In our previous study (Asikin-Mijan et al. 2018), the optimum condition for deoxygenation of triglycerides model compound (triolein) and realistic feedstock (WCO, JCO, PFAD) for green diesel production over NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 catalyst were studied under N2 flow atmosphere condition. Table 4 compilation of optimum condition data in experimental work that were done in this system. Due to an excellent achievement of the NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 catalyst in optimizing the deoxygenation activity using 7 wt.% catalyst loading at 350 oC within 60 min, hence, this optimum condition was used as a basis to conduct optimization of CPO via RSM approach and the response of each experimental runs are depicted in Table 3. The suitability of quadratic model as well as the adequacy of the generated RSM model was explained in supplementary section.
Table 4
Summary from experimental studies conducted in semi-batch reactor under N2 flow condition over NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 catalyst [16].
Feedstock
|
FFA (%)
|
Optimum condition
|
Hydrocarbon yield (%)
|
n-(C15 + C17) product selectivity
|
Triolein
|
2.5
|
Catalyst Loading: 7 wt.%
Time: 60 min
Temperature: 350 oC
|
92
|
61
|
WCO
|
18.4
|
87
|
54
|
JCO
|
15.4
|
74
|
80
|
PFAD
|
86.3
|
81
|
80
|
3.1 Interaction effect between deoxygenation parameters
The effect of the three reaction parameters towards the reactivity of deoxygenation process were presented in the form of three-dimensional (3D) response surface plot and contour plot. The presence of surface shape from 3D-surface plot indicated the effectiveness of interaction of two deoxygenation parameters towards the hydrocarbon yield and product selectivity. Meanwhile, the straightforward contour plot explains the overall nature of the response surface for the reaction model. Based on the interpretation from the model’s plots, a narrow and precise range of optimum value corresponding to the high yield of hydrocarbon as well as product selectivity can be obtained (Kılıç et al. 2014).
Figure 2a-b shows the 3D response plot and 2D contour plot for interaction between catalyst loading (A) and reaction time (B) towards hydrocarbon yield, where the temperature is fixed at 340°C. Result shows that maximum hydrocarbon yield obtains more than 77% when the catalyst loading in the range 4.5 wt.%, and at time between ~ 70 min. Nevertheless, increment of catalyst amount along with reaction time exhibit negative impact on the hydrocarbon yield. This agreed with negative interaction of AB in Eq. S1, which suggesting that simultaneous increase of both parameters will render negative impact on product yield. It was noted that reduced hydrocarbon yield at longer reaction time is caused by the unfavourable side reactions such as over-cracking or further polymerization of the deoxygenated liquid into lighter fractions. Additionally, longer reaction time reaction time will cause extensive catalyst deactivation due to coking, which in thus lowered deoxygenation activity (Pattanaik and Misra 2017).
Figure 2c-d displays 3D response surface plot and 2D contour plot of interactions between catalyst loading (A) and temperature (C) towards hydrocarbon yield, with reaction time at 105 min. Similar with above finding, high catalyst loading (> 7 wt.%) dramatically decrease the hydrocarbon yield. This phenomena was due to the excess of catalyst that resulted to mass transfer limitation between the oil and solid catalyst, which reduced the rate of deoxygenation process (Hermida et al. 2015). Based on the 2D contour plot, maximum hydrocarbon yield (77%) is achieved when 4.5 wt.% of catalyst were loaded into the reaction with reaction temperature ~ 320°C within 105 min. When comparing with data obtained in Fig. 2a-b, it clearly seen that reaction temperature plays an critical role in intensifying the kinetic reactivity of deCOx. The reaction model indicated that deoxygenation process was positively assisted at milder reaction temperature (320oC).
The 3D response surface plot and 2D contour plot of interaction between reaction time (B) and temperature (C) of toward hydrocarbon yield using fix amount of catalyst loading (5 wt.% catalyst) were shown in Fig. 2e-f. Short reaction time and higher reaction temperature positively influence the deoxygenation activity. Notably, prolonging the reaction time in deoxygenation process does not improve the reaction activity and yield of product especially at intermediate temperature. High deoxygenation activity at higher reaction temperature was in agreement with Kubicka et al., (Kubičková and Kubička 2010), which yielded greater hydrocarbon yield when the reaction proceeded at higher reaction temperature. Similar finding also was reported by Pattanaik & Misra (Pattanaik and Misra 2017). Rich hydrocarbon obtained at high reaction temperature is highly correlated with the occurrence of cracking reaction via C-C bond cleavage (Ishihara et al. 2012). Whereby high cracking of CPO generally will lead to the formation of condensable reaction product which mainly comprised of short hydrocarbon fractions (gasoline: C8-C12) (Asikin-Mijan et al. 2017a). Based on the results generated from the Box-Behnken study, it can be concluded that optimum condition CPO deoxygenation toward formation of straight chain hydrocarbon fractions (77–81%) can be achieved at lower reaction temperature 300–340 oC, 5 wt.% catalyst loading and short reaction time ≤ 105 min.
Based on the curvatures nature of 3D surfaces in Fig. 2b, 2d and 2f, the results indicated that the mutual interaction of catalyst loading (A) with reaction time (B) was higher, as compared to the interaction parameters of AC and BC. Besides, the 3D surface plot revealed that the hydrocarbon yield varies remarkably with the increase of reaction time and catalyst loading. This revealed that most important variable in motivating the deoxygenation of CPO are reaction time and catalyst loading.
3.2 Product distribution profile for optimized hydrocarbon liquid product
To examine the predicted validity of Box-Behnken experimental design, the optimum condition of deoxygenation reaction of CPO over NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 catalyst was performed under one optimized condition; reaction condition: 5 wt.% catalyst loading, 105 min at 340 oC under N2 flow. Based on GC-FID analysis, the experimental result showed that the total hydrocarbon yield obtained is 75%, which is slightly less than predicted value from the reaction model (77%). The small degree of error (average of error = 2.2%) indicated the high accuracy of this deoxygenation model. It should be noticed that the liquid deoxygenated product also mainly diesel hydrocarbon fractions (n-(C15 + C17)) (72%) and minor of gasoline fractions n-(C8-C12) (Fig. 3a-b). As mentioned in Table 1, majority of fatty acid composition in CPO are C16 (palmitic acid − 9.2 wt.%) and C18 (oleic acid – 17.4 wt.% and linoleic acid – 39.6 wt.%). As shown in the product selectivity profile, the NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 catalysed process rendered high deCOx selectivity with product favored of Cn−1 hydrocarbons. As a result, n-C15 and n-C17 hydrocarbon fractions are dominant in the liquid hydrocarbon. GC-MS analysis was conducted to determine the chemical composition of deoxygenated liquid product. As shown in Fig. 3c, majority of compounds in the liquid product consist of alkanes and alkenes with carbon range of C8 – C20 (selectivity ~ 77%), followed by alcohol which are E-11,13-Tetradecadien-1-ol, 1-Dodecanol and cis-7-Dodecen-1-yl acetate (selectivity 5.33%) and ketone (selectivity 0.47%). The chemical functional group of CPO and optimized deoxygenated liquid product is displayed in Fig. 3d. The FTIR spectra of CPO showed the chemical characteristics of triglyceride (vegetable oil), with five main absorption bands at 715 cm− 1 (C-H stretch), 1160 cm− 1 (C-O stretch, carbonyl ester), 1453 cm− 1 (C-H bend), 1740 cm− 1 (C = O, ester) and 2920 cm− 1 (C-H bend). In the case of deoxygenated liquid product, result indicated shifting of absorption band from 1740 cm− 1 (attributed to C = O of ester group in triglyceride) into the absorption band at 1709 cm− 1 (attributed to C = O of carboxylic acid) (Asikin-Mijan et al. 2016a). Disappearance of C-O group from deoxygenated product strongly affirmed that the oxygenated species is removed during the reaction.
3.3 Stability and reusability of NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3
According to the literature (Lee et al. 2013), catalyst’s reusability play critical role in determining the economical application of NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 for for large-scale green diesel production. Due to this reason, the NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 catalyst was reused for several runs under optimum deoxygenation condition at 340 oC, 105 min, and 3 wt.% catalyst loading under N2. The catalyst was treated with hexane after each cycle, in oder to remove adsorbed organic materials followed by drying for 2 h in an oven. The results (Fig. 4a) indicated constant reactivity for five runs, which hydrocarbon yield was 75%, 71%, 70%, 69% and 66% for respective cycles, and the n-(C15 + C17) selectivity of 64–72 % for the five consecutive runs. It was suggested that the occurrence of coke deposition on the catalyst’s active sites during each reaction cycles has resulted the marginal decrease of catalytic activity (Asikin-Mijan et al. 2020c)(Basyar et al. 2018).
The coke deposition of fresh and spent NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 (after fifth runs) was investigated by using TGA analysis (Fig. 4b). TGA profile indicated that fresh catalyst rendered minor weight-loss stage (5.01 ± 0.21%) at the temperature of 100–250°C, which attributed to decomposition of adsorbed water. Nevertheless, insignificant water weight loss is observed for spent catalyst, which suggesting multiple thermal deoxygenation process throughout the five runs facilitated the dehydration pathway, thus resulted in moisture-free NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 catalysts (Communication et al. 2016). However, the spent catalyst showed significant second weight loss (23.2 ± 0.25%) at heating range of 300–600 oC that due to desorption of coke as CO or CO2 (Asikin-Mijan et al. 2016b). Generally, the coke that desorbed at this range of temperature considered as “soft coke”, where the soft coke originates from the physicorbed carbonaceous or side product. Owing to the noticeable amount of coke formation on spent catalyst after five runs, hence it is strong affirmed that the reduction of the deoxygenation reactivity and deCOx product highly correlated with the coke deposited on the active sites of NiO-CaO5/SiO2-Al2O3 catalysts.