Germination responses of Triticum durum (Vitron) under Cd stress and organic amendments
This study examined the effects of organic amendments on germination parameters (germination kinetics, germination speed, germination rate and emergence rate) in durum wheat (Triticum durum var. Vitron) exposed to 50 ppm of cadmium.
The results represented on figure 1 indicate that under Cd stress, the kinetics of germination expresses three phases, a phase of latency, which had with the imbibition of seeds; an exponential phase where one attends an acceleration of germination and a stationary stage indicating a break of germination. Completely, whatever the organic amendment used; the germinative capacity of Cd-stressed seeds is increased compared to the stressed seeds without organic amendment (Cd) and no stressed seeds with no organic amendment (T0) and this for the PN, WL and SF used, when a maximum rate of germination had been expressed on the 6th day.
Cd exposure significantly reduced speed germination index (1,183 ± 0,076 for T0 versus 0,540 ± 0,314 for Cd‐exposed)
Applied organic amendments significantly increased speed germination index (SG) as shown in Table 1 (p = 0,027). Significant differences of seed germination were observed in figure 2 between stressed seeds without organic amendment (Cd) when SG = 0,540±0,314 and stressed seeds in soil added by peanut shell (PN) when SG = 1,218±0,296.
A Kruskal-Wallis non-parametric test (Table 2) revealed no significant difference (p > 0.05) in the germination rate and the emergence rate of Triticum durum (Vitron) grown under controlled conditions with Cd-50 ppm across the various organic amendment treatments.
Table 01. Analysis of variance of the speed of germination (SG) of Triticum durum grown in the presence of cd (50 mg kg−1) and organic amendments
Source
|
Df
|
Sum Sq
|
Mean Sq
|
F value
|
Pr (>F)
|
SG
|
5
|
0
999
|
0,200
|
3,927
|
0,027
|
Error
|
11
|
0,560
|
0,051
|
|
|
Total
|
16
|
1,559
|
|
|
|
Table 02. Kruskal-Wallis analysis of germination rate and emergence rate of Triticum durum grown in the presence of Cd (50 mg kg−1) and organic amendments
Kruskal-Wallis test
|
Germina
ion rate
|
Emergence rate
|
K (Observed value)
|
9,000
|
5,560
|
K (Critical value)
|
11,070
|
11,070
|
DDL
|
5
|
5
|
P-value
|
0,109
|
0,351
|
Alpha
|
0,05
|
0,05
|
Growth parameters responses of Triticum durum (Vitron) under Cd stress and organic amendments
The effects of organic amendments on various growth parameters of Triticum durum (Vitron) seedlings exposed to cadmium (Cd) stress (50 mg kg−1) were investigated. Seven growth parameters were measured: leaf area, total weight, total plant length, length of the aerial part, root length, number of roots and number of leaves.
Analysis of variance (Table 03) revealed a very highly significant effect (p < 0.0001) of organic amendments on the leaf area (LA), total plant height (TPH), length of the aerial part (APL) and total weight (TW) of Triticum durum seedlings grown under Cd stress compared to the Cd (Cd stress wihtout amendments). Highly significant impact of organic amendments on the total weight of Triticum durum (Vitron) grown under controlled conditions with 50 ppm cadmium (Cd) stress was also shown.
Cd exposure significantly reduced total weight (0,487 ± 0,058 g for T0 versus 0.093 ± 0.054 g for Cd‐exposed), leaf area (9.360±0.675 cm2 for T0 versus 1.066±0.455 cm2 for Cd‐exposed) and length of the aerial part (34.00 ± 1.732 cm for T0 versus 11.333 ± 5.572 cm for Cd‐exposed).
Organic amendments SF and WL displayed a very highly significant effect (p < 0.0001), while amendments PN and PS exhibited a significant effect (p = 0.012) on total weight compared to the Cd (without organic amendments).
Figure 2.b, visually demonstrates a substantial increase in total weight for Triticum durum treated with organic amendment SF (0.483 ± 0.035 g) and WL (0.347 ± 0.064 g) compared to the Cd (0.093 ± 0.054 g). Similarly, a significant increase in total weight was observed with amendments PN (0.260 ± 0.026 g) and PS (0.260 ± 0.046 g) compared to the Cd.
Organic amendment SF (5.265±0.608 cm2) significantly enhanced (p < 0.0001) the leaf area of Triticum durum (Vitron) subjected to cadmium stress (50 mg kg−1) compared to the Cd (1.066±0.455 cm2). Other amendments WL (3.848±0.919 cm2), PN (3.98±0.179 cm2) and PS (3.458±1.110 cm2) also exhibited a highly significant (p < 0.01) for WL and significant (p < 0.05) increases in leaf area for PN and PS compared to the Cd.
Organic amendments SF (33.167 ± 2.3631 cm) and WL (28.833 ± 1.607 cm), along with the T0 (38.333 ± 2.517 cm), resulted in a very highly significant increase (p < 0.0001) in total plant length compared to the Cd treatment (14.667 ± 4.311 cm). Seedling total length was also highly significantly increased (p = 0.002) following application of organic amendments PN (26.000 ± 0.000 cm) and PS (26.000 ± 2.784 cm) compared to the Cd.
The impact of SF organic amendment on the length of the aerial part (shoot length) in Triticum durum cultivar Vitron exposed to cadmium stress revealed a highly significant effect (p = 0.001) on shoot length PS (25.000 ± 0.500 cm) compared to the control treatment Cd (11.333 ± 5.572 cm). Organic amendment SF (23.000 ± 3.500 cm ) highly significantly enhanced shoot length in cadmium-stressed plants (50 ppm). Other amendments (PN, 21.167 ± 0.289 cm and WL, 21.333 ± 2.02 cm) also exhibited significant increases (p < 0.05) in shoot length compared to the Cd. These findings suggest that organic amendments, particularly amendment SF, can potentially mitigate the detrimental effects of cadmium stress on the growth of Triticum durum (Vitron).
No significant effect (p > 0.05) of organic amendments on root length of Triticum durum (Vitron) relative to the cadmium Cd treatment. Mean root lengths for the SF, PN, PS, WL, and T0 treatments were 7.000 cm ± 1.803 cm, 5.500 cm ± 1.803 cm, 2.333 cm ± 0.289 cm, 6.500 cm ± 1.500 cm, and 3.333 cm ± 0.289 cm, respectively. The mean root length of the Cd was 3.333 cm ± 1.528 cm.
Table 03. Analysis of variance of leaf area (LA), total plant height (TPH), length of the aerial part (APL), root length (RL) and total weight (TW) in Triticum durum cultivated in the presence of cadmium (50 mg kg−1) and organic amendments.
|
Df
|
Sum Sq
|
Mean Sq
|
F value
|
Pr (>F)
|
TW
|
5
|
0,341
|
0,068
|
28,668
|
< 0,0001
|
LA
|
5
|
117,286
|
23,457
|
42,939
|
< 0,0001
|
TPH
|
5
|
959,333
|
191,867
|
28,193
|
< 0,0001
|
APL
|
5
|
799,403
|
159,881
|
18,902
|
< 0,0001
|
RL
|
5
|
55,500
|
11,100
|
5,920
|
0,006
|
Table 04. Kruskal-Wallis Test for root and leaf number of durum wheat exposed to cadmium (50 mg kg−1) and organic amendments
|
Number of roots
|
Number of leaves
|
K (Observed value)
|
11,161
|
8,442
|
K (Critical value)
|
11,070
|
11,070
|
DDL
|
5
|
5
|
p-value
|
0,048
|
0,134
|
Alpha
|
0,05
|
0,05
|
A Kruskal-Wallis test (Table 04) revealed no significant effect (p > 0.05) of organic amendments on leaf number relative to the Cd (seedlings exposed to cadmium stress without amendments). But it revealed a significant increase (p < 0.05) in root number for wheat treated with organic amendment.
Figure 03 (e), shown that organic amendment WL resulted in the highest root number (30.333 ± 4.509) compared to Cd (08.333 ± 1.528). Amendment PN (18.667 ± 8.386), SF (17.333 ± 2.517) and PS (11.667 ± 2.887) did not influence root number.
Physiological and biochemical responses of Triticum durum (Vitron) under Cd stress and organic amendments
Kruskal-Wallis test (Table 05) revealed a significant effect of organic amendments on the relative water content (p < 0.05) of Triticum durum plants exposed to Cd stress. Compared to Cd treatment (32.146±12.953 %), PS (67.445±17.887 %), WL (64.476±8.726 %) and the unamendment-uncontaminated plants, T0 (61.085±11.283 %), the PN (95.460±167.421%) and SF (87.713±2.836%) application showed a very highly significant effect (p= 0.001).
Analysis of variance (ANOVA) revealed no significant effect (p > 0.05) of organic amendment on relative electrolyte leakage (%) and a significant influence (p < 0.05) on the membrane stability index (MSI) of Triticum durum (Vitron) grown under controlled conditions with 50 mg kg−1 cadmium (Cd) stress.
Cd exposure significantly reduced membrane stability index (68.973 ± 5.635 % for T0 versus 35.282 ± 13.486 % for Cd‐exposed)
Compared to the Cd treatment (35.282 ± 13.486 %), organic amendment with WL (67.470 ± 8.149 %) resulted in a significant increase (p < 0.05) in MSI.
Analysis of variance revealed a very highly significant effect (p < 0.001) of organic amendment on total chlorophyll content. As illustrated in the table below, the mean of total chlorophyll content in seedlings treated with PS (5649.161 ± 757.450 mg/g FW) was significantly greater than the Cd treatment (1885.318 ± 963.730 mg/g FW). In contrast, the other organic amendments, PN (3310.122 ± 178.846 mg/g FW), SF (1969.796 ± 446.967 mg/g FW), WL (1686.245 ± 871.902 mg/g FW), as well as T0 (2838.719 ± 1360.910 mg/g FW), did not significantly increase (p > 0.05) total chlorophyll content compared to the Cd.
Table 05. Influence of organic amendments application on physiological traits of wheat planted in Cd toxic soil
Treatments
|
Relative water content (RWC) %
|
Relative electrolyte leakage (REL ) %
|
Membrane stability index (MSI) %
|
Total chlorophyll content (mg/g FW)
|
T0
|
61,085±11,283 ab
|
23,535±11,907
|
68,973±5,635 b
|
2838,719±1360,910 a
|
Cd
|
32,146±12,953 a
|
32,584±15,710
|
35,282±13,486 a
|
1885,318±963,730 a
|
SF
|
87,713±2,836 b
|
27,170±14,032
|
62,267±10,251 ab
|
1969,796±446,967 a
|
PN
|
167,421±95,460 b
|
43,772±12,535
|
60,998±4,502 ab
|
3310,122±178,846 ab
|
WL
|
64,476±8,726 ab
|
43,870±2,627
|
67,470±8,149 b
|
1686,245±871,902 a
|
PS
|
67,445±17,887 ab
|
51,964±34,139
|
49,041±13,853 ab
|
5649,161±757,450 b
|
p-value (Kruskal-Wallis test)
|
0,040 *
|
|
Pr>F (ANOVA)
|
|
0,385 ns
|
0,016 *
|
0,001 ***
|
Compost was applied at the rate of 10% to wheat; Cd was without organic amendment. Means, in each column, sharing same letters differ nonsignificantly at (p ˃ 0.05) according to post hoc HSD Tukey test. Values presented in table are means of three replicates
Asterisk shows significant effects at (p ≤ 0.05) and (p ≤ 0.001), ns nonsignificant.
The wheat exhibited significant changes in various biochemical parameters. These markers included protein, proline, and soluble sugar levels quantified in both root and foliar tissues. The impressive response of these biochemical parameters suggests their potential as indicators for identifying the most effective organic amendments for maximizing Cd removal.
Two-way ANOVA analysis (Table 06) showed that organic amendments type and interaction between organs significantly influenced protein content, (P = 0.002), proline content, (P< 0.001) and soluble sugar content (P= 0.013).
Table 06. Two-way ANOVA of protein, proline, and soluble sugar levels in Triticum durum cultivated in the presence of cadmium (50 mg kg−1) and organic amendments.
As shown in figure 4a, the addition of organic amendments (PS) exhibited a significant increase (p < 0.05) on protein content in the root of Triticum durum plants cultivated at 50 mg kg−1 of Cd (23.548 ± 2.034 mg/g FW) compared to the plants exposed to Cd alone (11,956± 1,310 mg/g FW). Conversely, no significant difference (p > 0.05) in root protein content was observed between the other organic amendments (WL, PN and SF). No significant differences (p > 0.05) were observed in leaf protein levels among all treatments, including the Cd control.
Cadmium treatment significantly increased proline content in roots (1.485 ± 0.566 mg/g FW) compared to T0 (0.759 ± 0.320 mg/g FW) (figure 4b). Organic amendment application (SF, PS, PN and WL) resulted in a reduction of proline content, suggesting a mitigating effect. SF (0.293 ± 0.135 mg/g FW) treatment displayed the very highly significant decrease (p < 0.001), followed by highly significant decrease (p < 0.01) with PS (0.457 ± 0.081 mg/g FW) and a significant decrease (p < 0.05) with WL (0.577 ± 0.205 mg/g FW) and PN (0.708 ± 0.137 mg/g FW) application.
In contrast to root tissues, organic amendment treatments did not significantly affect (p > 0.05) proline content in foliar organs compared to the Cd treatment. These findings indicate that cadmium exposure specifically induced proline accumulation in Triticum durum roots, while organic amendments, particularly SF, alleviated this stress response in roots.
Organic amendment SF resulted in a highly significant increase (p < 0.0001) in sugar content of Triticum durum roots (18,562 ± 3,341 mg/g FW) compared to the roots of plants cultivated in Cd contaminated soil without amendments (6,898 ± 2,319 mg/g FW). PN application also displayed a significant increase (p < 0.05) in root sugar content (15,107 ± 2,354 mg/g FW) compared to the Cd treatment. All organic amendment treatments did not exert a significant influence (p > 0.05) on sugar content in foliar organs compared to the Cd control.