The aim of this study was to determine the prevalence of SSC and study the clinical and hematological features of SSC in two groups of children with SCD. These groups are related to two different ancestries with the AI and African haplotypes of the sickle gene and live in the Eastern province of SA. The analysis revealed that SSC was common among SCD children, but the difference between the two groups was not significant. The clinical features of the episodes among the African haplotype–related children (SWs) were more severe than those among their peers with the AI haplotypes. Notably, children with Sβ thalassemia and those who had splenomegaly prior to the occurrence of SSC were more prone to develop SSC. There was no mortality in this study, reflecting increased awareness and successful parental education in addition to easy access and free medical services in SA.
Prevalence
The overall prevalence of SSC in the current study was 14.7% in SCD patients, in accordance with previous reports from different countries (1–35%)[4, 8, 13–15]. This figure is almost the same as that reported in a tertiary hospital(14.5%) in Riyadh (central region of SA) [16]. The patients’ ancestries were not specified in that study.
In the present study, the prevalence among Eastern children (with the AI haplotype) was 12.7%, which is in line with other reports from India where SCD patients genuinely carry the AI haplotype[17–19]. This figure is higher than that reported in an earlier study from the same Eastern Saudi Region (1.7%)[20]. However, in that study, the patients were younger than 4 years (in an area known to have SSC mainly in older children) [9, 21] and even in adulthood. Zakaria et al. reported a prevalence of 7.8% of SSC among adults (older than 17) in the same Eastern area[22].
The prevalence of 15.5% among SW children (with the African haplotypes) is greater than the 7% reported earlier by Hawsawi et al. in the Western region in 2001.[8] This could be explained by increased awareness and parents’ knowledge of disease complications over time, resulting in increased numbers of patients diagnosed with SSC. On the other hand, it is less common than what has recently been reported in SCD children by Basuni et al. (31%)[23] in the Western area, and Alsultan et al. (23%) in SCD patients at all ages in the SW region. The variability in prevalence in different regions could be attributed to the possible variation in genetic mutations and the environmental differences as the Eastern province is approximately 1500 km from these areas.
In concordance with other studies, our analysis revealed a significantly greater prevalence of SSC among SCD children with HBS/β-thalassemia genotype than among their peers with homozygous SS disease[4, 19, 24]. The reason for this is unknown, however, some authors have suggested that HBS/β-thalassemia patients may have maintained some of the splenic function necessary for sequestration to occur[4].
The SSC relapse rate in our patients was high (78%) which is in accordance with other studies [4, 15]. In contrast, in older studies the recurrence rate was only 49–50%[8, 25]. This difference was hypothesized to be due to increased rates of survival after the first SSC and increased numbers of diagnosed patients[15]. The risk factors for SSC recurrences have not yet been established. In our statistical analysis, the only factor significantly associated with recurrence was steady-state HB. Brousse et al. reported a lower risk when the first episode occurred after 2 years of age[15]. In another study, a baseline splenic size ≥ 3 cm and the age of the 1st SSC between 2 and 5 years were predictive, whereas HBS > 72% at the time of diagnosis of SCD, vaso-occlusive crisis (VOC) as a revealing sign of SCD and neutrophil count ≥ 5400 / mm3 at the time of diagnosis were associated with a lower risk of recurrence[4].
Features of the 1 st SSC
Studies have shown that the clinical features of SCD are relatively mild in places where the AI haplotype is predominant, namely India and Eastern SA. The exact reason for this is not fully understood. This may be due to higher levels of HBF and the co-inheritance of alpha thalassemia[26]. Information about SSC in these places is scarce.
Studies on SSC in the Eastern, Western and SW regions of SA, where SCD is most prevalent, are scarce, with limited details[8, 9, 21, 27]. Our study suggested that the 1st splenic sequestrations were severe among SW children (African haplotype group). They occurred at a young age with a low steady-state HB which decreased to lower levels and in three occasions were accompanied by circulatory collapse. In addition, they recurred more frequently. Table (5) shows that these findings are comparable to the available data in previous studies on similar population but in their original provinces (Western and SW regions)[8]. They are also similar to episodes that occur in SCD patients of African origin in other countries, including Jamaica[5], Tunisia[4] and France[15].
Table (5) [Supplementary file]: Saudi studies showing SSC in SCD children with African haplotypes in the western and SW regions.
On the other hand, the study demonstrated milder attacks among Eastern children with the AI haplotype, which is in line with previous studies on similar populations in the Eastern region (Table 6)[9, 21]. SSC is considered an important SCD complication in India, and the details of its prevalence and natural history are lacking.[28]
Table (6) [Supplementary file]: Saudi studies showing SSC in SCD children with AI haplotypes in the Eastern Region.
A comparison of the 1st episode characteristics in this report supports our hypothesis that SSC is more severe among the SW children (African haplotype group) than among their Eastern peers (the AI haplotype group). Interestingly, the splenic enlargement characteristic of these episodes was more marked in the Eastern patients. The reason for this could be related to the characteristic late persistence of splenomegaly and possibly some splenic function in Eastern patients.[29]
These differences between the two groups could be explained by genetic and/or environmental factors affecting the sickling process. Both groups of children were living in the same environment in the Saudi Eastern province. They shared the climate (temperature, air quality, humidity, rainfall, and wind speed), altitude, exposure to infection, medical care, and socio-economic status (all of them are military personnel dependent). This finding supports the theory that SW children retain the severity of their African haplotype of the sickle gene despite living in an environment of mild SCD[10]. Additionally, the severity of their SSC is likely related to genetic rather than environmental factors as shown in the present study.
Splenomegaly
Splenomegaly in SCD is assumed to be caused by a moderate amount of stiff RBC entrapment, which results in limited splenic enlargement with minimal hematological alterations. Its prevalence varies according to genetic and environmental factors[30]. In areas where its prevalence is high (> 50%), it is considered a risk factor for the occurrence and recurrence of SSC[4, 14]. In our cohort, 84% of patients with SSC had splenomegaly before the first episode which was predictive for SSC in multivariate analysis.
The concentrated sickled RBCs are unable to pass through the small endothelial slits of the splenic venous sinuses and rejoin the intravascular system[30, 31]. This condition typically resolves spontaneously, but occasionally, the obstruction may spread, leading to rapid splenic filling with RBCs that cannot flow out. A large blood volume may become acutely retained within the spleen, leading to SSC[3]. The reason for this rapid spread of small occlusive events in the spleen rather than spontaneous resolution is still unknown. In the present study, there was no significant difference in the steady state splenic size between the two groups of patients. However, the rate of splenic enlargement increased more significantly during the 1st SSC in Eastern SA (AI haplotype group) than in their SW peers (African haplotype group). After stabilization and a reduction in the size of the spleen upon discharge from the hospital, a significant difference in the splenic size persisted.
Earlier studies have shown that patients in the Eastern region (with the AI haplotype) have a unique splenic characteristic of SCD as they have fibro-congestive pathology, rendering large spleens persist for longer periods[29]. It has been reported that a high level of HBF can be an important factor contributing to the persistence of splenomegaly and predisposing patients to SSC[4]. However, the higher HBF in Eastern children than in their SW peers was not statistically significant. The difference in splenic size appeared in this study only after the patients experienced the 1st SSC, which may have triggered this change in the spleen. Surgical splenectomy was performed in 50% of our patients. Splenectomy may be needed if SSCs are difficult to manage or if they recur[32]. The remaining patients either refused the operation or underwent auto-splenectomy.
Limitations of the study and future directions
There are several limitations to this study. The first is the retrospective nature of the study, with difficulty in obtaining all the precise important data. Second, this was a single-center study with a small number of patients, particularly Eastern children, which limits its generalizability. Third, there is a paucity of literature, particularly Saudi studies, on SSC. Fourth, other episodes may have been treated in other hospitals and were not included in this study. Further prospective multi-center studies in different regions of SA with more representative samples are needed to enhance our understanding of the natural history of SSC in children with SCD. This will be helpful in developing appropriate care models.