Study design:
We conducted a retrospective study of consecutive adults with MMA (moyamoya syndrome and moyamoya disease) treated in our tertiary hospital by MBH between March 2012 and June 2021.
Population
We included adult patients registered in our database with an MMA treated by MBH.
MMA was diagnosed using established criteria (1). The indication for surgery was based on the usual recommendations and French guidelines (14): recent ischemic events (TIA or stroke) with hypoperfusion and/or vascular reserve impairment or severe vascular reserve impairment with clinical symptom other than stroke.
During the study period, patients with a surgical indication according to our multidisciplinary assessment, no hemorrhagic presentation and predominant frontal hypoperfusion were treated by MBH surgery. French guidelines do not impose a specific technique for revascularization in adults with MMA (14). Studies in children and a few in adults have suggested considering burr holes as an option for moyamoya patients (4, 5). This technique allows for a large-scale revascularization of frontal areas, unlike other techniques, which are more efficient for improving the perfusion of the peri-sylvian parenchyma in lateral hemispheres. Based on these characteristics, it was a hospital decision to choose multiple burr-hole surgery as a first line of treatment for patients with predominant frontal hypoperfusion. Patients with hemorrhagic presentation or more diffuse hypoperfusion were treated by direct or indirect by-pass.
Surgical modalities:
Under general anesthesia, with careful blood pressure monitoring during induction and the surgical procedure, all patients were treated with the same surgical technique of multiple burr holes (MBH). Surgery was performed by 3 experienced neurosurgeons (JCS, PB, SB). After coronal incision, the epicranium was exposed. In front of the hypoperfused region, an epicranial flap was prepared and a burr hole was performed. The dura and arachnoid meningeal layers were carefully opened under microscope and the epicranial flap was deposited against the cerebral cortex in the subdural space (Fig. 1).
Clinical Data collection:
Baseline demographic, clinical and radiological data were recorded in our database.
Follow-up:
All periprocedural (< 7 days post-operation) and pre-discharge complications were collected. All patients were assessed during clinical visits, at least every 6 months. During follow-up, TIA and symptomatic stroke (cerebral infarction and intracerebral hemorrhage) were reviewed to calculate the risk of stroke recurrence after discharge. Stroke was defined as an acute neurological symptom associated with neuroimaging evidence of corresponding acute infarction (symptomatic cerebral infarction) or hemorrhage (symptomatic intracerebral hemorrhage). The number of subsequent recurrent events was also recorded. Functional independence was assessed using the modified Rankin score (mRS), both before surgery and at the end of follow-up.
Radiological data collection:
All included patients underwent DSA (digital subtraction angiography), perfusion-weighted imaging, both before and 6 months after surgery.
DSA :
The development of transdural anastomoses was assessed on digital subtraction angiography 6 months after surgery using a modified Matshushima score.
Matsushima score (15) :
-
Grade A: area vascularized by the external carotid branches (EC) corresponding to more than 2/3 of the territory irrigated by the middle cerebral artery
-
Grade B: area vascularized by the EC branches is between 1/3 and 2/3 of the territory irrigated by the middle cerebral artery
-
Grade C: area vascularized by the EC branches is less than 1/3 of the territory irrigated by the middle cerebral artery
We used the Matshushima score by performing two separate analyses of the middle and anterior cerebral artery territories and adding a Grade 0. Grade 0 corresponded to no area vascularized by the external carotid branches
Perfusion imaging acquisition and analyses:
Perfusion-weighted images were acquired using a gradient echo sequence with the following parameters: TR 1710, TE 20 ms, FOV 100, matrix 108 x 108, flip angle 90°, 4-mm-thick contiguous sections, NEX 1. We measured cerebral perfusion using dynamic susceptibility contrast-enhanced MRI.
TMax maps on baseline and post-surgery MRIs were processed using Olea Sphere® software. Tmax below 2 secondes is usually considered normal perfusion. In patients with chronic hypoperfusion (moyamoya and others), a TMax threshold above 6 s correlates with critical hypoperfusion as assessed using XeCT (13). TMax maps were created using increasing 2 s step thresholds, from 2 s to 10 s. To assess perfusion improvement, we performed a visual qualitative analysis. It was performed by two investigators (PB, CM) by consensus. Then, we performed a quantitative analysis of the hypoperfused parenchyma volume according to TMax thresholds. The distribution of these hypoperfused volumes was converted into a percentage by hemisphere in order to homogenize the results.
Ethical considerations:
According to French ethical and regulatory law (Public Health Code), retrospective studies based on the exploitation of usual care data not need be submitted to an ethics committee, but they have to be declared or covered using the reference methodology of the French National Commission for Informatics and Liberties (CNIL). Toulouse University Hospital signed a commitment of compliance with the reference methodology MR-004 of the CNIL. After evaluation and validation by the data protection officer and according to the General Data Protection Regulation, this study fulfilled all the criteria. It is registered in the register of retrospective studies of the Toulouse University Hospital (register no.: RnIPH 2021-66) and covered by MR-004 (CNIL number: 2121529 v1). This study was approved by Toulouse University Hospital and confirms that the ethical requirements were totally respected in the above report.
Statistical analysis:
We considered each hemisphere separately as an independent parameter, as is usually proposed in MMA. Because of the small number of subjects and the abnormal distribution, we performed non-parametric tests.
The probability of survival without stroke/TIA recurrence after surgery was calculated with Kaplan Meier analysis. Survival time was calculated from date of discharge after surgery until date of stroke/TIA occurrence at follow-up or the last known date without stroke/TIA during follow-up. For patients experiencing multiple stroke/TIA events during follow-up, data were censored after the first event.
The parenchymal hypoperfusion rate in each 2 seconds interval (0–2; 2–4, etc.) were compared before and after surgery by the Wilcoxon test for matched groups. The difference of pre- and post-operative variations between each interval has been evaluated by a Kruskal-Wallis test.
We compared the percentages of normally perfused parenchyma volume (Tmax < 2 s) and hypoperfused parenchyma volumes with Tmax > 2 s: Tmax > 4 s (slightly hypoperfused), Tmax > 6 s (severely hypoperfused) and Tmax > 8 s (critically hypoperfused) before and after surgery using the Wilcoxon test.
The association between improvement of hypoperfusion and collateral development or Suzuki grade was assessed using Fisher’s test.
Values are given as median (range) or means ± SD except where specified. All tests were bilateral. A p-value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.