Using a combination of shallow shotgun sequencing and mitochondrial hybridization capture, we recovered unique time series of marine mammal species occurrence covering the past ~ 12,000 years from four coastal marine sediment cores around Northern Greenland. By integrating the faunal data retrieved from the cores with environmental proxy records, we identified periods of environmental changes and associated shifts in species distributions at levels detectable via sedimentary ancient DNA.
Ecosystem-wide changes in Melville Bay during the Holocene
The analysis of the Melville Bay 26G core, retrieved from the continental shelf of north-west Greenland (Fig. 1), revealed the paleoceanographic conditions and marine mammal communities throughout the entire Holocene, following the last deglaciation.
The six oldest samples in the laminated section of this core (> 213 cm depth in core) did not contain marine mammal DNA, nor did we detect foraminifera associated with Atlantic-derived water masses, but we detected low numbers of DNA assigned to codfishes and priapulids in the shotgun sequencing data (Fig. S7d). During the Last Glacial Maximum (~ 26.5 to ~ 19 cal ka BP), the Greenland Ice Sheet extended to the edge of the continental shelf in Melville Bay, and only retreated from the outer coast by 11.6 ± 0.3 cal ka BP, when the marine-based ice sheet collapsed in Melville Bay62. In marine sediment cores, retreating ice-sheet deposits can be identified by a transition of laminated sediments containing none or low amounts of foraminifera to homogeneous sediments with dropstones and foraminifera58. The six samples retrieved from the laminated section of the core > 213 cm thus originate from retreating ice-sheet deposits characterized by high sedimentation rates and therefore likely represent a short time period at or just prior to 11.6 ka BP.
The first marine mammal DNA we detected was from ringed seal at 11.0–13.8 cal ka BP. This finding pre-dates the earliest Holocene fossil evidence (dated 9.1–9.7 cal ka BP63) of this species in Greenland – and indeed of any marine mammal species – by ~ 2 ka. The same sample revealed DNA of codfishes, diatoms, and pinnipeds in the shotgun sequencing data (Fig. S7d). For our DNA findings of ringed seals and codfishes, we identified a positive correlation, not just for Melville Bay 26G, but across samples from all four cores (Fig. S10). The analysis of Melville Bay 26G for foraminifera revealed near-absence before 10.5 cal ka BP (Data sheet 3, Fig. 2c), albeit an increase in the presence of foraminifera had been recorded in marine sediments of northernmost Baffin Bay at ~ 12.3 cal ka BP50,64. Ringed seals are physiologically adapted to life in the pack ice and are at present found in the Arctic year-round65. Our finding supports the hypothesis that ringed seals were the first marine mammals to move north after the end of the Last Glacial Maximum38.
Between 11.4–7.3 cal ka BP, we detected DNA of marine mammals that are at present found in the region year-round (e.g. narwhal), only seasonally (e.g. harp seal), or not at all (fin whale) (Fig. 2, Table S4), potentially reflecting a non-analogous community structure in the Early Holocene as compared to recent and historic surveys14,15,66,67. This period also had the highest diversity of detected eukaryotic families and the highest abundance of foraminifera associated with relatively warmer waters of Atlantic origin, which indicates increased intensity of the West Greenland Current (Fig. 2).
The detection of narwhal DNA at 11.4 ± 1.2 cal ka BP predates the earliest Holocene fossil record for narwhals in Greenland (dated 6.1 ± 0.2 cal ka BP, from the northern tip of Greenland 83.65° N)35 by almost five millennia, and an older fossil (dated 6.8 ± 0.1 cal ka BP) from northern Ellesmere Island, Canada (82° N)68. Similarly, the detection of bowhead whale DNA at 10.7 ± 1.0 cal ka BP predates the earliest fossil record of this species in Melville Bay (at 9.3–9.0 cal ka BP69) by at least 500 years. In contrast to the relative scarcity of bowhead whales in the Greenland fossil record, their fossil occurrence in the Canadian Arctic Archipelago documents their presence at similar latitudes (~ 73° N) as Melville Bay (~ 75° N) as early as 10.5 ka BP70,71.
Temperate cetaceans, including minke whales and orcas, are known to migrate northward along the west coast of Greenland during the summer months17, albeit Melville Bay is at the northern limit of their present-day distribution range (Table S4). Fin whales, which we detected at 7.8 ± 0.7 cal ka BP, have not previously been recorded along the west coast of Greenland further north than 71° N in present-day and historic surveys16,73,74. In addition to temperate marine mammals, we also detected DNA from the low-arctic hooded seal (at 11.4 ± 1.2 and 4 ± 0.4 cal ka BP), harp seal (11.4–0.9 cal ka BP), and beluga (7.9–3 cal ka BP). Both hooded and harp seals migrate northward along the west coast of Greenland during summer, but in contrast to harp seals, which forage in shallower waters15,75, hooded seals generally stay further offshore14. For belugas, Melville Bay is known as a migration corridor between their summer distribution hotspot in the Canadian Arctic and their wintering grounds further south along the west coast of Greenland67.
The detection of temperate and low-arctic marine mammal species suggests that during the Early-to-Mid Holocene, they were present in the area at densities that are detectable in marine sediments. We hypothesize this expansion or northward shift in their distribution ranges was associated with environmental changes. Specifically, the redundancy analysis (RDA) of DNA detections and reconstructed paleoenvironmental proxy measurements revealed air temperature to be a significant driver of community change (Fig. S11). Furthermore, our analysis of foraminiferal assemblages from Melville Bay 26G revealed high foraminifera counts, indicating increased intensity of the West Greenland Current 10 − 7 cal ka BP (Fig. 2c), which is in line with previous paleoceanographic reconstructions from northernmost Baffin Bay50,64,76. The biomarkers brassicasterol, dinosterol, and IP25 were also relatively high in Melville Bay between 10.5–6 cal ka BP, indicating a phase of high primary productivity and stable ice-edge conditions77,78. The West Greenland Current transports relatively warmer waters of Atlantic origin northwards along the west coast of Greenland79 and its prevalence has been shown to affect the size and abundance of marine organisms at the base of the food web80.
Our detections in the Early-to-Mid Holocene of temperate species such as orcas, fin whales, and minke whales at 75° N may reflect a northward expansion relative to their present-day distribution, similar to the occurrence of boreal mollusc species along the west coast of Greenland (9.2–5.6 cal ka BP), which has been interpreted as a consequence of higher sea-surface temperatures associated with an increased intensity of the West Greenland Current81. To date, the mechanisms controlling increased northward heat transport are not yet fully understood, but certain atmospheric conditions can facilitate increased intensity of the West Greenland Current82.
Overall, our DNA assemblage from Melville Bay 26G contained both Arctic and temperate species, which may indicate the coexistence of species in non-analogous communities. However, the age uncertainty of our individual sediment samples from this core span at least several hundred years (ranging from 0.4–1.6 ka) and therefore we cannot rule out that replacement of species may have occurred at a finer temporal scale (Fig. 2e).
In Disko Bay (69° N), an increased prevalence of temperate cetaceans such as humpback whales has been observed during the summer months since the 18th century83. Humpback whales, which are found at lower latitudes during most of the year, have been observed in the shallower waters of Disko Bay later in the summer, whereas bowhead whales migrate to Disko Bay earlier and spend more time in deeper waters. The co-occurrence rather than replacement of species may be facilitated by bowhead whales feeding on copepods and amphipods, while humpback whales target krill and fish83,84. However, further south, off the coast of south-east Greenland, the increased presence of temperate marine mammal species correlates with a decrease in Arctic species6.
Following this period of higher species diversity, marine mammal detections were more sporadic in the Mid-to-Late Holocene (7.2–3 cal ka BP), although we still detected species occurring seasonally in the region today (Fig. 2e). In the same period, we detected less eukaryotic families (Fig. S7d), and the abundance of foraminifera indicative of increased intensity of the West Greenland Current decreased (Fig. 2c). The timing matches the disappearance of boreal mollusc species in western Baffin Bay after 5.6 cal ka BP81 and eastern Baffin Island after 3 cal ka BP71, both attributed to a decline in sea-surface temperature. Similarly, sea-surface temperature reconstructions based on diatom and dinocyst assemblages of a sediment core from northernmost Baffin Bay showed a transition from fluctuating but higher temperatures > 4 cal ka BP, to lower temperatures < 4 cal ka BP76.
After 3.2 cal ka BP, marine mammal detections were rare and we only detected DNA of species that occur seasonally in the region today in one sample (harp seal at 0.9 cal ka BP). In this period, our Melville Bay 26G foraminifera data suggests low influx of Atlantic-derived water masses, potentially reflecting a phase of a weaker West Greenland Current, as has been suggested based on a paleo-oceanographic reconstruction using another marine sediment core from southern Melville Bay49. Furthermore, data from several other marine sediment cores indicate a phase of increasing sea ice concentrations and decreasing phytoplankton production during the Late Holocene in northern Baffin Bay52,64,85 and Disko Bay36. A shift from low-arctic species such as harp seal and harbor porpoise > 3 cal ka BP to Arctic endemic marine mammals such as ringed seals and bowhead whales < 3 cal ka BP has also been described based on the analysis of archaeological middens86,87. The change in the consumption of marine mammals by paleo-inuit communities along the west coast of Greenland may reflect the species that were most prevalent in the environment at a certain time period.
Only two samples were dated to < 2.2 cal ka BP, and thus we have limited temporal resolution for the most recent past for the region. However, one sample (2.2 ± 0.7 cal ka BP) with DNA of narwhal, bearded seal, and ringed seal falls within the Roman Warm Period, which is a period of relatively higher temperatures in the context of the Late Holocene ~ 2.2–1.3 ka BP88, during which marine sediment cores in Baffin Bay have recorded increased intensity of the West Greenland Current36,50. In contrast, the youngest sample (0.2 ± 0.3 cal ka BP) contained only ringed seal DNA and fell within the Little Ice Age – the most recent cold period ca. 0.6 − 0.1 ka BP88 – where low intensity of the West Greenland Current has been recorded36,50. The absence of marine mammals in periods of colder climates and lower intensity of the West Greenland Current could point to a southward shift in distribution, as has been identified for bowhead whales during the Little Ice Age based on fossil remains89.
The opening of the Nares Strait
Our two northernmost cores, Lincoln Sea 12-GC (82.58° N) and Hall Basin 24PC (81.62° N) (Fig. 1a), provide unique insights into the Holocene history of marine mammal populations along the northernmost coast of Greenland. Today, the region is regarded as part of the ‘Last Ice Area’, where the persistence of multiyear sea ice may provide a refuge for Arctic species under global warming90. During the Late Pleistocene (19 − 13 ka BP), the narrow connection between northernmost Baffin Bay and the Lincoln Sea known as the Nares Strait was covered by shelf-based ice extending between the Ellesmere Island and Greenland ice sheets34. The retreat of shelf-based ice marks the opening of the Nares Strait ~ 9 cal ka BP, although sea ice is still pronounced throughout most of the year today51,91.
The Lincoln Sea 12-GC core, retrieved north-east of Hall Basin 24PC, extends back ~ 12 ka BP, whereas Hall Basin 24PC only covers the past 9.5 ka BP (Fig. 1c). We did not detect any marine mammal DNA in Lincoln Sea 12-GC > 8.4 cal ka BP (Fig. 3); the Early Holocene has been characterized as a period of seasonal sea ice and relatively higher primary productivity in the southern Lincoln Sea56. Even if the previous detection of the sea ice algae biomarker IP25 and primary productivity biomarker brassicasterol in the same core corresponding to the Early Holocene indicate suitable sea-surface conditions56, marine mammals may not have been able to access the habitat as long as the Nares Strait was covered by glacial ice. The first detection of marine mammal DNA (ringed seal; 8.4 ± 0.1 cal ka BP) supports this, occurring shortly after the opening of the Nares Strait ~ 9 cal ka BP51,91. At the same time, the detection of ringed seal DNA is in line with our findings for Melville Bay 26G and provides further evidence that ringed seals are the first marine mammals to move to newly accessible habitats38.
We provide evidence for the occurrence of narwhals in the Lincoln Sea by 7.9 ± 0.1 cal ka BP; we detected narwhal DNA in all samples < 7.9 cal ka BP from Lincoln Sea 12-GC (except one sample dated 5.3 ± 0.2 cal ka BP), and in five out of ten Hall Basin 24PC samples, indicating the presence of the species in the area at a density that is detectable in the cores (Fig. 3). Our findings suggest colonization of the newly accessible habitat by populations migrating north from Baffin Bay through Nares Strait occurred within a few hundred years of the strait opening. Although single narwhal observations have documented the species´ presence in the Nares Strait92–94, their northernmost recognised management unit (Smith Sound) lies further south (~ 78° N) and only partly includes Nares Strait. As our understanding of past and present distributions of narwhals improves, the consequences for current management units and marine protected areas will need to be considered, especially in the light of expected future northward distribution shifts8,95.
In the Hall Basin 24PC core (81.62° N), our DNA detections indicate a later establishment of marine mammals than for Lincoln Sea 12-GC, albeit the period 8.5–5 cal ka BP was only covered by two samples (7.3 & 8.1 cal ka BP, Fig. 3). A possible explanation may be the earlier retreat of the Ryder Glacier from the mouth of Sherard Osborn Fjord (estimated at > 10.7 ± 0.4 ka cal BP)32 relative to the retreat of the Petermann Glacier from the Petermann fjord mouth (estimated at 7.5 cal ka BP)96. Although the Lincoln Sea 12-GC core (in proximity to the Ryder Glacier) and Hall Basin 24PC core (in proximity to the Petermann Glacier) were collected outside the actual fjords, the dynamics of the two glaciers during the Holocene have had a strong impact on the marine ecosystems, as seen e.g. by the dramatic increase in the abundance of foraminifera < 8.5 cal ka BP in another Hall Basin marine sediment core (OD1507-18GC)58.
In the Mid-to-Late Holocene (5 − 2 cal ka BP), Hall Basin 24PC recorded the presence of harp seal, hooded seal, and beluga: three migratory species to the northernmost part of Baffin Bay, of which only harp and hooded seal have been observed north of 80° N in present-day and historic surveys (Fig. 4)61,67. Albeit based on a single sample, the detection of beluga DNA in Hall Basin 24PC at 2.5 ± 0.0 cal ka BP coincides with the timing of higher air temperatures (+ 0.9° C as compared to the pre-industrial average29), suggesting a northward distribution shift of the species during past warmer climates. This matches habitat suitability models, which predict a northward shift of suitable habitat from areas where belugas occur in summer today (~ 75° N) into parts of Nares Strait (~ 79° N), assuming warming < 2° C as compared to the pre-industrial average8.
In the Lincoln Sea 12-GC core, which is further north (82.58° N) than Hall Basin 24PC, all samples with hooded seal DNA were > 0.9 ± 0.3 cal ka BP, prior to the most recent re-advance of the Ryder glacier and the re-growth of its ice tongue to the outer sill of Sherard Osborn fjord at < 0.9 ka BP32, which may have negatively impacted habitat suitability for this species.
Episodic marine mammal detections in north-east Greenland over the past 10 ka
The marine ecosystem of the north-east Greenland shelf is shaped by the East Greenland Current (Fig. 1a), which transports cold water masses and > 90% of the sea ice exported from the Central Arctic Ocean into the North Atlantic97, and a deflected branch of the West Spitsbergen Current, which transports relatively warm and saline water masses from the North Atlantic98.
In sediment core North-East Greenland 73G (79.07° N), we identified several discrete periods over the past 10 ka where samples contained marine mammal DNA from multiple species, interspersed with episodes where samples were characterized by the absence or near-absence of marine mammal DNA (Fig. 4). Between 10 − 9 cal ka BP, we detected harp seal DNA. In the same period, sea ice biomarkers indicate conditions between open sea and dense drift ice (i.e. marginal ice zone conditions), high primary productivity, and elevated Atlantic water influence57,99. The environmental conditions may thus have facilitated the seasonal migration of harp seals further north than in periods with increased sea ice cover or low primary productivity. Between 9 − 8 cal ka BP, we recorded the near-absence of marine mammal DNA (Fig. 4e); a time interval characterized by relatively low sea ice algae productivity, low primary productivity, and low Atlantic water influence (Fig. 4c). In contrast, harp seal DNA occurs again (along with narwhal and ringed seal DNA) between 8–6.9 cal ka BP, a period with similar environmental conditions as 10 − 9 cal ka BP.
Between 6.9 cal ka BP and 4 cal ka BP, we retrieve DNA from bowhead whale, bearded seal, and ringed seal, but not harp seal. In this period, sea ice algae and primary productivity remained stable, while Atlantic water influence decreased notably after 6.5 cal ka BP (Fig. 4c). Similar to 9 − 8 cal ka BP, environmental conditions in the region may not have been favorable for harp seals, and their distribution may have shifted further south.
We only detected bowhead whale DNA in one sample 5.7 ± 0.2 cal ka BP, although the current presence of the species in this region has repeatedly been reported100,101. It has been hypothesized that bowhead whales were present in north-east Greenland in the Early Holocene38, based on their Early Holocene presence in Svalbard102, where the timing of the last deglaciation (and thus the availability of suitable habitat) was similar to north-east Greenland103,104. However, few bowhead whale fossils have to date been found in east Greenland; one Early Holocene record further south (72.08° N; 8.6 ± 0.1 cal ka BP)105, one Mid Holocene at the same latitude as our core (79.34° N; 5.0–5.7 cal ka BP)106 and one Mid Holocene record further north (81° N; 5.9 ± 0.1 cal ka BP)39.
A key difference between marine ecosystems around Svalbard and north-east Greenland is the interplay of currents transporting cold and warm water masses, leading to sea surface temperatures ~ 5°C lower on the north-east Greenland shelf, as compared to the Svalbard shelf107. Our low genetic detection of bowhead whales in marine sediments and rare fossil discoveries in the region suggest a limited past presence of the species along the east coast of Greenland.
After 3 cal ka BP, we did not identify DNA assigned to codfishes in any of the North-East Greenland 73G samples. We also did not detect DNA assigned to harp seal, which correlates with the detection of codfishes (Fig. S10). Overall, marine mammal detections are rare, with narwhal DNA recorded in five of 13 samples, and ringed seal DNA in three of 13 samples. The youngest sample (0.3 ± 0.1 cal ka BP) contained the highest number of sequences of any marine mammal (bearded seal) in this core. Both sea ice algal productivity and phytoplankton productivity increase slightly after 1 ka, pointing towards a shift in the environmental conditions that has been interpreted as reflecting the formation of the North-East Greenland polynya99. Polynyas are annually recurring ice-free areas in high latitudes characterized by high primary productivity that can support high abundances of Arctic species communities, including marine mammals85,108. In contrast to the North Water polynya (located in northernmost Baffin Bay), the history of the North-East Greenland polynya has so far received less attention99. Our findings of episodic rather than continuous detection of marine mammal DNA in the region encompassing the North-East Greenland polynya potentially reflects the instability of this marine ecosystem and vulnerability to climatic changes as has been inferred for the North Water polynya85.