This nationwide study provides a comprehensive overview of cancer screening participation, offering valuable insights into the prevalence and determinants of screening for breast, cervical, colorectal, and prostate cancers. Our findings reveal significant variations in screening rates among different cancer types and highlight the influence of socio-demographic factors, health insurance coverage, and comorbidities on screening participation. For breast cancer, factors such as possession of complementary health insurance, high cholesterol levels, and hypertension were significantly associated with increased screening participation. Notably, prevalence of screening was higher in obese individuals compared to individuals with normal weight. In cervical cancer screening, urban residency, possession of basic and complementary health insurance, history of lung disease, high cholesterol levels, alcohol consumption, and HPV vaccination were positively associated with screening participation. Interestingly, hypertension was associated with lower odds of screening participation in this group. In colorectal cancer screening, rural residency was linked to higher screening participation among both males and females. Possession of complementary health insurance, high cholesterol levels, and hypertension were significant predictors of increased screening participation. Additionally, prior cancer diagnosis and cardiovascular disease were associated with higher screening rates among males. In prostate cancer screening, factors significantly associated with increased screening participation included possession of basic and complementary health insurance, cardiovascular disease, lung disease, high cholesterol levels, and hypertension. These findings underscore the crucial role of health insurance coverage, comorbid health conditions, and demographic factors in influencing cancer screening participation in Iran. The disparities observed in screening rates across different cancers and population groups highlight the need for targeted interventions and policies to enhance screening uptake.
This study highlights the underutilization of screening programs and indicates a need for more robust national strategies to improve cancer management and prevention. In comparison to developed countries, Iran's cancer screening participation rates are notably lower. For instance, BC screening rates in the United States for women aged 50–74 stand at 94.1%, while Iran's rates are considerably lower with 24.99%[17]. CC screening shows similar trends, with Sweden reporting an 81.4% participation rate, significantly higher than Iran with 42.2%[18]. This comparison could also be applied to countries in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region, where participation rates in cancer screening programs do not exceed 25% in the best cases[19]. These discrepancies suggest underlying systemic issues that need to be addressed.
Various factors contribute to these disparities, including residential area, wealth index, complementary insurance, marriage status, and age groups. Urban residents have higher odds of participating in cervical cancer screening programs compared to rural residents, which could be partly attributed to easier access to health facilities. However, rural areas demonstrate greater participation in colorectal cancer (CRC) screenings, indicating that the healthcare system in these regions may be more effective at reaching local population which echoes success of previously implemented programs such as IraPEN(part of WHO package of essential noncommunicable (PEN) disease interventions for primary health care) in these regios[10, 20]. Previous studies in other countries, higher socio-economic status was significantly associated with a greater contribution to cancer screening plans [21–23]. In our adjusted model, the wealth index did not yield statistically significant associations for any of the included cancers. While that may be the case both basic health insurance and complementary health insurance coverage were associated higher cancer participation. The results reflect the fact that financial problems could be among the barriers to an optimal participate uptake. In Iran, most of the costs for cancer screening are covered through basic insurance plans. However, due to the current economic challenges of Iran and being listed LMIC according to the World Bank's classification, out-of-pocket payments remain significant for the majority of the population. In contrast, individuals with complementary insurance plans are better covered for the screening service fees. By decreasing out-of-pocket payments and reducing financial barriers to service uptake, insurance plans can positively impact healthcare service utilization[24]. This reduction in financial barriers can help lower the social and financial burden of cancer incidence. Married women tend to participate more in BC and CC screening plans, duo to a higher general awareness by appearing more in healthcare centers for child and maternal health care[25].
There are also some more specific factors that need more attention in cancer screening profiles are highlighted in this study. According to national guidelines and the WHO Cancer Country Profile 2021, the target population for breast cancer screening in Iran starts at 30 years, which is younger than the global peak age of breast cancer prevalence[26]. However, participation in breast cancer screening among the 30–39 age group is almost half that of the 40–49 and 50–59 age groups. This is concerning, especially given that there is an operational screening plan for breast cancer in place.
For cervical cancer, the absence of a national HPV vaccination program makes it crucial to have a more widespread screening program[27]. Currently, only about 4 in 10 adult females are screened for cervical cancer. Although there is an organized program for cervical cancer screening, it is not yet fully operational[28]. In the target population of 30–49 years, nearly one in two adult females have been screened at least once, which is better than the situation for breast cancer. Nonetheless, there is still a long way to go to meet the WHO 2030 strategy goal of having 70% of women screened with a high-performance test by 35 years of age and again by 45 years of age[6]. Currently, there is almost a 20% gap between the current situation and the 2030 goal.
Prostate and colorectal cancer screening also present areas of concern in the current study. Currently, only one in five individuals of the starting age for prostate cancer screening, and one in twenty for colorectal cancer screening, are being screened, which is insufficient considering population changes. In Iran, colonoscopy is predominantly used, but the health system lacks the infrastructure to support a national screening system that covers all individuals over the starting age for colon cancer screening. This is a costly intervention for Iran, given the current economic situation of Iran and being currently evaluated as LMIC [29].
Future Perspectives
Cancer control remains a top health priority in all low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), and early cancer detection is a crucial component of this effort. Effective planning and implementation of early cancer detection programs must integrate a comprehensive approach that includes prevention, screening, early diagnosis, treatment, and palliative care. These interventions should be carefully selected based on national priorities, available resources, feasibility, and cost-effectiveness in the local context.
Policymakers must understand that cancer screening will only achieve the desired outcomes when conducted through a population-based approach with appropriate quality assurance[8]. In LMICs, priority should be given to the interventions listed by the WHO as the ‘best buys’ for addressing NCDs, including cancer, as outlined in the updated Appendix 3 of the Global Action Plan for the Prevention and Control of NCDs 2013–2030[30]. Primary prevention strategies, such as implementing the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), vaccination against hepatitis B and HPV, improving infrastructure to promote physical activity and healthy eating habits, and educating the population about various risk factors, are essential for cancer control in LMICs. To effectively scale up cancer screening rates for major cancers through national cancer control plans, several best-buy interventions and other recommended strategies can be employed. Vaccination against human papillomavirus (HPV) for girls aged 9–13 and screening women aged 30–49 for cervical cancer using visual inspection with acetic acid, Pap smears, or HPV tests are critical. Mammography every two years for women aged 50–69 can aid in early breast cancer detection. Additionally, colorectal cancer treatment at early stages and basic palliative care are essential. Further measures include liver cancer prevention via hepatitis B immunization, oral cancer screening in high-risk groups, and population-based colorectal cancer screening for those over 50 using fecal occult blood tests. These interventions should be linked with timely treatment and supported by policies, infrastructure, and public awareness initiatives to reduce the social and financial burden of cancer[31]. Additionally, scaling up cancer screening rates for major cancers requires addressing key barriers and implementing targeted solutions through national cancer control plans. Developing or updating national policies to include cancer screening as an essential service, establishing evidence-based guidelines, and engaging stakeholders ensures a coordinated approach. Aligning policies with regional and global recommendations and advocating for adequate financial support are vital. Investment in infrastructure and workforce, including diagnostic equipment, facilities, and trained healthcare providers, is essential. Community awareness and education campaigns, addressing myths and misconceptions with culturally sensitive messages, and utilizing social media and hotlines can enhance engagement. Ensuring access to high-quality screening services through population-based programs, mobile clinics, and reducing financial barriers is crucial. Integrating quality assurance, monitoring, and establishing robust information systems linked with cancer registries will help evaluate and improve screening programs[32–36]. These strategies can significantly increase cancer screening rates, leading to earlier detection and better outcomes.
Enhancing access to quality and timely diagnostic and treatment services for cancer not only improves survival rates for common cancers but also reduces health inequities, which are particularly pronounced in LMICs. While implementing cervical cancer screening with an appropriate algorithm is advisable for all LMICs with a high cancer burden, the decision to introduce screening for breast, oral, and colorectal cancers is more complex and requires thorough discussions among stakeholders to make an informed decision[37]. Further research at national level is needed to develop affordable, simple technology-based, point-of-care screening tests for these cancers. Screening for other cancer types is not recommended for countries with limited resources[8].
Strengths and Limitations
As a part of the most recent WHO STEPs project, this is the first study providing data for the cancer screening profile of the Iranian population from all 31 provinces. The most prominent strength of this survey was the use of a nationwide representative survey data of urban and rural participants aged 18 and above, which certified more confident inference. However, there were some limitations in the study. This study provides information solely on one-time participation in screening programs, with no data on the frequency or continuous participation in these programs. The breast cancer screening information only includes mammograms, with no data on ultrasound imaging of the breasts. As this study is based on a self-reported questionnaire, the results could be subject to recall bias. Finally, the information in this study comes from a national survey rather than an ongoing registry, which should be considered when interpreting the findings.