3.1.1 Shoot fresh weight
The shoot fresh weight of Brassica juncea showed highly significantly results in both fertilizer and salt stress treatment, but their interaction was not significant (Table 2). Peels (eggshell + banana peel) treatment notably increased shoot fresh weight by 9%, whereas the combination of peels and Bacillus megaterium resulted in only a 1% increase under non-stress condition. Compared to the control, the combined treatment of B. megaterium with peels and NPK was statistically significant. Under 150 mM salt stress, shoot fresh weight decreased by 43% relative to the control (Fig. 1A). However, all treatments showed a positive response to salt stress. The peels treatment revealed the highest increase in shoot fresh weight by 37%, while the NPK treatment had the lowest increase by 4%. Overall, all treatments significantly enhanced shoot fresh weight under salt stress condition.
Table 2
Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on Shoot fresh weight, Shoot dry weight, Root fresh weight, Root dry weight, Shoot length, Root length, Leaf area and Leaf number under salinity stress.
Source | Df | Shoot fresh weight | Shoot dry weight | Root fresh weight | Root dry weight | Shoot length | Root length | Number of leaves | Leaf area |
Fertilizer | 4 | 57.064167 *** | 0.1265*** | 0.317955*** | 0.0046967*** | 267.9*** | 17.234917*** | 18625*** | 18625*** |
NaCl | 1 | 1133.4453 *** | 6.88323*** | 2.7240533*** | 0.0048133*** | 1604.5453*** | 114.66075 *** | 290083.33*** | 290083.33*** |
Fertilizer*NaCl | 4 | 13.936167* | 0.0177133 ns | 0.024995* | 2.1333e-4 ns | 22.968667* | 0.6149167 ns | 3208.3333 ns | 3208.3333 ns |
Error | 20 | 3.521<- | 0.0066067<- | 0.0065467<- | 1.9667e-4<- | 7.347<- | 0.4799167<- | 1250<- | 1250<- |
3.1.2 Shoot dry weight
In case of shoot dry weight of Brassica juncea revealed highly significant effects under salt stress and fertilizer treatment, while the interaction between fertilizer and NaCl was non-significant (Table 2). Compared to the control, all treatments positively enhanced shoot dry weight under non-stress conditions, with the maximum increase of 7% observed in the peel powder treatment and the minimum increase of 2% in the NPK treatment. Salt stress significantly reduced shoot dry weight by 32%. However, peels, B. Megaterium, their combination and NPK treatment mitigated the harmful effects of salt stress and improved shoot dry weight compared to the control. Under salt stress, the peels treatment resulted in the maximum increase of 24% in shoot dry weight, while B. megaterium treatment showed a minimum increase of 6% compared to control (Fig. 1B).
3.1.3 Root fresh weight
The analysis of variance for the root fresh weight of Brassica juncea showed that NaCl treatment and fertilizer had a highly significant effect, including their interaction (Table 2). Compared to the control, peels treatment showed highest increase by 22% in root fresh weight, while smallest increase by 3% from NPK fertilizer. under non-stress conditions. All treatments (peels, B. megaterium, peel + B. megaterium, and NPK fertilizer) increased root fresh weight under no stress. Under salt stress, root fresh weight decreased by 28% compared to the control. However, all treatments improved the root fresh weight by 43%, 12%, 12%, and 9%, respectively, under salinity stress (Fig. 1C). Among these, the peel treatment showed a significant effect under salt stress, while B. megaterium combined with peel and NPK treatments were not statistically significant.
3.1.4 Root dry weight
Root dry weight of Brassica juncea showed highly significant effects under salinity stress and fertilizer application, but their interaction was non-significant (Table 2). Compared to the control, all treatments enhanced root dry weight under non-stress conditions, with the maximum increase of 50% observed in peels treatment and the minimum increase of 21% in the NPK treatment. Peels treatment reveals statistically highly significant effect, while B. megaterium and NPK treatment showed non-significant effect under non-stress conditions. Root dry weight was reduced by 19% under NaCl stress compared to the control (Fig. 1D). Under salt stress, all treatments positively affected root dry weight, with the peel’s treatment showing the highest increase of 54% and NPK showed the lowest increase of 41% compared to the control.
3.1.5 Shoot length
Highly significant effects on shoot length in Brassica juncea were observed under salinity stress and fertilizer treatment. The interaction between fertilizer and NaCl was significant (Table 2). All treatments increased shoot length compared to the control without salt stress, with highest increase (18%) was observed from the combine treatment. Peels treatment alone increased shoot length by 17%, B. megaterium by 5%, and NPK by 2%. NaCl decreased shoot length by 28%. Under salt stress, all treatments improved shoot length, with peels treatment having the most significant effect, increasing shoot length by 44%. B. megaterium increased shoot length by 18%, the peel powder and B. megaterium combination by 28%, and NPK by 5% under salt stress (Fig. 2A).
3.1.6 Root length
The root length of Brassica juncea exhibited highly significant results under both fertilizer and salt stress, with a non-significant interaction between fertilizer and NaCl (Table 2). The combined treatment of peels and B. megaterium resulted in the maximum increase of 29% in root length compared to the control under non-stress conditions. Peels, B. megaterium and NPK treatments increased root length by 23%, 21%, and 6%, respectively, compared to the control without stress (Fig. 2B). B. megaterium, peels, and their combination combine treatment showed statistically non-significant with each other. Root length decreased by 36% under salt stress compared to the control. All treatments positively affected root length under salt stress, with the combined treatments showing the highest increase of 55%, and NPK showing the smallest increase of 1%. Peels and B. megaterium treatments showed non-significant effect, while their combination was highly significant effect under salt stress.
3.1.7 Number of leaves plant− 1
The analysis of variance data showed that both salt stress and fertilizer treatments had highly significant effects on the number of leaves in Brassica juncea. The interaction between salinity and fertilizer was non-significant (Table 2). All treatments positively affected leaf area compared to the control without salt stress. The maximum increase in leaf number (22%) was observed with peel treatment, while the minimum increase (3%) was with NPK fertilizer. B. megaterium and its combination with peel treatment increased leaf number by 3% and 13%, respectively, compared to the control without stress. Salt stress reduced the number of leaves by 22%. Under salinity stress, peels treatment increased the number of leaves by 28%, B. megaterium by 8%, NPK increased 12% compared to control (Fig. 2C).
3.1.8 Total leaf area plant− 1
In case of leaf area of Brassica juncea showed highly significant effects under salinity stress and fertilizer treatment, with a non-significant interaction between salinity and fertilizer (Table 2). All treatments increased leaf area compared to the control without salt stress. The maximum increase in leaf area (27%) was observed with peels treatment, while the minimum increase (14%) was with the combination of peels and B. megaterium treatment (Fig. 2D). B. megaterium and NPK treatments increased leaf area by 20% and 16%, respectively, compared to the control without stress. Salt stress significantly reduced leaf area by 16%. Under salt stress, peel powder treatment increased leaf area by 6%, B. megaterium by 8%, and their combination by 3%. NPK and the combination treatment were statistically non-significant under salt stress.
3.2 Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on Physiological parameters of Brassica juncea under salinity stress.
3.2.1 Net CO2 assimilation rate
Brassica juncea plant showed highly significant effect under fertilizer and NaCl treatment in net CO2 assimilation rate (A). Interaction between fertilizer and NaCl also highly significant (Table 3). All treatments elevated the assimilation rate when compared with control no addition of stress. Maximum increase 67% in CO2 assimilation rate was observed with peels treatment. In relation to control, B. megaterium treatment increase 53%, its combine form increased 44% and NPK treatment increase 51% in CO2 assimilation rate with no addition of stress. NaCl showed negative response and decrease 29% in CO2 assimilation rate in relation to control. But all treatments were improved the CO2 assimilation rate when compared with control under salt stress. B. megaterium treatment showed highly significant effect and it resulted maximum increase 86% in CO2 assimilation rate when compared with control under salt stress. Peels treatment increase 26%, combine treatment increase 76% and NPK increase 49% in CO2 assimilation rate when compared with control under salt stress. (Fig. 3A).
Table 3
Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on SPAD value, Intercellular CO2 concentration (ci), Stomatal conductance (gs), Rate of photosynthesis (A), Rate of transpiration (E), Variable fluorescence (Fv), Maximal fluorescence (Fm), Maximum quantum yield of photosystem II (Fv/Fm), Minimal fluorescence (Fo) and Fv/Fo ratio, Water potential, Osmotic potential and turgor potential under salinity stress.
Source | Df | SPAD value | Ci | gs | A | E | Fo | Fm | Fv | Fv/Fo | Fv/Fm | Water potential | Osmotic potential | Turgor potential |
Fertilizer | 4 | 33.5753*** | 2813.1333 *** | 0.010521*** | 99.642872*** | 0.038845*** | 262.86667*** | 9056.2833*** | 12008.58*** | 2.0050083*** | 0.014227*** | 830*** | 13429.917*** | 8589.9167*** |
NaCl | 1 | 168.033*** | 3763.2*** | 0.0644033*** | 361.08821*** | 0.28812*** | 720.3 *** | 82477.633*** | 104430*** | 5.0939681*** | 0.14686*** | 6750*** | 65894.533*** | 30464.533*** |
Fertilizer*NaCl | 4 | 7.69333** | 369.7 ** | 0.00346** | 30.186988*** | 0.039761*** | 70.8 ns | 5834.7167*** | 6628.083*** | 0.1443325ns | 0.0014378* | 33.333333ns | 1110.2833* | 1061.95* |
Error | 20 | 1.6633333<- | 82.566667<- | 7.1e-4<- | 2.4293033<- | 0.0038267<- | 36.3<- | 511.86667<- | 572.3<- | 0.0763984<- | 4.564e-4<- | 56.666667<- | 323.56667<- | 319.23333<- |
3.2.2 Stomatal conductance (gs)
The stomatal conductance of Brassica juncea plants was affected and showed highly significant results in both fertilizer and NaCl treatment. Interaction between fertilizer and NaCl was significant (Table 3). In comparison to control, all treatments showed positive response and enhanced the stomatal conductance with no addition of stress. Maximum increase (65%) of stomatal conductance was observed in peel treatment while minimum increase 40% was found in combine treatment with no addition of stress (Fig. 3B). Compared to control B. megaterium treatment increase 42% while NPK treatment increase 43% with no addition of stress. NaCl treatment showed highly significant results and effectively reduced 42% of stomatal conductance. Maximum increase 39% of stomatal conductance was observed in combine treatment and minimum increase 20% was observed in both peel and NPK treatment under salt stress respective to their control.
3.2.3 Intercellular CO2 concentration (Ci)
In case of intercellular CO2 (ci) concentration Brassica juncea plant showed highly significant result in both NaCl and fertilizer treatment. Interaction between NaCl and fertilizer was significant (Table 3) All treatments showed positive response and increased the ci concentration compared to control without stress plant. Maximum increase (25%) in ci was observed with treatment of peels and minimum increase 20% was found in NPK treatment with no addition of stress. B. megaterium treatment enhanced 24% ci concentration and its combine form enhanced 22% compared with control no addition of stress. Ci concentration was remarkably affected due to salt stress. Ci concentration reduced 4% in parallel to control (Fig. 3C). Under salt stress all treatments improved the ci concentration. Ci concentration of Brassica juncea increased by 12%, with Peels treatment. B. megaterium treatment increased by 21%, its combine form increased 24% and NPK treatment increased by 9% under salt stress.
3.2.4 Transpiration rate
Salt stress significantly affected the transpiration rate of Brassica juncea and reduced particularly 14% in parallel to control. Interaction between fertilizer and NaCl was highly significant (Table 3). As compare to control, peels treatment improved the transpiration rate. Maximum increase (38%) of transpiration rate was observed in peels treatment compared to control with no addition of stress. Moreover, B. megaterium treatment increase 27%, its combine form increased 5% and NPK treatment increase 21% of transpiration rate in contrast to control with no addition of stress (Fig. 3D). Under salt stress all treatments showed highly significant effect and elevated the rate of transpiration. Maximum increase (22%) of transpiration rate found with combine treatment under salt stress. However, B. megaterium treatment increase 14%, peels treatment increased 6% and NPK treatment increase 19% rate of transpiration under salt stress.
3.2.5 Total chlorophyll content (SPAD value)
In Brassica juncea plant the SPAD value revealed highly significant effect under salt stress and fertilizer treatment. Interaction between salinity and fertilizer was significant (Table 3). All treatments showed remarkable response and increase the SPAD value relative to control with no addition of salt stress. Maximum increase 15% in SPAD value was observed with NPK treatment. When compare to control plant, peels treatment increased 14%, B. megaterium treatment increase 6% and combine treatment increase 6% in SPAD value with no addition of salt stress (Fig. 4A). In comparison NPK and B. megaterium showed statistically non-significant results while peels treatment and its combine form showed significant effect in contrast to control to with no addition of salt stress. NaCl showed negative response and reduced 10% in SPAD value opposed to control. But all treatments were improved the SPAD value respective to their control in salt stress. Peel treatment showed highly significant effect and it resulted maximum increase 14% in SPAD value under salt stress. B. megaterium increased treatment increase 7%, combine treatment increase 12% and NPK increase 7% in SPAD value under salt stress.
3.2.6 Water Potential
The result showed that Brassica juncea exhibited highly significant changes in water potential under both NaCl and fertilizer treatments. The significant interaction between them (Table 3). Compared to control, peels treatment showed the greatest increase in water potential (66%), while the lowest increase (22%) was observed with NPK in the absence of stress. B. megaterium treatment enhanced water potential by 33%, and the combined treatment (B. megaterium + peels) increased it by 44% compared to control without stress. Under salt stress, water potential decreased by 39% relative to the control, but all treatments still showed positive effects. Peels treatment resulted in the highest increase in water potential (73%), while B. megaterium and NPK treatment caused the lowest increase (27%) under salt stress (Fig. 4B). Statistically significant differences were observed among B. megaterium, peels, their combination, and NPK treatments under salt stress conditions.
3.2.7 Osmotic potential
In case of osmotic potential of Brassica juncea showed highly significant effects under both NaCl and fertilizer treatments, with a significant interaction between NaCl and fertilizer (Table 3). Compared to control, peels and its combine treatment resulted highest increase in osmotic potential (16%), whereas NPK showed the lowest increase (6%) without stress. B. megaterium treatment improved osmotic potential by 11%, compared to control without stress. Under salt stress, osmotic potential decreased by 13% relative to the control, but all treatments still showed positive effects. B. megaterium treatment led to greatest increase in osmotic potential (18%), peels treatment increase (17%), while NPK resulted in the lowest increase (10%) under salt stress (Fig. 4C).
3.2.8 Turgor pressure
Turgor potential of Brassica juncea plants showed highly significant result under fertilizer and NaCl treatments. The interaction was significant between NaCl and fertilizer (Table 3). All treatment showed positive results compared to control. Combine treatment had highest increase in turgor potential (14%), while NPK treatment had lowest increase (5%) without stress plant. B. megaterium treatment improved turgor potential by 9%, and the peel treatment increased it by 12% relative to the control without stress. Under salt stress, turgor potential decreased by 10% compared to the control, but all treatments still revealed positive effects relative to this stress condition. The B. megaterium treatment achieved the maximum increase in turgor potential (17%), whereas the minimum increase was observed with peels and NPK treatment (9%) and combine treatment increase (16%) under salt stress (Fig. 4D).
3.2.9 Chlorophyll fluorescence
Chlorophyll fluorescence parameters responded variably to different treatments, including Bacillus megaterium, peels, their combined form, and NPK, as well as under salt stress (Table 3). The minimal fluorescence (F₀) showed weak modulation across all treatments, had a negligible effect on the basal level of PSII activity and F₀ increase by (17%) under salt stress (Fig. 5A). However, maximum fluorescence (Fm) elevated with treatment of Bacillus megaterium, peels, their combination and NPK, showed an improvement in the efficiency of the photosynthetic apparatus. Fm greatest increase was observed by (34%) in peels treatment without stress plant. Salt stress affected the Fₘ and it decrease 10% due to detrimental impact of salinity on PSII efficiency (Fig. 5B). But all treatments respond positively under salt stress. Combined treatment increased by 23% of Fm under salt stress. In case of Variable fluorescence Fv all treatments behaved positively and enhanced. Maximum Fv found in peels treatment by 52% compared to control without stress plant. Salinity stress reduced the Fv by 20% but all treatment still responds positively under salinity stress (Fig. 5C). Maximum Fv was observed in combined treatment by 42% under salinity stress. Furthermore, the Fv/F₀ ratio denotes variable fluorescence to minimal fluorescence, reduced by 32% under salt stress may be reduction in the photochemical efficiency of PSII. This decline emphasizes the adverse effect of salinity on the photosynthetic process. while the treatments elevated system performance and showed maximum Fv/F₀ ratio by 42% compared to control without stress and 66% in peels treatment under salinity stress (Fig. 6A). The FV/Fm ratio revealed maximum increase by 19% in NPK treatment compared to control, while Bacillus megaterium and peels treatment showed increases by 13% and 17% respectively under no salt stress. Under NaCl stress all treatments improved FV/Fm ratio, with peels treatment showing the highest increase by 17%. Bacillus megaterium, combined and NPK treatment resulted in 17%, 14%, and 4% increases, respectively, under salt stress. Salt stress reduced FV/Fm ratio by 17% (Fig. 6B).
3.2.10 Chlorophyll a
Chlorophyll a content in Brassica juncea exhibited highly significant effects under salt stress and fertilizer treatments. The interaction between salinity and fertilizer also being highly significant (Table 4). All treatments positively affected chlorophyll a content compared to the control without salt stress. The maximum increase of 18% in chlorophyll a was observed with the combined treatment, while the minimum increase of 2% was observed with NPK fertilizer. Peels treatment increased chlorophyll a by 17%, B. megaterium by 5%, and NPK by 2% compared to the control without stress. NaCl treatment significantly reduced chlorophyll a by 28% compared to the control (Fig. 7A). Under salt stress, all treatments improved chlorophyll a compared to the control. Peels treatment showed the highest increase (44%), B. megaterium (18%), the peel + B. megaterium combination (28%), and NPK (5%). B. megaterium and their combination treatment were statistically significant under salt stress, whereas NPK was non-significant.
Table 4
Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on Relative water content (RWC), Relative membrane permeability (RMP), Malondialdehyde (MDA), Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), Chlorophyll A (ch a), Chlorophyll B (ch b) and carotenoids under salinity stress.
Source | Df | RWC | RMP | MDA | H2O2 | Ch a | Ch b | Carotenoids |
Fertilizer | 4 | 269.38333 *** | 204.13333*** | 8.425013*** | 0.1322144*** | 4.3987e-4*** | 1.5469e-4*** | 1.4591704 *** |
NaCl | 1 | 1128.5333*** | 496.13333*** | 138.5824*** | 0.5837238*** | 0.0027906*** | 0.001509*** | 30.02731*** |
Fertilizer*NaCl | 4 | 19.95* | 41.966667*** | 4.1386825*** | 0.0588049*** | 1.5745e-4 *** | 1.1287e-5ns | 0.2159214 ns |
Error | 20 | 4.8<- | 4.8333333<- | 0.3862144<- | 5.4988e-4<- | 1.1086e-5<- | 4.4393e-6<- | 0.0940647<- |
3.2.11 Chlorophyll b
In case of chlorophyll b of Brassica juncea exhibited highly significant results in both fertilizer and NaCl treatments. The interaction between salinity and fertilizer being notably significant (Table 4). Compared to the control, all treatments enhanced chlorophyll b levels. The peels treatment revealed maximum increase of 38%, while the B. megaterium treatment showed a minimum increase of 26% without stress plant. Under NaCl treatment, chlorophyll b levels significantly decreased by 34%. However, treatments with peels, B. megaterium, their combined and NPK mitigated the negative effects of NaCl stress and improved chlorophyll b content relative to their control. Among these, the peels treatment resulted in increase of 34%, whereas the B. megaterium treatment showed a minimum increase of 27%, under salt stress (Fig. 7B).
3.2.12 Carotenoids
The carotenoid content in Brassica juncea was affected by salt stress. Analysis of variance data showed highly significant results for both fertilizer and NaCl treatments, while the interaction between NaCl and fertilizer was non-significant (Table 4). All treatments showed to an increase in carotenoids compared to the control without salt stress. The NPK treatment showed the maximum increase of 29% in carotenoids, Peels increased by 25%, B. megaterium increased by 25%, their combined form increased by 13 with no stress plant. NaCl treatment alone had a negative impact, reducing carotenoid content by 25% compared to the control. However, under NaCl stress, all treatments improved carotenoid content compared to the control (Fig. 7C). Among these, Peels treatment showed a highly significant effect, resulting in an 18% increase in carotenoids. B. megaterium increased by 10%, their combined form enhanced by 1% and NPK enhanced by 17% under NaCl stress.
3.2.13 Relative water content
In case of relative water content of Brassica juncea showed highly significant results for fertilizer and salt stress. The interaction between them was non-significant (Table 4). Peels treatment increased relative water content by 27%, while NPK showed a 5% increase without stress. B. megaterium treatment resulted in a 13% increase, but the combination of B. megaterium and peels had no effect compared to the control (Fig. 7D). Under salt stress, relative water content decreased by 17% compared to the control. However, all treatments showed a positive response under salt stress, with peels treatment revealed by 30% increase and NPK a 22% increase compared to the control under salt stress
3.3 Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on Membrane stability of Brassica juncea under salinity stress.
3.3.1 Malondialdehyde
The interaction between fertilizer and salinity was highly significant (Table 4). Malondialdehyde (MDA) content, a negative indicator of plant stress, increased with stress. Without stress, all treatments reduced leaf MDA compared to the control. The maximum decrease of 31% in leaf MDA was observed with peels treatment, while the minimum decrease of 4% was found with the combined treatment of B. megaterium and peels (Fig. 8A). B. megaterium alone reduced leaf MDA by 2%, and NPK reduced it by 19% compared to the control without stress. NaCl significantly increased leaf MDA content, with a maximum increase of 103% under salt stress. However, all treatments improved leaf MDA content under salt stress, with peels treatment reducing it by 33% and B. megaterium treatment by 20% under salinity stress.
3.3.2 Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) content
In case of Hydrogen peroxide activity Brassica juncea plants revealed highly significant results for fertilizer and salinity treatments. The interaction between salinity and fertilizer was also highly significant (Table 4). Compared to the control, all treatments reduced H2O2 activity without added stress. The maximum decrease of 42% in H2O2 activity was observed with B. megaterium treatment, while the minimum decrease of 13% was found with the combined treatment of B. megaterium and peels. Peels treatment reduced H2O2 activity by 18%, and NPK reduced it by 24% compared to the control without stress. All treatments were statistically significant compared to each other with no stress. NaCl significantly increased H2O2 activity, with a maximum increase of 67% under salt stress (Fig. 8B). However, all treatments improved H2O2 activity under salt stress, with the combined treatment reducing it by 43% and B. megaterium the treatment by 30% under salt stress.
3.3.3 Relative membrane permeability
The relative membrane permeability of Brassica juncea showed highly significant effect under salt stress and fertilizer treatment, with a highly significant interaction between salinity and fertilizer (Table 4). Relative membrane permeability, a negative characteristic indicating cell membrane leakage, increased with stress. Without stress, all treatments reduced relative membrane permeability compared to the control. The maximum decrease of 31% was observed with the combined treatment of peels and B. megaterium, while the minimum decrease of 13% was found with B. megaterium treatment alone (Fig. 8C). Salinity stress significantly increased relative membrane permeability by 31% compared to the control. Under salt stress, all treatments improved relative membrane permeability, B. megaterium showed the maximum decrease of 35% and NPK showed the minimum decrease of 20% under salt stress.
3.4 Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on biomolecules parameters of Brassica juncea under salinity stress.
3.4.1 Activity of catalase
The catalase activity of Brassica juncea plants showed highly significant effects both in fertilizer and NaCl treatment. Interaction between salt stress and fertilizer was significant (Table 5). In comparison to control, all treatments showed positive response and elevated catalase activity without addition of stress. Maximum increase by 47% of catalase activity was observed in B. megaterium treatment while minimum increase 27% was found in NPK when compared to control with no addition of stress. Peels treatment increased by 29%, while its combine form (B. megaterium + peels) increase by 36% of catalase activity in contrast to control with no addition of stress. Highly significant effect was obtained with salt stress and it resulted maximum increase by 46% of catalase activity in parallel to control. Under salinity stress all treatments showed positive response and enhanced catalase activity. Peels treatment increase by 28%, B. megaterium increase by 13% and its combine form increase 21% while, NPK increased by 7% of catalase activity of Brassica juncea plants under salt stress. (Fig. 9A).
Table 5
Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on Total soluble protein (TSP), Catalase (CAT), Peroxidase (POD), Super oxide dismutase (SOD), Ascorbate peroxidase (APX), Total phenolic content (TPC), Leaf proline (LP) under Salinity stress.
Source | Df | TSP | CAT | APX | POD | SOD | TPC | LP |
Fertilizer | 4 | 9.202e-7*** | 4.6464e-5 *** | 0.0096967*** | 4.6161e-5*** | 1754459.4*** | 188346.08*** | 0.1168826*** |
NaCl | 1 | 2.0973e-5*** | 3.7725e-4 *** | 0.1860422*** | 0.002677*** | 13310050*** | 3547092.4 *** | 2.4328381*** |
Fertilizer*NaCl | 4 | 2.3767e-7** | 1.192e-5* | 9.1728e-4* | 2.0612e-6ns | 1367629.7*** | 22291.913* | 0.03590547*** |
Error | 20 | 4.8727e-8<- | 3.856e-6<- | 3.0756e-4<- | 3.0118e-6<- | 33318.304<- | 6472.2885<- | 0.0014372<- |
3.4.2 Peroxidase activity
In case of peroxidase activity of Brassica juncea plants revealed highly significant effects under salt stress and fertilizer treatments. The interaction between salt stress and fertilizer was non-significant (Table 5). Compared to the control, all treatments boosted peroxidase activity without stress plants. The maximum increase by 32% was observed with combined treatment of B. megaterium and peels, while the minimum increase by 1% was found with NPK fertilizer. Peels treatment alone increased peroxidase activity by 28%, and B. megaterium by 10%. Under salt stress, there was a highly significant effect, resulting in a maximum increase by 96% in peroxidase activity compared to the control. All treatments elevated peroxidase activity under salinity stress. Peels by 21%, B. megaterium by 9%, the combined form by 19%, and NPK by 9% (Fig. 9B).
3.4.3 Superoxide dismutase activity
In case of superoxide dismutase activity of Brassica juncea plants showed highly significant results with both salt stress and fertilizer treatments. The interaction between NaCl and fertilizer was also highly significant (Table 5). Compared to the control, all treatments elevated superoxide dismutase activity without stress plants. The maximum increase by 78% was observed with NPK fertilizer, while the minimum increase of 14% was found with peels treatment. B. megaterium elevated activity by 49%, and the combined treatment with peels increased it by 75% without stress plants. Under salinity stress, superoxide dismutase activity enhanced significantly, with a maximum increase by 84% compared to the control (Fig. 9C). Plants treated with peels, the combined treatment of B. megaterium and peels, and NPK all enhanced superoxide dismutase activity under salt stress.
3.4.4 Ascorbate peroxidase activity
The ascorbate peroxidase activity of Brassica juncea plants shown statistically highly significant results with both fertilizer and NaCl stress treatments. Compared to the control, all treatments enhanced ascorbate peroxidase activity without stress. The maximum increase by 58% was observed with B. megaterium treatment, while the minimum increase by 43% was found with peels treatment without stress condition. The interaction between fertilizer and NaCl was significant (Table 5). NaCl stress had a highly significant results, it was maximum increase by 93% in ascorbate peroxidase activity compared to the control. Under salt stress, all treatments boosted ascorbate activity. Peels treatment enhanced it by 6%, B. megaterium by 22%, the combined form by 16%, and NPK by 15% (Fig. 9D).
3.4.5 Total phenolic
The addition of NaCl treatment increased the accumulation of phenolics content in Brassica juncea plants. Under salinity stress, the application of peels and B. megaterium shown highly significant effect on total phenolic content. The interaction between fertilizer and salt stress was significant (Table 5). All treatments elevated total phenolic content positively. The maximum increase by 59% was observed with the combined treatment of peels and B. megaterium compared to the control without stress plant. Peels treatment alone enhanced total phenolic content by 39%, B. megaterium by 23%, and NPK by 38% compared to the control without stress. NaCl treatment alone increased total phenolic content by 79% compared to the control. Under salt stress, the combined treatment of peels and B. megaterium resulted in the maximum increase of 19% in total phenolics compared to the control. Peel powder treatment increased total phenolics by 13%, B. megaterium by 11%, and NPK by 5% under NaCl stress (Fig. 10A).
3.4.6 Leaf Proline
Leaf proline content of Brassica juncea plants revealed highly significant effect under salt stress and fertilizer treatments. All treatments elevated leaf proline levels. Compared to the control, the maximum increase by 149% was observed with the combined treatment of peels and B. megaterium, while the minimum increase by 56% was found with B. megaterium treatment without stress plants (Fig. 10B). NPK increased leaf proline by 99%, and B. megaterium treatment with peels increased it by 66% compared to the control without stress. The interaction between NaCl and fertilizer was highly significant (Table 5). Salt stress had a highly significant effect, enhancing leaf proline levels by 201% compared to the control. Under salt stress, all treatments increased leaf proline levels. The maximum increase by 22% was observed with the combined treatment of peels and B. megaterium, while the minimum increase by 2% was found with NPK fertilizer. Peels treatment increased leaf proline by 22%, and B. megaterium treatment increased it by 11% under salt stress.
3.4.7 Total soluble protein
In the case of total soluble protein in Brassica juncea plants had highly significant results with both fertilizer and NaCl treatments. The interaction between NaCl and fertilizer was also significant. Compared to the control, all treatments positively enhanced protein content without stress plant (Table 5). The maximum increase by 31% in protein content was observed with the combined treatment of peels and B. megaterium, while the minimum increase by 2% was found with NPK and B. megaterium compared to the control without stress. The peels treatment alone increased protein levels by 14% compared to the control without stress. Under salt stress, there was a highly significant effect noted resulting in a maximum increase of 69% in protein content compared to the control. All treatments showed a positive response and enhanced protein content under salt stress. Specifically, peels treatment increased protein content by 35%, B. megaterium by 1%, their combined form by 25%, and NPK by 4% under salt stress (Fig. 10C).
3.5 Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on inorganic ion of Brassica juncea under salinity stress.
3.5.1 K+ ion in shoots
Under salt stress, the concentration of K+ ions in the shoots of Brassica juncea decreased as the NaCl concentration increased. A highly significant effect was observed for both fertilizer application and salt stress, and their interaction was also significant (Table 6). All treatments resulted in a positive increase in potassium ion levels in the shoots compared to the control with no stress addition. The maximum increase in K+ ions by 38%, was observed with peels treatment, while the minimum increase by 18% was found with NPK fertilizer, compared to the control with no stress addition. Combined treatment with B. megaterium and peels increased K+ ions by 36%, and B. megaterium alone increased by 23%, compared to the control with no stress addition. K+ ion uptake in shoots decreased by 29% compared to the control under salinity stress. However, all treatments under salt stress showed increases in K+ ion levels by 46% with peel powder, 26% with NPK, 23% with B. megaterium and 29% with combined B. megaterium and peels treatment (Fig. 11A).
Table 6
Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on Shoot Na+, Shoot k +, Root k +, Shoot Ca++, Root Ca++ ion, Number of pods and seeds weight under salinity.
Source | Df | Shoot Na+ | Root Na+ | Shoot Ca++ | Root Ca++ | Shoot K | Root K | No. of pods | Seeds weight |
Fertilizer | 4 | 195.23983*** | 260.30772*** | 173.93943*** | 173.93943*** | 142.5129*** | 212.30772*** | 454.36667*** | 0.11217*** |
NaCl | 1 | 1241.6618*** | 974.55337*** | 295.72068*** | 295.72068*** | 1208.1644*** | 489.55337*** | 4737.6333*** | o.797073*** |
Fertilizer*NaCl | 4 | 16.680103* | 31.4774907*** | 71.824578*** | 71.824578*** | 12.026437* | 19.4774907* | 125.46667*** | 0.0.01862*** |
Error | 20 | 5.2766614<- | 4.0508181<- | 4.6657263<- | 4.6657263<- | 4.1068444<- | 5.05317664<- | 5.6<- | 4.5333e-4-<- |
3.5.2 K+ ion in roots
K+ ion in roots of Brassica juncea was affected under salt stress. K+ ion in roots was decreased when NaCl concentration increased. Analysis of variance data showed highly significant effect under salt stress and fertilizer. Interaction between NaCl and fertilizer was significant (Table 6). All treatment showed positive result and elevated potassium ion in roots compared to control with no addition of stress. Maximum increase by 39% of K+ ion in roots was obtained in peels treatment while its minimum increase by12% in B. megaterium treatment in contrast to control with no addition of stress. Furthermore, combine treatment (B. megaterium + peels) increase 26% and NPK increase by 16% compared to control with no addition of stress Fig. 11B). Salinity stress considerably reduced the K+ ion in root and it resulted decrease by 26% as opposed to control. But in salinity stress all treatments showed increase 48%, 46%, 40% and 74% respectively K+ ion in roots.
Ca 2+ ion in shoots
Ca2+ ion in shoot of Brassica juncea showed highly significant effects under salt stress and fertilizer treatment. The Interaction between NaCl and fertilizer was highly significant (Table 6). All treatment showed positive result and increase calcium ion in shoots when compared to control with no addition of stress. Maximum increase 19% of calcium ion in shoot was obtained in peels treatment while minimum increase 1% was found in NPK when compared to control with no addition of stress. B. megaterium increased 1% and its combine form increased 13% in comparison to control with no addition of stress (Fig. 11C). Salt stress lowered the calcium ion in shoot and it resulted decrease by 19% in comparison to control. Maximum increase 92% of calcium ion was observed in combine treatment (Peels + B. megaterium) when compared to control under salt stress. B. megaterium increased by 58%, peels increased by 88% and NPK increase by 58% of Ca2+ ion in shoots in comparison to control under salt stress.
3.5.3 Ca2+ ion in roots
In case of ca2+ ion in roots of Brassica juncea showed highly significant results under salinity and fertilizer treatment. Interaction between salt stress and fertilizer was significant (Table 6). All treatments showed positive response and enhanced calcium ion uptake in roots when compared to control with no addition of stress. Maximum increase by 14% of calcium ion in root was obtained in peels treatment while minimum increase by 3% was found in NPK compared with control without stress plant. B. megaterium increase by 8% and its combine form increased 9% compared to control with no addition of stress. There was remarkable reduction of calcium ion in root was observed under salt stress and it resulted decrease 20% in corresponding to control. Maximum increase 64% of calcium ion was observed in combine treatment (Peel + B. megaterium) compared with control under salt stress. B. megaterium increase by 42%, peels increase by 62% and NPK increase by 39% of Ca2+ ion in roots compared with control under salt stress (Fig. 11D).
3.5.4 Na+ ion in shoot
Na+ ion in shoot of Brassica juncea plant showed highly significant effects in both fertilizer and salt stress treatment (Table 6). Interaction between salinity and fertilizer was significant. In comparison to control, plants treated with Peel, B. megaterium, its combination, NPK reduced the Na+ ion uptake with the no addition of stress. Maximum decrease by 31% of sodium ion in shoot of Brassica juncea was noted in combined treatment (Peels + B. megaterium) while minimum decrease by2% was observed in NPK when compared to control with no addition of stress. Moreover, B. megaterium treatment decrease by 12% and peels treatment decrease 24% of Na+ ion in shoots in parallel to control with no addition of stress. Na+ ion in shoot of Brassica juncea was increase 52% when compared with control under salt stress. But all treatments lowered the Na+ ion by 23%, 20%, 23% and 19% compared to control under salt stress (Fig. 12A).
3.5.5 Na+ ion roots
Na+ ion in roots of Brassica juncea showed highly significant results in both fertilizer and NaCl treatment. Interaction between salinity and fertilizer was highly significant (Table 6). In comparison to control, plants treated with peels, B. megaterium, its combination, NPK reduced the Na+ ion uptake with no addition of stress. Maximum decrease by 29% of Na+ ion in Brassica juncea roots was observed in peels treatment while minimum decrease 11% was observed in NPK when compared to control with no addition of stress. Moreover, B. megaterium treatment decrease by 18% and combined treatment decrease 19% of Na+ ion in roots when compared to control with no addition of stress (Fig. 12B). Na+ ion in shoot of Brassica juncea was increased 35% when compared with control under salt stress. But all treatments lowered the Na+ ion by 28%, 26%, 28% and 22% in comparison to control under salt stress.
3.6 Effect of organic waste material and rhizobacteria on yield parameters of Brassica juncea under salinity stress.
3.6.1 Number of pods plant− 1
Statistical analysis data revealed that both NaCl and fertilizer treatments significantly affected the number of pods in Brassica juncea plant. The highly significant interaction between salinity and fertilizer (Table 6). All treatments showed a positive response, increasing the number of pods compared to control with no salt stress. The maximum increase in the number of pods was 66% with peels treatment, while minimum increase by 27% with NPK in the absence of stress (Fig. 13A). B. megaterium treatment enhanced the number of pods by 37%, and the combined treatment of B. megaterium and peels increased by 49%, compared to the control with no stress. Under salt stress, the number of pods decreased by 22% compared to the control. However, peels treatment increased the number of pods by 23%, B. megaterium treatment by 13%, the combined treatment by 26%, and NPK by 4% under salt stress.
3.6.2 Weight of 100 Seeds
In seeds weight of Brassica juncea plant showed highly significant effect in fertilizer and salt stress. Interaction between fertilizer and salt stress was highly significant (Table 6). All treatments demonstrated positive results and enhanced the seeds weight of Brassica juncea. Peels treatment showed remarkable results and enhanced the seeds by 98%, B. megaterium enhance 72%, combine treatment (Peel + B. megaterium) enhance 92% and NPK enhance by 40% seed weight of Brassica juncea plant in relation to control with no addition of stress. Salt stress negatively impeded the seeds weight and its reduced 36% in contrasted to control (Fig. 13B). All treatments revealed positive results and increased the seeds weight under salt stress. Maximum seeds weight was observed in peels treatment under salt stress. B. megaterium enhanced seeds weight by 40%, combine treatment enhance 66% and NPK enhance by 36% as compare to their respective control under salt stress.