This study elucidates the role of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs) in the occurrence, progression, diagnosis, and prognosis of stroke, leveraging existing scRNA-seq and bulk RNA-seq datasets. Due to the lack of post-stroke human brain data, we analyzed scRNA-seq data from the brains of mice subjected to middle cerebral artery occlusion (MCAO) at five critical time points—3 hours, 12 hours, 1 day, 2 days, and 3 days post-stroke—to observe NETs function during the transition from the hyperacute to the acute phase. Simultaneously, we utilized bulk RNA-seq data from human peripheral blood at three time points post-stroke (3 hours, 5 hours, and 1 day) to integrate with our mouse brain data, providing a comprehensive view of NETs evolution and their impact on stroke progression and prognosis. This integration also supports the development of a diagnostic model for rapidly identifying hyperacute stroke, potentially enhancing the efficacy of thrombolysis and mechanical thrombectomy interventions.
Ischemic stroke initiates with thrombus formation, obstructing cerebral blood supply. Traditionally linked to aberrant platelet activation and dysregulated blood coagulation, the past decade has broadened our understanding to include the significant role of peripheral immune cells, such as monocytes and neutrophils, in thrombus development19, aligning with our assessments of immune cell infiltration in the whole blood of post-stroke patients. Notably in 2017, study demonstrated substantial neutrophil and NETs accumulation in stroke-related thrombi, with elevated plasma NETs levels20, consistent with our evaluation of NET expression in whole blood. This suggests a profound connection between NETs and thrombus formation. Recent studies have elucidated various mechanisms by which NETs promote thrombosis, such as their DNA serving as a scaffold for F12 to activate the coagulation cascade, and their histones recruiting and activating platelets via TLR2 and TLR421. Current research on NETs in thrombosis has largely focused on the effects of individual components rather than the holistic role of NET structure itself. Utilizing a bioinformatics approach, we conducted a comprehensive evaluation of NETs, analyzing their interactions with other cells and pathways to uncover previously neglected targets. Our findings link NET expression in stroke patients to critical biological processes including hypoxia, glycolysis, inflammatory responses, and the JAK/STAT pathway. This aligns with existing literature indicating the JAK/STAT pathway's role in neutrophil activation and NET release22, the dual role of inflammation in stimulating and being exacerbated by NETs, and the contribution of reduced glycolysis to decreased NET production23. Notably, while hypoxia has been implicated in NET formation in contexts such as gastric cancer24, its specific relationship to NETs in ischemic stroke remains unexplored. Considering the frequent co-occurrence of hypoxia and inflammation in stroke, we hypothesize that hypoxia significantly contributes to NET formation, presenting an overlooked yet critical area of study in ischemic stroke's pathophysiology.
We propose that the effects of NETs following the onset of IS can be broadly categorized into effects within the brain and those in the periphery. Peripherally, NETs primarily contribute to thrombus stability. Evidence indicates that thrombi in patients who experience stroke onset beyond 4.5 hours contain significantly increased NET levels25. Intriguingly, older thrombi not only show denser NETs accumulations but also display enhanced resistance to dissolution26. Although the specific mechanisms underlying thrombus reinforcement by NETs remain largely unexplored, our data reveal a marked increase in NETs expression in the stroke group compared to controls. Notably, the concentration of NETs peaks at five hours post-onset and remains at a relatively high level throughout the day. This sustained elevation likely plays a critical role in maintaining thrombus stability. We propose that these persistently elevated NET levels are essential for thrombus reinforcement, representing a potential target for therapeutic intervention to mitigate the progression of ischemic damage.
Moreover, current research predominantly focuses on the interaction between platelets and neutrophils, while neglecting to discuss the relationships between neutrophils and other immune cells in the periphery. Although certain studies suggest that in mice, monocytes, NETs and platelets may collaborate to facilitate thrombus formation27, such research is inherently limited by the species and thus remains superficial. According to our findings, we observed no correlation between NETs and M0 macrophages or M2 macrophages in the control group of human whole blood. Conversely, in the stroke group, a significant positive correlation emerged among these cells. These results imply that macrophages may become activated following thrombus formation and subsequently engage in interactions with NETs. Such interactions could potentially contribute to maintaining high levels of NETs or reinforcing thrombi.
Currently, many researchers believe that the primary roles of NETs in the brain involve breaching the blood-brain barrier (BBB), exacerbating neuronal death, hindering vascular remodeling, and promoting inflammation21. Owing to the brief lifespan of neutrophils, their limited absolute numbers in the brain, and the intricate architecture of the brain, the spatiotemporal distribution of neutrophils in the brain following stroke remains poorly understood, particularly regarding temporal dynamics. Some studies suggest that neutrophils begin to appear in the brain as early as 12 hours following tMCAO, peaking within 1–2 days28. Other studies contend that due to neutrophil accumulation in the peri-infarct cortex, the greatest accumulation of neutrophils in the cortex and striatum is observable on day 3 post-cerebral ischemia23. Conversely, in certain transient MCAO models, only a minority of ischemic mice exhibit substantial neutrophil infiltration within the first day, while generally the number of neutrophils increases on days 2 and 429. Our findings generally support the first notion, indicating that neutrophils infiltrate the brain as early as 12 hours post-insult, reaching a maximum by the second day and declining by the third day. In essence, we have elucidated the temporal trajectory of neutrophils in the brain following MCAO from a single-cell perspective.
To date, analyses of neutrophils and NETs in post-stroke brains have predominantly been limited to tissue sections, lacking integration with single-cell RNA sequencing to thoroughly explore neutrophil clusters and their specific roles. Our study fills this gap in the field, providing a detailed landscape of neutrophil dynamics in MCAO mice from 3 hours to 3 days. Initially, we identified seven neutrophil clusters. The Mmp8 + neutrophil cluster are extremely sensitive to chemokines, and they first respond to chemokines into the brain. Given its high expression of Mmp8, we speculate that it may disrupt the BBB through MMPs related pathways30, resulting in sustained entry of peripheral immune cells into the brain and mediating deleterious effects during the acute phase of IS.
The C1qc + neutrophil cluster, responsive secondarily to chemokines, predominantly migrates towards the stroke-affected hemisphere and may undergo a transformation into Mbnl2 + neutrophils. We propose a novel hypothesis: this transformation could involve C1qc + neutrophils releasing mitochondrial DNA to form NETs21, subsequently transitioning into Mbnl2 + neutrophils. Analysis of mitochondrial gene expression across different clusters revealed that Mbnl2 + neutrophils exhibit notably lower mitochondrial levels compared to the high levels in C1qc + neutrophils (Figure S1h), supporting our hypothesis. Functionally, enrichment analysis suggests that these transformations may be linked to processes such as cytoplasmic translation and protein folding, potentially enhancing NETs production. Intriguingly, at 1 day post-stroke, Mbnl2 + neutrophils show a significant increase in communication frequency and intensity with C1qc + neutrophils relative to the sham group (Figure S3g), suggesting a tight association and a possible feedback mechanism that promotes this phenotypic shift. While past research has predominantly focused on lytic NETs formation, our findings emphasize the significance of C1qc + neutrophils, potentially opening a new perspective on NETs in stroke research, particularly regarding mitochondrial NETs formation, an underexplored area.
At 2d, the expression of NETs reaches its peak, whereas by 3d, there is a comprehensive decline in both neutrophil count and NET expression: The NET expression in the stroke group even falls below that of the sham group, with the ipsilateral stroke side exhibiting lower NET expression than the contralateral side. The Mmp8 + neutrophils, which contribute most to NET production, show a significant decrease in their NET expression at 3d. Neutrophils, which dominate cellular communication, revert to levels comparable to those in the sham group at 3d. We speculate that this may signify functional exhaustion of neutrophils within the brain.
Notably, by 3d, our cellular communication analyses reveal a significant increase in the number and strength of communication between macrophages/microglia and Mbnl2 + neutrophils. Thus, we propose that the neutrophil exhaustion observed at 3d could be related to the phagocytic clearance of NETs and neutrophils by these scavenger cells23.
Consequently, based on the analysis of neutrophil proportions and pseudotime ordering, we propose the following timeline for the differential neutrophil clusters: 1. Mmp8 + neutrophils are the first responders to chemokines, rapidly infiltrating the brain where they produce NETs and participate in the disruption of the BBB. 2. C1qc + neutrophils, as the second wave of chemoattractant-responsive cells, preferentially migrate to the stroke-affected hemisphere and undergo conversion within the hemisphere into Mbnl2 + neutrophils. This transformation may occur through a mechanism involving mitochondrial NETs formation. 3. The transformed Mbnl2 + neutrophils accumulate within the brain tissue and are gradually cleared by macrophages and microglia. Our work provides a clearer understanding of neutrophil dynamics in the brain, furnishing more precise information and references for the identification of therapeutic targets.
Presently, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) endorses only two therapeutic strategies for IS: pharmacological thrombolysis with tissue plasminogen activator (tPA) and mechanical thrombectomy 31. The time window for tPA is limited to 4.5 hours, and delays in acquiring medical imaging results often jeopardize timely treatment for many patients32. Thus, developing a rapid, simple and robust method for initial screening of suspected patients is crucial for their treatment and prognosis. Analysis of clinical samples has revealed that virtually all thrombi in stroke patients contain NETs, with plasma levels of NETs also being elevated20. Consequently, we propose that NETs represent a highly promising peripheral blood biomarker for stroke. Through differential analysis and WGCNA, we identified key genes associated with NETs in the peripheral blood of stroke patients. Leveraging machine learning techniques, we established a straightforward and robust linear model capable of identifying patients in the hyperacute stage of stroke. This model achieved the AUC value exceeding 0.98 in both training and validation cohort, with minimal variation influenced by gender or age. These findings underscore the remarkable robustness and vast potential of our model.F12, that is Factor XII (FXII), is the zymogen of serine protease factor XIIa (FXIIa)33. It has been reported that F12 –/– mice have reduced thrombosis, but normal hemostasis, and several substances supporting FXII autoactivation have been identified, which contain NETs33. In addition, the mechanism by which it interacts with NETs to generate thrombi has been addressed earlier. Plexin domain containing 2 (PLXDC2), also known as TEM7R, is a member of the tumor endothelial marker (TEM) family34. PLXDC2 has been identified as a regulator of several brain activities, including the coordinated control of proliferation and cell fate specification along and across the neuroaxis35, which has been reported in a few pieces of literature that it can be coordinated with the remaining nine genes to diagnose IS 36.
Building on our primary findings, the subsequent validation through targeted in vitro and in vivo experiments provides crucial biological insights that not only support our computational predictions but also deepen our understanding of their clinical implications. The observed consistency across different experimental settings underscores the reliability of our data and presents a compelling case for the translational potential of our findings. The in vitro validation using OGD to simulate ischemic conditions significantly reinforces the biological relevance and mechanistic understanding of NETs formation and SN gene expression changes in response to stroke-like conditions. Notably, the alterations in NET formation and subsequent gene expression changes observed in neutrophils provide compelling evidence supporting our bioinformatics predictions and underline the sensitivity of these cells to ischemic conditions. These observations are pivotal as they not only validate the robustness of our computational analyses but also provide a mechanistic link to potential therapeutic targets. Furthermore, our in vivo experiments employing the tMCAO model demonstrate significant changes in peripheral blood levels of key SN genes post-cerebral ischemia. This highlights the translational potential of these biomarkers for early detection and monitoring of stroke progression in a clinical setting. The consistency between our in vitro and in vivo findings not only strengthens the case for these SN genes as reliable biomarkers but also advances our understanding of the cellular dynamics at play during the hyperacute phase of ischemic stroke.
The key to the treatment and prognosis of IS lies in the reperfusion of the brain; however, current thrombolytic agents are constrained by a narrow therapeutic time window, inconsistent efficacy, and potential side effects. Evidence suggests that NETs within thrombi increase over time following stroke onset, rendering clots more rigid and resistant to lysis26. This observation partly elucidates why the therapeutic window for thrombolysis is so brief and its efficacy unpredictable. Besides dissolving existing NETs, inhibiting further NETs formation is equally vital. We postulate that peripheral NETs induction might be linked to the Jak/Stat signaling pathway, implying that blocking this pathway could be pivotal. Furthermore, we speculate that peripheral blood macrophages may contribute to sustained NETs generation, presenting another potential target. To facilitate further investigation, we constructed a ceRNA network focusing on peripheral SN genes. Within the brain, we have characterized distinct neutrophil clusters and inferred their roles, suggesting that Mmp8 + neutrophils could be a target during the acute phase of stroke, potentially pivotal in alleviating BBB damage. Meanwhile, C1qc + neutrophils are postulated as a primary source of NETs; targeting their clearance and inhibition may reduce NETs production, thereby mitigating cerebral tissue destruction.
Our study has several limitations. Firstly, although we utilized single-cell technologies to map the temporal and functional landscape of neutrophils, our findings are constrained by the use of murine models, which may not fully replicate the intracranial environment of human patients. Secondly, the dataset we used lacks sufficient time points, and the sample size for constructing diagnostic models was limited. Lastly, while our experimental validation addressed key aspects, further functional and predictive testing are required to fully substantiate our hypotheses.
Despite these limitations, the pioneering findings of our study have opened numerous avenues for further research and practical applications. The elucidation of neutrophils' roles and their dynamic transitions within the context of stroke sets the stage for more targeted investigations into their mechanistic contributions, both in animal models and potentially in human clinical settings. These insights are pivotal for refining our models and deepening our understanding of stroke pathophysiology. Moving forward, we aim to expand our dataset and refine our methodologies to address the identified gaps, thereby enhancing the reliability and applicability of our findings to broader clinical scenarios.