Restoration of lost marsh platforms can include de-novo construction using dredged sediments. Two restoration projects constructed with beneficial use material in 2004 and 2015 were planted with native vegetation in the anticipation they would function similarly to adjacent Juncus roemerianus (Black needlerush) dominated salt marshes. Planted J. roemerianus, however, failed to establish and exists sparsely in the restored marsh. To better understand potential sources of failure, this study assessed vascular plant diversity in Spring and Fall of 2017 through 2019 and demonstrated establishment of both planted and naturally recruited vegetation. The two constructed sites were found to have higher species richness and plant diversity (Shannon-Wiener H’, and Simpson’s D) than the natural reference marsh, in part due to the higher elevations of the two constructed sites. The plant diversity metrics indicated the two beneficial use restorations did not meet the species composition of the reference marsh. Further monitoring should be conducted to observe the species development over the long term with considerations given to the potential future marsh change.