Our study results indicate that the group injected with the secretome of MSC, combining TDSCs and ASCs, showed a significant increase in PINP levels compared to the control group. However, the tested groups observed no significant differences between PIIINP levels.
Procollagen types I and III are crucial building blocks in all connective tissues. These two markers, associated with collagen metabolism, specifically PINP and PIIINP, have been widely used in bone tissue as early predictors of the success of an intervention. PINP and PIIINP markers have recently been used to assess collagen metabolism in human Achilles tendons (11, 13).
The higher PINP levels in the combination group of TDSCs and ASCs indicate increased Type I collagen synthesis, which is essential for tendon healing. Type I collagen is the primary component of the extracellular matrix in tendons, providing structural strength and stability (14). This increase in PINP suggests that the combination of MSC secretome injection can enhance or accelerate the formation of new collagen in chronically injured tendons.
In addition to the increase in PINP, it is also essential to understand the dynamics of connective tissue healing, which involves interactions between various cell types, such as fibroblasts and macrophages, and the role of growth factors released during the healing process. MSC secretome injections may modulate the microenvironment of the damaged tissue by enhancing fibroblast activity and reducing inflammation through paracrine actions, contributing to increased collagen synthesis and extracellular matrix remodeling (15, 16).
On the other hand, the lack of significant differences in PIIINP levels between groups suggests that while there is an increase in Type I collagen synthesis, there is no corresponding increase in Type III collagen synthesis. Type III collagen is typically found in the early stages of wound healing and forms granulation tissue (17, 18). Type III collagen is later replaced by more mechanically resistant Type I collagen. The lack of significant differences in Type III collagen levels may indicate that the MSC secretome is more effective in facilitating structural repair through Type I collagen proliferation than Type III collagen. Additionally, measurements taken in the sixth-week post-operation (second-week post-injection) may correspond to the remodeling phase, where Type I collagen production begins to replace Type III collagen, leading to naturally higher PINP levels than PIIINP. This conclusion is supported by experimental studies showing that the primary increase in Type I collagen occurs during the regenerative phase, starting around 4–6 weeks post-operation (19, 20).
Furthermore, although this study did not show significant differences in PIIINP levels, previous studies have suggested that combining cellular and molecular therapies, such as the use of immunomodulated scaffolds, may yield more optimal outcomes in tendon healing, particularly in terms of long-term structural and functional repair (21, 22). Our findings align with previous research showing that the application of MSC secretome, especially when enriched with growth factors and cytokines, can enhance tissue injury healing by increasing Type I collagen synthesis without causing excessive fibrosis (23, 24).
Histopathological analysis of the rat tendons revealed no significant differences in the total histopathological scores between the groups injected with MSC secretome and the control group. The histopathological score includes assessments of collagen quantity, angiogenesis, and cartilage formation in the tested tendons. These findings suggest that while there is an increase in Type I collagen synthesis, as indicated by elevated PINP levels, significant structural changes at the histopathological level may not be evident in the short term or under the specific conditions of this study. This could be due to various factors, including the study's duration, the secretome dose used, or the complexity of the chronic tendon healing process (25–27).
This study has several limitations that require further consideration. First, the results were obtained by directly injuring the previously healthy rat tendons. This differs slightly from the chronic injury process, which often includes natural degenerative aspects. Additionally, the increase in PINP with secretome injection may theoretically facilitate tendon repair and positively influence tendon injury healing success rate. However, these experimental results cannot be directly translated into clinical practice. Further research is needed to confirm these theoretical benefits of secretome use.
Despite the limitations, our results may pave the way for new management approaches to improve tendon injury repair outcomes based on secretome injections. This strategy offers several advantages as MSC secretomes can be easily produced in large quantities, stored efficiently, and do not require as many cells as MSC transplantation. Additionally, this strategy avoids risks associated with cell therapy, such as immunological reactions, cells failing to survive during transplantation, cell entrapment in pulmonary capillaries, and infection (28).
The significant increase in PINP levels in the combination group of TDSCs and ASCs compared to the control group suggests that this secretome combination could accelerate the healing of chronic tendon injuries. However, the histopathological results highlight that molecular-level improvements do not always correlate with observable microscopic changes in the short term. Therefore, long-term studies with continuous observation are needed to confirm the effectiveness of this therapy in repairing the structure and function of injured tendons.