Control of household insect pests with synthetic insecticides is not really encouraging due to their environmental negative effects and high cost of procurement. Use of nanoparticles in the control of agricultural and household pests has been widely advocated due to their environmental friendly nature and their high entomotoxic effects [31, 32]. The root and leaf extracts of P. alliacea bio-fabricated nearly spherical AgNPs, having size range of 5.95–76.91 nm within 10 minutes of reaction. Earlier, Lateef et al. [31] reported the use of leaf aqueous extract of P. alliacea for the synthesis of AgNPs with antimicrobial, anticoagulant and antioxidant activities. However, there is no report on the use of the root extract of the plant for the synthesis of AgNPs until now. Also, this is the first report of the evaluation of biogenic AgNPs synthesized by P. alliacea as insecticides against cockroaches. Therefore, Pa-AgNPs were tested on common household insect (cockroach) with the two modes of application (contact and fumigant) at three concentrations (1, 5 and 10% v/v).
The results revealed that biosynthesized AgNPs exhibited insecticidal action against the studied insect, which clearly suggested that the tested Pa-AgNPs had insecticidal properties. This observation aligns with Yeguerman et al. [33] that reported the significant effects of biosynthesized polymeric nanoparticles from peppermint, Palmarosa geranium, lavender and rosemary on German cockroach. However, the extracts of P. alliacea used in the formulation of insecticides had been reported in some studies. For instance, the oil extracted from P. alliacea reportedly killed adult mosquitos within 2 h of application [34]. Similarly, P. alliacea and some other plant extracts had been tested against field insect pests of okra and cowpea [35, 36]. However, the existing studies have shown that the effectiveness of P. alliacea used in the formulation of nano-insecticides can be attributed to the organic compound called dibenzyltrisulfide [37, 38]. Insecticidal effect of this Pa-AgNPs was made possible due to the ability of nanoparticles to bind and adsorb other chemical compounds with ease and circulate them in insect body systems [39, 40]. In addition to this, Azeez et al. [41] and Lateef et al. [30] reported that AgNPs had high penetration potential of the particles of cellular metabolism which might cause deformation of DNA and inhibits the normal functioning of enzymes of the target organisms. Also, nanoparticles have been reported to have had effects on insects’ antioxidant and inhibited enzymes which eventually results to their death [42].
Comparatively, there was no significant difference in the efficacy of P. alliacea leaf and root in the formulations of nano-insecticides which indicates that any of this plant part can be used in the formulation. Within one hour of application, just only 25% of the studied cockroaches were killed through contact, while 50% mortality was observed through fumigant exposure at highest concentrations. Similarly, 100% mortality was recorded within 3 h of exposure through fumigant action. Meanwhile, it took 4 h to achieve 100% mortality through contact action. This is an indication that the route of exposure of Pa-AgNPs is one of the major determinants in the control of cockroaches. However, delayed insecticidal effects observed through contact toxicity might have been linked to the inability of nano-insecticide formulations to penetrate cuticle of the cockroaches easily and this suggests that Pa-AgNPs killed faster through respiratory system. This observation substantiates Abdel-Raheem and Eldafrawy [43] that reported that silver nanoparticles tested on the cockroaches through fumigant killed faster than the contact toxicity. Earlier study has proved that essential oil nanoparticles exhibited insecticidal action through contact against German cockroach [44]. This implies that the route of exposure is one of the factors influenced the toxicity of nano-insecticides formulations.
Data collected also suggested that the effectiveness of the tested biosynthesized AgNPs depended on the concentrations applied irrespective of mode of application. For instance, 75% mortality of cockroach was recorded at 10% v/v, while 43.8–52.1% mortality was achieved at 5% v/v. Meanwhile, 25-31.3% of the tested cockroach was killed at 1% after 3 h of application. This present study concurs with the earlier observation by Abdel-Raheem and Eldafrawy [43] which reported that effectiveness of silver nanoparticles against cockroaches was dose-dependent.
Although synthetic insecticide (lambdacyhalothrin) killed faster than biosynthesized AgNPs formulations, this is an indication that the tested nano-insecticides had delayed effects on the studied insect and this action is one of the major characteristic features of botanical insecticides. However, biosynthesized nanoparticles have been described as environmental-friendly due to their less toxicity to humans and environment [31, 32]. Thus, the delayed effects of biosynthesized AgNPs against cockroaches cannot be an absolute obstacle to their use as an alternative to synthetic insecticides putting into the consideration, the environmental positive effects of nano-insecticides over synthetic insecticides.