 MPa and 0.32 MPa, respectively, and energies Ej of 1.07 mJ·mm² and 0.18 mJ·mm², respectively.
The strength parameters of the pastilles during radial compression decreased significantly with increasing diameter dm, while the modulus E tended to increase, although without statistically significant differences. Although the density ρa and work Ls corresponded with the diameter dm, the pastilles' resistance to radial compressive loads was inversely proportional to this dm. Larger diameter pastilles deformed more easily, requiring less energy, and generated lower maximum stresses until the pastilles cracked. This could be attributed to the lower homogeneity of the material compacted in larger diameter dm, as the effect of friction δ between the material and the hole surface increased radially from the axis, locally weakening the internal structure of the pastilles.
Table 4
Results of analysis of variance, mean values, and SD for pastilles modulus of elasticity (E), specific agglomerate deformation energy (Ej), and maximum tensile strength during agglomerate (pastille) cracking (σp), considering wood species (TW), material pretreatment (MT), type of agglomerate load (TL), and die opening diameter (dm) for raw and fungal pretreated particleboards
Factor
|
E, MPa
|
Ej, mJ·mm–2
|
σp, MPa
|
Radial compression – all agglomerates
|
TW
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
TL
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
dm
|
0.8057
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
MT
|
0.0160
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
Mean and ± SD for wood species (TW)
|
Pine
|
22.38b* ± 19.52
|
55.99a ± 63.17
|
45.60a ± 46.15
|
Poplar
|
8.49a ± 6.20
|
65.31b ± 71.94
|
50.22b ± 51.47
|
Mean and ± SD for type of agglomerate load (TL)
|
RC
|
24.65b ± 18.42
|
0.62a ± 0.66
|
1.23a ± 1.31
|
AC
|
6.21a ± 2.48
|
121.29b ± 43.74
|
94.90b ± 19.64
|
Mean and ± SD for die opening diameter (dm, mm)
|
6
|
15.57a ± 14.22
|
35.88a ± 37.26
|
40.43a ± 41.03
|
8
|
15.73a ± 17.41
|
69.47b ± 72.59
|
52.57c ± 53.25
|
10
|
15.01a ± 16.52
|
76.61c ± 79.10
|
50.72b ± 51.09
|
Mean and ± SD for material pretreatment (MT)
|
Raw
|
16.57b ± 16.64
|
51.61a ± 57.40
|
40.45a ± 41.27
|
Treated
|
14.29a ± 15.41
|
69.70b ± 75.83
|
55.36b ± 54.54
|
Axial compression (AC) – pastille
|
TW
|
0,9999
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
dm
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
MT
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
Mean and ± SD for wood species (TW)
|
Pine
|
6.22a ± 2.47
|
110.9a ± 43.7
|
89.0a ± 21.3
|
Poplar
|
6.22a ± 2.50
|
130.5b ± 42.5
|
100.1b ± 16.7
|
Mean and ± SD for die opening diameter (dm, mm)
|
6
|
9.15c ± 1.90
|
71.0a ± 16.6
|
79.5a ± 16.8
|
8
|
5.43b ± 0.74
|
138.3b ± 30.7
|
103.9c ± 18.3
|
10
|
4.09a ± 0.67
|
152.7c ± 28.4
|
100.4b ± 15.1
|
Mean and ± SD for material pretreatment (MT)
|
Raw
|
5.69a ± 1.90
|
102.8a ± 36.2
|
80.2a ± 15.1
|
Treated
|
6.74b ± 2.86
|
138.6b ± 44.2
|
109.0b ± 12.1
|
Radial compression (RC) – pastille
|
TW
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
dm
|
0.1365
|
0.0040
|
< 0.0001
|
MT
|
0.0034
|
< 0.0001
|
< 0.0001
|
Mean and ± SD for wood species (TW)
|
Pine
|
38.5b ± 15.2
|
1.07b ± 0.67
|
2.14b ± 1.31
|
Poplar
|
10.8a ± 7.8
|
0.18a ± 0.14
|
0.32a ± 0.22
|
Mean and ± SD for die opening diameter (dm, mm)
|
6
|
22.0a ± 17.9
|
0.72b ± 0.82
|
1.40c ± 1.57
|
8
|
26.0a ± 19.9
|
0.60ab ± 0.59
|
1.24b ± 1.30
|
10
|
25.9a ± 17.5
|
0.54a ± 0.51
|
1.06a ± 1.00
|
Mean and ± SD for material pretreatment (MT)
|
Raw
|
27.5b ± 17.7
|
0.40a ± 0.13
|
0.74a ± 0.25
|
Treated
|
21.8a ± 18.8
|
0.84b ± 0.87
|
1.73b ± 1.70
|
* Values between factor levels with different letters are statistically significant at p < 0.05.
Pastilles from fungal pretreated materials exhibited more than double the strength σp and energy Ej. They displayed lower modulus E values than those made from raw materials. The modulus E did not show clear consistency with the values of fibrous structure CF, NDF, ADF, and ADL, nor with hemicellulose, cellulose, and lignin, highlighting the complex influence of material chemical composition on the elasticity of the pastilles. Interestingly, a significant correlation was observed between the energy Ej and strength σp and the fibre content. The highest values of strength σp correlation coefficients were noted for CF, NDF, and ADL at 0.956, − 0.944, and 0.881, respectively, suggesting that lignin content significantly affects the mechanical strength of the pastilles. Higher lignin content was associated with increased strength, likely owing to its natural binding and material stiffening properties. Furthermore, the pastilles strength increased inversely with cellulose content, while hemicellulose had no significant impact on Ej and σp.
In conclusion, these results verify that biological pretreatment with Pleurotus ostreatus can beneficially influence the physicochemical properties of particleboard materials, enhancing its density and efficiency in the pressure agglomeration process, which has implications for solid biofuels and the composites industry. The research findings substantiate the hypothesis that biological pretreatment improves pressure agglomeration properties and opens new avenues for further experiments.
3.3. Anaerobic fermentation, methane yield, and biogas composition
The comminuted materials exhibited very high values of TS (94.08% ± 0.64%) and VS (99.23% ± 0.20%), theoretically suggesting a favourable biogas yield. Comparing raw materials, these values were higher for particleboards than wood shavings. After fungal pretreatment, there was a statistically significant reduction, particularly noticeable in particleboards. This indicates that the fungus more extensively decomposed the UF-containing particleboards than the shavings without UF. For pretreated pine shavings, both TS and VS decreased significantly, from 94.20–93.40% and from 99.49–99.03%, respectively (Table 5), demonstrating the effectiveness of the fungal degradation process.
According to the findings (Kupryś-Caruk et al. 2023), the inoculum had a low TS content of 2.12% but a high ash content of 37.45% in TS, resulting in a relatively low VS content of 62.55%. Consequently, after blending approximately 13 g of materials with the inoculum, the contents of TSme and VSme in the blends were consistent, at 2.77% ± 0.01% and 71.29% ± 0.05%, respectively. However, in the blends with materials after biological pretreatment, TSme and VSme contents were lower than with raw materials, indicating decomposition by the fungus. After anaerobic fermentation, the contents of TSmf and VSmf in the blends decreased significantly to 2.13% ± 0.10% and 58.07% ± 1.06%, respectively, reflecting relative reductions of 23% and 19%. The decreases of TSmf in blends with pretreated materials were smaller than those with raw ones. In contrast, the cutbacks in VSmf were more significant, evidencing effective bioconversion of the treated organic matter (Karthikeyan et al. 2024) by specialised microorganisms during anaerobic fermentation (Chojnacka and Moustakas 2024). This suggests the transformation of biomass components during fungal pretreatment into more volatile (Piątek et al. 2016) and readily degradable forms (Wainaina et al. 2019), advantageous for anaerobic fermentation. This was facilitated by changes in the physicochemical properties of the materials by Pleurotus ostreatus, significantly reducing lignin content (Fig. 2), a significant barrier in biomass degradation and fermentation processes. Selective lignin degradation increased cellulose accessibility to enzymes that decompose organic matter. At the same time, hemicellulose reduction may have enhanced the porosity and water absorption of the material (Manyi-Loh and Lues 2023), supporting fermentation processes. These changes in the lignocellulosic structure enhanced the biogas production potential of the processed materials.
Table 5
Parameters (mean values and ± SD) of physicochemical properties of pine and poplar comminuted shavings and particleboards, raw and after 17 weeks of pretreatment with Pleurotus ostreatus and results of tests of yield biogas and its composition; TS, TSme, TSmf, total solids in the comminuted material, the blends of comminuted material and inoculum before and after fermentation; VS, VSme, VSmf, volatile solid in the comminuted material, the blend of comminuted material and inoculum before and after fermentation; Y, YCH4, yield in terms of volatile solid, biogas and methane, respectively; CCH4(CO2, O2, H2), concentration of methane, carbon dioxide, oxygen and hydrogen, in biogas, respectively
Parameter
|
Pine
|
Poplar
|
shavings
|
particleboard
|
shavings
|
particleboard
|
raw
|
treated
|
raw
|
treated
|
raw
|
treated
|
raw
|
treated
|
TS, %
|
94.20a* ± 0.07
|
93.40b ± 0.06
|
94.89a ± 0.05
|
93.27b ± 0.01
|
94.43a ± 0.08
|
94.35a ± 0.03
|
94.69a ± 0.09
|
93.40b ± 0.03
|
VS, %
|
99.49b ± 0.02
|
99.03a ± 0.06
|
99.36a ± 0.01
|
98.91b ± 0.01
|
99.32a ± 0.01
|
99.30a ± 0.04
|
99.38b ± 0.08
|
99.07a ± 0.02
|
TSme, %
|
2.78a ± 0.01
|
2.78a ± 0.01
|
2.78a ± 0.01
|
2.78a ± 0.01
|
2.70a ± 0.11
|
2.78a ± 0.01
|
2.76a ± 0.04
|
2.78a ± 0.01
|
VSme, %
|
71.36b ± 0.01
|
71.24a ± 0.01
|
71.32b ± 0.01
|
71.22a ± 0.01
|
71.32a ± 0.01
|
71.31a ± 0.01
|
71.32b ± 0.02
|
71.25a ± 0.01
|
TSmf, %
|
2.13a ± 0.19
|
2.16a ± 0.07
|
2.00a ± 0.31
|
2.09a ± 0.06
|
1.98a ± 0.01
|
2.13b ± 0.06
|
2.22a ± 0.14
|
2.28a ± 0.02
|
VSmf, %
|
58.1a ± 0.2
|
57.8a ± 0.1
|
58.4b ± 0.1
|
57.3a ± 0.1
|
57.1a ± 0.3
|
56.8a ± 0.6
|
60.0b ± 0.1
|
58.9a ± 0.1
|
Y, ml·g–1
|
59.0a ± 6.1
|
194.9b ± 3.9
|
46.8a ± 3.0
|
184.7b ± 3.1
|
218.1a ± 4.2
|
295.4b ± 4.1
|
119.7a ± 4.8
|
380b ± 1.5
|
YCH4, ml·g–1
|
34.3a ± 5.2
|
108.3b ± 3.1
|
29.3a ± 1.4
|
109.1b ± 2.0
|
138.8a ± 6.6
|
169.3b ± 1.2
|
71.0a ± 5.0
|
206.7b ± 1.5
|
CCH4, %
|
66.6b ± 0.4
|
64.9a ± 0.9
|
69.8b ± 0.3
|
64.4a ± 1.8
|
65.0b ± 0.1
|
62.8a ± 0.1
|
64.3b ± 0.2
|
62.2a ± 0.4
|
CCO2, %
|
26.3a ± 0.5
|
29.4b ± 1.3
|
21.7a ± 0.4
|
28.5b ± 1.4
|
28.3a ± 0.2
|
31.5b ± 0.1
|
28.9a ± 0.2
|
31.7b ± 0.2
|
CO2, %
|
0.87a ± 0.18
|
0.82a ± 0.18
|
0.95a ± 0.05
|
1.36a ± 0.65
|
0.90a ± 0.17
|
0.69a ± 0.04
|
0.97a ± 0.18
|
1.04a ± 0.13
|
CH2, %
|
6.23b ± 0.34
|
4.92a ± 1.24
|
7.52b ± 0.05
|
5.74a ± 0.2
|
5.78b ± 0.07
|
4.98a ± 0.03
|
5.78b ± 0.11
|
5.04a ± 0.03
|
* Values in each row between raw and treated material with the different letters are statistically significant at p < 0.05.
The biogas yield of 711 ml·g–1 VS from microcrystalline cellulose fell within the acceptable range of 745 ml·g–1 VS ± 10% per the VDI 4630 standard. The maximum biogas yield was substantially higher from materials subjected to fungal pretreatment than raw materials (Table 5), indicating that Pleurotus ostreatus effectively modified substrates, enhancing substrates’ availability for fermentative microorganisms. Additionally, degradation of UF resin during fungal pretreatment cannot be excluded. Although the methane content in biogas was inversely proportional to the biogas yield (r = − 0.801), the methane and biogas yields were in accordance (r = 0.998). The dynamics of the cumulative methane yield (Fig. 3) mirrored that of the biogas. The highest rate, achieved on the fourth day of anaerobic fermentation and sustained the longest (until day 26) with a methane production efficiency of 207 ml·g–1 VS, was characteristic of pretreated poplar particleboards with UF. Compared to raw particleboards at 71 ml·g–1, this was a 2.9-fold increase. In contrast, the smallest increase (1.2-fold) was observed for poplar shavings, though the methane yields were relatively the highest in the raw state and after pretreatment, at 139 ml·g–1 VS and 169 ml·g–1 VS, respectively. The most significant increase (3.7-fold) occurred for pine particleboards, but the methane yields for raw and pretreated states were much lower, at 29 ml·g–1 VS and 109 ml·g–1 VS, respectively. These yields were comparable to those for pine shavings, at 34 ml·g–1 and 108 ml·g–1 VS, respectively, representing a 3.2-fold increase.
In general, methane yields were higher from poplar than from pine materials. However, the effect of Pleurotus ostreatus pretreatment was more pronounced on pine than on poplar shavings and particleboards compared to raw materials of both wood species. The higher methane yields from poplar materials can be attributed to their significantly lower lignin content than pine, at 26.7% vs. 37.8% for shavings and 24.9% vs. 38.4% for particleboards, respectively (Table 2). After biological pretreatment, the absolute decrease in lignin content was 5.4% and 7.3% for pine and 8.3% and 6.8% for poplar, respectively. The relative decreases were similar, with average reductions in lignin content slightly higher in pine materials at 7.03%, compared to 6.86% in poplar materials. The correlation coefficient between methane yield and lignin content was negative, at − 0.848. The effect of this material pretreatment was more significant than rice straw with P. ostreatus, which reduced lignin content by 3.3% (Datsomor et al. 2022). In the study with four Pleurotus spp. fungi (P. diamor, P. eryngii, P. sajor-caju, P. citrinopileatus) on corn stover, lignin content was reduced by 1.85–3.32% (Wang et al. 2021). Two AA14 members of the LPMO from the white rot fungus Pycnoporus coccineus were found to significantly enhance wood saccharification efficiency by oxidatively cleaving highly resistant xylan-coated cellulosic fibres (Couturier et al. 2018). Small secreted proteins, together with lignocellulose-degrading enzymes, were elucidated to be integral components of the secretome and were hypothesised to also play a role in saprophytes and function in P. ostreatus as components of the ligninolytic system (Feldman et al. 2017). Converting lignocellulosic biomass to biofuels requires a critical pretreatment process to break down the recalcitrant lignin structure. For this purpose, several known ligninolytic enzyme assays were conducted, and the activity of lignin peroxidase, laccase, dye-decolorising peroxidase, and aryl-alcohol oxidase on the decomposition of an empty cluster of oil palm fruit was detected, confirming their ability to degrade lignin (Riyadi et al. 2020). No results were found on the treatment of UF-bonded wood.
The biogas’ methane, carbon dioxide, and hydrogen concentrations closely correlated with lignin content with correlation coefficients of 0.892, − 0.916, and 0.912, respectively. The inverse correlation of these biogas components was with cellulose, while hemicellulose showed no consistency with these components. The oxygen content in the biogas was below one percent (except for PIBT, which showed slightly more significant variability), and no correlation with lignocellulosic compounds or the effect of biological pretreatment was found. After pretreatment with Pleurotus ostreatus, the proportions of methane and hydrogen in the biogas decreased, while that of carbon dioxide increased significantly. This suggests that the quality of biogas slightly deteriorated after fungal pretreatment, as indicated by the negative correlation coefficient between methane content in biogas and material pretreatment method (r = − 0.641), but generally, the quality of the biogas, characterised by a high methane content of 62–70% and low carbon dioxide levels (around 30%), was excellent, with hydrogen typically comprising 5–6%. No hydrogen sulphide was detected in the biogas, except in isolated instances during the first five days of anaerobic fermentation and the process with raw poplar shavings between the 10th and 22nd days, at a gas meter detection limit, i.e., 10 ppm.
In summary, the results confirmed the hypothesis that biological pretreatment with Pleurotus ostreatus altered the physicochemical properties of materials, particularly particleboards, positively affecting anaerobic fermentation processes. Reducing lignin and hemicellulose content increased biogas yield, with significant implications for future industrial applications.