3.1 Effects of PH concentration to the single- and mixed-bacteria degradation rate and biomass
Compared with physical and chemical method, biological remediation has become a low-cost and high-efficient method in removing hydrocarbons in different PH pollution environments (Santos Neto and de Oliveira et al., 2014). In this study, single- or mixed-bacteria was utilized to degrade PH of different concentrations. As shown in Fig. 1A, the degradation rate of single-bacteria was changed with the increase of PH concentration. When the concentration of PH was 5.00 g/L, the biodegradation rate was over 53.25 ± 2.15% (Fig. 1A). Among them, the PH degradation rate of D-2 was highest and it reached to 74.54 ± 3.26% (Fig. 1A). However, according to the degradation rate of PH (over 5.00 g/L), the biodegradation efficiency was significantly decreased (Fig. 1A), which shows that high concentration of hydrocarbons could limit the biodegradation and bioavailability in the PH pollution ecosystems. Under 10.00 g/L condition, the highest biodegradation rate was 53.41 ± 2.59% in D-6, meanwhile D-1 also had lowest hydrocarbon availability among bacteria (Fig. 1A). In addition, D-2 had the second higher biodegradation rate and it reached to 52.17 ± 2.47% (Fig. 1A). Compared with 10.00 g/L, the hydrocarbon biodegradation rate of 15.00 g/L was further declined, among which the highest (D-2) was only 37.49 ± 1.19%. Moreover, the biodegradation rate of D-1 was decreased to 16.57 ± 0.68% (Fig. 1A). Above all, the PH degradation bottleneck concentration of single-bacteria was 10.00 g/L in this work.
In oredr to enhance the biodegradation efficient of high concentration PH, mixed-bacteria were adopted to degrade 10.00 g/L PH. In this study, the combination of D-4 with D-6 had the highest PH degradation rate among different bacteria combinations, and the biodegradation rate has reached to 64.47 ± 2.36% in 10.00 g/L (Fig. 1B). Meanwhile, the biodegradation rate of PH in the combination of D-4 with D-7 was also over 60% and it reached to 60.54 ± 2.41% (Fig. 1B). When single-bacteria were used to degrade 10.00 g/L PH, the lowest of biodegradation rate was 38.74 ± 1.52% by D-1 (Fig. 1A). However, compared with single-bacteria, the biodegradation rate of D-1 plus D-4 has decreased to 24.25 ± 0.78% (Fig. 1B), which shows that the substrate competition of mixed-bacteria was higher than single-bacteria.
Meanwhile, by detecting the maximum biomass of single-bacteria in different PH concentrations (Fig. 1C), the biomass of bacteria might have a positive effect to biodegradation rate of PH. Between different treatments, the maximum value of single-bacteria biomass was obtained in 5.00 g/L, and that of D-2 has reached to 2.37 ± 0.06. However, with the increasing PH concentration, the maximum biomass of single-bacteria was significantly declined (Fig. 1C). Among them, the maximum biomass of D-1 has decreased to 0.79 ± 0.02 in 15.00 g/L (Fig. 1C). Under the mixed-bacteria degradation condition, the maximum value of biomass was increased to 2.46 ± 0.08 and 2.32 ± 0.06 in the combinations of D-4 with D-6 and D-4 with D-7, respectively, but that of bacteria biomass in D-1 plus D-4 was decreased to 0.92 ± 0.03 (Fig. 1D).
3.2 Biodegradation characterized of PH under single- and mixed-bacterial conditions
The residual contents of PH under different biodegradation treatments were measured in this study, and the biodegradation result showed that bacteria has different degradation characteristics in different types of PH (Fig. 2). In the condition of low PH concentration (5.00 g/L), the residual contents of short-chain PH (tridecane to heptadecane) were lower than other types of PH (mid-long chain and PAHs), and the biodegradability of PAHs was lowest among different types of PH (Fig. 2A), which indicated that single-bacteria preferentially metabolism simple carbohydrate as substrate in different kinds of hydrocarbons (Moscoso et al., 2012). Moreover, the degradation efficiency of D-2 in different types of PH was highest among different bacteria (Fig. 2A). With enhancing of biodegradation strength (from 10.00 g/L to15.00 g/L), the residual contents of PH were obvious increased particularly in 15.00 g/L. At the same time, among PH, the residual contents of mid-long chain and PAHs were higher than short-chain in the high concentration PH condition (over 5.00 g/L). Additionally, the degradation ability of bacteria in different types of PH was also significantly decreased in the high PH concentration condition (Fig. 2A).
Among different groups, the residual contents of short-chain, mid-long chain, and PAHs were lowest in the combination of D-4 and D-6 (Fig. 2B). Meanwhile, compared with single-bacteria (D-2), the biodegradation contents of these types’ PH were also increased in D-4 plus D-6 (Fig. 2B). However, the PH biodegradation contents of D-1 plus D-4 was lower than D-1 (Fig. 2B), which also indicated that the substrate competition of mixed-bacteria was higher than single-bacteria. Between different types of PH, the biodegradation rates of short-chain (particular in D-4 plus D-6) were higher than any others (Fig. 2B). Compared with short-chain, the biodegradation rates of mid-long chain and PAHs was low, especially PAHs (Fig. 2B). However, in the combination of D-4 plus D-6 and D-4 plus D-7, the biodegradation rates of PAHs were beyond 50%. Moreover, the mid-long chain biodegradation efficiency of mixed-bacteria was higher than single-bacteria (Fig. 2B).
3.3 Biodegradation characteristic of mixed-bacteria with surfactant
Due to the solubilization effect of surfactant, when the surfactant concentration is gradually close to critical micelle concentration (CMC), surfactant can boost the PH to dissolve in the hydrophobic center of micelles, which is conducive to microbial metabolism of hydrocarbons, and then improve the efficiency of bacteria degradation of hydrocarbons (Perez-de-Mora et al., 2011). When tween-80 was added into petroleum hydrocarbon biodegradation system, and with the increasing of tween-80 concentration, the biodegradation rate of PH by mixed-bacteria was initially increased (50 mg/L to 150 mg/L), and then gradually decreased (150 mg/L to 200 mg/L) (Fig. 3A). Among different treatments, the highest biodegradation rate of mixed-bacteria was 71.26 ± 3.56% with 100 mg/L tween-80, and these results were obtained in the combination of D-4 and D-7 (Fig. 3A). Meanwhile, the biodegradation trend of PH by adding rhamnolipid was the same to tween-80 (Fig. 3B), but the group of D-5 plus D-7 was reached to the highest PH degradation rate under 150 mg/L rhamnolipid (Fig. 3B). Additionally, the biodegradation conditions of mixed-bacteria under with or without surfactant were optimized, and the result of biodegradation characteristic was shown in Table 1. The biodegradation rates of PH by tween-80 (100 mg/L) and rhamnolipid (150 mg/L) were increased to 76.09 ± 1.14% and 81.25 ± 4.27%, respectively (Table 1).
Table 1
PH degradation rate under different conditions by mixed-bacteria
Surfactant
|
Factor
|
Condition
|
Degradation rate (%)
|
Factor
|
Condition
|
Degradation rate (%)
|
Non-added
|
Temperature (°C)
|
20
|
72.39 ± 5.62
|
Speed (r/min)
|
150
|
73.25 ± 4.21
|
25
|
75.33 ± 6.89
|
180
|
78.57 ± 5.62
|
30
|
78.39 ± 5.82
|
200
|
80.41 ± 6.87
|
35
|
79.36 ± 7.55
|
220
|
80.75 ± 4.55
|
Initial pH
|
5
|
70.85 ± 6.48
|
Proportion of mixed-bacteria
|
3:1
|
69.15 ± 5.85
|
6
|
72.08 ± 5.60
|
2:1
|
68.07 ± 6.67
|
7
|
81.15 ± 6.75
|
1:1
|
72.09 ± 7.14
|
8
|
80.52 ± 6.72
|
1:2
|
71.25 ± 6.76
|
9
|
78.58 ± 5.84
|
1:3
|
70.85 ± 5.74
|
Tween-80
|
Temperature (°C)
|
20
|
72.39 ± 5.62
|
Speed (r/min)
|
150
|
73.25 ± 4.21
|
25
|
75.33 ± 6.89
|
180
|
78.57 ± 5.62
|
30
|
78.39 ± 5.82
|
200
|
80.41 ± 6.87
|
35
|
79.36 ± 7.55
|
220
|
80.75 ± 4.55
|
Initial pH
|
5
|
70.85 ± 6.48
|
Proportion of mixed-bacteria
|
3:1
|
73.69 ± 5.85
|
6
|
72.08 ± 5.60
|
2:1
|
72.19 ± 6.67
|
7
|
81.15 ± 6.75
|
1:1
|
81.58 ± 6.29
|
8
|
80.52 ± 6.72
|
1:2
|
75.49 ± 6.76
|
9
|
78.58 ± 5.84
|
1:3
|
76.28 ± 7.14
|
Rhamnolipid
|
Temperature (°C)
|
20
|
75.26 ± 5.74
|
Speed (r/min)
|
150
|
79.69 ± 5.49
|
25
|
79.92 ± 7.22
|
180
|
83.96 ± 6.38
|
30
|
84.65 ± 4.98
|
200
|
87.39 ± 6.84
|
35
|
85.18 ± 5.37
|
220
|
87.69 ± 5.68
|
Initial pH
|
5
|
73.56 ± 6.34
|
Proportion of mixed-bacteria
|
3:1
|
73.44 ± 7.65
|
6
|
78.54 ± 5.28
|
2:1
|
81.39 ± 6.34
|
7
|
88.05 ± 7.14
|
1:1
|
88.35 ± 7.58
|
8
|
84.15 ± 6.34
|
1:2
|
79.69 ± 6.84
|
9
|
76.29 ± 6.34
|
1:3
|
75.58 ± 7.22
|
Compared with non-surfactant added treatments, the biodegradation rate in different types of PH were further increased after optimizing degradation conditions. Among them, mixed-bacteria has the highest degradation rate for short-chain hydrocarbon, and the residual concentration was below 510 mg/L (Table 2). Meanwhile, the residual contents of mid-long chain were decreased to below 700 mg/L, particularly in D-5 plus D-7 (483.58 ± 39.48 mg/L) (Table 2). In this study, PAHs held the lowest biodegradation rate among different treatments, but the biodegradation rates of PAHs were beyond 35% after optimizing degradation conditions of mixed-bacteria (Table 2).
Table 2
Residual contents of PH under different degradation systems
Surfactant
|
Combinations
|
Short chain (mg/L)
|
Mid-long chain (mg/L)
|
PAHs (mg/L)
|
Non-added
|
D-4 + D-6
|
724.57 ± 69.58
|
893.74 ± 69.27
|
1172.69 ± 95.81
|
Tween-80
|
D-4 + D-7
|
500.22 ± 36.71
|
682.48 ± 59.47
|
659.3 ± 47.29
|
Rhamnolipid
|
D-5 + D-7
|
261.65 ± 26.57
|
483.58 ± 39.48
|
419.77 ± 36.49
|
3.4 Compared with the metagenomics difference of mixed-bacteria under different treatment conditions
In order to increase the degradation efficient of PH by mixed-bacteria, surfactants were added in degradation system of PH and proved that these could further enhance the degradation rate of mixed-bacteria. Meanwhile, the metagenomics of mixed-bacteria were measured which was aimed to compare the degradation mechanism of hydrocarbons under different treatments (with and without surfactants).
3.4.1 Metagenomics sequencing
In this work, the metagenomics of mixed-bacteria under different treatments were measured and shown in Table S1. After the raw data of metagenomics was filtered, the valid data of mixed-bacteria was beyond 6.70 Gb (Table S1). Meanwhile, the value of Q20 and Q30 in different treatments was beyond 97% and 93% (Table S1), respectively, which indicated that these data could prove the accuracy of metagenomics. Between different treatments, after valid data was assembled, the contigs number and map were over 1.250 and 99.70% (Table S2), respectively. Moreover, the numbers of coding gene were over 16.990 in each treatment, and these gene could construct a non-redundant gene set (containing 67,258 genes) (Table S2).
3.4.2 Annotation metabolic pathways of mixed-bacteria under different treatments
The non-redundant gene set constructed by different mixed-bacteria systems and was annotated to KEGG database, and the results were displayed in Fig. 4A. In the first level annotation of KEGG, which includes metabolism, genetic information processing, environmental information processing, and cellular processes have important role on the PH degradation of mixed-bacteria under different conditions (Fig. 4A). Among them, the metabolism of mixed-bacteria has the largest proportion in different functional modules (Fig. 4A).
In the second level annotation of KEGG database, the relative abundance of global and overview maps, carbohydrate metabolism, and amino acid metabolism under different treatments were higher than any other modules in the metabolism functional (Fig. 4A). In the different degradation systems of mixed-bacteria, strain could consider hydrocarbons or surfactant as carbon and utilized them to meet the demand for energy through glycolysis and tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCA), therefore these pathways played an important role on the carbon metabolism of mixed-bacteria (Wang and Shao. 2013). At the same time, when the mixed-bacteria were used to degrade PH under different conditions, the osmotic pressure of environmental may be changed. Therefore, as to adjust the degradation efficiency of mixed-bacteria to hydrocarbons, the amino acid metabolism could act as the balance role of osmotic pressure (Vieira et al., 2007). Additionally, the global and overview maps covered almost all functional pathways in microorganisms, so it played an important role in the process of microbial metabolism of hydrocarbons.
Surfactant not only could enhance the bioavailable of PH, but also has an advantage to improve of carbon metabolism, thus these processes promoted the genetic information expression of microorganisms (Congiu and Ortega-Calvo. 2014). Meanwhile, the compatibility of PH or surfactant with mixed-bacteria was different, which might be led the microorganism to response the environmental condition, so the the relative abundance of genetic information has changed. Therefore, the relative abundance of replication, repair and translation is higher than other functions between genetic information modules (Fig. 4A). Owing to the solubilization of surfactant, the contact areas between microorganisms and hydrocarbon were expanded, meanwhile greatly increasing the frequency of PH entering the cell through cell membrane (Banat et al., 2014), eventually it results in higher relative abundance of membrane transport in environmental information processing module (Fig. 4A). Additionally, different strategies were utilized to degrade hydrocarbons in this work, which led to different interaction modes between microorganisms under different conditions, so the relative abundance of cellular community in the module of cell process was higher than other functions.
3.4.3 Degradation functional difference of mixed-bacteria under different systems
Different strategies were used to degrade hydrocarbons in this work, and the degradation efficiency of mixed-bacteria was obvious increased under added surfactant condition, which indicated that the carbon metabolism function of microorganism might be affect by surfactant.
In the different degradation systems of mixed-bacteria, the relative abundance of global and overview maps, carbohydrate metabolism, and amino acid metabolism was higher than any other modules through function difference analysis (Fig. 4B), meanwhile these results also showed that above functions had an important role in the process of microorganism hydrocarbons absorption, transportation, and metabolism. Moreover, in the functional module relative abundance of global and overview maps, carbohydrate metabolism, amino acid metabolism, membrane transportation, signal transduction, and cell motility with a difference between different degradation systems (Fig. 4B), which showed that the function of mixed-bacteria was adjusted and the ability of absorption and metabolism was enhanced in order to degrade hydrocarbon by adding surfactant. Additionally, compared with rhamnolipid, the relative abundance of each functional module was not significant different between tween-80 and non-added surfactant, which indicated that chemical surfactant only might enhance the bioavailable of hydrocarbons by solubilization and not adjust the inter functional modules of microorganism.
Further to analysis the hydrocarbon metabolism pathway of mixed-bacteria under different degradation conditions (Fig. 4C). In the functional module of global and overview maps, each pathway in tween-80 condition was higher than non-added surfactant and rhamnolipid system, especially biosynthesis of secondary metabolites, biosynthesis of antibiotic, biosynthesis of amino acid, and carbon metabolism. As chemical surfactant, tween-80 had a toxic with growth of microorganism. However, in order to maintain the stability of microorganism, the antibiotic and amino acid biosynthesis level of mixed-bacteria was increased to resist and adapt to current environment (Kempf and Bremer. 1998). Meanwhile, the PH also had an inhibition effect to the growing microorganism, thus the relative abundance of each functional module was enhanced to synthesized the needed energy of microorganism and to response to environmental stress under the simultaneous action of tween-80 and PH (Deng et al., 2016). Furthermore, in the condition of rhamnolipid, the relative abundance of whole functional module was lower than others system, which indicated that rhamnolipid might have the potential to increase the environmental adaptability of microorganisms.
In the functional module of amino acid metabolism, the glycine, serine, and threonine synthesis level of mixed-bacteria were enhanced in order to gain energy and maintain osmotic pressure, meanwhile these actions were response and adapt to the stress of PH and tween-80. Therefore, the relative abundance of above pathways in non-added surfactant and tween-80 was higher than rhamnolipid condition (Fig. 4C). In the functional module of carbohydrate metabolism, the relative abundance of glycolysis and TCA pathway in non-added surfactant and tween-80 was also higher than rhamnolipid condition (Fig. 4C), which indicated that the improvement of these pathways were aimed to increase the energy supply also adapt to current environment,
In the functional module of membrane transport and signal transduction, the relative abundance of ABC transporters and two-component system in rhamnolipid condition was higher than non-added surfactant and tween-80 system (Fig. 4C). Recently, it had been approved that ABC transporters and two-component system play an important role on the degradation of PAHs and improvement of microorganism stress resistance, respectively (Sierra-Garcia et al., 2003). Therefore, based on the above results showed that rhamnolipid might adjust the hydrocarbon transportation method of mixed-bacteria and enhance the PH tolerance of microorganism, and eventually the potential of mixed-bacteria environmental adaptation was increased.
In the functional module of cell motility, the relative abundance of bacteria chemotaxis in rhamnolipid condition was higher than non-added surfactant and tween-80 system (Fig. 5). And the chemotaxis of microorganism had a close relationship with PH, thus above result indicated that the improvement of bacteria chemotaxis will provide an advantage to further to increase the degradation efficiency of hydrocarbons by mixed-bacteria (Wadhams and Armitage. 2004).
3.5 Annotation and difference analysis of carbohydrate enzyme under different mix-bacteria conditions
In the PH degradation process of microorganism, the carbohydrate enzyme had a vital role on the catalysis of hydrocarbon absorption, transformation, and energy acquisition (Varjani. 2017). Based on the annotation result of carbohydrate enzyme under different treatments (Fig. 5A), the relative abundance of glycosyl transferase (GT) was higher than any other enzymes in the degradation process of mixed-bacteria, and its relative abundance rate had been reached to 40.6%. Meanwhile, the relative abundance of glycoside hydrolase (GH) and carbohydrate esterase (CE) had a higher ratio in the mixed-bacteria hydrocarbon metabolism process (Fig. 5A). However, between these different carbohydrate enzymes, the relative abundance rate of PL had only 0.1% (Fig. 5A), which showed that PL could have a little role on the hydrocarbons degradation process of mixed-bacteria.
Among different treatment systems, the relative abundance of GT, GH, and CE had a higher level in the hydrocarbon metabolism process of mixed-bacteria (Fig. 5B). Under non-added surfactant condition, the relative abundance of GT was highest among different function enzymes, meanwhile these PL was also lower than any other enzymes (Fig. 5B). In treatment of tween-80 was added to the degradation system of mixed-bacteria, the relative abundance of GT was also highest, and these values were similar with non-added surfactant condition (Fig. 5B). However, compared with non-added surfactant system, the relative abundance of GH and carbohydrate-binding module (CBM) was increased in the condition of tween-80. And in the system of rhamnolipid, the relative abundance of GT and auxiliary activities (AA) was lower than non-added surfactant and Tween80 condition, yet these of CE, CBM, and PL was higher than another degradation system (Fig. 5B). To sum up, added surfactant, particular in rhamnolipid, could have an effect on the expressing level of carbohydrate enzyme and to regulate of microorganism functional modules, then it ultimately improve the potential of mixed-bacteria to metabolize hydrocarbons.
3.6 AlkB and nah gene abundance comparison of different degradation systems
In the hydrocarbon metabolism process of microorganism, the oxygenase expressed by alkB and nah genes played an important role in the degradation of aliphatic hydrocarbons and aromatic compounds (Choi et al., 2002). In this section, the gene abundance of alkB and nah was significant difference between different degradation conditions (Table 3), which indicated that increasing the solubility of hydrocarbons and improving the conditions of microorganism degradation system could enhance the PHs utilization potential of mixed-bacteria.
Table 3
Abundance of the alkB and nah genes in different kinds of mixed-bacteria (copies per mL)
|
Non-added
|
Tween-80
|
Rhamnolipid
|
alkB
|
6.29 ± 0.45×106a
|
2.59 ± 0.12×107b
|
1.36 ± 0.11×109c
|
nah
|
3.57 ± 0.27×105a
|
6.82 ± 0.51×106b
|
4.82 ± 0.36×108c
|
Lower-case letters in the same line indicate significant difference at p < 0.05. |
Under non-added surfactant condition, the gene abundance of alkB and nah was significantly lower than rhamnolipid and tween-80 (Table 3), which showed that enhancing bioavailable of hydrocarbons could promote the carbon metabolism of mixed-bacteria. Meanwhile, in the system of added surfactant, the above gene abundance also showed the significant difference (Table 3), which indicated that the toxic of surfactant had an inhibition effect to increase hydrocarbons degradation efficiency of mixed-bacteria.