LCH is a rare disease characterized by the clonal proliferation of LCs, which are identical to normal dendritic cells. LCs are atypical and immature cells of the mononuclear phagocytic system that can infiltrate tissue virtually anywhere in the body, and they may manifest in localized lesions or as a component of widespread systemic diseases [7, 9]. The cases described in this report exhibit the typical clinical features of LCH, including the fact that it occurs more commonly in males and in cases of MS-LCH. LCH with hepatic involvement is relatively rare, especially in adults, and usually presents as part of a disseminated disease process [10–12]. Only a few cases of isolated liver involvement have been reported to date [5, 13–15]; for example, Key et al. reported data from nine patients with liver involvement, five of whom solely exhibited hepatic involvement [13]. Most of the studies published to date have been single-case reports. In the present study, patients with LCH with liver involvement were predominantly adults (71.4%), a finding that differs from what has been reported in the literature, and three patients had isolated liver involvement, two of whom were adults and of whom was one a child. This discrepancy could be explained by the fact that our hospital is a general hospital whose Hepatic Department is well-known in South China, and many patients with liver diseases are admitted to our hospital for treatment.
The clinical presentations and imaging signs of LCH involving the liver are variable and nonspecific, and the diagnosis depends on both the site of the lesion and the disease stage. However, some patients were asymptomatic, making a proper diagnosis difficult. Overall, the symptoms of LCH with isolated liver involvement tend to be much milder than those of LCH with the involvement of other organs. In this study, two patients (28.6%) with isolated liver involvement were asymptomatic, while the other five reported upper abdominal discomfort, polydipsia, polyuria, or jaundice. The imaging findings revealed evidence of hepatocellular carcinoma, cholangiocarcinoma, granulomatous inflammation, and cholangitis, among other disease processes, and none of our patients was diagnosed with LCH based on imaging studies alone. Thus, a combination of pathological and immunohistochemical evidence remains the gold standard for the diagnosis of LCH. As reported in the literature, the macroscopic appearance of hepatic lesions in LCH varies from single to multiple in number, from small to large in size, and from subcapsular to deep in terms of the location of nodules. Some authors have reported solid tumor-like or, occasionally, multicystic masses [13, 16, 17]. In the present study, most cases involved multiple lesions, and one case involved the formation of an abscess. Microscopically, LCs selectively affect the portal tract [18]. The LCs had an abundant pink cytoplasm and lobulated, coffee bean-shaped, or contorted nuclei with a fine chromatin pattern and indiscernible nucleoli. In LCH lesions, tumor cells comprise less than 1% to more than 70% of granulomas (median, approximately 8%), and the number of eosinophils and activated T cells varies greatly as well, depending on the status of and factors released as part of the cytokine storm [19–23]. In the present study, four patients had typical morphology in some portals, whereas other portals exhibited mild changes; this morphological variability may depend on the disease stage. For example, the portal region undergoes mild expansion during the early stages of lesion development. In LCH, only individual LCs invade the bile duct epithelium, and only a slight degree of inflammatory cell infiltration of the bile duct occur; thus, it is very difficult to correctly diagnose LCH based on the presence of such morphology from H&E staining, especially in punctured tissue. Under these conditions, observations must be conducted carefully to more accurately assess the presence of bile duct epithelial damage, epithelial vacuolar degeneration, and the spacing beside epithelial cells with any degree of eosinophil infiltration, all of which are clues that could point to the presence of LCH. Labeling of S100 and CD1a using IHC could aid in the detection of LCs and the verification of an LCH diagnosis. LCs are often difficult to identify in the advanced stages of the disease. Portal/periportal fibrosis, bile ductular proliferation, ductopenia, and cirrhosis are the main manifestations of primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). In some cases, tumor cells may never be found in liver tissue with nonspecific portal inflammation or SC morphology [13, 16, 17]. This indirect involvement of the liver may occur through the production of a large array of cytokines and chemokines through LCH at other sites [24, 25]. One patient in this study had SC in the absence of LCs, but that individual had a history of skin LCH, which provided insight that led to the diagnosis of liver LCH. After liver transplantation, the host liver was extensively observed, and LCs were found in the focus, confirming direct involvement. Thus, it is important to have a good understanding of a patient’s detailed clinical history in cases of SC in which LCs are undetected based on morphological assessments and IHC. If a patient has extrahepatic LCH or central diabetes insipidus, the lesions may be secondary manifestations of LCH involving the liver.
The disease course of LCH may vary greatly between individual cases. In one patient in this study, a few cells that were spindly to ovoid in shape were observed, which were accompanied by numerous small lymphocytes and a small number of eosinophils; these observations led to the differential diagnosis of inflammatory pseudotumor-like FDC tumors and inflammatory myofibroblastic tumors (IMTs). With respect to FDC tumors, solitary liver lesions are well-circumscribed, with or without a fibrous pseudocapsule, and scattered atypical spindly to ovoid cells with indistinct cell borders, large vesicular nuclei, and distinct nucleoli are invariably present. The atypical cells exhibited positive immunolabeling for FDC markers (CD21+ and CD35+) and positive EBV detection via ISH, which can facilitate the diagnosis. However, spindle-shaped cells in IMTs were consistently positive for SMA and ALK in 50% of the patients. One patient presented with chronic suppurative cholangitis and abscess formation. In addition, there were a large number of mixed inflammatory cells, including frequently observed eosinophils, in the background in most of the patients. Collectively, all of these factors led to the consideration of possible infections, including those that were bacterial, fungal, and parasitic in nature. However, in the present study, all of the microbial staining techniques failed to identify an infectious cause in any of the patients, and the follow-up information did not suggest the presence of an infection. Importantly, the morphology of LCH involving in the liver is complex, making detection difficult, especially in samples collected via needle biopsy.
Currently, there is no standard treatment for LCH, and progression-free survival among high-risk patients is less than 50% [23]. Liver involvement in cases of is considered a poor prognostic factor, and the treatment for such cases consists of systemic chemotherapy and targeted therapy. SC complicated by the presence of LCH can lead to end-stage liver cirrhosis and poor responses to therapy [11, 16]; in such cases, liver transplantation may be a favorable treatment option [17, 26–29], and the survival rate of children following liver transplantation for LCH-related liver disease is excellent. However, in this study, one patient with SC died of LCH recurrence one year after liver transplantation. The prognosis of patients with LCH with isolated liver involvement is better than that of patients with MS-LCH with liver involvement. Three patients with single-organ involvement, including one patient who underwent ablation and two patients who underwent chemotherapy, experienced favorable outcomes in the present study, which is consistent with the literature. Because early treatment can improve the prognosis of LCH involving the liver, early diagnosis is of primary importance.