Panicle Length
Statistically significant variance occurred in panicle length. The panicle length varied substantially among the accessions, with a mean value of 19.00 to 29.01 cm. The longest panicle length (29.1 cm) was observed in ASS04 followed by 27.6 in ACC18, while the shortest panicle length (19.0 cm) was discovered in ACC03 followed by 19.06 cm in ACC27 respectively (Table 2). Panicle length has very low correlation with yield per hill (Fig. 4).
Table 2
Variability and field performance of 30 rice varieties
Association | Panicle length (cm) | Field Grain/Panicle | Unfiled Grain/Panicle | Grain Length (mm) |
1 | 21.8p | 57.0u | 26.0i | 7.81i |
2 | 23.8j | 113.0k | 37.0f | 7.81e |
3 | 19.0t | 125.0i | 51.0d | 7.47ll |
4 | 29.1a | 188.6a | 8.6q | 9.86a |
5 | 22.1o | 174.0cd | 10.0pq | 7.74ij |
6 | 23.8j | 173.0d | 17.0l | 7.56jkl |
7 | 21.8p | 97.0o | 14.3m | 7.38lm |
8 | 24.1i | 111.0l | 39.0e | 7.69ijk |
9 | 24.6h | 137.0g | 14.6m | 7.90i |
10 | 23.2l | 81.0r | 75.0a | 8.97cd |
11 | 21.1q | 125.0i | 17.0l | 7.50kl |
12 | 20.3r | 89.0p | 53.0c | 7.83i |
13 | 23.0m | 110.0l | 11.0op | 7.84i |
14 | 23.1lm | 107.0m | 60.0b | 8.59efgh |
15 | 22.6n | 105.0n | 23.0j | 8.76cd |
16 | 23.6k | 90.0p | 24.0j | 8.46gh |
17 | 26.5c | 121.0j | 20.3k | 6.14o |
18 | 27.6b | 141.0f | 17.0l | 6.49n |
19 | 22.0o | 186.6b | 32.0g | 7.81i |
20 | 25.4e | 81.0r | 24.0j | 9.23b |
21 | 26.5c | 131.0h | 33.0g | 9.65a |
22 | 25.2f | 73.0s | 18.3l | 8.54fgh |
23 | 25.0g | 175.0c | 11.0op | 8.66efg |
24 | 22.7n | 83.0q | 12.0no | 8.70ef |
25 | 24.0i | 169.0e | 29.0h | 7.17m |
26 | 24.0d | 170.0e | 50.0d | 5.65p |
27 | 19.6s | 72.0s | 32.0g | 7.41ll |
28 | 26.6c | 52.0v | 39.0e | 7.70ijk |
29 | 27.5b | 140.0f | 14.0m | 8.43h |
30 | 20.4r | 68.0t | 13.0mn | 9.09bc |
LSD0.05 | 0.16 | 1.58 | 1.90 | 0.21 |
LSD0.01 | 0.22 | 2.10 | 2.54 | 0.27 |
Level of Significance | ** | ** | ** | ** |
CV% | 0.43 | 0.82 | 4.25 | 1.60 |
Here, LS = Level of Significance, ** = 1% Level of significance and, * = 5% Level of significance |
Total number of Grain per Panicle |
With a range of 81.0 to 220.0 grains, the total amount of grain per panicle varied significantly. The maximum total amount of grain per panicle (220.0 grains) was noticed in ACC26 followed by 218.67 grains in ACC19 whereas, the minimum total amount of grain per panicle (81.0 grains) was revealed in ACC30 followed by 83.0 grains in ACC01 sequentially (Fig. 1). There is very low correlation between total number grain per panicle and yield per hill (Fig. 5)
Field Grain per Panicle
Significant variance was additionally observed in the field grain per panicle, which ranged from 52.0 to 188.6 grains. The largest number of field grains (188.6 grains) was noticed in ACC04 followed by 186.6 field grains per panicle in ACC19, meanwhile the lowest number of field grains (52.0) was observed in ACC28 followed by 57.0 field grains per panicle in ACC01 respectively (Table 2).
Unfilled Grain per Panicle
With a range of 8.6 to 75.0 grains, the unfilled grain per panicle also varied significantly. The least number of unfilled grains (8.6 grains) was noted in ASS04 followed by 10.0 unfilled grains per panicle in ACC05 as well the maximum number of unfilled grains (75.0 grains) was recorded in ACC10 followed by 60.0 grains in ACC14 (Table 2).
Grain Length
The accessions ranged in grain length from 5.65 mm to 9.86 mm. The most extended grain length (9.86 mm) was found in ACC04 followed by 9.65 mm in ACC21 and the most concise grain length (5.65 mm) was exposed in ACC26 followed by 6.14 mm in ACC17 correspondingly (Table 2).
Grain Breadth (mm)
The thicknesses of grain breadth ranged from 1.91 mm to 3.34 mm, indicating substantial variations among the accessions. The broadest grain (3.34 mm) was identified in ACC04 and ACC08 followed by 3.21 mm in ACC01, whereas the narrowest grain (1.91 mm) was detected in ACC26 followed by 2.00 mm in ACC18 sequentially (Table 3).
Table 3
Variability and field performance of 30 rice varieties
Association | Grain breadth (mm) | Defective Grain Length (mm) | Defective Grain Breadth (mm) |
1 | 3.21b | 5.80hi | 2.63e |
2 | 2.79i | 6.98b | 2.37l |
3 | 3.18c | 5.55jkl | 2.50h |
4 | 3.34a | 7.63a | 2.92a |
5 | 2.91f | 5.53jklm | 2.60f |
6 | 2.73k | 5.22n | 2.49hi |
7 | 3.12d | 5.26n | 2.68c |
8 | 3.34a | 5.38lmn | 2.65d |
9 | 2.32q | 5.76hij | 2.11r |
10 | 3.09e | 6.31def | 2.75b |
11 | 2.53o | 5.37lmn | 2.25p |
12 | 2.82h | 5.95gh | 2.57g |
13 | 2.71l | 5.70ijk | 2.41k |
14 | 2.60n | 6.14efg | 2.28o |
15 | 2.73k | 6.33de | 2.30n |
16 | 2.63m | 6.68c | 2.34m |
17 | 2.04t | 4.45o | 1.65w |
18 | 2.00u | 3.88p | 1.80u |
19 | 2.30r | 5.70ijk | 2.09s |
20 | 3.18c | 6.53cd | 2.74b |
21 | 2.60n | 6.71c | 2.45j |
22 | 2.76j | 6.08fg | 1.66w |
23 | 2.62m | 6.33de | 2.50h |
24 | 2.15s | 6.30def | 2.02t |
25 | 2.77j | 5.31mn | 2.40k |
26 | 1.91v | 4.28o | 1.76v |
27 | 2.88g | 5.54jklm | 2.65d |
28 | 2.45p | 5.50klm | 2.21q |
29 | 3.10e | 6.33de | 2.66d |
30 | 2.83h | 6.68c | 2.48i |
LSD0.05 | 0.01 | 0.23 | 0.01 |
LSD0.01 | 0.02 | 0.31 | 0.02 |
Level of Significance | ** | ** | ** |
CV% | 0.41 | 2.51 | 0.44 |
Here, LS = Level of Significance, ** = 1% Level of significance and, * = 5% Level of significance |
Defective Grain Length (mm) |
Additionally, there was substantial variation in defective grain length, with values ranging from 3.88 mm to 7.63 mm. The greatest defective grain length (7.63 mm) was monitored in ACC04 followed by 6.98 mm in ACC02, despite the fewest defective grain length (3.88 mm) was revealed in ACC18 followed by 4.28 mm in ACC26 individually (Table 3).
Defective Grain Width
The range of the defective grain width was 1.65 mm to 2.92 mm. The largest width of defective grain (2.92 mm) was observed in ACC04 followed by 2.75 mm in ACC10, in which the shortest grain width (1.65 mm) was discovered in ACC17 followed by 1.66 mm in ACC22 in corresponding order (Table 3).
Weight of 1000 Grains
The weight of 1000 grains varied from 9.5 g to 31.26 g. The heaviest grain (31.26 g) was recorded in ACC04 followed by 30.75 g in ACC24. In contrast, the lightest grain (9.5 g) was observed in ACC26 followed by 9.7 g in ACC17 correspondingly (Fig. 2).
Yield per hill
The yield assessment reveals notable variation among the various association, regarding values varying from 53.64 g to 187.19 g per hill. The highest yield (187.19 g) was discovered in ACC10 followed by 186.2 g in ACC12. Conversely, the lowest yield (53.64 g) was found in ACC08 followed by 53.65 g in ACC07 individually (Fig. 3).
3.1 Cluster analysis
The 30 rice varieties were grouped into six clusters to identify the most homogenous groups with the best performance (Table 4). Cluster analysis revealed that Cluster III exhibited the best overall results for rice production, followed closely by Cluster I. In contrast, Cluster VI, which included ACC10 and ACC12, showed comparatively lower performance than Clusters III and I (Fig. 7). Cluster II displayed the lowest performance among all clusters, with minimal variation in morphological traits (Fig. 6), indicating limited potential for yield improvement.
Table 4
Six cluster of rice varieties
Cluster | Association |
I | ACC01, ACC22 |
II | ACC02, ACC03, ACC08, ACC09, ACC11, ACC14, ACC17, ACC18, ACC21, ACC29, |
III | ACC04, |
IV | ACC05, ACC06, ACC19, ACC23, ACC25, ACC26, |
V | ACC07, ACC13, ACC15, ACC16, ACC20, ACC24, ACC27, ACC28, ACC30 |
VI | ACC10, ACC12, |
Figures 6 and 7 show varying coefficients of variation among rice varieties, with ACC22-ACC28 displaying the highest coefficients, indicating greater variability in their trait values.Figure 6. Coefficient variation in rice varieties
3.2 PCA analysis
PCA analysis revealed that grain length, grain breadth, defective grain length, defective grain breadth, and 1000-seed weight had the strongest significant correlations among all parameters (Table 6). Consequently, Clusters I and III demonstrated the highest performance in these traits, including grain length, grain breadth, defective grain length, defective grain breadth, and 1000-seed weight (Table 5).
Table 5
Coefficient variation among parameters
Components | Initial Eigenvalues | Extraction Sums of Squared Loadings |
Total | % of Variance | Cumulative % | Total | % of Variance | Cumulative % |
Panicle length | 3.811 | 38.106 | 38.106 | 3.811 | 38.106 | 38.106 |
Filled grain per panicle | 2.253 | 22.531 | 60.637 | 2.253 | 22.531 | 60.637 |
Unfilled grain per panicle | 1.427 | 14.267 | 74.904 | 1.427 | 14.267 | 74.904 |
Grain length | 0.912 | 9.118 | 84.021 | | | |
Grain breadth | 0.625 | 6.252 | 90.273 | | | |
Defective Grain Length | 0.514 | 5.139 | 95.412 | | | |
Defective Grain Breadth | 0.250 | 2.505 | 97.917 | | | |
1000 seed Weight | 0.121 | 1.212 | 99.129 | | | |
Yield per hill | 0.087 | 0.871 | 100.00 | | | |
Total number of grains per panicle | 1.50 | 1.50 | 100.00 | | | |