Decellularized ECM has been studied as a potential regenerative therapy for several decades 3,57–59. However, few studies have characterized the effects of brain decellularized ECM scaffold properties on neural lineage development, stem cell differentiation 35,43,48 or its therapeutic potential in neurological diseases such as stroke 60,61. In other words, the application of brain decellularized ECM for the regeneration of CNS tissue still holds several frontiers that need to be explored. In this study, we established an optimized protocol to produce brain decellularized ECM from three specific regions and evaluated their effect on neuronal maturation and recovery capacity in an in vitro model of brain ischemia.
The original total number of cells in a tissue that is targeted for decellularization is seldom reported. In addition, even less studies have considered the number of cells in different regions of a porcine brain 62. This initial information may be useful to determine the efficiency and quality of the decellularization process. In our case, using the isotropic fractionator technique, we were able to quantify the total number of cells per specific brain region (i.e., cortex, cerebellum, remaining areas) 63. Our data indicated that the cortex represented more than 65% of the mass of the brain, while the cerebellum accounted for just over 10%. Interestingly, the cerebellum contained close to 40% of all brain cells, despite representing the smallest section of the brain. Our results were in good agreement with previously published studies that have used the isotropic fractionator to characterize the brain cellular composition for several species, including the porcine (Sus scrofa domesticus) brain 62. Neuroanatomical studies have established that the cortex may possess 45% of the cell population, while the cerebellum accounts for up to 40% of the cellular presence with only 1/5 of the mass of the cerebral cortex. This relationship also seems to apply to the human brain and other species in the evolutionary ladder that show a similar pattern between the cortex and the cerebellum 62,64.
Our isotropic fractionator results correlate well with the values of DNA content measured in each brain section in a per-mg-dry-tissue basis, as well as in the quantification of histological sections after labeling with eosin/hematoxylin. Our decellularization protocol successfully eliminated most of the DNA content present in all three highly-cellularized studied brain regions, although none was under the threshold value of 50 ng/mg-dry-tissue, established as the gold standard for other tissues 65. Previous studies with porcine brain decellularized ECM have reached the threshold value 43,48, so our protocol could be tailored to be more aggressive or extended for a longer period to reach the before mentioned threshold. However, the risk is to further compromise the tissue’s integrity and bioactivity.
The cell density of the tissue of interest is an important consideration for decellularization purposes, since removing the cellular components from the decellularized ECM is important to minimize possible cytotoxicity or immunological rejection for the culture/host. Also, native tissue with a higher cell number/mg-tissue ratio may be prone to more considerable loss of tissue ultrastructure over the course of the decellularization process regardless of the aggressiveness of the protocol. We observed such behavior in the cerebellar tissue, the native tissue with the highest cell density compared to the cortex and the remaining areas. The cerebellum decellularized ECM presented the greatest protein and structural loss after decellularization. Thus, relative cell density of the native tissue may serve as an indirect predictor of biological performance, considering that one of the most important aspects of decellularization is the conservation of the tissue's structural and bioactive proteins at the end of the process 43.
Brain decellularized ECM scaffolds generated with our decellularization protocol maintained a high degree of morphological and ultrastructural integrity, as assessed by SEM and Coomassie Blue staining, despite losing significant amounts of proteins in general and specific neurotrophic factors evaluated by ELISA. NGF and BDNF serve as growth factors that promote the development and regeneration of CNS and support crucial neuronal processes including synaptic activity, neuronal growth, neuronal regeneration and plasticity 66. In the present study, we measured NGF and BDNF to determine if they were retained after the decellularization process. As expected, NGF, which is a well-known soluble neurotrophin reported to be involved in the constitutive pathway, the activity-dependent pathway, or in both 67, was mostly eliminated from all decellularized scaffolds in comparison to native tissues. In contrast, certain levels of BDNF were retained in all brain decellularized ECM scaffolds, and the decellularized cortex and remaining areas presented even higher levels of BDNF per mg of dry tissue than its native counterpart, which has been reported previously as a relative effect of the loss of cell-associated proteins and other less tightly-bound ECM components 43. For example, in cortical extracts BDNF has been found enriched in a vesicular fraction isolated from lysed synaptosomes 68, which could explain its stronger interaction with the ECM and its resilience to the detergents and other chemicals used during decellularization. As we only found higher BDNF retention in the cortex and remaining areas ECM, this may suggest a differential storage of BDNF depending on associated brain regions.
Also, the brain decellularized ECM scaffolds promoted high cell viability in PC12 cells and supported appropriate attachment of cortical primary cell cultures. In addition, the fact that brain decellularized ECM could elicit a morphological change indicative of PC12 stimulation and neuronal maturation confirms the presence of supportive proteins and neurotrophins, such as BDNF, that are known to modulate the behavior and differentiation in neural cell lineages 69. However, there may be other extracellular components that could be triggering the development and maturation of the PC12 cells that are worth exploring. If matched correctly, the biochemical composition and structural properties of brain decellularized ECM scaffolds may be able to induce differentiation into site-appropriate functional cells that can replace lost CNS tissue in cases of brain injury or neurodegenerative pathology 70.
The effects of region-specific brain decellularized ECM have not been tested in in vitro or in vivo as a recovery treatment in cerebral ischemia or hypoxia models. We established an OGD model with PC12 cells to analyze the cell recovery potential of soluble brain decellularized ECM and other control treatments, after the hypoxic insult (i.e., oxygen-glucose deprivation). Previous studies determined that an OGD model using 6 h of hypoxia falls in the category of cytotoxicity/apoptotic response, with more than 25% loss of PC12 cell viability measured by MTT assay 71 that could still be recovered 71,72, making it an ideal ischemia cell recovery model. All three region-specific brain decellularized ECM treatments had a considerable cell recovery effect, with the cerebellum decellularized ECM having the best response at 91.5% cell viability after 48 h, an increase of 36.4% compared to the vehicle group at the same timepoint. This response was similar to the positive control BDNF, which is a neural growth factor that can block caspase-3, a protein that is a major player in apoptosis 73, and has been detected in early stages of brain ischemia associated to neuroprotection in neuronal networks 74–76. After our decellularization process, all region-specific brain decellularized ECM still contained measurable levels of BDNF, which could explain the similar responses. However, the levels of other neurotrophins (e.g., NT-3, NT-4, CTNF) in the decellularized ECM were not measured and their role in the cell recovery results is still unknown.
Taken together, our results show that region-specific brain decellularized ECM can retain structural and biochemical cues that can promote neuronal maturation under normal in vitro conditions, and robust cell recovery after oxygen-glucose deprivation using the PC12 cell line. Indeed, in vitro models using cell lines can be very convenient and biologically useful; however, often they have characteristics that are different from primary cells, and the changes needed to immortalize cell lines can sometimes allow them to withstand harsher treatments that may not be viable for primary cells or in vivo applications 77. We have performed preliminary experiments to study the effects of region-specific brain decellularized brain ECM as a substrate on mixed primary cortical cultures, which are much more delicate to culture (Fig. 10). All experiments with animal to isolate primary cells were carried out under an approved protocol by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC) of the School of Medicine of the University of Miami, strictly complying with the ARRIVE guidelines. Our results showed that primary cells were able to adhere, grow and express classic neural biomarkers, such as the neuronal nuclear antigen (NeuN+) and glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP+), over the course of 7 days. Primary cells on the control substrate (PLL) exhibited a homogeneous coverage of the coverslip surface, with the presence of neurons and glial cell well distributed throughout the surface (Fig. 10A). Attachment to the decellularized ECM-coated coverslips was also well-distributed; however, NeuN+ expression seemed to be concentrated in certain clusters of cells throughout the surface (Fig. 10B-D), which may better represent the natural organization of the cells in brain.