Chemical Composition of CSP. The X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analysis reveals the chemical composition of cockle shell powder (CSP). As shown in Table 2., the predominant oxide in CSP is calcium oxide (CaO), comprising 46.55%, followed by silicon oxide (SiO₂). Other oxides present in CSP include sodium oxide (Na₂O), iron(III) oxide (Fe₂O₃), sulfur trioxide (SO₃), alumina oxide (Al₂O₃), magnesium oxide (MgO), potassium oxide (K₂O), and titanium dioxide (TiO₂), with concentrations of 0.333%, 0.285%, 0.0948%, 0.0771%, 0.0277%, and 0.0232%, respectively. According to Olivia (2017), the calcium oxide (CaO) found in seashells significantly enhances the physical and mechanical properties of the specimens. The amount of CaO is crucial for increasing the density and strength of the specimens. Furthermore, Nasution (2016) notes that the impact strength of the composite improves with higher compositions of cockle shell powder. Notably, cockle shells contain about 99.00% calcium oxide (CaO) (Hazurina Othman, 2013). However, the presence of CaO can also be interpreted as an indication of calcium carbonate (CaCO₃), which is converted to CaO during the thermal decomposition process (Sainudin, 2020).
Table 2
Mix Chemical Composition of CSP
Chemical composition (%)
|
CSP
|
---|
Calcium Oxide (Cao)
|
46.55
|
Silicon Oxide (SiO₂)
|
0.819
|
Sodium Oxide (Na₂O)
|
0.333
|
Iron III Oxide (Fe₂O₃)
|
0.285
|
Sulfur Trioxide (SO₃)
|
0.0948
|
Alumina Oxide (Al₂O₃)
|
0.0771
|
Magnesium Oxide (MgO)
|
0.0277
|
Potassium Oxide (K₂O)
|
0.0232
|
Titanium Dioxide (TiO₂)
|
-
|
LOI
|
-
|
Particle Size Distribution of CSP. Figure 6 illustrates the particle size distribution of cockle shell powder (CSP). The minimum size distribution of the powder passes through 75 µm. Observations indicate that the sieve size of 0.6 mm contains the highest weight accumulation of cockle shell powder. As the particle size of the ground cockle shell powder decreases, the decomposition rate of the cockle shell increases (M. Mohamed & Yousuf, 2012). Nasution (2016) notes that smaller particle sizes can enhance the composite interface area, thereby increasing impact strength. However, water absorption rises for all particle sizes of cockle shell powder due to the high hygroscopic nature of CSP, which is primarily composed of magnesium oxide (MgO) and calcium oxide (CaO).
Effect of CSP on the Workability. Fresh mortar with varying percentages of cockle shell powder (CSP) as a partial cement replacement was tested using the flow table test to determine workability. The results of the flow table test for the fresh mortar specimens are presented in Fig. 7. The consistency of the control mortar was higher than that of the mortar containing different percentages of CSP. The control mortar had a value of 114%, meeting the standard for mortar. However, when comparing the mortar containing different percentages of CSP, the 6% CSP mixture also achieved a consistency value of 114%, similar to the control. The lowest consistency values were recorded for the 9% and 12% CSP mixtures, with values of 113% and 112%, respectively.
The presence of CSP significantly affects the workability of the mortar, as the flow values decrease when CSP is added to the mixture. This decrease is due to the absorption properties of CSP, which reduce the workability of the mortar mix. According to Hazurina Othman (2013), when cockle shell powder is used, it reduces the water demand, leading to higher workability. However, as the percentage of CSP increases, more water is required. The high calcium oxide concentration in CSP accelerates the cement hydration reaction rate when incorporated into the mixture (Olivia, 2017).
Effect of CSP on the Compressive Strength. Figure 8 shows the compressive strength of the control mortar is higher than that of the mortar containing different percentages of cockle shell powder (CSP). The compressive strength of the control mortar at 7 days was 18.59 MPa. In comparison, the 6% CSP specimen achieved a strength of 18.14 MPa, which is nearly similar to that of the control sample. The lowest compressive strength values for 7 days among the CSP specimens were 14.83 MPa for 3%, 14.64 MPa for 9%, and 14.67 MPa for 12% CSP.
At 28 days, the compressive strength of the control sample was recorded at 23.68 MPa, while the 6% CSP mixture exhibited a strength nearly equivalent to the control sample. The lowest compressive strength values at 28 days for the CSP specimens were 20.55 MPa for 3%, 19.21 MPa for 9%, and 20.81 MPa for 12% CSP. The strength of the mortar increases with longer curing durations. Calcium silicate hydrate (C-S-H), a product of cement hydration, is formed when water reacts with the minerals alite and belite (Silva, 2020). The high CaO content in cockle shell powder can slow down hydration, reducing strength during the early stages of curing. However, the increase in strength becomes more pronounced with extended curing periods (Hazurina Othman, 2013).
According to Lertwattanaruk (2012), increasing the curing time positively affects compressive strength, although the strength remains lower than that of the control sample. Etuk (2012) found that the compressive strength of specimens decreased as the amount of partial replacement increased in the mortar mix. As the percentage of CSP replacement increases, the strength of the mortar specimens tends to decline because cockle shell powder contains less reactive material compared to Portland cement (Abdelouahed, 2019). Based on the testing, the optimum percentage of CSP as a partial cement replacement is 6%, as its compressive strength is nearly equivalent to that of the control sample.
Effect of CSP on the Water Absorption. Figure 9 shows the water absorption of the control mortar is lower than that of the mortar containing different percentages of cockle shell powder (CSP). The water absorption value for the control mortar at 7 days was 11.42%. In comparison, the specimens with 6% and 12% CSP recorded values of 11.53%, which is nearly similar to that of the control sample. The lowest water absorption values for 7 days among the CSP specimens were 10.64% for 3% CSP and 10.14% for 9% CSP.
At 28 days, the water absorption value for the control mortar sample was 9.12%. The 6% CSP replacement exhibited a water absorption of 9.75%, which is close to that of the control sample. In contrast, the 3%, 9%, and 12% CSP specimens recorded higher water absorption values of 11.17%, 11.79%, and 10.09%, respectively. The water absorption at 28 days increased proportionally from the 7-day results for the 3% and 9% CSP replacements, which can be attributed to the higher porosity of the specimens containing cockle shell.
According to Zhang (2019), the porous nature of materials and their permeability significantly influence the rate of absorption and liquid transfer. Therefore, materials with high permeability exhibit a higher absorption rate. For the 6% and 12% CSP replacements, the water absorption value decreased at 28 days due to the increased compactness of the cockle seashell mortar, resulting in a reduced number of capillary voids. Capillary voids are particularly significant in cockle shell mortar, facilitating the formation of new products during the hydration of cement (Abdelouahed, 2019). Overall, the specimen containing 6% CSP exhibited the lowest water absorption, confirming it as the optimum percentage for partial cement replacement.
Microstructural Analysis of Mortar. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) was conducted to analyze the microstructural characteristics of the cockle shell powder (CSP) mortar. Figure 10 displays the morphology of the CSP mortar at magnifications of 5000x and 10000x. From Fig. 10, it can be observed that the CSP mortar exhibits an angular and irregular texture due to the varying particle size distribution resulting from the grinding process. Additionally, it reveals a calcite crystal pattern and structure. According to Hariharan (2014), a solid-state displacement reaction begins during the mechanical milling of the reaction powder mix, leading to irregular particle distribution and form.
Meanwhile, Fig. 11 presents the Energy Dispersive X-ray (EDX) analysis of the CSP mortar. The primary elements in the CSP mortar are composed of Oxygen (59.45%), Carbon (21.65%), Calcium (21.65%), and Silicon (0.98%), with oxygen being the most abundant element. The presence of calcium indicates the incorporation of CSP within the mortar. According to Islam (2011), there are three distinct types of calcium: calcite, aragonite, and vaterite. Ca(OH)₂ can carbonate without an organic substrate, resulting in the formation of calcite crystals. Cockle shells serve as a naturally clean source of calcium carbonate polymorphs, primarily aragonite. However, high temperatures convert the aragonite polymorph to calcite, which is thermodynamically the most stable form (Hariharan, 2014).